Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To accept a public sector job over a Big4?

131 replies

somewhereovertherainboww · 04/05/2022 20:21

Job offer 1: public sector (finance), central London location so a fairly easy commute, 9-5 hybrid with 2 days WFH

Job offer 2: one of the Big 4, audit, regional office, a 1.5 hour (pricey) commute by train, very long hours and rarely WFH

I am returning to full time employment after years of being a SAHM to 2 DC(4&6 y.o.).

My heart says option 1 is more family friendly and “meaningful” but my head says a Big 4 in my CV can set me up for life, offers better progression opportunities and pay.
DH is not on six figures and my earning potential is definitely higher, which puts pressure on me to go for option 2. DH is happy to do school drop offs and pick up from clubs in the evening to allow me to work long hours but I worry I will barely get to see the children on weekdays.

OP posts:
rooinspace · 05/05/2022 08:26

Another thing to remember about the Big 4 job is that (depending on your level) you could be spending considerable amount of time at client sites rather than in the office. And naturally these clients will be regionally grouped around your office rather than your home. So whilst commute to office is 1.5hr by train, from say London, and for example the office is in Bristol - it’s likely the clients will be spread around Bristol and area which means you could be commuting to rural Somerset/Wales depending on the client.

TheKeatingFive · 05/05/2022 08:14

I guess it depends what you want longer term too. Taking a public sector job now would make it harder to move to private sector, whereas Big 4 experience will open more doors.

However a junior role in Big 4 would be very challenging to balance with family.

Tough one. Think of what you want 5 years, 10 years down the line.

MyJobisNotOuting · 05/05/2022 08:09

So qualified?
You will be looking at £120K minimum. What really each offering?

Believeitornot · 05/05/2022 07:59

MojoMoon · 05/05/2022 07:07

You say these are fairly junior - are you not fully qualified yet?

I'd think about how much your children benefit over their life by having a higher household income - wealthier children have better educational, job and health outcomes. You will be able to fund and support them in various ways - education, deposits on homes etc which make a massive difference to their lives and how easy it will be for them to have kids, get a career they enjoy, have the confidence to get the life they want.

They have a dad taking care of them and doing school pickups so they will be fine.

If you are the one who can provide the higher income, they probably benefit more from that than having you making packed lunches, doing laundry and watching swimming lessons etc.

It’s exhausting a parent though. Doing a long commute with a stressful job is incredibly hard with children - especially when they’re younger and get ill a lot.

it’s not just the practical element but the emotional side too. There’s nothing wrong with feeling guilty, but be aware that the guilt can happen!

we made it work because we had a nanny as both of us worked. But I found it harder once they got to school although flexible working and wfh makes the world of difference

HardyBuckette · 05/05/2022 07:43

LakieLady · 05/05/2022 07:14

You ought to factor into your decision that what is a 1.5 hour commute according to the timetable will often be considerably more.

When my DP was commuting to London, there was never a week when at least one day's travel wasn't irrevocably fucked by some event or other. Sometimes it was every damn day.

This was my thinking too. Three hours a day commuting is essentially the minimum. If they were going to allow a couple of days a week wfh and that would be in the contract, might be different.

HouseofGods · 05/05/2022 07:36

Job 1.

Job 2 hours plus commute and travel to client locations are enough to put me off. I did it as a trainee and remained in audit but working 0.8 as a senior manager after DC1 then I made the move to FE sector (still as an accountant). The hours, pension and holidays once you have kids are invaluable. Audit just still isn't very family friendly.

If you try job 1 and don't like it or decide the higher salary of Big 4 would make life easier then you can always move. The big forms will always be open to hiring good auditors even when not actively recruiting as retention is so difficult. Think of that as your safety net.

Everyoneishappier · 05/05/2022 07:20

Nearly 30 years in public sector. (I admit I am institutionalised.) but I still think it is a fabulous place to work for parents. I had 3 kids, worked full time but extremely flexibly from the moment I returned from Mat leave with the first. Over the years that's included full time / term time only / Full time compressed hours.

The main difference between private and public sector is between being in an environment focussed on profits (high pressure) and one focusing on service to the public. (pressure of a different type)

There is no lack of progression opportunities within the public sector.

LakieLady · 05/05/2022 07:14

You ought to factor into your decision that what is a 1.5 hour commute according to the timetable will often be considerably more.

When my DP was commuting to London, there was never a week when at least one day's travel wasn't irrevocably fucked by some event or other. Sometimes it was every damn day.

MojoMoon · 05/05/2022 07:07

You say these are fairly junior - are you not fully qualified yet?

I'd think about how much your children benefit over their life by having a higher household income - wealthier children have better educational, job and health outcomes. You will be able to fund and support them in various ways - education, deposits on homes etc which make a massive difference to their lives and how easy it will be for them to have kids, get a career they enjoy, have the confidence to get the life they want.

They have a dad taking care of them and doing school pickups so they will be fine.

If you are the one who can provide the higher income, they probably benefit more from that than having you making packed lunches, doing laundry and watching swimming lessons etc.

MarshaBradyo · 05/05/2022 07:07

Tough one

i guess it comes down to your mental space on either

whichever you feel you can do best

Believeitornot · 05/05/2022 07:06

HardyBuckette · 05/05/2022 07:00

Three hours a day commuting, probably more if the trains aren't cooperative, with virtually no wfh option? I'd run away screaming.

Yep!

HardyBuckette · 05/05/2022 07:00

Three hours a day commuting, probably more if the trains aren't cooperative, with virtually no wfh option? I'd run away screaming.

MarieG10 · 05/05/2022 06:48

Given the circumstances you describe and both being fairly junior, I would go for the public sector offer. May be easier to getting yourself back into work and the pension is usually worth several times the private sector one unless there is a massive pay discrepancy.

Good luck

Believeitornot · 05/05/2022 06:48

somewhereovertherainboww · 04/05/2022 20:21

Job offer 1: public sector (finance), central London location so a fairly easy commute, 9-5 hybrid with 2 days WFH

Job offer 2: one of the Big 4, audit, regional office, a 1.5 hour (pricey) commute by train, very long hours and rarely WFH

I am returning to full time employment after years of being a SAHM to 2 DC(4&6 y.o.).

My heart says option 1 is more family friendly and “meaningful” but my head says a Big 4 in my CV can set me up for life, offers better progression opportunities and pay.
DH is not on six figures and my earning potential is definitely higher, which puts pressure on me to go for option 2. DH is happy to do school drop offs and pick up from clubs in the evening to allow me to work long hours but I worry I will barely get to see the children on weekdays.

If job 1 is an accountancy option take it. If it’s what I think it is, you can end up on the same path as big 4 grads (I know because I did an ACA at a public sector organisation).

FussyLittleFucker · 05/05/2022 06:46

Option 1 without question!

spaceman1 · 05/05/2022 06:42

I think you should go for option 1, that way you will be able to see your children more.

Ratonastick · 05/05/2022 06:39

I’d go Big 4 purely for the long term gain, even if you just do 2-3 years then move on. I worked for EY in the dim and distant and, while it wasn’t a great environment, I can honestly say that it set my career up and is still a reference point 25 years later. I also recruit senior people in the finance field and I do lean towards Big 4 experience or training, particularly people who have come from regional offices rather than London, because I have found that they work to higher standards. Maybe that is snobbery (and the best person I ever worked with was ex BDO which disproves my own point), but Big 4 is definitely a CV positive. I have also see a lot of senior finance specs over the years and most still want Big 4.
It’s harder to jump between public and private sector in finance, largely because the requirements are so different (probably easier to go from private to public than vice versa), so choosing public sector now could definitely limit your future options.

Haus1234 · 05/05/2022 06:23

If it really is more of a junior role I would not do Big 4 with young kids. All my friends training in audit lived in hotels Monday to Friday as they had to be on client site (which could be anywhere so may well be further than your 1.5 hour away office) - it’s not conducive to family life.

Chessie678 · 05/05/2022 00:38

I had a few thoughts on this.

Could you ask for part-time at the big four? My impression is that they are struggling to recruit in many fields at the moment and are keen to appear more family friendly so they may well agree to this. Might make it more manageable though you'd have to be sure that it would genuinely be part time and not just working 5 days for lower pay than your colleagues.

I also doubt that it is Big Four with a 1.5 hr commute or nothing. If you've been offered two jobs you'll be offered more similar ones and mostly it's an employees market in these fields.

I'd also suggest calculating your likely pay per hour in both roles. I'm a lawyer but there's some overlap between what I do and the Big Four - I'm supposed to work a minimum of 36 hours per week (and that's recorded hours where I'm doing something productive) on a 4 day contact though frequently it's more than that in practice. In the public sector a full time contract would be c. 36 hours and you get time off in lieu if you work over that. So though I'm still paid more than I would be in the public sector for the hours the difference is nothing like as much per hour as you would think.

The progression opportunities are much better where I am now though and if I want to make really serious money at some point I have much better options for it having had the private sector experience.

There's a question of how far you realistically see yourself progressing at the Big Four. If you can't imagine ever being a partner, it may not be worth working in more junior roles trying to prove yourself there. The Big Four ask for a lot of their mid level employees for pay which is often not spectacular in the scheme of things relative to the hours and responsibility involved. They can partly do this due to the potential rewards of partnership. If you don't want that you can end up working very hard for years without ever seeing the real reward for it. It's a dilemma I often have myself as I can't really imagine partnership alongside young children.

Namechanger355 · 05/05/2022 00:04

Just became a non equity partner in a big 4 firm - not audit- and the money is good. I have lots of flexibility in terms of remote working and managing my workload - but obviously it can be hard work.

im happy where I am for now though will need to see if it’s sustainable long term. The commute and balance is important

Mumtofourandnomore · 04/05/2022 23:59

I would go for the Big 4 role if it were based in one location and was hybrid. I would also go for Big4 if you could then transfer internally to their Public Services division (and audit Public Service clients) - then you get the PS hours, but the Big 4 name. I worked in private sector audit for PwC but did summers in their Public Services division and really enjoyed it although it was quite a different culture.

PwC were a fantastic employer when I trained with them - the biggest benefit was definitely to my CV. I subsequently moved into industry and have never struggled to find a job, I’ve combined three employers (5 roles) with having four children and have found it easy to ask for flexible working and work 3/4 days because big corporates really like and rate ex-Big 4 employees. In the long-term, pay is better, progression is better, bonuses are better - do 2 or 3 years and you will be set for life.

Tigerandthetea · 04/05/2022 23:53

I’ve worked for Big 4. I wouldn’t be where I am without them. I have got every job I’ve interviewed for since. Six figures before 30. Learned a lot.

big 4 also has a HUGE flexible working policy so you’d 100% be able to wfh a lot!

Fairisleflora · 04/05/2022 23:49

I have done all sorts in all sorts of firms inc in the public sector. I was shocked at the lack of professionalism and pride in a lot of areas of public sector pissed me off. People with ‘jobs for life’ who couldn’t be bothered to respond to emails, or answer basic queries. You don’t get that as much in the private sector as they would be sacked. Also pay grades and no bonuses means if you work hard it won’t be financially rewarded or recognised - leading the aforementioned lack of professionalism.

Creative34 · 04/05/2022 23:44

@SickAndTiredAgain

Ernst and Young, or EY as they now preferred to be called... why does everyone call them Ernest and Young?!

I think that’s why they changed to EY. That’s why Deloitte put a dot after their name... so that everyone stopped called them Deloittes 😂

TokyoTen · 04/05/2022 23:30

Personally I'd go for big 4 and get it on my CV for 2 to 3 years. Better chance of progression and wide range of experiences.

Swipe left for the next trending thread