Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My love of Gone with the Wind and other problematic films/literature

113 replies

RedSquirrel111 · 04/05/2022 20:09

Interested in other opinions on this.

I first read Gone with the Wind in school and since then have gone through 3 copies. It's my favourite comfort book that I re-read a couple of times a year. I also adore the film, Vivien Leigh and the gorgeous technicolor cinematography.

However it is undeniably and explicitly racist. Both the film and the book, more so the book (if you can measure such things). I fell in love with Scarlett as the first 'fuck you' 3 dimensional female character I'd ever read, and I still love her.

Do you read it as 'a book of its time'? (With a critical eye but still enjoy it?) Or is it one that whilst I don't want to say 'cancelled' should be resigned to history in the way that, say, birth of a nation, has been?

When it comes to artists I'm very much 'separate the art from the creator' and therefore have no problem reading Roald Dahl for example.

However this is different as its the subject matter and not just the author.

I'd especially be grateful for the view of any BAME women - especially if American!!!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Vikinga · 10/05/2022 05:20

I loved that film as a teen. I loved all historical romances/films and was in love with Rhett and though Scarlett was so beautiful. Her child dying was heart breaking.

I want to watch it again with adults eyes.

However in terms of being horrified, I have been horrified by the xenophobia and racism I have witnessed in recent years when we should know better. The condemnation of muslims. The lack of humanity and help towards refugees like the Syrians. Brexit and the hatred towards eastern Europeans.

We grew up learning about the horrors of slavery. About nazis and ethnic cleansing. We have a world of knowledge at our fingertips, yet, a little propaganda by odious white men and so many people support it. That's what has really worried me in recent years. Before I would have bet my life that it would never happen in our society and in our times.

People are sheep and most follow the crowd. They are self serving and are willing to sacrifice others wellbeing (people, animals, planet) for their own comfort.

The way animals are abused and yet we still consume them, leaves me speechless too. How can you see footage of these sentient creatures being tortured and yet be happy to eat them?

My friend's white, educated father told her that white hetero men are being hard done by now. People are so deluded that it is mind boggling.

I can excuse people who lived in a time when there wasnt all this knowledge at hand. Where conditions were a lot more different but for it to happen now is unforgivable.

Indicatrice · 10/05/2022 04:44

ancientgran · 05/05/2022 17:35

He might not have been silent but he still sat at the big "white" table.

Exactly @ancientgran

Indicatrice · 10/05/2022 04:38

LemonDrizzleSlice · 04/05/2022 21:24

Yes, read the book when I was a teen and seen the film a few times.

Perhaps I remember what I saw in it, rather than what was there. IYKWIM?

Then perhaps you should read it again before saying it’s not racist?

Ratrick · 10/05/2022 02:16

Is anyone calling for it to be banned?

LeavesOnTrees · 09/05/2022 23:25

It's easy to look back on slavery and think it was, quite rightly, horrendous and that we'd never accept it now. What is harder, is to answer the question of how on earth it was allowed to go on for so long. How can humans commit such awful atrocities.

GWTW is from the perspective of a spoilt plantation owner's daughter. She was brought up with slavery being a part of life and acceptable. It takes a lot of insight to truly question what is deemed normal in your lifetime. GWTW is interesting from this angle.
I don't think books should ever be banned.

XelaM · 09/05/2022 08:19

Classica · 09/05/2022 01:06

I do think a lot of people think GWTW was written during or soon after the Civil War, rather than in 1936.

Margaret Mitchell based her novel on the accounts of Southern soldiers/contemporaries who lived during the war. It wasn't too long after the war. The war ended in 1865 and she was born in 1900, so she grew up with stories of the war and the old South.

Ratrick · 09/05/2022 01:08

NannyGythaOgg · 09/05/2022 01:03

Doing what I hate here as I haven't read the full thread - but read the first few pages

BUT
Shakespeare, Dickens et al. We know life is not like that now - even were there are uncomfortable comparisons. It does't stop us appreciating their version of what happened then - Dickens particularly.

I'm old and I watch the 'it was alright in the xxs' and sometimes I agree and sometimes I think 'it still should be' (maybe rarely). But I also see things happening now that I am damn sure are going to be questionable in a few years time. Things that younger people than me think are fine and I know won't be.

Slavery is worse than most/all of these but we can't know what we don't know. And hindsight is always 20-20 (or 8-8 in modern terms)

As pointed out on the first page, GWTW was protested for being racist at the time of its release (well, at least by the time of the movie’s release). I guess the difference is that the majority of US society still thought racism was okay in the 30s. All to say, while standards (particularly among white people) have changed somewhat, it was always a controversial book.

Classica · 09/05/2022 01:06

I do think a lot of people think GWTW was written during or soon after the Civil War, rather than in 1936.

NannyGythaOgg · 09/05/2022 01:03

Doing what I hate here as I haven't read the full thread - but read the first few pages

BUT
Shakespeare, Dickens et al. We know life is not like that now - even were there are uncomfortable comparisons. It does't stop us appreciating their version of what happened then - Dickens particularly.

I'm old and I watch the 'it was alright in the xxs' and sometimes I agree and sometimes I think 'it still should be' (maybe rarely). But I also see things happening now that I am damn sure are going to be questionable in a few years time. Things that younger people than me think are fine and I know won't be.

Slavery is worse than most/all of these but we can't know what we don't know. And hindsight is always 20-20 (or 8-8 in modern terms)

MangyInseam · 09/05/2022 00:33

Really OP, if you can't read and enjoy that, you can't read and enjoy most literature written more than five minutes ago.

LetitiaLeghorn · 09/05/2022 00:14

@dreamingbohemian Put me on the side eye list because I love Gone with the Wind. 😔

dropthevipers · 08/05/2022 23:57

Race has always been america's besetting sin. Check this out-massive popular hit only 30+ years before GWTW. prepare to be shocked/amazed this ever got published-voices.pitt.edu/TeachersGuide/Unit%206/AllCoonsLookAliketoMe.htm

LeniGray · 08/05/2022 22:58

I don’t agree with cancelling books. Not read GWTW but I still have a collection of Tintin books from many years ago, that I’ll dip into once in a while. Some character depictions are problematic, however it doesn’t stop me enjoying them. They’re a product of a particular time, and I think societies that start trying to erase uncomfortable parts of history reflected in literature or art are going in a backwards direction.

XelaM · 08/05/2022 22:44

Branleuse · 06/05/2022 09:21

I absolutely loved the book, but have never seen the film. It didnt even occur to me how racist it was, but so much flies over my head. I guess thats part of the problem

Omg you have never seen Gone with the wind?!?! It's one of the best films of all time and Vivien Leigh's performance of Scarlett is the best performance by a female actress ever in my opinion.

Brainwave89 · 06/05/2022 09:38

I am ethnically Indian. Generally I do not favour censorship for old movies and books where the context or writing presents issues such as stereotyping or negative portrayals. I think you simply read understanding the historic background and context. Most books and films these days would contain some warning upfront of inappropriate language or content. Literature in particular is quite a good way of demonstrating how casual racism was even in relatively recent times.

Branleuse · 06/05/2022 09:21

I absolutely loved the book, but have never seen the film. It didnt even occur to me how racist it was, but so much flies over my head. I guess thats part of the problem

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 05/05/2022 20:50

As my name suggests I have a love of GWTW. But mostly as a romance with good characters. I too loved Scarlett as a kick ass woman who didn't live by the rules of society. Nowadays though I see that she's just selfish & spoilt. But I still enjoy it.

Whilst the lionisation of the KKK is awful it does give a human story that I think is interesting. It shows how everyone sees things from a pretty selfish perspective. The former plantation owners have not a moment's pause for how they treated their slaves, Ashley aside. But to defend 'their own' they rally together to 'fight back'. And it's shown as reasonable and justified.

Books give a window into the lives and thinking of people not like you. That's why they are awesome. We suspend our disbelief and build empathy (or rage!) as we find characters we liked are flawed and human.

Although all that said I do love a bit of Rhett Butler action 😁

Pemba · 05/05/2022 18:57

Oh thanks Strychnine. I had forgotten. I suppose the BBC thought it was good cheap programming that would reel viewers in to vote etc. Well I quite enjoyed it at the time. They also did 20 (or 50) greatest Britons. Who won, Churchill?

StrychnineInTheSandwiches · 05/05/2022 18:52

I remember that, @pemba. I have a feeling Tolkien or CS Lewis came in at the top spot.

Pemba · 05/05/2022 18:52

She should have had the humanity and empathy to know that the KKK was evil. She must have been aware of lynchings of black Americans that were happening during her lifetime. Plus the rise of fascism in Europe etc. If she was an intelligent woman, aware of the world around her.

I don't know about the Pulitzer prize, I suppose they awarded it because 1
GWTW was outstandingly popular at the time. 2. It dealt with 'big themes' - the American Civil war. However reading it today it doesn't seem to have much literary merit IMHO.

I think of the pro KKK film 'Birth of a Nation' which was also lauded as an artist masterpiece at the time, but now is just a historic curiosity.

Allywill · 05/05/2022 18:37

It’s a bit more than a “bodice ripper” - it won the Pulitzer Prize. And Margaret Mitchell was born in 1900 and started writing GWTW in 1926 - in a world where black civil rights didn’t really exist and segregation and discrimination was very much a fact of life.

Pemba · 05/05/2022 18:01

I tried to read it once but found Margaret Mitchell's glorification of the KKK etc very distasteful. I was surprised because it was listed in the BBC's 'Top Fifty Books of all time' or similar title. It was on about 15 years ago. It was a series with different celebrities doing presentations advocating different books, then viewers could vote for the winner. Anyone else remember that? (GWTW wasn't the winner, can't remember what was now).

I wouldn't want it banned or anything (slippery slope) but I think that, like a pp said, it will probably become less and less popular over the years. Hopefully. It is just a historical bodice-ripper really, hardly great literature. And I don't know about it being 'of its time', the storyline does take place in the 1860s, but don't forget Margaret Mitchell was writing in the 1930s and should have known better. Shame on her really.

ancientgran · 05/05/2022 17:35

emuloc · 05/05/2022 09:17

Yes, not allowed to claim her oscar in the usual way, because she was black. I do believe that Clark Gable was furious, and spoke up about the way she was being treated. He was not silent.

He might not have been silent but he still sat at the big "white" table.

Allywill · 05/05/2022 17:12

Ashley explicitly says in the book that he would have freed all the slaves of the war hadn’t done so. Scarlett is a hard hearted bitch who not only steals her sisters husband but also uses and condones abuse of convict labour - Margaret Mitchell is on record as saying she always saw Melanie as the heroine not Scarlett.

Ratrick · 05/05/2022 16:57

Derail not detail.