Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is cruel for a puppy?

82 replies

walkingonnete · 04/05/2022 18:53

My sister shares a 9 year old daughter with her ex - they coparent very well and they get on great as friends - for instance, they will have a coffee and a chat at drop offs etc.

My niece is an only child and has been asking for a puppy. Both my sister and ex BIL want a dog but are unable to do it alone so they agreed on a puppy shared between two houses. Basically the puppy will be with my sister on the nights she has niece and the puppy with be with ex BIL the nights he has niece.

They got the puppy last week and she is so tiny and sister has just called me and said she has dropped her off there and is a bag of nerves. She has been training her etc and it's been going well but she's worried about leaving her.

I have told sister this will never work, I have had dogs all my adult life and they need consistency. They will never know their owner if they are here, there and everywhere. I also can't imagine getting a puppy, building a bond then leaving them to go to a random house.

It breaks my heart thinking how confused this poor puppy will be tonight.

The puppy is at ex BIL tonight then back with sister tomorrow then back with ex BIL on Friday until Monday. How can that not be confusing to the pup?

I give it a few months before they have to re home. It won't work but she is adamant it will. AIBU?

OP posts:
JoeGoldberg · 04/05/2022 20:31

HandbagsnGladrags · 04/05/2022 20:26

I think it's done in the parents benefit not the kids in the majority of cases, and that having a regular stable consistent base to call home is not to be underrated.

Appreciate it's not the optimum family life for a child but do you suggest that women stay in abusive marriages for the sake of the child? I speak as someone who was in that situation, and the only damage my child has suffered from it (now grown up) is at the hands of her controlling father who she now refuses to see. Consequently, I'm not 'tied to him forever' as another poster has suggested.

No that's not what that poster was saying. I also fled with my DC from an abusive marriage and whilst life was a nightmare for a while (trying to find us somewhere to live, applying for benefits plus the ptsd fall out), it was 100% with it.

The stable home is with me, on my own, with me exh on the very periphery only occasionally having our DC.

Foodbanksshouldbeobsolete · 04/05/2022 20:29

I do think there are occasions in which it can work with children and that is when the child has the right level of emotionally resilience, intellectual capacity and an equally strong relationship/attachment with both parents (who have always had a 50:50 role in care giving and carrying the mental load which is rare in couples which end in divorce in the first place), and who have a good coparenting relationship. But having it as the standard when the conditions are not normally ideal for such an arrangement is not done for the child IMO. It's for the parents to feel it's equal (even when it's not and their roles have always been different eg. One in the nurturing role and one in the providing role). It doesn't work so well with babies because they are more primal in their instincts and they don't form relationships in a more complex way yet. Puppies and dogs too actually are much more like that, they like to know who the leader/provider of food and care is and chopping and changing that is not to the dogs benefit but to the joint owners. More capacity for a situation where the dog has had a couple owning until they are an adult dog and then they split up and share the dog, than with a puppy. But still less than ideal and not really in the dogs interests.

walkingonnete · 04/05/2022 20:27

Foodbanksshouldbeobsolete · 04/05/2022 20:17

The alternative would be for them to have one home and see the other parent in that home, outside the home or for occasional overnights/holidays but that they have a consistent base. The only way I would inflict 50:50 or close on a child is if it was court ordered, as much as I think it's so important for establishing their attachment in early life it is just as important in older kids to have a base. I grew up in nearly 50:50 and ended up agoraphobic and at one house. I refused to go to school or would leave school early so that I wouldn't be picked up and go to the house I was unhappier at.
Not just my experience, either a lot of kids really struggle/struggled as kids. Jacqueline Wilson book 'the suitcase kid' captures well the feeling of homelessness. Grown ups all talked about having and two of everything. For me it always felt like having half of everything. As soon as I was settled in one home and routine I would be ripped out of it. I think it's done in the parents benefit not the kids in the majority of cases, and that having a regular stable consistent base to call home is not to be underrated.

In fairness my niece does have a stable household, she's with my sister most of the month, with her dad around 8 nights. Nothing else for it, she still needs to see her dad. However not sure how it works for a puppy, differently I'd imagine.

OP posts:
HandbagsnGladrags · 04/05/2022 20:26

I think it's done in the parents benefit not the kids in the majority of cases, and that having a regular stable consistent base to call home is not to be underrated.

Appreciate it's not the optimum family life for a child but do you suggest that women stay in abusive marriages for the sake of the child? I speak as someone who was in that situation, and the only damage my child has suffered from it (now grown up) is at the hands of her controlling father who she now refuses to see. Consequently, I'm not 'tied to him forever' as another poster has suggested.

JoeGoldberg · 04/05/2022 20:25

@Foodbanksshouldbeobsolete I actually agree with you btw, I wasn't trying to be goady I just wondered if we shared the same mindset. Luckily my exh didn't want anywhere near 50/50 - he has DC occasionally on an ad hoc basis - but if he had wanted it he'd have had to take me to court to gain it. Sorry not sorry. I firmly believe kids need a stable base.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 04/05/2022 20:25

My own dog stays with my in-laws during the week while we work - he has different rules in each house and manages just fine.

At home, he's allowed on furniture, upstairs etc. - that's not allowed at the in-laws and he knows he has to sleep on the floor or in his bed there. It didn't take long for FIL to train him and he seems just as happy there as he is here.

Foodbanksshouldbeobsolete · 04/05/2022 20:17

The alternative would be for them to have one home and see the other parent in that home, outside the home or for occasional overnights/holidays but that they have a consistent base. The only way I would inflict 50:50 or close on a child is if it was court ordered, as much as I think it's so important for establishing their attachment in early life it is just as important in older kids to have a base. I grew up in nearly 50:50 and ended up agoraphobic and at one house. I refused to go to school or would leave school early so that I wouldn't be picked up and go to the house I was unhappier at.
Not just my experience, either a lot of kids really struggle/struggled as kids. Jacqueline Wilson book 'the suitcase kid' captures well the feeling of homelessness. Grown ups all talked about having and two of everything. For me it always felt like having half of everything. As soon as I was settled in one home and routine I would be ripped out of it. I think it's done in the parents benefit not the kids in the majority of cases, and that having a regular stable consistent base to call home is not to be underrated.

JoeGoldberg · 04/05/2022 20:15

walkingonnete · 04/05/2022 20:02

@JoeGoldberg that she lives in one home?

But it's absolutely none of your business. If your niece manages it ok then so will a puppy.

And actually I was asking that poster what they'd suggest re. children not living between two houses. Because when a marriage ends that tends to be the only option.

TheIoWfairy · 04/05/2022 20:06

I have had my mum's dog to stay occasionally since about 6 months old, no problem. Dog has learned that stairs are ok here, but not there, and knows 'pavement etiquette' required at ours - dog is happy everywhere, with everyone. Arrangement seems to suit all. Just make 'house rules' clear to puppy and they'll be ok.

PleasantFucker · 04/05/2022 20:06

But it's none of your business whether the parents will be still tied together when the kid turns 18🥴

tothemoonandbackbuses · 04/05/2022 20:05

I think it will be fine. If they always send it’s bed and toys with it and have the same food bowls etc if will help.
when we got our first puppy as children many years ago we were all going to London for the day a couple of weeks later. So my parents booked the puppy into the kennels for a couple of nights, people were horrified such a young pup was going into kennels. Pup was fine, very much fussed over in the kennels because they didn’t get such young ones. Now leaving pups in daycare in normal

cats are also fine between two houses as we frequently have a relatives cat when they go on holiday. The cat knows exactly where he is and is quite happy

Hallyup89 · 04/05/2022 20:05

I think it would be more unkind to have it in one house for a few weeks until it's trained and settled and then send it somewhere else. It'll seem like it's leaving it's mother again.

Better to get it used to it's routine from the beginning.

HairyBum · 04/05/2022 20:03

Pup will be fine. Your sister gas her most of the month. Lots of dogs go elsewhere for care or visits

walkingonnete · 04/05/2022 20:02

@JoeGoldberg that she lives in one home?

OP posts:
JoeGoldberg · 04/05/2022 20:01

Foodbanksshouldbeobsolete · 04/05/2022 19:58

I agree
I don't think it works well for most kids either to be split between two homes, but am ready to have my arse handed to me for that unpopular opinion.

What's the other option then? Genuine question.

Foodbanksshouldbeobsolete · 04/05/2022 19:58

I agree
I don't think it works well for most kids either to be split between two homes, but am ready to have my arse handed to me for that unpopular opinion.

Honeyroar · 04/05/2022 19:56

As long as both homes want, love and care for the dog I think it will be fine. It might take a tad longer for the pup to settle and be trained but dogs are very adaptable. Many dogs spend time with dog sitters quite happily. I had cabin crew friends that left their dogs with sitters for days. The dogs were perfectly happy.
As for your comments about them still being tied together in nine years time when the child is 18, they have a daughter! They’ll be tied in some ways forever. It’s good if they can work together.

And you sound rather judgemental!

Aprilx · 04/05/2022 19:56

That would be very unkind to do to a cat, but I would have thought a dog would cope.

DinoRock · 04/05/2022 19:49

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 04/05/2022 19:48

But a 12 week old puppy isn't the equivalent of a human newborn.

At 12 weeks, a puppy is old enough to be left alone for very short periods, to go on walks, to attend daycare, to socialise with other dogs.

Nothing bad will happen because the puppy lives in two different homes - if anything, it will be hugely beneficial as the puppy will have two, wonderful homes to go and lots of people to socialise and spend time with.

Yes my mistake, its been so long since I had a dog in my life .

DinoRock · 04/05/2022 19:48

OfstedOffred · 04/05/2022 19:46

Dinorock

This isnt a newborn puppy. It's a weaned puppy old enough to have left its mother.

Ah yes fair point. Ignore me. If its fine for a 1 year old child it's fine for a dog.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 04/05/2022 19:48

DinoRock · 04/05/2022 19:40

I would personally think for the first few months of its life it should be in one home. Its been removed from its mother. It needs to feel safe. Then once settled there then it's time to introduce the 2nd home. Much like a newborn baby wouldn't be sent between homes.

But a 12 week old puppy isn't the equivalent of a human newborn.

At 12 weeks, a puppy is old enough to be left alone for very short periods, to go on walks, to attend daycare, to socialise with other dogs.

Nothing bad will happen because the puppy lives in two different homes - if anything, it will be hugely beneficial as the puppy will have two, wonderful homes to go and lots of people to socialise and spend time with.

LunchBoxPolice · 04/05/2022 19:47

It’s a dog, it’ll be fine. It might be good for your niece to have the continuity of the dog going between homes with her (although you don’t seem bothered about your niece having the upheaval of two homes, only the dog..)

OfstedOffred · 04/05/2022 19:46

Dinorock

This isnt a newborn puppy. It's a weaned puppy old enough to have left its mother.

OfstedOffred · 04/05/2022 19:45

Human children are sent to nurseries, childminders, for sleepovers at grandparents, swap between divorced parents homes, all from young ages.

And you are more worried about the puppy? It'll be fine as long as they are consistent with rules/training.

DinoRock · 04/05/2022 19:40

I would personally think for the first few months of its life it should be in one home. Its been removed from its mother. It needs to feel safe. Then once settled there then it's time to introduce the 2nd home. Much like a newborn baby wouldn't be sent between homes.

Swipe left for the next trending thread