Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To accept a public sector job over a Big4?

131 replies

somewhereovertherainboww · 04/05/2022 20:21

Job offer 1: public sector (finance), central London location so a fairly easy commute, 9-5 hybrid with 2 days WFH

Job offer 2: one of the Big 4, audit, regional office, a 1.5 hour (pricey) commute by train, very long hours and rarely WFH

I am returning to full time employment after years of being a SAHM to 2 DC(4&6 y.o.).

My heart says option 1 is more family friendly and “meaningful” but my head says a Big 4 in my CV can set me up for life, offers better progression opportunities and pay.
DH is not on six figures and my earning potential is definitely higher, which puts pressure on me to go for option 2. DH is happy to do school drop offs and pick up from clubs in the evening to allow me to work long hours but I worry I will barely get to see the children on weekdays.

OP posts:
Alldressedup · 04/05/2022 23:13

Definitely option 1. Have you done audit before? I found it soul destroying (top 4 firm). Deathly boring, long hours, working off-site in random places, zero job satisfaction.

Someone else has already said this but you can end up working anywhere in the country doing audit. Are you prepared to do this, sometimes for weeks at a time, rushing home on a Friday for a brief weekend before going back Sunday evening?

Also, much as some client teams were lovely it is not the same as being part of a proper team as you are moving from client to client and often working with different colleagues from one job to the next. The whole experience definitely impacted my mental health.

I now work in the public sector (non-finance role now) and I knew it was the right move immediately. Yes there are lots of things that frustrate the hell out of it but ultimately the work is a lot more satisfying/ worthwhile and I am so much happier. Many friends who stayed out ended up leaving once they had kids too. Just wasn’t compatible despite what they like to make out. But…it depends what you want the most. Remember, the top 4 will be there in a few years if you wanted. And they’ll always be looking for people to join the audit team (there’s a reason!!).

I don’t tell many people what I used to do - it’s definitely not an asset on my cv.

Blossomtoes · 04/05/2022 23:04

somewhereovertherainboww · 04/05/2022 23:02

My gut tells me to go for option 1. I used to be very career-oriented (pre-kids), not so much now. My values and priorities have changed and I want to be there for my children, however, I worry about progression opportunities, should I chose to go down the public sector route. Both roles are at a fairly junior level but I’m looking at it from a long term perspective.

In which case, go for the public sector. I went from press officer to head of comms in four years in local government.

somewhereovertherainboww · 04/05/2022 23:02

My gut tells me to go for option 1. I used to be very career-oriented (pre-kids), not so much now. My values and priorities have changed and I want to be there for my children, however, I worry about progression opportunities, should I chose to go down the public sector route. Both roles are at a fairly junior level but I’m looking at it from a long term perspective.

OP posts:
GingerFigs · 04/05/2022 22:52

I'd say the Big 4 is better on your CV. But it's also a long commute and long hours. And it will be long hours. Audit roles in the Big 4 in my experience are relentlessly long hours. Although depends on your seniority.

Personally with young kids and the stage of life I'm at now where I'm not chasing a good CV I'd take job 1. More flexibility and a better pension (public sector pension wins out over private any day).

lugeforlife · 04/05/2022 22:49

I've worked in Big 4 all my career pretty much (2 of them) and don't recognise the horror stories but will qualify that by saying a, I don't work in audit and b I've not worked for Deloitte.

Hours can be long sometimes of course but I don't work disproportionately longer than friends/family in other industries. And days get flexed, there is a focus on wellbeing (I am quite cynical about this but they are trying).

I am surprised re WFH as certainly everyone in our office can/does in the very department.

But but but I'd be cautious re the salary prospects. Yet it's well paid but friends who have moved mid tier or in house earn similarly and we actually are struggling to retain at the moment as salary bandings have remained static and it's only really by promotion that people see pay progression.

Booboobagins · 04/05/2022 22:42

Local government every day of the week. IME, promotions arise fairly regularly if you want to climb the slippery pole.

I truly wish I'd stayed in local government. And you're CV will not be negatively affected cos its about the work you did and successes not who you worked for per se.

TheTeddyBears · 04/05/2022 22:41

The first one because you have kids. Public sector is very flexible the only thing is that u don't get pay rises or very little. Most I've had in 7yrs is 1.5% most years have been 0.5 or 1% but some years like last yr we got nothing and again same coming yr. unless ur on a very low salary u get a tiny rise. Frustrating but great pension, holidays, flexi time and flexible working.

TheHatinaCat · 04/05/2022 22:40

What's your gut feeking? I always think you know deep down which option would be best. It's not always logical.

SAHM to long commute and long hours will be tough. Are you ambitious? If so, do they have any senior women or is it all blokes? As a woman with children I think you are far better off in public sector. There are generally more women, more women in management positions, more part-timers (who actually get promoted) and work/life balance is better.

I've had jobs that looked great on paper (job and company) but didn't live up to expectations at all. Don't be dazzled by the hype and bigger salary.

AuditAngel · 04/05/2022 22:40

I am audit background, currently top 10, but regional (just outside London). I now work in a internal role, but would not work big 4 with a 1.5 hour commute with small kids.

My DD15 is currently suffering some ill health and being close to home, and having the support of my bosses, knowing I can walk out if she needs me, is invaluable,

tkwal · 04/05/2022 22:32

I would always choose quality of life over size of wage packet. Choose job 1 which will allow you more family time and less stress.There will always be another job opportunity, your children won't always need you to be there for them as much as they do now.
This isn't intended as criticism either but I was kind of stunned by your comment about your DHs earning power. Even if he doesn't earn 6 figures, I'm not sure he deserves what sounds like a put down

Mellowyellow222 · 04/05/2022 22:32

If you are going into the civil service at a senior level you might not get the WFH as regularly as you hope - if you are regularly briefing ministers and committees etc you might find yourself increasingly being required in the room.

Blossomtoes · 04/05/2022 22:29

My money would be on greater potential for career progression in the public sector. Women particularly benefit from the soft benefits which don’t detract from promotion prospects. If you’re thinking medium to long term I’d go the public sector route every time.

CakenTea · 04/05/2022 22:26

I trained in Big 4 audit before kids, it was bloody awful! Long hours and random assignments all over the place, not just locally. Also super dull. I would have really struggled to manage young kids too.

However if you are thinking higher up than entry level, you may have more autonomy and flexibility. Have heard horror stories about junior trainees being watched on camera when working remotely through busy season, to check they are not slacking!!

springsmiles · 04/05/2022 22:22

I would go with big 4 get experience and the name on your cv as it will stand you in good stead when moving to the public sector.

I've worked for a big 4 and loved it, yes hours were long, but pay was brilliant.

somewhereovertherainboww · 04/05/2022 22:22

Thanks everyone, some really helpful advice and a lot of food for thought. I cannot answer some of the questions as I’m a bit paranoid about outing myself, however, it seems that the majority of posters would go for option 1, which also happens to be my preference.

OP posts:
Chattanooger · 04/05/2022 22:20

I’m at the Big 4, audit trained but now in another dept.

Take public sector, the work life balance will make it worth it.

Aghh · 04/05/2022 22:16

Big 4 because if it doesn’t work out there’s loads of wfh public sector jobs to flip to whereas you’d struggle to flip the other way.

Plus, it might be amazing ! Public sector finance will never be amazing.

poppetandmog · 04/05/2022 22:16

I work in big 4 and am currently signed off work sick with stress. Absolutely not compatible with young children. Take job 1.

Mariposista · 04/05/2022 22:12

I worked in a Big4. I am tough, but I survived 18 months. It killed my MH and the stress left me with a serious autoimmune problem (fortunately now ok). The pay was appalling, the commute was hell, and I was miserable for the full time. It sounds impressive, but I wouldn't go back there even if you offered me 6 figure salary. I am freelance now, earning 3x as much and I love my job. Go for option A OP. Please do.

buckingmad · 04/05/2022 22:11

I am literally working my notice at big 4 because I want to spend more time with my little one.

ThisGirlCantAlways · 04/05/2022 22:09

I work at a big4, and they are keen for people to wfh, London and regions

Zilla1 · 04/05/2022 22:09

Big 4 while you can even for a couple of years will probably halo your CV for life.

Tinkywinkydinkydoo · 04/05/2022 22:05

My husband has worked for 2 of the Big 4 firms in audit. We hardly used to see him. He’d come home at 6, have dinner, relax for an hour then had to do work again from around 8pm, then work on the weekends too. It wasn’t sustainable. I think going from being a Sahm and being there constantly with your children to a Big 4 firm will be quite a drastic shock. My husband now does have a fantastic paying job though due to having worked in the 2 firms he did but it was a good few years of long long hours to get there.

Maurepas · 04/05/2022 22:04

I got the impression with one of the big 4 who I had dealings with that they at least showed they were family friendly as I was told more than once that one of the guys I had meetings with had a very young child so he did not get much sleep - or something similar! No reduction of fees for me though!

Heronwatcher · 04/05/2022 22:02

No way would I take job 2 with young kids, unless you really really want/need the money. They are young for such a short time and regardless of your DH being free to do pick ups etc, you will miss so much. Plus the 1.5 hour commute will be a killer especially at the moment- there’s a real shortage of train drivers and other staff so you may be beset with problems like cancellations etc. It sounds like the terms and conditions are much better with job 1 which is worth quite a bit, plus I imagine that the pension will be better.

Swipe left for the next trending thread