Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My love of Gone with the Wind and other problematic films/literature

113 replies

RedSquirrel111 · 04/05/2022 20:09

Interested in other opinions on this.

I first read Gone with the Wind in school and since then have gone through 3 copies. It's my favourite comfort book that I re-read a couple of times a year. I also adore the film, Vivien Leigh and the gorgeous technicolor cinematography.

However it is undeniably and explicitly racist. Both the film and the book, more so the book (if you can measure such things). I fell in love with Scarlett as the first 'fuck you' 3 dimensional female character I'd ever read, and I still love her.

Do you read it as 'a book of its time'? (With a critical eye but still enjoy it?) Or is it one that whilst I don't want to say 'cancelled' should be resigned to history in the way that, say, birth of a nation, has been?

When it comes to artists I'm very much 'separate the art from the creator' and therefore have no problem reading Roald Dahl for example.

However this is different as its the subject matter and not just the author.

I'd especially be grateful for the view of any BAME women - especially if American!!!

OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 04/05/2022 20:44

As if the people of the time were inferior, instead of being of their time, of their knowledge, experience, social culture, history.

Quite. Do these people ever stop to think about aspects of their own society and culture that won't be so palatable in the future?

I don't see any good that can come of cancelling GWTW. We won't have any historic literature left if we get carried away with that kind of stupidity.

AtomicBlondeRose · 04/05/2022 20:42

I don’t think we should “cancel” historic literature. However I suppose they’re self-cancelling in a way - I had never read GWTW and was interested in it as being a classic, a depiction of the time and so on. But I really couldn’t get past the way the black characters are portrayed, even in the context of the period it was written and the period it shows. I imagine lots of people would feel like that so it would just drop out of favour as has happened to countless books and films over time.

RedSquirrel111 · 04/05/2022 20:41

LaLaLouella · 04/05/2022 20:30

I'm struggling in a similar way as I absolutely adored this book as a teen and it was the first film I loved and watched over and over. I find it difficult to revisit now as I can't get past how problematic it is!

My daughter is now the age I was when I first read it and I really don't know wether or not to encourage her to read it. Part of me wonders if she'll be so enraged by the racism and mysoginy that she'll hate it as she's a lot more clued up about these issues than I was as a teen.

But, part of me really doesn't want her to read it, love it, and then be embarrassed or uncomfortable about discussing it with her friends who are POC.

That interests me as I've always thought it as feminist. I think Scarlett is such a brilliant character - she went through such a journey of 'southern belle' to 'hard hearted business woman'
And her internal struggle that she would be like her mother as soon as she had the time.... that part I thought was revolutionary

OP posts:
Artichokeleaves · 04/05/2022 20:39

Its a social document. It not only describes and helps a reader to understand some of the key issues of the time through the media of fiction and the eyes of different characters, it shows the social perspectives and the way of looking at the issues at the time it was written. It is valuable for many reasons, tracking the progress and evolution of how social attitudes changed, how fiction dealt with slavery. Uncle Tom's Cabin played a similar role.

We cannot just hide this and pretend it never happened; the history and understanding it, properly, is part of evolving beyond it. This ridiculous cancel culture/don't touch anything contaminated just stops all understanding and thought, and will just obliterate any learning from that period being possible. It's afraid of learning. It's afraid of connecting with and understanding complexities and people from another time and place. And there's something childish and rather stupidly superior about it too. As if the people of the time were inferior, instead of being of their time, of their knowledge, experience, social culture, history.

LaLaLouella · 04/05/2022 20:30

I'm struggling in a similar way as I absolutely adored this book as a teen and it was the first film I loved and watched over and over. I find it difficult to revisit now as I can't get past how problematic it is!

My daughter is now the age I was when I first read it and I really don't know wether or not to encourage her to read it. Part of me wonders if she'll be so enraged by the racism and mysoginy that she'll hate it as she's a lot more clued up about these issues than I was as a teen.

But, part of me really doesn't want her to read it, love it, and then be embarrassed or uncomfortable about discussing it with her friends who are POC.

YarnHoarder · 04/05/2022 20:27

I think books make fantastic historical records of the values and norms of societies and help us understand what life could like for many people. These are obviously largely written by middle class white men (not all but many) so context is important but when written records from other perspectives don't exist and oral histories can be unreliable (thinking about older texts and further back in time here).

It's important we're critical of these texts but that doesn't mean they shouldn't be read, particularly as part of a school curriculum where these views can be challenged and learned from. Historical literature has so much to offer but have to be understood in the context of those times while recognising racism/sexual assault/murder/abuse/etc were never ok.

HereBeFuckery · 04/05/2022 20:26

This gets discussed in the context of the National Curriculum, frequently. For example, Y9 often read Of Mice and Men, which portrays racist and disabilist attitudes and normalises them as part of the context of the Great Depression and its aftermath. It's presented as such in lessons, as an era from which we can learn.
If we erase all historical discrimination, how can we teach children to be vigilant against discrimination in future?

x2boys · 04/05/2022 20:26

It depicted Slavery which happened
There was a lot of terrible things that happened in times gone by we can't ignore them and pretend it never happened.

Antarcticant · 04/05/2022 20:23

(White British woman) I think it's more dangerous to try to pretend racism didn't exist in the past, or even to acknowledge but cover it up and not talk about it. As white people we have to recognise that white privilege is built on centuries of racism, and books which exhibit this, as long as we can see it for what it is, are part of that ongoing education.

Ferngreen · 04/05/2022 20:18

I would think this book should never be cancelled. How can you understand society at that time (also the society at the time it was published) if you remove the books demonstrating people's attitudes, however flawed they seem now.

RedSquirrel111 · 04/05/2022 20:17

NrlySp · 04/05/2022 20:13

You are aware of the issues. Presumably you are not racist after reading it? The world has learnt to be better with that particular issue (even though slavery in other forms still exists) and as Churchill said 'a Nation that forgets it’s past has no future'

Thank you. That's a good way of looking at it.
As it was written in the 30s I kind of think it stands up as an example of southern pre-WW2 race culture.
But then I may be making excuses as I still enjoy it so much

OP posts:
NrlySp · 04/05/2022 20:13

You are aware of the issues. Presumably you are not racist after reading it? The world has learnt to be better with that particular issue (even though slavery in other forms still exists) and as Churchill said 'a Nation that forgets it’s past has no future'

RedSquirrel111 · 04/05/2022 20:10

Sorry, I didn't mean to post this under AIBU

OP posts: