Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My love of Gone with the Wind and other problematic films/literature

113 replies

RedSquirrel111 · 04/05/2022 20:09

Interested in other opinions on this.

I first read Gone with the Wind in school and since then have gone through 3 copies. It's my favourite comfort book that I re-read a couple of times a year. I also adore the film, Vivien Leigh and the gorgeous technicolor cinematography.

However it is undeniably and explicitly racist. Both the film and the book, more so the book (if you can measure such things). I fell in love with Scarlett as the first 'fuck you' 3 dimensional female character I'd ever read, and I still love her.

Do you read it as 'a book of its time'? (With a critical eye but still enjoy it?) Or is it one that whilst I don't want to say 'cancelled' should be resigned to history in the way that, say, birth of a nation, has been?

When it comes to artists I'm very much 'separate the art from the creator' and therefore have no problem reading Roald Dahl for example.

However this is different as its the subject matter and not just the author.

I'd especially be grateful for the view of any BAME women - especially if American!!!

OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 04/05/2022 21:51

I think that even if there is overt racist sentiment or language, portraying black characters as complex/sympathetic/ multi dimensional makes a big difference.

If there is respect for basic humanity, then the story can remain relevant and engaging.

Boood · 04/05/2022 21:50

I tried reading it a couple of years ago and had to give up. I was expecting it to be “of its time”, but I thought the racism went beyond that, it felt completely ingrained in the tone of the narrative, and I felt tainted and horrible reading it. I only got a couple of chapters in, so maybe it improved. But I think there’s a difference between a book depicting racism, and a racist book, and GWTW was the latter. I wouldn’t cancel it, but I wouldn’t shed a tear if people lost interest in reading it and it went out of print. That’s just natural progress, not rewriting history. There are a lot of books that were considered good when they were written that have gone out of fashion or no longer appeal to modern taste.

LemonDrizzleSlice · 04/05/2022 21:50

Or The Wind Done Gone.

XelaM · 04/05/2022 21:50

Gone with the Wind is most certainly racist. It's undeniable if you read the novel. It romanticises a terrible period in history. It's still very enjoyable, but you have to understand that it's complete and utter fiction. Read Uncle Tom's Cabin for the other side of the story.

LemonDrizzleSlice · 04/05/2022 21:44

I mean, this is not a hill I'm going to die on, I'm a white woman. But showing racism is not the same as being racist.

LemonDrizzleSlice · 04/05/2022 21:43

But having racist characters is not the same as a book being racist.

RedSquirrel111 · 04/05/2022 21:40

codeVeronica · 04/05/2022 21:21

Have you read the book? It quite clearly depicts slavery and the KKK as good things. Not to mention the awful stereotypes.

Yes, the 'gone with wind' is a lament to how things used to be....
With plantations built on slavery.
Never mind the characters such as 'Big Sam'
There's a bit in the book that explains how 'N* are like children'
The racism is completely undeniable. My question is if you can still enjoy it.

OP posts:
artisanbread · 04/05/2022 21:27

Sorry for terrible typos. of their time and in the past

artisanbread · 04/05/2022 21:26

I just try to see things as if their time. Books and films help us to understand how things were in the last and can give us an insight into why change was needed. You don't have to agree with racism or sexism to enjoy great literature.

TheKeatingFive · 04/05/2022 21:25

How could the other stars do it, Clark Gable was supposed to be her friend.

I know. It's hard to understand their behaviour now, it seems so heartless. I guess cultural norms were very different, which is exactly the point.

LemonDrizzleSlice · 04/05/2022 21:24

Yes, read the book when I was a teen and seen the film a few times.

Perhaps I remember what I saw in it, rather than what was there. IYKWIM?

codeVeronica · 04/05/2022 21:21

LemonDrizzleSlice · 04/05/2022 20:46

I'm not really sure how it's racist? It depicts black people as having injustice done to them, when Scarlett causes the menfolk to go out on her behalf. It shows black enslaved people acting with dignity and grace.

Yes, it shows black servants. But is that inherently racist? It is a snapshot of how things were. It doesn't treat the black characters as "lesser", quite the opposite. Many of the white characters are shown in far worse light.

The exception perhaps is Prissy.

Have you read the book? It quite clearly depicts slavery and the KKK as good things. Not to mention the awful stereotypes.

MrsWateringcan · 04/05/2022 21:20

What an interesting thread. I too used to love this film as a teen and I'm ashamed to say I only picked up on the v uncomfortable and blatant racism when I rewatched it as an adult.

The modern day author I have a huge issue with is David Walliams - I think his books are awful, with a thread of racism and classism running through nearly all of them. Total cringe. Doesn't even have the excuse of having been written several decades ago. My kids used to love them (not bought by me!) so we used some of the characters as a talking point.

He's been compared to Roald Dahl (problematic himself!) but I don't think his books have the clever darkness of RD's nastier characters.

Sorry, slight derail there.

ancientgran · 04/05/2022 21:17

TheKeatingFive · 04/05/2022 21:15

When you think of her turning up that night in her beautiful blue dress with gardenias in her hair and how she must have felt as she was shown to that table at the back, unable to sit with her costars it makes me want to weep.

I agree, there's something so sad about this

Heartbreaking isn't it, not to mention that she couldn't even go to the premier in Atlanta with the other stars. How could the other stars do it, Clark Gable was supposed to be her friend.

TheKeatingFive · 04/05/2022 21:15

When you think of her turning up that night in her beautiful blue dress with gardenias in her hair and how she must have felt as she was shown to that table at the back, unable to sit with her costars it makes me want to weep.

I agree, there's something so sad about this

ancientgran · 04/05/2022 21:12

When you think of her turning up that night in her beautiful blue dress with gardenias in her hair and how she must have felt as she was shown to that table at the back, unable to sit with her costars it makes me want to weep.

She died in debt to the IRS and her wish to be buried in the Hollywood Cemetery was denied as it was a segregated cemetery. How sick is that, a segregated cemetery.

TheKeatingFive · 04/05/2022 21:07

Hattie McDaniel first african american to win an oscar... in a ceremony held in a venue that she would otherwise have not been allowed into

I remember reading about this. She was put at the back of the room at a table with only a couple of other black actors/actresses for company, while the white stars had pride of place. Awful.

StrychnineInTheSandwiches · 04/05/2022 21:06

ancientgran · 04/05/2022 21:04

I can cope with the book and film, I loved the film when I first saw it. The thing I couldn't cope with was the way Hattie McDaniel was treated at the Oscars and that her colleagues let it happen. Can't forgive that.

Her story is very sad.

I only read about that recently, that she had to sit in a separate room from the white nominees.

ancientgran · 04/05/2022 21:04

I can cope with the book and film, I loved the film when I first saw it. The thing I couldn't cope with was the way Hattie McDaniel was treated at the Oscars and that her colleagues let it happen. Can't forgive that.

Her story is very sad.

1000yellowdaisies · 04/05/2022 21:04

StrychnineInTheSandwiches · 04/05/2022 21:01

This is an interesting article that focuses on African Americans who protested against Gone With the Wind at the time. So it's not just modern sensibilities seeing it in a 21st century light.

www.nytimes.com/2020/06/14/movies/gone-with-the-wind-battle.html

Thats interesting....

1000yellowdaisies · 04/05/2022 21:02

I loved the book and I LOVE the film. I remember staying up late to watch it with my mum one weekend and being captivated by Scarlett in the red dress
she wears when Rhett forces her to go to Melly's house... Scarlett is tough and strong and scheming and Vivien Leigh is so watchable.

There are bits that are terrible in it. Mainly the marital rape and racism. There was a disclaimer on when beforehand when i last saw it on tv. But you can still enjoy it whilst recognising its faults.
But it is a piece of history in itself.... Hattie McDaniel first african american to win an oscar... in a ceremony held in a venue that she would otherwise have not been allowed into.

I don't agree with cancelling films or books. Its the thin end of the wedge and we'd end up cancelling masterpieces because they dont suit modern sensitivities.

StrychnineInTheSandwiches · 04/05/2022 21:01

This is an interesting article that focuses on African Americans who protested against Gone With the Wind at the time. So it's not just modern sensibilities seeing it in a 21st century light.

www.nytimes.com/2020/06/14/movies/gone-with-the-wind-battle.html

My love of Gone with the Wind and other problematic films/literature
IceandIndigo · 04/05/2022 20:59

To me, my main concern with depictions of racism (or other ‘isms) in fiction would be if the person reading it isn’t aware the attitudes or behaviour depicted are unacceptable today, and therefore might be influenced by them. I’d be more concerned about children reading Enid Blyton than an adult reading GWTW, certainly in your case as you are clearly aware of the problematic aspects.

XelaM · 04/05/2022 20:48

RedSquirrel111 · 04/05/2022 20:09

Interested in other opinions on this.

I first read Gone with the Wind in school and since then have gone through 3 copies. It's my favourite comfort book that I re-read a couple of times a year. I also adore the film, Vivien Leigh and the gorgeous technicolor cinematography.

However it is undeniably and explicitly racist. Both the film and the book, more so the book (if you can measure such things). I fell in love with Scarlett as the first 'fuck you' 3 dimensional female character I'd ever read, and I still love her.

Do you read it as 'a book of its time'? (With a critical eye but still enjoy it?) Or is it one that whilst I don't want to say 'cancelled' should be resigned to history in the way that, say, birth of a nation, has been?

When it comes to artists I'm very much 'separate the art from the creator' and therefore have no problem reading Roald Dahl for example.

However this is different as its the subject matter and not just the author.

I'd especially be grateful for the view of any BAME women - especially if American!!!

I LOVE "Gone With the Wind" - both the novel and the Vivien Leigh film (it's my favourite film of all time next to Godfather). She was the perfect Scarlett (best performance by a female actress ever in my opinion). I think Scarlett O'Hara is the best female heroine of all time. HOWEVER, the novel is quite shocking in its content and certainly romanticises the slave-owning South and the KKK!

I read "Uncle Tom's Cabin" afterwards for the other side of the story. "Uncle Tom's Cabin" over "Gone with the Wind" every time.

LemonDrizzleSlice · 04/05/2022 20:46

I'm not really sure how it's racist? It depicts black people as having injustice done to them, when Scarlett causes the menfolk to go out on her behalf. It shows black enslaved people acting with dignity and grace.

Yes, it shows black servants. But is that inherently racist? It is a snapshot of how things were. It doesn't treat the black characters as "lesser", quite the opposite. Many of the white characters are shown in far worse light.

The exception perhaps is Prissy.