Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU of is BUPA Insurance a waste?

59 replies

bloodynewusernameagain · 04/05/2022 15:34

I'm 39, currently pregnant. Have BUPA Health insurance

I took out insurance via BUPA and disclosed a previous UTI and the policy was confirmed stating they won't cover anything(!) in my abdomen. Which for a starter I thought was pretty shit if all I had was a UTI, don't 50% of women have one at some point in their lives?!

So I thought fuck it I'll cancel, then Covid hit and I thought I'll wait 'til the pandemic ends and cancel - not that I could really see any benefit to the cover re. Covid but just in case of cancer, NHS being under stress re. Covid etc etc. Then at the beginning of this year I became pregnant and thought well finally I might find some benefit to having private insurance. There doesn't seem to be anything at all - no option of getting anything (even paying a top up/supplementary/addition bit) birth wise, post-natal physical issues, neo-natal, anything.

Am I completely missing the point of private health coverage? It is about £70 per month and all I can think that it covers is cancer?

I keep uhhming and ahhing over whether to cancel. Please help me decide!

YABU - Keep the coverage you'd be a fool to lose the 2 years cover built upnow
YANBU - Waste of money/private health insurance is a rip off

Thank you!

OP posts:
Tyrellius · 21/06/2022 02:52

So what is the best private healthcare company in the UK? I might have to take the hit and pay for it too, after the last few NHS shambles.

Brainwave89 · 05/05/2022 12:08

I have had good use of health insurance over the years. My father in particular had two knee operations that he would have waited at least a year for. it made a big difference to his life quality. On the limitations and exclusions I think you do need to be aware of these. In particular mental health is excluded from most general policies as is pregnancy and pre-existing conditions. It is possible to find policies which will provide cover for these elements but they are very expensive.

edwinbear · 05/05/2022 11:59

I had a surgical repair of a prolapse, caused from childbirth, paid for by medical insurance. DS also had his undescended testicle corrected at 9 months via medical insurance, I've had a number of scans and investigations covered as well, I wouldn't be without it personally. Although it's primarily paid for by my work with a small top up contribution from me.

BigWoollyJumpers · 05/05/2022 11:55

It was also cumbersome and time consuming to use since you can't self refer to a specialist in this country but first have to go through your GP and so on

One benefit of the pandemic is that you don't need to go via GP anymore. Just call up BUPA and self refer. It's marvellous.

Justincase77 · 04/05/2022 17:55

We got BUPA mainly in case we need cancer treatment. In fact DH did, with chemo assigned at one of the country’s leading NHS cancer centres. But they said there would be a delay because of backlog and he could not afford that. We said fine, we have BUPA which will authorise this through your private clinic They called back the next day with a place the following week. BUPA paid £100/session cash back for the chemo.

BTW the NHS care was exemplary. BUPA has gotten rather expensive. But as hypocritical as I feel keeping it, it may have saved the life of DH and with cancer and surgical backlogs now worse we may need it in the future. So it is worth it for us. But we are older than you

Matchingcollarandcuffs · 04/05/2022 17:47

I have just been discharged from a private hospital today after private ankle surgery yesterday. I would still be waiting to see a Consultant on NHS. I fell last year and shredded my ligaments. All the post op physio would be covered too. I've paid in £2700 over 2 years (£110 a month for family of 5), took it out at beginning of Covid after have a sense that the NHS would be decimated. My op would have been £6k+ and then there's the cost of the consultant spots, MRI, physio etc.

I get private GP so have used that too for DD when I couldn't get her in with our normal GP, but cost of meds privately is high. Her antibiotics were £19, and I'm having to pay £58 for 2 weeks blood thinning injections and a week's painkillers.

If my premiums go up loads in October I'll cancel, most of my health issues wouldn't be covered as pre existing, was just 'luck' it was an accident

Inkyblue123 · 04/05/2022 17:34

Yes. I have it as a work benefit for at least 5 years and never been able to use it - pregnancy and exclusions . But the NHS is soo crap at the moment I would be worri d about not having it. I’ve paid for private paediatric for my DC a couple of times. If I were paying out of my own packet I would be looking for other providers - Bupa seem
particularly expensive or maybe self insure

Crazycatlady83 · 04/05/2022 17:24

Doesn't it depend on the level of cover you have? We have ours through my husbands employment. It's pretty comprehensive. In the last year, I have claimed due to a skin problem and back problems whilst pregnant (I had physio for my back) We also claimed when our baby was experiencing vomiting (worried it was reflux) So far we have had 5 consultants appointments, skin testing and blood testing. Our lovely consultant diagnosed a CMPA and our baby is so much better now! We would have been lost on the NHS waiting list for ages if we didn't have it.

eatingapie · 04/05/2022 17:24

IME Bupa are not good and also making the sector a bit shitter for everyone (I’m a bit out of touch now though as have a different job)- they are eroding some of the standards people expect from private health insurance (IMO!). Insurance is good for minor/moderate health complaints that the NHS will put off for as long as possible. A few years ago cancer treatment would be quicker on the NHS but that might not be the case now.

AchatAVendre · 04/05/2022 17:22

I think the only way to use private health insurance in this country is to take it out, get a couple of surgeries and then stop it when the premiums go up.

A lot of people think this is what healthcare systems in Europe mean - premiums go up if you've had a condition or surgery or whatever, but in most cases they are prevented from doing so by law.

I had good treatment from AXA but it went up to £200 per month after one surgery and I stopped it. It was also cumbersome and time consuming to use since you can't self refer to a specialist in this country but first have to go through your GP and so on.

I think once you have most of your body and many conditions excluded, its not worth having.

The insurance industry in this country is unusually unregulated compared to everything else! Must be plenty of government ministers with shares in it.

Mindymomo · 04/05/2022 17:13

We’ve had private health insurance for 25 years. My son has had over £15,000 in knee operations, husband has had eye operation, knee operation and then in April 2020 when all private hospitals were handed over to the NHS had to wait 2 weeks until the private hospital would take him for a triple heart bypass. Because he was in a NHS hospital, they paid him £150 per night and the operation and stay in a private hospital was over £25,000. Over the years we increased the excess and taken off outpatient cover, we only had £500 anyway, so not a great amount. At the moment there is still a waiting list for private consultations. My husband is having a small operation soon on the NHS, not heart related, just because if there were a problem with his heart, the NHS hospital is more equipped than our local private hospital.

calliopea · 04/05/2022 17:01

I agree, it's crap.

We switched to vitality purely because even though all insurance cover is kind of the same with its stupid loopholes, at least with vitality we get half price gym membership, perks with points, and you can see a GP fact to face for £20!

choosername1234 · 04/05/2022 16:41

Pregnancy and birth aren't usually included because of the premarital for massive compensation claims if something does go wrong

summerlovinvibes · 04/05/2022 16:39

Not BUPA but I've contacted my private insurance today to try and get some physio as am in terrible pain with my back / hips. They won't cover me because I'm pregnant. Waste of time! Might cover for duration of pregnancy if it's not going to help.

OddsandSods · 04/05/2022 16:37

It doesn’t cover GP, emergency, dental, pregnancy. It’s really good for fast tracking access to routine surgery, physio, mental health and other elective stuff. It can also be good for cancer care but bupa like a clear treatment plan. We have it through DH work benefits package so it’s worth it but I wouldn’t bother otherwise.

AttackCat · 04/05/2022 16:35

It’s the nature of insurance really to not be good value for most people, most of the time, but be terrifically helpful to a few people on rare occasions. Your premium is subsiding the person who does get cancer or have an accident etc - whether that person is you or not is the the unknown!

We’ve used ours a few times to access screening/diagnostics quickly - including a cancer screen for me, they were able to see me same day which was amazing as I was so worried I wasn’t sleeping or eating!

No health insurance covers routine pregnancy issues AFAIK.

BigWoollyJumpers · 04/05/2022 16:33

We have family cover through DH, and are, generally a very healthy family, in the sense of no chronic issues. However, we have claimed a lot in the last few years:

Lots of Physio for all of us for various injuries
Full spectrum of bloods, scans, MRIs etc for DH for Lymes (nothing available via NHS as they don't really think it is a "thing"). He got antibiotics from NHS, but that was it.
Full allergy testing for DD1 who passed out on a bus in London, couldn't breathe, and didn't know the cause. NHS A&E checked her over, but BUPA did all the tests.
Lots of clinical counselling for DD2 for PTSD following an RTA
Full spectrum of bloods for DD2 who was very ill in 6th form, NHS did basic bloods, but privately she got double, and they screened for things not available on NHS.
We have all had moles removed privately.

So, for us, it has been good for all the "other" random shit you either can't access on NHS, or wait times are too long on NHS.

doingitforthegirls · 04/05/2022 16:30

@GiltEdges

My point was the scan I needed didn't have anything to do with pregnancy - but just because it involved my female reproductive organs it was automatically refused as being a fertility investigation when all I needed it for was to to know if my tubes were blocked or not to determine whether I would be high risk for another ectopic- and nearly die....again.
As it so happens. I did go on to have another ectopic....and nearly die....again!

WhatWouldKeanuDoo · 04/05/2022 16:27

I was so glad I had private health insurance through work when I was diagnosed with depression. Was seen by a consultant the same week & had over a year (approx. £30ks worth) of cbt, counselling, therapy & consultant support. I would have been screwed without it.

LetHimHaveIt · 04/05/2022 16:27

Much against my politics, I took out a policy with Benenden when my local surgery declined so badly that it became virtually impossible to get an appointment. I was less bothered about myself but v worried for my children. It costs nearly fifty a month for myself and the three children, and it's hard to find it every month, but I'd never be without it, now. I've used the online/telephone GP twice in three years and it was effortless. So quick and easy.

GiltEdges · 04/05/2022 16:26

pregnancy might be a choice but a male colleague broke both his arms playing footpath a week later ....a voluntary sport and had all his medical expenses covered privately how is that fair? 🤷🏻‍♀️

Because he had an accident... and accidents are covered.

GiltEdges · 04/05/2022 16:25

Personally I wouldn't pay for it myself, but I receive PMI as a benefit in kind through my employer and have been able to use it for a variety of small, but useful things e.g. physio. I also opted to cover DS and he recently had a two stage procedure in a private hospital that he'd been on a waiting list with the NHS for 2 years+ and still waiting.

doingitforthegirls · 04/05/2022 16:24

I have it via work and honestly wouldn't bother with it otherwise. I think it's incredibly sexist not to cover pregnancy. They refused to do a HSG scan of my tubes to check for blockages....after I nearly died from a ruptured ectopic because they said it was to do with fertility investigations......pregnancy might be a choice but a male colleague broke both his arms playing footpath a week later ....a voluntary sport and had all his medical expenses covered privately how is that fair? 🤷🏻‍♀️

YayitisfinallySpring · 04/05/2022 16:22

I got rid of mine 12 years ago. I now pay as I go and can get one year interest free credit. I've worked out that I've spent a lot less going privately this way. No hassle with having to get the insurers to agree the treatment.

WhateverHappenedToMe · 04/05/2022 16:21

My mother's free BUPA cover ended the day my father died. We looked at the cost, and set up an investment account with a monthly direct debit equivalent to the BUPA premium.

When she needed a hip replacement that account paid in full, and also for a week of residential care afterwards.