Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My love of Gone with the Wind and other problematic films/literature

113 replies

RedSquirrel111 · 04/05/2022 20:09

Interested in other opinions on this.

I first read Gone with the Wind in school and since then have gone through 3 copies. It's my favourite comfort book that I re-read a couple of times a year. I also adore the film, Vivien Leigh and the gorgeous technicolor cinematography.

However it is undeniably and explicitly racist. Both the film and the book, more so the book (if you can measure such things). I fell in love with Scarlett as the first 'fuck you' 3 dimensional female character I'd ever read, and I still love her.

Do you read it as 'a book of its time'? (With a critical eye but still enjoy it?) Or is it one that whilst I don't want to say 'cancelled' should be resigned to history in the way that, say, birth of a nation, has been?

When it comes to artists I'm very much 'separate the art from the creator' and therefore have no problem reading Roald Dahl for example.

However this is different as its the subject matter and not just the author.

I'd especially be grateful for the view of any BAME women - especially if American!!!

OP posts:
Ratrick · 05/05/2022 16:56

NrlySp · 04/05/2022 20:13

You are aware of the issues. Presumably you are not racist after reading it? The world has learnt to be better with that particular issue (even though slavery in other forms still exists) and as Churchill said 'a Nation that forgets it’s past has no future'

Bit of a detail but Churchill never said that. It was a meme dreamed up by the American right in 2020, to try and give added legitimacy to their arguments against removing confederate statue.

XelaM · 05/05/2022 16:23

PussGirl · 05/05/2022 15:09

Gone With The Wind is one of my favourite books too - I didn't like the follow-up, Scarlett, at all, however - a watered down PC version written for a modern audience.

The "follow up" (not written by MM) was awful!

Everyone wanted to get MM to write a final happy ending chapter but she refused. In fact, I think she wrote the last chapter first, so she knew from the start there would be no happy ending

dreamingbohemian · 05/05/2022 16:22

The racism is completely undeniable. My question is if you can still enjoy it.

I mean.... really OP?

Yes, I think historical books should be kept available as something to be taught and learned from. I'm not saying they should be burned or anything like that.

But that is very different from, as you say, wearing out three copies of a book because you love it so much you keep reading it for enjoyment. I genuinely don't understand how you can love reading a book that is thoroughly racist, that presents the KKK as a good and honourable thing. That plays a huge role in Dixie nostalgia, which props up white nationalists to this day.

I'm a white American and I would seriously side-eye any other American who told me they love this book and re-read it all the time. I understand it might not be so obvious for Brits. But maybe have a think about it.

emuloc · 05/05/2022 16:05

Thehundredthnamechange · 05/05/2022 16:01

Perhaps we should destroy all literature that doesn't fit in today, which will probably be anything published pre-2020? In fact, perhaps we should just erase all of history?

Maybe you should relax a bit, you sound het up.

StrychnineInTheSandwiches · 05/05/2022 16:05

Mandodari · 05/05/2022 14:46

@StrychnineInTheSandwiches
So very true, I love the fact that QV was the epitome of family life and motherhood but in truth was a tyrant who referred to her babies as frogs and thought they were too repulsive to look at until they were six months old!

she (and a lot of her relatives) certainly had a frogginess about the eyes!

StrychnineInTheSandwiches · 05/05/2022 16:03

Thehundredthnamechange · 05/05/2022 16:01

Perhaps we should destroy all literature that doesn't fit in today, which will probably be anything published pre-2020? In fact, perhaps we should just erase all of history?

the hysterics have commenced

Thehundredthnamechange · 05/05/2022 16:01

Perhaps we should destroy all literature that doesn't fit in today, which will probably be anything published pre-2020? In fact, perhaps we should just erase all of history?

emuloc · 05/05/2022 16:01

PussGirl · 05/05/2022 15:09

Gone With The Wind is one of my favourite books too - I didn't like the follow-up, Scarlett, at all, however - a watered down PC version written for a modern audience.

Nothing wrong with that at all.

PussGirl · 05/05/2022 15:09

Gone With The Wind is one of my favourite books too - I didn't like the follow-up, Scarlett, at all, however - a watered down PC version written for a modern audience.

JaninaDuszejko · 05/05/2022 14:49

MsTSwift · 05/05/2022 14:23

We were watching Yes Minister the other day and there was a totally racist joke. Our 13 year old was horrified couldn’t believe e it was on tv. Our explanation that it was of it’s time sounded rather lame

DD (14) and I have been watching Young Sheldon and while it's a modern programme it's set in the 80s and DD was horrified at some of the main characters saying well meaning but ignorant comments that we would now consider microagressions. I should point out for those that haven't seen it that we are absolutely expected to be see these comments as of their time. As someone who remembers the 80s I found DDs response quite enlightening on how far we've moved (e.g. I know my Mum wouldn't think there was anything wrong with what was said because the characters were being polite and welcoming).

DD also finds the sexist and homophobic jokes in Friends quite shocking, I'm 100% with her there. I'm surprised that it is still so popular actually, it's looking very dated.

Mandodari · 05/05/2022 14:46

@StrychnineInTheSandwiches
So very true, I love the fact that QV was the epitome of family life and motherhood but in truth was a tyrant who referred to her babies as frogs and thought they were too repulsive to look at until they were six months old!

StrychnineInTheSandwiches · 05/05/2022 14:41

Her attitude towards children was they were an unfortunate bi product of sex rather than something she wanted.

Sounds like Queen Victoria...

JemmyP · 05/05/2022 14:34

Mandodari · 05/05/2022 14:10

@JemmyP
I can't remember that bit. All I remember is Scarletts duel thinking when it came to marriage. When she was single, she mocked the married women and how dull and fat they were yet saw marriage as first an escape route and secondly as a conveyance. Her attitude towards children was they were an unfortunate bi product of sex rather than something she wanted.

Yes. It was a 'refreshingly' different portrayal of motherhood, especially for its time.

MsTSwift · 05/05/2022 14:23

We were watching Yes Minister the other day and there was a totally racist joke. Our 13 year old was horrified couldn’t believe e it was on tv. Our explanation that it was of it’s time sounded rather lame

Mandodari · 05/05/2022 14:10

@JemmyP
I can't remember that bit. All I remember is Scarletts duel thinking when it came to marriage. When she was single, she mocked the married women and how dull and fat they were yet saw marriage as first an escape route and secondly as a conveyance. Her attitude towards children was they were an unfortunate bi product of sex rather than something she wanted.

JemmyP · 05/05/2022 13:28

Mandodari · 05/05/2022 13:06

@XelaM
They also left Scarletts other children out and what a truly terrible mother she was.

Weren't they practically running Tara at the point she left with Rhett. I wondered what reception she'd have been given returning there after Rhett left her.

XelaM · 05/05/2022 13:12

Mandodari · 05/05/2022 13:06

@XelaM
They also left Scarletts other children out and what a truly terrible mother she was.

Yes, definitely. She had two other kids with Charles and Frank, but I could kind of see why the film thought they were unimportant enough to leave out. Scarlett didn't think much of them 😂

Mandodari · 05/05/2022 13:06

@XelaM
They also left Scarletts other children out and what a truly terrible mother she was.

Mandodari · 05/05/2022 12:55

@MichaelAndEagle
I always thought the relationship between Mammy and Scarlett to be one of the most fascinating aspects of the book. It was clear that Mammy was a slave but she had the ability to control Scarlett and Scarlett really needed her as an ally, as a confidante and as a mother figure. Rhett wanted her to have a good opinion of him so he saw her as some one worthy of respect. I used to wonder why, when the option of freedom was available, why did Prissy and the others remain. It wasn't until I was watching an episode of Blackish that I heard of neo slavery and how that continued up to the 1930s.

XelaM · 05/05/2022 12:31

On the subject of the film, my other disappointment about the film (aside from Ashley) were that the Tarleton brothers - who were my favourite characters in the novel - were almost non-existent in the film bar the first scene.

XelaM · 05/05/2022 12:26

slaves*

XelaM · 05/05/2022 12:26

JaninaDuszejko · 05/05/2022 11:30

I think it's a shame Uncle Tom's Cabin is considered somehow offensive. It had a profound effect on me when I read it as a teen. It's so powerful. And of course it was powerful enough to effectively start the Civil War.

I think taste and sensibilities changes so what was powerful and important can become less so with time. But on the other hand there is renewed interest in the autobiographies of people who were enslaved like Frederick Douglass and Olaudah Equiano. They speak to us more now than a novel written by a white woman.

I found Uncle Tom's Cabin very powerful. It showed how there were "nice" slave owners who treated their slaves well, but because slaves were considered property- when anything happened to the "nice" owners (death/bankruptcy/divorce) saves were then passed on just like other assets were and could end up anywhere.

XelaM · 05/05/2022 12:22

Yes, Rhett is definitely written as the good guy despite the rape.

As for the film, I think the casting was superb except Ashley! It was impossible to understand what Scarlett saw in Ashley in the film. Who would posters have cast as Ashley Wilkes if they had the choice?

Mandodari · 05/05/2022 12:13

I think context is everything. TCM recently showed GWTW. Before it was broadcast, there was programme explaining the facts of slavery, the fact that the book was written in 1936 and it wasn't a contemporary account and also covered the disgusting treatment of Hattie McDaniels. I think, but can't be certain, that use of the n word was removed. I think that explaining the context of the film, highlighting its historical inaccuracies and discussing how society has changed or not is a better move that saying ban it.

Ponoka7 · 05/05/2022 11:31

I'm not black, but I'm of Native American descent. It grates when I see the santitized, racist versions of cowboy films, but they are of their time and should still be available. It bothers me that some cowboy/Indian shows are still in operation, they are actually depicting a genocede and ethnic cleansing. Likewise Canada being seen as so much more civilised than the US, yet it hides its treatment of first nation people.
If we banned every sexist book then there'd be very few available and why shouldn't we take the same stance against sexism? I think education is always the key and for any young people starting off reading the classics etc, a wide range of reading material and it being discussed.