Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to give dog away to trainer

108 replies

usuallyquiet1 · 04/05/2022 12:07

Hello, i know this is awful and i feel so bad about it but am struggling to get used to life with a dog. He is so sweet natured and generally lovely but my 2 main troubles are not leaving the house for more than 3 hours as i dont want him to be alone, and my daughter (shes 4) cant have any toys downstairs anymore.

We are first time dog owners and ive done that typical thing of not knowing what i was getting into. Our dog trainer has seen im struggling and said she could take him if we cant manage. I wondered if anyone has come through the other side of this and either learned to love their dog , or has given their dog away and never been forgiven by their child ! Thats my other worry, will she and my husband ever forgive me.
How do people mange with dogs and small children, i think i had an idea they would play together but in reality my daughter is missing out on baking, craft etc as the dog chews up anything in sight. I guess this seems really basic as a question but i struggle to believe in myself and swing in mood and decision. The dog (im only not saying name as trying to be discreet !) is only 10 months old and has been with us for 8 months now. He is walked twice a day and we send him to dog care if going out but its such an adjustment never going out unless preplanned again. Does anyone else struggle with their dog and do their children play with it ?
i think my aibu is , am i satan if i give away our daughters first pet for the sanity of the family !

OP posts:
caringcarer · 04/05/2022 16:58

Get the dog neutered. It will help calm him. When dd playing on floor put her in a large playpen so dog does not get her toys. Make sure dog has lots of toys but play with it too. Lots of long walks to use up energy. Don't turn him out. He loves you and has done nothing wrong. He won't understand and will miss you all. Keep training him and he will calm down in time. He is still a puppy.

Maytodecember · 04/05/2022 16:47

usuallyquiet1 · 04/05/2022 13:08

thank you for replying, ivve neen going round in circles about this. He is a cockapoo, not neutered yet . My husband loves him dearly and would be so sad to see him go. I love him too but i fell constantly guilty about him which is affecting me a lot. Is he happy, is he lonely, he sleeps downstairs and i worry he needs a companion and so it goes on. I do tend to worry about everything in life so sm probably overthinking things . The dog tainer walked in one day to me crying and i explained how i was struggling and she said if we were to rehome him then she could take him, her first priority though was to help him be the family pet we wanted.
I think i was an idiot really about the being left alone, my husband has had a dog previously and i just thought he knew about dogs. But he has told me since that was years ago and they just left him as didnt know it was wrong (he calls it 70s parenting ).
I think im worried about my daughter missing out and i can see from the replies that maybe i should be teaching him to leave things and let her play downstairs and we do have him at dog care so am thinking thas parts ok. '
I think i am the classic got a dog and didnt know what to expect . Has anyone else taken a long time to get used to their dog and now wouldnt be without it ?
He is a lovely boy. Feels so guilty whatever i do

You’re humanising your dog. Yoyr dog doesn’t time how long you’re out, feel miserable because he’s missing out on the cinema/ kids play date or whatever. Leave Radio 4 on for him ( they like the voices) a Kong with something delicious squished into it. He’ll be happy when you return but he’s not been clock watching.

Your dog will do what you train it to do. I’ve never had a dog chew anything it shouldn’t because I treat them as dogs from day one. I’m the pack leader, they’re my pack and they’re dogs. Get yourself aCesar Milan book.

Your daughter can cook, bake, play with toys, anything. The dog goes behind a baby gate or in a crate. Then when everything’s cleared away, good dog, out for a play in the garden.

But if it all seems too much there’s no point making yourself miserable for the next 13-14 years and he’d be ok re-homed.

queenMab99 · 04/05/2022 16:35

I got my present dog 5 years ago, I had a previous springer spaniel who died around 10 years ago, so I thought I knew the breed, and was aware how lively they can be, but this one is like a souped up version. So although OP may have done some research, you can not guarantee just how difficult it is going to be. He has been much easier to deal with since he was about 2 or three, but the first year was horrific for me, and I thought I had made a terrible mistake, on the other hand he is very loving and his mischief is quite entertaining. My grandchildren who are here most days for a couple of hours, have had to learn to be tidier, and put things out of his reach.
I would try to persevere a few months longer, as they do calm down after the first year. My adult nieces each got a labrador from the same litter, and one, who went to the niece with absolutely no experience, is at 15 months a quiet well behaved angel, while her sister and her husband who are experienced owners got the troublesome, overexcited one.

oakleaffy · 04/05/2022 16:31

usuallyquiet1 · 04/05/2022 16:09

thank you all for your replies, i really appreciate your thoughts. I think ive said it unfairly to the trainer, when she came that time i was in a mess and i said first i was thinking of re homing him, only then did she say she could take him. It wasnt her suggestion at all.
She is a lovely lady and im absolutely certain she would only want the best for him . No way she would be selling him, ive seen those two together and they get on so well. Also we arent seeing her for training at the moment , it was just in the beginnig so any issues i have lie with me and my husband.
On all the other points, yes i have done the wrong thing in getting a puppy without fully understanding what this involved. I am completely at fault here and am just figuring out what to do.
It a very valid point re training, we did loads in the beginning and then we slowly stopped. Am taking that onboard.
Im going to talk to my husband again and show him all this.
Thank you everyone

Every day is a training day with a pup !
They do like to ''Push the boundaries'' ..''What can I get away with here?'' when they hit adolescence especially.

Literally whatever someone does with their dog is ''Training'' , wether for good or ill.

Ours at 5 months decided she didn't want her nails clipping..and began to ''nose bodge'' and bite softly at my hands, rolling over deliberately so I couldn't cut her nails.
Had I stopped til she was ''in the mood'', her nails would be like talons now..

Instead, I persisted, with kind firmness, rewarding with a treat when the job was done.

She is now miles better :)

Even sweet natured ones can'' try it on'' {Don't WANT to come in from garden!}... but simple daily training , not to scrounge at the table, not to pull on the lead, not to mouthe at hands.. but instead praise for
Walking nicely on lead, Recalling well ,
Allowing nails to be cut without fuss
Lots of positive rewards.

With out first dog I did feel a bit 'At sea'' when her recall went through an iffy phase {A Lurcher} I phoned the dog warden , was very good, and gave solid advice.
I'd say with our first dog, after a year, I felt that she really became a lot easier.

IF you are happy to put ''good'' daily training in place, Just by stuff you do with him, you could have a lovely, well mannered dog.

Plenty of you tube videos on dog positive training .

ShirleyPhallus · 04/05/2022 16:13

I love him too but i fell constantly guilty about him which is affecting me a lot. Is he happy, is he lonely, he sleeps downstairs and i worry he needs a companion and so it goes on.

sorry op but to your dog, you are his companion

usuallyquiet1 · 04/05/2022 16:09

thank you all for your replies, i really appreciate your thoughts. I think ive said it unfairly to the trainer, when she came that time i was in a mess and i said first i was thinking of re homing him, only then did she say she could take him. It wasnt her suggestion at all.
She is a lovely lady and im absolutely certain she would only want the best for him . No way she would be selling him, ive seen those two together and they get on so well. Also we arent seeing her for training at the moment , it was just in the beginnig so any issues i have lie with me and my husband.
On all the other points, yes i have done the wrong thing in getting a puppy without fully understanding what this involved. I am completely at fault here and am just figuring out what to do.
It a very valid point re training, we did loads in the beginning and then we slowly stopped. Am taking that onboard.
Im going to talk to my husband again and show him all this.
Thank you everyone

OP posts:
Lady089 · 04/05/2022 15:55

StorytimeSasha · 04/05/2022 14:51

Well if you ignore all the posters who probably refer to dogs as ' fur babies' , you can absolutely end this misery for you , your family and the dog by rehoming him.

We did this with a rescue dog we had - nothing prepares you for the sometimes 24/7 disruption to your life. There's commitment and hard work ..then there's having your life ruined. We were pretty much conned by the rescue centre we got ours from, who did take him back ( no refund of the £100's we had 'donated' to pay for him) .

If you want the joy of a dog without the stress of owning one, might I recommend you seek out local centres who need dog walkers? there are plenty of organisations that need this service.

That whole post says a lot about you.

WiddlinDiddlin · 04/05/2022 15:52

Dog trainer/behaviour consultant here..

You are right at the hardest bit of puppy raising - the adolescent phase, where puppies are coping not only with the normal adolescent stuff... where do I fit with others of my own species, how do I conduct myself, what if I push boundaries..

But they ALSO have to contend with being evolved to live with humans.. so all the above, but with another species.

That is tough.

In another 14 months time, it is likely you'll have a dog who can be left a reasonable amount of time (four hours perhaps without a break, longer with a break of course), who can be trusted around other peoples stuff and things, who is more fun to be with and more reliable and predictable....

But...

If you don't want to be a dog owner. If you don't want to spend the next 12+ years thinking about your dogs needs when its less than easy and convenient, if you don't want to clean up hair and go for walks in the rain and ensure food is put away not left within reach...

Don't be a dog owner. Rehome your dog to someone suitable. Consider that an owner upgrade for your dog because for a dog, their family ARE their world... and a world that finds you an inconvenience and a chore... is not somewhere anyone should be forced to live.

I really hate the trend of shaming people who rehome dogs responsibly - not everyone wants to be a dog owner, it is that simple. People who do not want to be dog owners, should not be dog owners.

On the other hand if you DO.. but this stage is hard, well it does get better, I promise. Just... not for a while yet.

Lady089 · 04/05/2022 15:52

You are irresponsible to get a dog without knowing anything about a dog. You sound like you want a dog without putting in any effort with training etc. Dogs are not commodities, I think it’s awful how so many people get dogs and palm them off when they no longer are convenient.

oakleaffy · 04/05/2022 15:46

StorytimeSasha · 04/05/2022 14:51

Well if you ignore all the posters who probably refer to dogs as ' fur babies' , you can absolutely end this misery for you , your family and the dog by rehoming him.

We did this with a rescue dog we had - nothing prepares you for the sometimes 24/7 disruption to your life. There's commitment and hard work ..then there's having your life ruined. We were pretty much conned by the rescue centre we got ours from, who did take him back ( no refund of the £100's we had 'donated' to pay for him) .

If you want the joy of a dog without the stress of owning one, might I recommend you seek out local centres who need dog walkers? there are plenty of organisations that need this service.

Reputable rescue centres ought to vet the owners thoroughly- and suggest a dog who might be a good match for your situation.

The bigger UK ones are usually very good.
They ought also to be very honest as to the dog’s “Issues”.
Our first dog ( Son was 9 yrs) was “Suggested” by a good Dog’s home - She was smaller and much younger than I wanted, and a different coat type to what I thought I liked ( eyeroll) but she was absolutely perfect .
A soulmate for 11.5 yrs

We has a home check and they were very thorough, and the dog warden advised with recall issue when pup was 7 months old.
Sadly many overseas rescues sell to anyone-
And these “ Adoptions” do frequently break down.

Staynow · 04/05/2022 15:42

Rather than shutting the dog in a crate why not get baby gates and then you can do the things you want with your daughter while he watches on from behind the gate. Does he have kongs and things he is allowed to chew? I would give it a bit longer to be honest.

oakleaffy · 04/05/2022 15:35

If you bought from a reputable breeder ( Unlikely- as very few would dream of selling to people with young children) the breeder surely would take the puppy back.
ours has a money back guarantee for a YEAR!
( amount returned diminishes with time, but still is significant)
She also will take back any if hers older - but this is someone who vets owners very thoroughly.

Dogs are not something to be bought on whim.

A trainer will likely sell yours on.

Rescues are full to bursting at the moment.

with dogs, you get out what you put in.

They do chew, as pups.

LadyCatStark · 04/05/2022 15:28

10 months is the worst month!! I’d wait til he’s a year old and see if he starts to calm down. I could have quite happily given my lab away to anyone that would take him at 10 months but now he’s 1 he’s an absolute dream 🥰.

LuaDipa · 04/05/2022 15:21

mycatisannoying · 04/05/2022 12:27

Maybe I'm missing something here, but is offering to home the dog not a highly unusual thing for a dog trainer to offer to do? Hmm
They're there to help fix the issue, and it seems strange that they'd do this by offering to take the dog off your hands. So what would they do differently at home, is what I'd be asking, if it's not working for you?

The cynic in me thinks that if they offer to take on every dog whose owner is struggling, it could be a good earner if they're then sold on.

Personally, I'd change your behaviourist and see how that goes.

Agreed.

Has the trainer not given any support in attempting to build up time apart so you can eventually leave the dog home for a couple of hours?

Or teaching the puppy that it isn’t to chew things that don’t belong to it?

Also do you have a crate so you can play with your dc and know the dog is safe and not causing havoc?

I know puppies are hard work and ours were extremely difficult to train, but I’m so glad we persevered as they are the heart of our family. Your ‘trainer’ sounds absolutely useless. Find a better one or try puppy training classes and make a decision then.

Mariposista · 04/05/2022 15:12

The dog is a puppy, in other words a baby! Of course he chews, that is typical puppy behaviour and he will grow out of it, provided he has a lot of stimulation and tough chewy toys (kong ones are good). His jaw is developing and he is discovering the world through his mouth. Of course you can't give him away for such selfish reasons - to him, you are his whole world. No wonder so many dogs have major trust issues with humans if they are just given up on.
Group puppy behaviour classes are good. You get to meet other dog owners and see that you're not alone. I remember laughing so much at some of the stories the other owners told - I assumed we were the only ones with a crazy puppy. It won't kill your daughter for now to have to leave toys upstairs.

Ifitdoesntmakesense · 04/05/2022 15:00

StorytimeSasha · 04/05/2022 14:51

Well if you ignore all the posters who probably refer to dogs as ' fur babies' , you can absolutely end this misery for you , your family and the dog by rehoming him.

We did this with a rescue dog we had - nothing prepares you for the sometimes 24/7 disruption to your life. There's commitment and hard work ..then there's having your life ruined. We were pretty much conned by the rescue centre we got ours from, who did take him back ( no refund of the £100's we had 'donated' to pay for him) .

If you want the joy of a dog without the stress of owning one, might I recommend you seek out local centres who need dog walkers? there are plenty of organisations that need this service.

I would absolutely never refer to my dog as a fur baby (the expression irritates me no end) but there is a difference between your circumstances and the op. You didn’t have the luxury of having a dog from a puppy so that you could train it effectively nor did you know it’s full background despite what the rescue centre said. If people are happy just to give a dog away because it’s too much hassle then a dog is probably not for them anyway.

mycatisannoying · 04/05/2022 14:55

You need to stop crying over it and be more proactive.
I had a pup as a single parent of 3, and a full-time job (had the full summer off when we got him though, and obviously use a dog-walker), and I thought the puppy stage would end me! It was one of the hardest things I've ever done. My puppy (now 7 years) was unbelievably gorgeous but really wasn't the brightest still isn't. He didn't get the hang of toilet training until he was 8 months old and his separation anxiety was next level! I described it as harder than the newborn baby phase.
Come on, woman up! You can do this. It WILL get better. I wouldn't be without my dog now. He brings so much joy every day.

StorytimeSasha · 04/05/2022 14:51

Well if you ignore all the posters who probably refer to dogs as ' fur babies' , you can absolutely end this misery for you , your family and the dog by rehoming him.

We did this with a rescue dog we had - nothing prepares you for the sometimes 24/7 disruption to your life. There's commitment and hard work ..then there's having your life ruined. We were pretty much conned by the rescue centre we got ours from, who did take him back ( no refund of the £100's we had 'donated' to pay for him) .

If you want the joy of a dog without the stress of owning one, might I recommend you seek out local centres who need dog walkers? there are plenty of organisations that need this service.

mumto2teenagers · 04/05/2022 14:50

We have 2 dogs and the reality is they do require a lot of time and commitment. Young dogs can be hard work. IMO the benefits of having dogs outweighs the negatives.

You need to invest the time now in properly training your dog, although if you have a dog trainer then it sounds as if you are doing this. Are the whole family involved in this training?

How is your dog when left alone? We only leave our dogs for about 3 hours at a time, we could leave them longer occasionally as they don't seem to mind when we leave them, we have cameras so we can check on them when we are out. We try to take them for a long walk before we go out and once we are gone they tend to sleep, I also WFH most of the time so we are not leaving them on a daily basis. How long the dog can be left for will depend on him, some dogs are happy to be left for a few hours, others get anxious pretty quickly.

Our dogs sleep downstairs and are quite happy to, the have each other for company but we had the first one for 3 years before getting a second dog and she was always fine at night on her own downstairs. Why do you feel you dog needs a companion at night?

Pegsmum · 04/05/2022 14:50

If you love the dog then hang in in there. I don’t need to tell you that pup’s are hard work, I’ve had dogs all my life yet I still have the ‘what the hell have I done’ feeling when a pup arrives. Your dog is still very young and probably won’t mature for a couple of years, but hopefully when it does it will be such a great friend for your 4 year old.
personally I wouldn’t give the dog to your trainer, that just seems a bit off for a trainer to suggest it. Good luck

kateandme · 04/05/2022 14:50

I think your what ifs and shock and prediction an awful future is also putting a wall arpund you and stopping you from working working through this and or building a bond which is essential.likr your in this stuck stress haze

kateandme · 04/05/2022 14:46

mycatisannoying · 04/05/2022 12:27

Maybe I'm missing something here, but is offering to home the dog not a highly unusual thing for a dog trainer to offer to do? Hmm
They're there to help fix the issue, and it seems strange that they'd do this by offering to take the dog off your hands. So what would they do differently at home, is what I'd be asking, if it's not working for you?

The cynic in me thinks that if they offer to take on every dog whose owner is struggling, it could be a good earner if they're then sold on.

Personally, I'd change your behaviourist and see how that goes.

Exactly this.seen it happen.trainers no EVERYONE they need to to sell it on.witnessed it 3 times before bloke was shut down...also theyd very rarely want another dog,especially untrained one.

BobbinHood · 04/05/2022 14:40

I don’t know about giving it away to the trainer vs anywhere else but your 4 year old should be able to enjoy her home properly and I can’t see how she can in this situation. My MIL has a cockapoo and it’s such a knobhead, even now it’s 3. I hate going round there with DD who is also 4, it just hassles us the whole time and I can’t relax.

StarDolphins · 04/05/2022 14:34

having a puppy is hard work but there’s nothing better than growing up with a dog! It won’t always be this hard & a puppy doesn’t come minus the short-term work!

i am a ‘death do us part’ dog owner (although I appreciate not everyone is)

if you’re committed to him, I would get a different trainer but if not I would give to a rescue or the breeder (as long as it wasn’t a money grabbing backstreet breeder of course!)

PussInBin20 · 04/05/2022 14:31

We got a puppy and tbh if I’d have known what it was really like to have one, then I wouldn’t have got him. Like you my DH had dogs and was even an army dog trainer in a previous job but although DDog does do as he:s told for DH - he is not quite the same with me! I am more a cat person really.

like you say, they are a tie and I’m thinking I may not even be able to go on holiday this year (booked and paid to go abroad) as I can’t find anyone to have him, and of course it’s my job to find someone.

I do love the little bugger though and couldn’t bear to get rid of him even though I do moan about him, as he’s a chewer too.

He is 18 myths now and he has just been neutered last week so I am hoping he will calm down a bit.

not sure what to advise you really - we are persevering but I totally know how you feel! I have heard Cockerpoos can be a handful though. Definitely train him.

what does your DH think?