Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Grandparents not wanting to do childcare...

485 replies

Chewchewaboogiw · 04/05/2022 23:32

Have been thinking about several people I know whose planned retirememt or part time work has been changed as they have been asked to do childcare for their dgc and now they are doing chikdcare say 3 days a week instead of their plan to travel. And not massively happy about it ( in one case another.baby due also)..I have seen a post response recently that said that they take dgc out but they are not there for childcare. If you dont do childcare for your dgc how did you say no?( I am not in that position at present but i can imagine it would be hard work ..) I would imagine / fear adult ds would be hurt if they were told no dont want to do chikdcare and cant imagine how it would be phrased in a positive way.. anyone said no and is it bu to say you dont want to ... or is it now expected. I know that all families.different, am just asking about families who are comfortable in saying no .

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
jewishmum · 14/05/2022 14:12

PumpkinsandKittens · 04/05/2022 23:38

My mum has never looked after my children, she made it clear it wasn’t happening and it was “my choice to have them”

Wow, horrid.

Robinni · 12/05/2022 00:14

Dinoteeth · 11/05/2022 15:22

@Drinkingallthewine

Honestly don't do it, when the time comes ensure Social Work are aware that you can't have her live with you.
The more you do the more SW will leave you to it.

Think it's rotten that your mum will help one sibling but not you. Even more mind boggling you are sisters it's not even favouring a DD over DS.

@Drinkingallthewine agree with this - say loud and clear to SW “There is no one available” and repeat on loop. It is not your job to give up your freedom night and day to accommodate someone who has treated you so unfairly by comparison to siblings. Meet with them and discuss the issue as shared responsibility when the time comes.

Mary46 · 11/05/2022 15:30

My friend is so good but feels the son is expecting too much now. 1 child.
The more you do.. she retired.

Dinoteeth · 11/05/2022 15:22

@Drinkingallthewine

Honestly don't do it, when the time comes ensure Social Work are aware that you can't have her live with you.
The more you do the more SW will leave you to it.

Think it's rotten that your mum will help one sibling but not you. Even more mind boggling you are sisters it's not even favouring a DD over DS.

Maggiethecat · 11/05/2022 15:18

@Drinkingallthewine - so why are you the doormat?

Drinkingallthewine · 11/05/2022 14:24

I really have no horse in this race, but would have found the discussion to be interesting if everyone weighing in started with their age and the time period their parents and grandparents did or did not help. I think that has a lot do with where the person is coming from.

I'm late 40s, DS is 10. We always had paid childcare for day to day stuff. SIL on his side babysat overnight once or twice a year to give us a night out, starting when DS was 2. (we had done likewise for her lot in the years before)
MIL did after school pick up one day a week - we didn't need it but it was engineered to get her back out of the house again after being widowed. And now she's passed away DS has such fond memories of hanging out at his nan's.

My own DM stated that she wouldn't babysit, and she's been true to her word. Not even in an emergency. Now, in her case, she was in the older group of kids in her own family so basically reared her younger siblings from about age 5 herself. She was forced to leave school to bring an income in to help support the household and the younger ones with money and hands on help. When she got married she quickly had loads of her own in succession. So I can fully understand she wants a child-free retirement and support that.

However, I won't lie- it hurts when she wouldn't help us in a genuine emergency, even once, but would happily hop in her car and drive for several hours to my sisters house to babysit because 'she needs a night out'. She's also babysat every single other grandchild several times a year. So the 'no babysitting' only really applies to me. But I also know that should DM require elderly care, she will point blank refuse a residential place, would not dream of imposing on my sister so it will fall to me likely to move her in with me, rearrange my life and home to cater for her needs. She's already starting to have an expectation that I can take my annual leave for her ad-hoc needs so expect that as she requires increasing care it will be a well established norm that I drop what I'm doing to do her bidding...

SockFluffInTheBath · 11/05/2022 14:23

BrylcreamBeret · 10/05/2022 22:52

I will only say this on the matter. Whether you are the parents or parents in law, if you ever told your children to have kids because you wanted grandbabies even though your children said no we don't want kids - you owe them free childcare.

In this day and age I should hope no woman is having children just to make other people happy.

Scrumbleton · 11/05/2022 00:14

I’ve been v clear with DD Thst when the time comes I’ll be available to help in school school holidays, emergencies and to let her go away for the odd weekend but that l won’t want to be part of an ongoing roster

WildCoasts · 10/05/2022 23:55

BrylcreamBeret · 10/05/2022 22:52

I will only say this on the matter. Whether you are the parents or parents in law, if you ever told your children to have kids because you wanted grandbabies even though your children said no we don't want kids - you owe them free childcare.

I can't agree. No-one made them listen or go ahead and have children. Anyone who does that is a bit silly as parents have the ultimate responsibility and care for their children. Even if the grandparents do childcare, anyone who has children still has that to take on. Who says, "Yes, Mum and Dad, as you request," when a parent expresses their wish for grandchildren? They should be saying, "I understand you want grandchildren but our lives are the ones impacted and we have ultimate responsibility, so we've decided not to have them."

I guess I'm off the hook then as I've told my children to do whatever makes them happy as far as having children themselves goes. I've been clear that they don't owe us grandchildren and I don't mind if I don't have them, because it's not my life to make that decision for.

BrylcreamBeret · 10/05/2022 22:52

I will only say this on the matter. Whether you are the parents or parents in law, if you ever told your children to have kids because you wanted grandbabies even though your children said no we don't want kids - you owe them free childcare.

SockQueen · 10/05/2022 22:46

justasking111 · 09/05/2022 13:06

Those 35 year old father's I wouldn't expect them to be any different as grandfather's. So despite the fact that they're retired expect these men to either be out or asleep in a chair.

I must say my dad (and to a degree, FiL) have both come into their own as grandfathers! Dad wasn't a bad father, but very typical of the time - he went out and earned the money (or not, in the early 90s recession, but was always job hunting) and Mum did virtually all childcare, housework, mental load etc, plus worked part time. I don't really remember playing much with him as a child, he was often on his computer at the weekend or tinkering with things around the house. He was more involved as a taxi service when we were teens - lived rurally with poor public transport. But he's been a lovely and hands-on grandpa much more than I, or perhaps even he, imagined! They don't do regular childcare, so I guess he doesn't see their occasional weekends of care as a chore so much as the day to day drudgery with small children. It's really nice to see.

Dinoteeth · 10/05/2022 21:29

@TAKESNOSHITSHIRLEY OK so while I don't envy having to live life on carers allowance and benefits.
You haven't worked outwith the house, so never needed someone paid or otherwise to mind your kids while you try to earn to pay the bills.

TAKESNOSHITSHIRLEY · 10/05/2022 20:31

Dinoteeth

i was certainly not funded, or a "kept" woman
my partner and i was carers on carers allowance and both claiming jointly all the other benefits that came with it(and fell rent and CT paid) plus 2 children on high care DLA.
put them all together and we were actually very well off

there is 1 adult and 1 child in my household now and even just us 2 we are well off

in fact my ex never worked in 22 years of being together(granted he was 17 when we got together) as he has mild asd himself so was unemployed then a carer till the day he left(hes actually a paid carer to his disabled new partner but that now his business) and ive been a carer and will continue to be a carer for years and years

justasking111 · 09/05/2022 13:06

Those 35 year old father's I wouldn't expect them to be any different as grandfather's. So despite the fact that they're retired expect these men to either be out or asleep in a chair.

Mary46 · 09/05/2022 13:02

My friend was saying she is earmarked for collecting when girl starts school!!! But I dont think should be presumed either that granny will do it!

Double3xposure · 09/05/2022 12:47

I find it interesting that Mumsnet is full of 35-year-old fathers who can’t possibly do any childcare for THEIR OWN children because of their very important job or their very important hobbies which take up evenings and weekends.

And of course they have the right to relax because they work terribly hard all week and earn money to pay the bills.

And yet 65-year-old women who don’t want to do childcare for someone else’s child because of their job or their hobbies are derided as selfish and threatened with being abandoned by their family in their old age age.

I wondered what the difference between these two groups is? Hmm Hmm

Dinoteeth · 09/05/2022 08:00

@TAKESNOSHITSHIRLEY how did you fund yourself when you became an ex?

I'll assume your DH now exH funded you until then.

ChocolateHippo · 09/05/2022 06:55

TAKESNOSHITSHIRLEY · 08/05/2022 17:00

ive a 11 and 17 y old not once have they been "minded" by anyone let alone expected my parents to provide childcare(my parents where 44,43 when i had son 1)they are 61 and 60 now and still work full time
even when i had son 2 in hospital son 1 was outside with my in-laws

reason 1 i chose to leave my job when i had son 1(i had as really well paying job at the time but i dont agree with putting babies in nurseries, childcare settings and schools) so when no 2 came alone i was already home

2 ive never needed anyone to have them overnight as my mind set was these children were mine so i wouldn't need a babysitter as i never wanted to leave them and as i follow(ed) an alternative parenting style as well(peaceful/hippy) i never fully trusted anyone to follow my way of life

3 it turned out both boys have complex mental disabilities(asd, add, odd, spd, pda to name a few) so i became a 24/7 carer in 2007 when son was 4 who chose to home educate so kids are with me 24/7 and that's how we live and love this lifestyle

both kids are very well loved by both sets of grandparents(technically ex in-laws in 2020 but we still have a good relationship as what their son did wasn't their fault)a aunt and uncle(my sister and bil)that are regularly involved in their life and a 9 and 12 y old cousins that's my youngest best friends(they attend school)

ive always hated the phase it takes a village to raise kids as i disagree with a million percent, my kids are my kids and no one has a say in how they are brought up so mind your own.

so many people feel like grandparents have a obligation to mind their kids and when this dont happen they kick off and create such a fuss

this is how society has been for years, same attitude with schools, kids get to 2 and 3 and straight away its the assumption they are attending nursery and school is used a s a childcare setting

And did the children's father feel the same as you? That being a good parent required him to be at home 24/7 with his children?

Waxonwaxoff0 · 08/05/2022 17:13

TAKESNOSHITSHIRLEY · 08/05/2022 17:00

ive a 11 and 17 y old not once have they been "minded" by anyone let alone expected my parents to provide childcare(my parents where 44,43 when i had son 1)they are 61 and 60 now and still work full time
even when i had son 2 in hospital son 1 was outside with my in-laws

reason 1 i chose to leave my job when i had son 1(i had as really well paying job at the time but i dont agree with putting babies in nurseries, childcare settings and schools) so when no 2 came alone i was already home

2 ive never needed anyone to have them overnight as my mind set was these children were mine so i wouldn't need a babysitter as i never wanted to leave them and as i follow(ed) an alternative parenting style as well(peaceful/hippy) i never fully trusted anyone to follow my way of life

3 it turned out both boys have complex mental disabilities(asd, add, odd, spd, pda to name a few) so i became a 24/7 carer in 2007 when son was 4 who chose to home educate so kids are with me 24/7 and that's how we live and love this lifestyle

both kids are very well loved by both sets of grandparents(technically ex in-laws in 2020 but we still have a good relationship as what their son did wasn't their fault)a aunt and uncle(my sister and bil)that are regularly involved in their life and a 9 and 12 y old cousins that's my youngest best friends(they attend school)

ive always hated the phase it takes a village to raise kids as i disagree with a million percent, my kids are my kids and no one has a say in how they are brought up so mind your own.

so many people feel like grandparents have a obligation to mind their kids and when this dont happen they kick off and create such a fuss

this is how society has been for years, same attitude with schools, kids get to 2 and 3 and straight away its the assumption they are attending nursery and school is used a s a childcare setting

You left your job though so you've not needed childcare. Not everyone can afford to do that. I'm a single parent, I need to work to pay the mortgage.

TAKESNOSHITSHIRLEY · 08/05/2022 17:00

ive a 11 and 17 y old not once have they been "minded" by anyone let alone expected my parents to provide childcare(my parents where 44,43 when i had son 1)they are 61 and 60 now and still work full time
even when i had son 2 in hospital son 1 was outside with my in-laws

reason 1 i chose to leave my job when i had son 1(i had as really well paying job at the time but i dont agree with putting babies in nurseries, childcare settings and schools) so when no 2 came alone i was already home

2 ive never needed anyone to have them overnight as my mind set was these children were mine so i wouldn't need a babysitter as i never wanted to leave them and as i follow(ed) an alternative parenting style as well(peaceful/hippy) i never fully trusted anyone to follow my way of life

3 it turned out both boys have complex mental disabilities(asd, add, odd, spd, pda to name a few) so i became a 24/7 carer in 2007 when son was 4 who chose to home educate so kids are with me 24/7 and that's how we live and love this lifestyle

both kids are very well loved by both sets of grandparents(technically ex in-laws in 2020 but we still have a good relationship as what their son did wasn't their fault)a aunt and uncle(my sister and bil)that are regularly involved in their life and a 9 and 12 y old cousins that's my youngest best friends(they attend school)

ive always hated the phase it takes a village to raise kids as i disagree with a million percent, my kids are my kids and no one has a say in how they are brought up so mind your own.

so many people feel like grandparents have a obligation to mind their kids and when this dont happen they kick off and create such a fuss

this is how society has been for years, same attitude with schools, kids get to 2 and 3 and straight away its the assumption they are attending nursery and school is used a s a childcare setting

pinkfluffydoor · 08/05/2022 16:12

@LuckySantangelo35 I'm speaking my own opinion and everyone is different. To me , after I retire I would love to do all the things I didn't get to do when I had children but even then, it still wouldn't fill up my days, weeks and months and we are talking about a good couple of decades of this if you live past your 80s and still in good health. God forbid I loose my husband or vice versa, I would always love to be involved and help as much as I can obviously not being the overbearing parents/in-laws. If my child doesn't choose to have children, then I guess I would try to be useful in other ways or let my child know that I will always be there for him. My life before children still had my family in it. I also had friends that I hardly speak as the relationship fizzle out overtime. Once your career, student and friendship days are over, then my purpose will be to live a full filling life that includes my child in it whether offering child care if he chooses to have a child or cook Sunday roasts or house sit when I need to it he doesn't choose to have children.

I know people who are also on the either end of the spectrum where they dump their kids on their parents full time or people who can't even get any help to cover a important health issue such as a surgery. I know people where their parents live abroad but have their in laws living 5 miles away, but still the parents abroad will fly out to help out during the hour of need. I've never been the one to dump my child or expect anyone to look after him, but it's nice to know I have a family and in-laws that will. It's also reassuring to know that if me and dh dies in some tragic way, my child will be well looked after by both sides of the family including aunts and uncles. People thrive when they are together and support each other and these past lockdowns have been very hard for me, my family/in-laws and to many other people.

Standrews · 08/05/2022 15:42

When our son and his wife were expecting they asked us formally how we wished to be involved with our dgc's life. We said we would be happy to help at times of need, would babysit for occasional nights out. Later when DGC was older we took her to school (just a walk away). She is now 14 and we are occasionally called upon to pick her up from High School which is a substantial drive away. We don't mind, it has always been the expectation that if it wasn't convenient we could say so. We have done this successfully for two granddaughters and this month we are baby sitting the DOG for 3 days! I am more nervous about this.

Robinni · 08/05/2022 14:44

@LuckySantangelo35

Well clearly you do have a problem as you took issue with @pinkfluffydoor saying they would love to be involved with childcare and it would give their life purpose…

As well as ranting on that retirement should be abc and not xyz. It is up to individuals to define what they want their retirement to be there is no right or wrong.

Obviously childcare should not be expected or assumed and anyone who has a half decent relationship with their parents will have a conversation with them when the time comes.

As for care in old age, no one is suggesting that parents be dismissed with no support if they don’t provide X amount of childcare.

What people have pointed out is that if a person decides to largely cut ties with their children and grandchildren, and aren’t involved in their lives much for say 20-30yrs. It’s unlikely they will have the same level of support as say beloved Granny Elsie and Granda John who spent years looking after the kids and making the Sunday dinner….. those are two extremes by the way - I think most of us are somewhere between Joan Collins and Granny Elsie.

LuckySantangelo35 · 08/05/2022 14:33

Robinni · 08/05/2022 14:23

@LuckySantangelo35 I thought you might like that idea 😊🍹

All I’m saying is stop cutting people down, you’ve been buzzing about this thread having a go anytime anyone says anything positive. With some ideas that were out of touch with reality (availability of care provision in the U.K.) and just generally being a bit aggro when somebody says they like caring for kids or think GP should be around.

If you want to be JC in retirement that is cool and more power to you. But not everyone does.

@Robinni

i totally understand that.

My point all along wasn’t that though. I have no issue with people who want to take care of their grandkids whilst their parents work - why would I?!

My point is that childcare from
grandparents shouldn’t be EXPECTED or assumed and that grandparents shouldn’t be dismissed when infirm with no support if they didn’t provide what their sons/daughters perceived to be the requisite amount of childcare.

that is all

Robinni · 08/05/2022 14:23

@LuckySantangelo35 I thought you might like that idea 😊🍹

All I’m saying is stop cutting people down, you’ve been buzzing about this thread having a go anytime anyone says anything positive. With some ideas that were out of touch with reality (availability of care provision in the U.K.) and just generally being a bit aggro when somebody says they like caring for kids or think GP should be around.

If you want to be JC in retirement that is cool and more power to you. But not everyone does.