Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU of is BUPA Insurance a waste?

59 replies

bloodynewusernameagain · 04/05/2022 15:34

I'm 39, currently pregnant. Have BUPA Health insurance

I took out insurance via BUPA and disclosed a previous UTI and the policy was confirmed stating they won't cover anything(!) in my abdomen. Which for a starter I thought was pretty shit if all I had was a UTI, don't 50% of women have one at some point in their lives?!

So I thought fuck it I'll cancel, then Covid hit and I thought I'll wait 'til the pandemic ends and cancel - not that I could really see any benefit to the cover re. Covid but just in case of cancer, NHS being under stress re. Covid etc etc. Then at the beginning of this year I became pregnant and thought well finally I might find some benefit to having private insurance. There doesn't seem to be anything at all - no option of getting anything (even paying a top up/supplementary/addition bit) birth wise, post-natal physical issues, neo-natal, anything.

Am I completely missing the point of private health coverage? It is about £70 per month and all I can think that it covers is cancer?

I keep uhhming and ahhing over whether to cancel. Please help me decide!

YABU - Keep the coverage you'd be a fool to lose the 2 years cover built upnow
YANBU - Waste of money/private health insurance is a rip off

Thank you!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SeasonFinale · 21/06/2022 11:41

Health insurance like any insurance seems expensive if you never need to claim but is a godsend if you do need to.

Also it provides other benefits such as swift consultations which may lead to nothing but brings peace of mind rather than being on a long waiting list, operations to suit you and your work schedule/social occasions such as weddings and holidays without needing to cancel/miss out.

As mentioned above means counselling and mental health services can be accessed almost instantly when needed rather than 2 years down the line (when it may be too late!)

So at the end of the day is personal choice as to whether the cost outweighs the peace of mind.

FOTB · 21/06/2022 11:27

StarCourt · 21/06/2022 11:04

@FOTB I took the job I've now been In for 6 months precisely because they offer private health which includes previous medical history disregarded. I pay for it and added my daughter but I think it's well worth it now

It's a standard perk in my line of work - God knows what I'll do when I'm so old I have to retire. Fingers crossed I'll be rich by then and be able to afford my own personal policy...

StarCourt · 21/06/2022 11:04

@FOTB I took the job I've now been In for 6 months precisely because they offer private health which includes previous medical history disregarded. I pay for it and added my daughter but I think it's well worth it now

Tomnooktoldmeto · 21/06/2022 11:01

We have Axa through DH’s job and there are no exclusions of pre existing conditions which is fantastic for me because I’m chronically I’ll and disabled

Both DC are covered till 25 which is great and takes them well past Uni till they’re working themselves

Over the years it’s been literally a lifesaver, I’ve had many investigations, operations and physio.

I’m currently waiting to have eye surgery but will have to wait for up to a year as I need a transplant and there is a shortage but it will be done privately when it’s done just in the nhs private wing of our local hospital

PipeScatter · 21/06/2022 10:23

Private healthcare is really useful for injuries and for access to procedures that would otherwise have a long waiting list with the NHS.

I wouldn't have it if my work didn't provide it as a benefit. It was useful though when I broke a bone and could access an immediate fracture clinic rather than wait for the NHS one. Plus then I felt like I'd freed up an NHS space that could be used by someone else.

A colleague of mine recently had a procedure that was an 18 month waiting list for on the NHS and she had it done within weeks. It wasn't something life limiting, but it was something that was causing her a lot of discomfort and pain, so it was useful to avoid the wait.

My DF has some cardio issues. If he had private healthcare they'd see him quickly, but as it is he's got to wait until November for an NHS consultant.

The problem with there being 2 systems is that if my DF was able to go private, he'd probably be seen by the same consultant that's seeing him on the NHS as many seem to work for both and therefore end up giving the NHS less time, thereby increasing the wait times.

If no-one had private healthcare, all these HCPs working in private would be able to work for the NHS, but then of course the NHS probably couldn't afford them. It's a bit of a conundrum!

TimeToChangeItUpNow · 21/06/2022 10:17

We had it through my work when my husband was diagnosed with stage 2 cancer. I think it might have saved his life as he'd been operated on and was about to start chemo before we got a call for his initial nhs referral from the GP.

Lastqueenofscotland2 · 21/06/2022 10:00

I have BUPA through work and admittedly have never needed it for anything pregnancy related as no DC. But every time I have needed it (I have a chronic skin condition which they cover) they have been amazing. Apointments within 24 hrs at most, excellent advice etc et.

JolieJ · 21/06/2022 09:56

I have it through my employer and our coverage includes pre-existing conditions which is rare. I've used it extensively, for physio for my back as well as ongoing therapy for my anxiety and some other minor things.

Definitely worth it for me

JackieCollinshasnoauthority · 21/06/2022 09:46

I don't want to make assumptions about anyone's politics but beneden isn't private healthcare in the same vein as Bupa. It's a not for profit mutual and has the expectation that everyone uses the NHS. It's only if waiting lists are excessive do they offer help

Chaoslatte · 21/06/2022 09:30

I’m with Bupa and have found them good but my policy is ‘medical history disregarded’ so I don’t have any issues with exclusions. Pregnancy is still excluded though which is standard. Given the recent NHS scandals I am considering paying for private maternity care separately.

Funkyblues101 · 21/06/2022 09:23

LetHimHaveIt · 04/05/2022 16:27

Much against my politics, I took out a policy with Benenden when my local surgery declined so badly that it became virtually impossible to get an appointment. I was less bothered about myself but v worried for my children. It costs nearly fifty a month for myself and the three children, and it's hard to find it every month, but I'd never be without it, now. I've used the online/telephone GP twice in three years and it was effortless. So quick and easy.

Against your politics? I'd say private healthcare is perfectly aligned with champagne socialism...

FOTB · 21/06/2022 09:20

As with all healthcare insurance providers, there are good policies and there are bad policies.

I don't think it's worth paying personally as you'll have to disclose prior history and your premiums for a decent policy will be ridiculous. However... it's absolutely worth getting it through work, as the cost is based on a general population of workers, and not your specific individual problems. Some stuff will still always be excluded, but far less. A group policy is always much better value than a private one!

Almost worth having a part-time job just to access medical insurance... As I type it, that sounds incredibly American. But I wouldn't be without private healthcare in the UK.

motherofawhirlwind · 21/06/2022 09:15

We have AXA through work (I added the family at my cost) and love it. I'd check if the lower abdomen exclusion is still in place - usually it's just for the first 2 years.

I've had loads of physio, xrays, an MRI and still having treatment for a frozen shoulder. OH had cancer treatment (minor) and physio. DD has had 2x surgeries and MH therapy galore. Plus online GP appointments, dental and optical cover and loads more.

Yes, it's expensive, but for the lack of wait times and reduced worry, it's invaluable to us.

LimpBiskit · 21/06/2022 09:14

I cancelled mine this year. The premium went up to 4.5k for the whole family and I've only used it once for DD when she was younger for an ear operation. It's money I can spend more effectively elsewhere.

SallyWD · 21/06/2022 09:12

I know the NHS is struggling but I had cancer and they were amazing. I had a scan the day after they suspected cancer, I met the consultant 2 days later and had surgery within a couple of weeks. I had a very thorough follow up programme and also received counselling on the NHS to help me deal with the stress. I just don't believe I could have got better treatment with BUPA.

Notinthemoodforthis · 21/06/2022 09:10

GiltEdges · 04/05/2022 16:26

pregnancy might be a choice but a male colleague broke both his arms playing footpath a week later ....a voluntary sport and had all his medical expenses covered privately how is that fair? 🤷🏻‍♀️

Because he had an accident... and accidents are covered.

plenty of pregnancies are accidents 😛

TheLette · 21/06/2022 09:07

It's standard that pregnancy is not covered by private health insurance. This should be clear from the policy terms. Annoying but I guess if it was covered, the insurance would either be a lot more expensive for everyone OR just for women of childbearing age (not sure if that would be allowed). From what I've read though you are safer giving birth in a large NHS hospital in case anything goes wrong. I also don't think you necessarily get good breastfeeding support in a private hospital (although perhaps not in the NHS either) based on an acquaintance's experience.

User46489 · 21/06/2022 09:07

It is worth it if you get it through work but now we are retired we would pay for stuff like hip or knee replacements out of savings as that sort of thing has a very long wait.

riesenrad · 21/06/2022 09:02

I have Bupa through work but pre-existing conditions are covered as it's a work policy.

When I was freelancing I had a personal policy with Vitality. They wouldn't cover skin conditions as I'd had an actinic keratosis; fair enough, I had it sorted out on the NHS anyway. I had no claims during either of the first two years.

But when it came to renewal, they increased the price even though I had platinum status (they have a system where you do "healthy" things and get points and then your premium is supposed to be cheaper) and after two years they still wouldn't cover skin lesions. I thought that was ridiculous and cancelled (and a bit later was back in paid work anyway so availed myself of the work cover). In my view a two year exclusion for pre-existing conditions is enough!

t was also cumbersome and time consuming to use since you can't self refer to a specialist in this country but first have to go through your GP and so on

yes this is the worst aspect. What people really need is access to a GP (which a lot of of private policies do now offer, even if only by video but that is probably only since covid). While the waiting lists for NHS consultants are long, you will get seen eventually. The issue is getting the referral in the first place.

Mabelface · 21/06/2022 08:54

Sounds like your special condition is too broad. Raise a complaint and it'll be looked at. Double check the cover for pregnancy and birth.

Most private medical insurance is for acute conditions, so they won't cover checks unless you actually have symptoms.

Fairyliz · 21/06/2022 08:43

I always think the best idea is to put away the money into an account that you don’t touch.
Then if you do need medical help you hopefully have a balance to pay to go private. If you don’t you will have a nice healthy balance in 30 years.

StarCourt · 21/06/2022 06:52

I've been looking for a therapist for my daughter and so many state on the BUPA search list that they are no longer accepting BUPA referrals as they don't pay their fees!

Ducksinthebath · 21/06/2022 06:36

My current bugbear is that my policy through my employer covers nothing menopause related or even vaguely gynaecological despite us being a very female skewed industry. But if I wake up tomorrow and decide I’m a man stuck in a woman’s body I can have a consultation with a gender specialist in five working days. 🤔

FuncaMunca · 21/06/2022 03:33

We've always had private insurance for the whole family through work and have used it quite a lot over the years eg for kidney stones, broken bone, non-cosmetic plastic surgery, ligament tear, physio, gynaecologist, yearly health check. Wouldn't want to be without it and always make sure it's included in our work benefits. Would I pay for it out of my own pocket if it wasn't? Probably

Onlyrainbows · 21/06/2022 03:22

I thought it was a waste of money and was only worth getting if I got cancer. 3-4 weeks later after I decided not to take it through work I was diagnosed with pre-cancer and going through actual cancer diagnosis at the moment, so I really wish I had taken it!