Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My love of Gone with the Wind and other problematic films/literature

113 replies

RedSquirrel111 · 04/05/2022 20:09

Interested in other opinions on this.

I first read Gone with the Wind in school and since then have gone through 3 copies. It's my favourite comfort book that I re-read a couple of times a year. I also adore the film, Vivien Leigh and the gorgeous technicolor cinematography.

However it is undeniably and explicitly racist. Both the film and the book, more so the book (if you can measure such things). I fell in love with Scarlett as the first 'fuck you' 3 dimensional female character I'd ever read, and I still love her.

Do you read it as 'a book of its time'? (With a critical eye but still enjoy it?) Or is it one that whilst I don't want to say 'cancelled' should be resigned to history in the way that, say, birth of a nation, has been?

When it comes to artists I'm very much 'separate the art from the creator' and therefore have no problem reading Roald Dahl for example.

However this is different as its the subject matter and not just the author.

I'd especially be grateful for the view of any BAME women - especially if American!!!

OP posts:
JaninaDuszejko · 05/05/2022 11:30

I think it's a shame Uncle Tom's Cabin is considered somehow offensive. It had a profound effect on me when I read it as a teen. It's so powerful. And of course it was powerful enough to effectively start the Civil War.

I think taste and sensibilities changes so what was powerful and important can become less so with time. But on the other hand there is renewed interest in the autobiographies of people who were enslaved like Frederick Douglass and Olaudah Equiano. They speak to us more now than a novel written by a white woman.

JemmyP · 05/05/2022 11:20

There's also the rape of Scarlett to consider, in finding it problematic as an inspiring story.

Beowulfa · 05/05/2022 11:16

For me, great literature is about complex, conflicted characters. So Scarlett goes on a fantastic feminist journey from spoilt brat to empowered woman, but she's a rich white Southerner whose comfortable upbringing and outlook is founded on slavery. I like to be challenged like this when reading.

I think GWTW offers a powerful counterpoint to other literature depicting the brutal reality of slavery in terms of whippings and physical labour (eg Toni Morrison). It shows what might superficially seem "nice" slave owners, who consider trusted slaves to be "part of the family". There's a sense of incredulity that black people might want more- the ingratitude! I think this insidious attitude is still very much pertinent in modern racial tensions in the US.

boonducks · 05/05/2022 10:52

I think it illustrates the era in a way that no-one could or would do now. So a historical document in more ways than one.

I haven't read GWTW for 40 years but I still have my copy. Time for a reread.

I read crime and thrillers. Doesn't mean I condone murder.

StrychnineInTheSandwiches · 05/05/2022 10:45

I suppose you could argue that Margaret Mitchell was the one trying to sanitise history seeing as the book was written in 1936.

NoviceNetwork · 05/05/2022 10:40

If you watch films with depicting violence, murder, rape, war etc. are you condoning them?

I don’t believe so.

Though I’d say it would be different if someone wrote something obviously racist/sexist/anyotherist today and you supported them by buying their material, you really can’t compare that to classics that are an example of their time.

I think trying to sanitise history, just because it makes us uncomfortable today, is a huge mistake.

CounsellorTroi · 05/05/2022 10:34

But it is a piece of history in itself.... Hattie McDaniel first african american to win an oscar... in a ceremony held in a venue that she would otherwise have not been allowed into.

She was allowed in but had to sit at a segregated table at the side, not where all the white people were sitting. She was also unable to attend the premiere of the film as it was held in a whites only theatre.

Hobbesmanc · 05/05/2022 10:20

I love the sweeping Hollywood grandeur of the film- and of course that score. . I recently tried to reread the book though and found it impossible to wade through. The film is obviously reflective of a shocking era in history and the portrayal of black characters is problematic but the book just champions racism. I won't read it again

emuloc · 05/05/2022 09:17

ancientgran · 04/05/2022 21:04

I can cope with the book and film, I loved the film when I first saw it. The thing I couldn't cope with was the way Hattie McDaniel was treated at the Oscars and that her colleagues let it happen. Can't forgive that.

Her story is very sad.

Yes, not allowed to claim her oscar in the usual way, because she was black. I do believe that Clark Gable was furious, and spoke up about the way she was being treated. He was not silent.

ancientgran · 05/05/2022 09:05

LemonDrizzleSlice · 04/05/2022 22:03

Maybe the redeeming factor is Rhett who saw it all as society bollocks from the start

Of course he is the redeeming factor. He shows the men as being unreasonable when they go out that night. He makes Scarlett face what she has done.

And then he rapes her.

x2boys · 05/05/2022 09:03

ancientgran · 05/05/2022 08:59

Wouldn't it have been lovely if he'd gone and sat with her.

Yes indeed that would have been a meaningful gesture .

ancientgran · 05/05/2022 08:59

x2boys · 05/05/2022 08:55

Apparently Clarke Gabel did offer to boycott the premiere ,but Hattie McDaniel insisted he went ( according to Wikipedia)
But yes she was treated terribly absolutely awful .

Wouldn't it have been lovely if he'd gone and sat with her.

x2boys · 05/05/2022 08:55

ancientgran · 04/05/2022 21:17

Heartbreaking isn't it, not to mention that she couldn't even go to the premier in Atlanta with the other stars. How could the other stars do it, Clark Gable was supposed to be her friend.

Apparently Clarke Gabel did offer to boycott the premiere ,but Hattie McDaniel insisted he went ( according to Wikipedia)
But yes she was treated terribly absolutely awful .

XelaM · 04/05/2022 22:49

On a more lighthearted note, Ashley Wilkes was completely miscast in the film. It was impossible to understand what Scarlett saw in him whereas in the novel (albeit it was annoying) I could understand what drew her to him.

XelaM · 04/05/2022 22:48

JaninaDuszejko · 04/05/2022 21:53

I read "Uncle Tom's Cabin" afterwards for the other side of the story. "Uncle Tom's Cabin" over "Gone with the Wind" every time.

Uncle Tom's Cabin has gone from being the best selling novel in mid Victorian England to barely read now because it too is full of racial stereotypes that we find unacceptable these days. Of course that doesn't stop it being historically important because of its role in the abolitionist movement.

I think it's a shame Uncle Tom's Cabin is considered somehow offensive. It had a profound effect on me when I read it as a teen. It's so powerful. And of course it was powerful enough to effectively start the Civil War.

sweeneytoddsrazor · 04/05/2022 22:47

It should make every young person who reads it ask themselves: in reality if I'd lived then what would I have believed and done?

That is a tough question because time and again we hear people say there is absolutely no way I could ever have done X Y or Z. But the truth is most people will actually conform with the acceptable norms of their society, reading a book like GWTW should make people realise that the past is something we should learn from, something we move on from, so we don't make the same mistakes again.

MichaelAndEagle · 04/05/2022 22:41

I can't remember very well, but doesn't Scarlett start to question her views about slavery and black people?
Isn't part of the books interest that she holds two opposing views, she loves her nanny (i read it a long time ago, can't remember the nanny's name) but also believes slavery is acceptable and black people are inferior to white.

It's the romanticising of it that is shocking and interesting. That complex characters you love, didn't question such evil.

It should make every young person who reads it ask themselves: in reality if I'd lived then what would I have believed and done?

Indeed, throughout history normal people who would consider themselves good, have participated in awful things.
Similarly, would I have sheltered or shopped a Jewish family if I'd lived in Nazi Germany. I know what I want to say..... but I didn't live then and there.

MalagaNights · 04/05/2022 22:24

"I don't support slavery" 🤣
Well done you.

But are you sure? You did enjoy Gone with the Wind.

Sorry @LetitiaLeghorn I know you're being flippant, but that is an example of the inanity we get reduced to.

(For the record, I don't support slavery either)

MalagaNights · 04/05/2022 22:18

You do know the US in the time of slavery was racist right?
And that many/most people thought it was fine?

That is what it depicts.
It's the romanticising of it that is shocking and interesting. That complex characters you love, didn't question such evil.

It should make every young person who reads it ask themselves: in reality if I'd lived then what would I have believed and done?

And that's the important question.
Not: Do you agree with the now current consensus it was deeply evil? That's easy and obvious and tells you nothing about people, the world or yourself.

What's the alternative? Only allow young people to read revised histories which explain everything within the current moral framework?
No old fiction, original texts, dissenting opinion, or 'problematic' texts?

Id confidently say a society which goes down that route is stunted and doomed.

LetitiaLeghorn · 04/05/2022 22:15

Gone with the Wind is one of my favourite books. Mum encouraged me to read it as a teenager and I loved it. But I don't support slavery. If you cancel books, where do you stop? Do you cancel Mozart's operas? Or Shakespeare or Moliere? These were all written in a time when people had different views of life. You can't wipe out all past culture.

LemonDrizzleSlice · 04/05/2022 22:03

Maybe the redeeming factor is Rhett who saw it all as society bollocks from the start

Of course he is the redeeming factor. He shows the men as being unreasonable when they go out that night. He makes Scarlett face what she has done.

RedSquirrel111 · 04/05/2022 21:59

LemonDrizzleSlice · 04/05/2022 21:44

I mean, this is not a hill I'm going to die on, I'm a white woman. But showing racism is not the same as being racist.

But it doesn't show racism... it romanticises slavery. The 'good' slaves like mammy stay with the family.
The ones that wanted freedom are drunk rapists. Hence why the upstanding men like Ashley formed the KKK.
Maybe the redeeming factor is Rhett who saw it all as society bollocks from the start
and swoon over Clarke Gable as if you'd fancy Ashley over Rhett????

OP posts:
JaninaDuszejko · 04/05/2022 21:53

I read "Uncle Tom's Cabin" afterwards for the other side of the story. "Uncle Tom's Cabin" over "Gone with the Wind" every time.

Uncle Tom's Cabin has gone from being the best selling novel in mid Victorian England to barely read now because it too is full of racial stereotypes that we find unacceptable these days. Of course that doesn't stop it being historically important because of its role in the abolitionist movement.

latetothefisting · 04/05/2022 21:52

I agree with other posters - if we cancelled, or just discouraged, consuming any media that doesn't confirm to our current sensibilities it would be really hard for people to ever understand the extent to which various minorities were disadvantaged, and as a result recognise the bravery and effort of those who fought to improve their position and be wary of how important it is to constantly support and protect current rights.

In terms of GWTW specifically, I read a really interesting article on how they adapted some of the problematic elements of the book for the film, OP, if you're interested? It's interesting that there were some 'racist' elements that were considered fine to keep while there was simultaneously others they understood even then would not be ok to have in film, plus the efforts they went to to actively appeal to black viewers, and the contradictory views of contemporaneous black people about the film....
www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/1999/12/gone-with-the-wind-and-hollywoods-racial-politics/377919/

Hmmph · 04/05/2022 21:52

Only by reading actual accounts of the time can you know how things were and learn from it. GWTW is so interesting because of the slavery. It is involved physical violence and cruelty, which is depicted in other books.

But it also involved situations that differed from that - where slaves where treated more like a much loved family pet.

Without that, you think that only mean nasty people had slaves and therefore now, in the modern world, you're safe from being racist as you're a 'nice' person. But knowing about slaves as being like a much loved family pet opens your eyes to how easy it was to think slavery was ok and how nice people can be racist, even whilst being nice. That racism and slavery didn't have to be cruel to happen.

Hope that makes sense.