Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to give dog away to trainer

108 replies

usuallyquiet1 · 04/05/2022 12:07

Hello, i know this is awful and i feel so bad about it but am struggling to get used to life with a dog. He is so sweet natured and generally lovely but my 2 main troubles are not leaving the house for more than 3 hours as i dont want him to be alone, and my daughter (shes 4) cant have any toys downstairs anymore.

We are first time dog owners and ive done that typical thing of not knowing what i was getting into. Our dog trainer has seen im struggling and said she could take him if we cant manage. I wondered if anyone has come through the other side of this and either learned to love their dog , or has given their dog away and never been forgiven by their child ! Thats my other worry, will she and my husband ever forgive me.
How do people mange with dogs and small children, i think i had an idea they would play together but in reality my daughter is missing out on baking, craft etc as the dog chews up anything in sight. I guess this seems really basic as a question but i struggle to believe in myself and swing in mood and decision. The dog (im only not saying name as trying to be discreet !) is only 10 months old and has been with us for 8 months now. He is walked twice a day and we send him to dog care if going out but its such an adjustment never going out unless preplanned again. Does anyone else struggle with their dog and do their children play with it ?
i think my aibu is , am i satan if i give away our daughters first pet for the sanity of the family !

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Mandodari · 05/05/2022 15:07

@usuallyquiet1
Have you tried clicker training? I found it very useful and can be done along side treat training. The other thing I would suggest is having a look at logic toys where they have to figure out the way to get a treat out, snuffle mats for dry food and kong toys. If you can get him using kongs but only when he is quiet and well behaved, you can use them as a comforter when you go out. Dog training is not easy but I so worthwhile and builds such a bond.

ShirleyPhallus · 05/05/2022 15:05

usuallyquiet1 · 05/05/2022 14:58

i think im missing some things out but as an update we are getting him neutered but waiting until next month as then he can recover in peace (its after school hols !) He does have his own chew toys and we do try and rotate so he doesnt get bored.

Im unfair saying our trainer, she did a pup course with us when he was small and has since looked after him once when we were on holiday . We are not currently in training with her. She really is fantastic and said we could call with any questions at anytime. She doesn't know of the current situation .
I think in all honesty ive been clueless and joined dog sites to read up on things and looked up food and sleep and basic training but not got any further. We started today with the leave it command (which he knows for treats) and we trained using my girls toys. He got it , and im going to work on this and other things each day now. Hes currently chewing on a yak thing and looking well happy.
Really a massive thank you, mumsnet is so good for this and im really glad of the help

This sounds good progress but please don’t think that neutering will solve all the issues, you should read up on it to see pros and cons - sometimes it makes make dogs more aggressive and you should be sure to fix the underlying issues first

usuallyquiet1 · 05/05/2022 14:58

i think im missing some things out but as an update we are getting him neutered but waiting until next month as then he can recover in peace (its after school hols !) He does have his own chew toys and we do try and rotate so he doesnt get bored.

Im unfair saying our trainer, she did a pup course with us when he was small and has since looked after him once when we were on holiday . We are not currently in training with her. She really is fantastic and said we could call with any questions at anytime. She doesn't know of the current situation .
I think in all honesty ive been clueless and joined dog sites to read up on things and looked up food and sleep and basic training but not got any further. We started today with the leave it command (which he knows for treats) and we trained using my girls toys. He got it , and im going to work on this and other things each day now. Hes currently chewing on a yak thing and looking well happy.
Really a massive thank you, mumsnet is so good for this and im really glad of the help

OP posts:
HazelBite · 05/05/2022 14:32

I haven't read the whole thread OP , and I don't know if anyone has suggested "borrow my doggie" I have joined but as many of the "owners" want their dogs minded in the "borrowers" home which I can't do as I have cats!
I'm happy to take anyones dog off for a very long tiring walk several times a week, I'm sure there are others like me who would give you some respite.

Cockerdileteeth · 05/05/2022 14:09

I'm late to the thread but glad you're feeling more positive OP. Try not to beat yourself up - I think probably the reality of a puppy can be a shock to the system however much someone researched/prepared. There's a reason people talk about the puppy blues.

Your pup is an adolescent and his brain is a construction site right now which won't be helping but as with kids, keep repeating, "it's a phase, this too shall pass". It's really important to keep on keeping on with training and expect some regressions and to be revisiting basics as they move through the teenage arsehole phase. Persevere and you should have a lovely companion dog at age 2ish but it is a long path though and I think the 6 week puppy courses maybe need to be clearer about that. There are lots of classes out there specifically for adolescent dogs. At a class like that you meet other owners going through the same tricky stage, too, which can be supportive.

I have an adolescent cocker, not a cockapoo, but cockapoos are half cocker after all so if it helps, mine (and many cockers) need lots of help learning to settle and to switch off but they also SO need the rest and downtime. We have done and continue to do lots of work with ours on that. His nap times are times when DS has free run and my full attention so it helps with balancing everyone's needs to make sure our dog is getting enough rest and downtime. It is also good for DS to learn to be considerate of the dog so I don't feel guilty that he has to give and take a bit, too.

We are doing training to give outlets for his breed instincts and short bouts of brain work tire him like nothing else, which also helps with balancing time for everyone in the house. I have seen cockapoos described as dogs with the brain of a professor and the attitude of a toddler who's eaten all the blue smarties...! It might be worth your while seeing a trainer who has specific experience with spaniels and spaniel crosses. We've got on best with trainers who own spaniels and know and love them :-)

Mandodari · 05/05/2022 13:58

You have the dog for 8 months only yet you expect him to be perfect. He is still a baby, still has a lot to learn. If you feel you cannot put in the hours, the best course is to let him go. Do it sooner rather than later as it will lessen the trauma of him losing his home. There are plenty of breed charities that will help him find his forever home. I'm not being harsh on you but I think you aren't prepared for the time, cost and effort involved with dog ownership.

Hoppinggreen · 05/05/2022 13:43

ChinstrapBobblehat · 05/05/2022 12:37

Dunno what happened there! An air spray from Pets at Home was a great deterrent for unwanted behaviour and really helps as a training aid. My dog’s 9 and if he’s being naughty I literally only have to show him the can and he’ll stop! It just makes a noise but is really effective.

And loads of people I know have had the exact same wobble you’re having now, OP, but they all got past it and none of them would give up their dogs now.

Its not a training aid, its a threat
Your dog behaves at the sight of the airspray because hes scared of it
Its an awful way to treat any animal

cecilthehungryspider · 05/05/2022 13:34

I haven't read the whole thread so sorry if I'm repeating things.

  1. It will get easier (much like having a baby), the dog will get less hyper, less inclined to chew, and will cope with being left for longer periods.
  2. Having a dog and small children together is hard! Their needs often conflict. Don't feel bad for finding it difficult.
  3. Keep going with training, it will be so worth it.
  4. It is ok to "manage" the dog in the home. Use gates to keep it in or out of specific rooms while still being able to see you. How you do that depends on the layout of your house. In one house we used to gate the dog in the kitchen at times to allow play in the rest of the house. In another house, we had a playroom so gated the child in there and the dog out. As long as the dog (or child) isn't shut away from the family all the time then that is fine.
  5. Make friends with other doggy people nearby then you can look after each other's dogs so you can have days out.
  6. If you do give it to the trainer you know it will have a good home so no need to beat yourself up.
GirlSYML · 05/05/2022 13:22

ChinstrapBobblehat · 05/05/2022 12:33

Haven’t had time to RTFT, so apologies if someone has said this, but a corrective air spray worked really well

Yes indeed I’m sure threatening the dog and making it afraid is effective 🙄🙄

MPharm · 05/05/2022 13:12

@ChinstrapBobblehat 😔Please don't use aversives on your poor dog, and please don't advise others to. Positive training methods are effective and much kinder. Yes it might be more effort but it's so worth it to have that positive bond and good relationship with your dog.

OP I know I'm late to the thread and you've taken lots on board already. Seriously consider changing your trainer. To have got to 10 months and not realised some of these basic things is possibly understandable, but not with a paid trainer. Our trainer taught impulse control which was invaluable, if you can find a positive reinforcement trainer who can teach you this it'll work wonders. I ended up with a 9 month old working cocker spaniel (mad!) with amazing impulse control. She's 18 months now but we can leave food on the coffee table and she won't touch it. I accidentally left chocolate on the lower shelf of the coffee table this week and she didn't go near it. Also more training and mental stimulation will tire your dog out and make him easier to be around.

ChinstrapBobblehat · 05/05/2022 12:37

Dunno what happened there! An air spray from Pets at Home was a great deterrent for unwanted behaviour and really helps as a training aid. My dog’s 9 and if he’s being naughty I literally only have to show him the can and he’ll stop! It just makes a noise but is really effective.

And loads of people I know have had the exact same wobble you’re having now, OP, but they all got past it and none of them would give up their dogs now.

ChinstrapBobblehat · 05/05/2022 12:33

Haven’t had time to RTFT, so apologies if someone has said this, but a corrective air spray worked really well

Thelnebriati · 05/05/2022 12:22

@usuallyquiet1 One quick question - does your dog have things he is allowed to chew? He shouldn't own them, you need to give them to him and take them away so he doesnt get into the habit of guarding them.

Ifitdoesntmakesense · 05/05/2022 11:40

I absolutely agree with posters about milan theory, it’s unhealthy. Fwiw we have a gundog that is working & we couldn’t train him (as is usual) until he was 6/7 months. He was house trained easily by 5/6months & by 10 months he was almost perfect, he’s a dog so no perfection ever but training was every day & most of the day. It’s so worth it as now he responds to hand signals for behaviour

Silversprinkles · 05/05/2022 11:25

And agree with PP, avoid Cesar Milan like the plague, his dominance theory has been completely disproved and is considered hugely outdated. The dogs may do what they are told but they are not happy dogs.

Silversprinkles · 05/05/2022 11:23

usuallyquiet1 · 05/05/2022 10:48

ok well i really appreciate all the helpful advice and i think i am seeing where im going wrong. I had lost hope and my way a bit.
Id like to say i was not going to and would never dump my dog , lets be honest if i was as selfish as someone said earlier (sorry not sure how to tag) id have sold him on and made money from him. That was never going to happen, i do love him and was trying to do whats best for everybody.
The baking thing was just an example and not my reason for giving him up at all, that was just one thing.

What ive learned from this is
1, i did not understand what i was getting into
2, i do love my boy
3, i am going to try, and i need to up the training and be consistant with it
4, i was trying to avoid danger for the dog by keeping toys out of the way but now i see i need to go head on and teach him to be around them .
5, not to feel guilty that he sleeps downstairs or that hes alone for short periods
6, to relook at crate training or just him being in other area while me and my girl do certain things
7, that it was daft to think my girl and him would play, although they do like it when we all play together
8, that i would really miss him if he went

im going to take up a lot of the advice here and move on from this. thanks everyone im really glad i posted as its really helpful getting all these insights

Very best of luck OP , you can definitely still turn this around with such a young dog. Daily commitment and you could have an adult, well trained, happy dog that will bring you all much joy for many years.

Calafsidentity · 05/05/2022 11:13

usuallyquiet1. that's a good update and I am sure you have the dog's best interests at heart. I think you need more confidence in yourself which will come from making firm decisions and setting out a strategy, so you are not reacting to situations that are out of control.

If you decide to commit to the dog, then the commitment to training should follow. Your trainer should be helping with this, not adding to your uncertainty! Have you considered a group class where you can talk to other owners who are going through similar things?

Offintothesunset · 05/05/2022 11:07

What a positive and insightful update@usuallyquiet1

Hoppinggreen · 05/05/2022 10:51

emmakenny · 05/05/2022 00:14

What age would you say is appropriate for children to be around dogs?
I do not have or intend to get a dog, I am just curious as I don't know very much about them.

Its a personal thing but I waited until my youngest child was 7
It just made everything so much safer and easier

Hoppinggreen · 05/05/2022 10:49

Maytodecember · 04/05/2022 16:47

You’re humanising your dog. Yoyr dog doesn’t time how long you’re out, feel miserable because he’s missing out on the cinema/ kids play date or whatever. Leave Radio 4 on for him ( they like the voices) a Kong with something delicious squished into it. He’ll be happy when you return but he’s not been clock watching.

Your dog will do what you train it to do. I’ve never had a dog chew anything it shouldn’t because I treat them as dogs from day one. I’m the pack leader, they’re my pack and they’re dogs. Get yourself aCesar Milan book.

Your daughter can cook, bake, play with toys, anything. The dog goes behind a baby gate or in a crate. Then when everything’s cleared away, good dog, out for a play in the garden.

But if it all seems too much there’s no point making yourself miserable for the next 13-14 years and he’d be ok re-homed.

Do NOT under any circumstances get a Cesar Milan book

usuallyquiet1 · 05/05/2022 10:48

ok well i really appreciate all the helpful advice and i think i am seeing where im going wrong. I had lost hope and my way a bit.
Id like to say i was not going to and would never dump my dog , lets be honest if i was as selfish as someone said earlier (sorry not sure how to tag) id have sold him on and made money from him. That was never going to happen, i do love him and was trying to do whats best for everybody.
The baking thing was just an example and not my reason for giving him up at all, that was just one thing.

What ive learned from this is
1, i did not understand what i was getting into
2, i do love my boy
3, i am going to try, and i need to up the training and be consistant with it
4, i was trying to avoid danger for the dog by keeping toys out of the way but now i see i need to go head on and teach him to be around them .
5, not to feel guilty that he sleeps downstairs or that hes alone for short periods
6, to relook at crate training or just him being in other area while me and my girl do certain things
7, that it was daft to think my girl and him would play, although they do like it when we all play together
8, that i would really miss him if he went

im going to take up a lot of the advice here and move on from this. thanks everyone im really glad i posted as its really helpful getting all these insights

OP posts:
Calafsidentity · 05/05/2022 10:45

What age would you say is appropriate for children to be around dogs?
I do not have or intend to get a dog, I am just curious as I don't know very much about them.

Personally I waited until my daughter was nine years old and we had guinea pigs before that. At that age they can follow instructions, be patient, not smother the dog or get too excited, participate in its care, and treat it respectfully.

I don't want to give you a hard time op as you sound very anxious with this but surely it's fairly predictable that if you buy a dog, you can't leave it alone for long periods of time, even less at the beginning? Even the most basic dog care book will tell you that, contrary to what your DH said. It sounds as though your DH was in a household where they neglected the dog, or everyone else looked after it and he didn't appreciate the level of work involved.

Also, chewing is a natural behaviour that can be managed. Your dog is at an age where they can test boundaries a bit. Personally, I would definitely persevere but your DH has to fully participate too. You've only had him for eight months so it is very early days. You can definitely make this work but it needs determination and commitment. If you don't have those, bluntly, your dog will sense it.

Kanaloa · 05/05/2022 09:58

emmakenny · 05/05/2022 00:14

What age would you say is appropriate for children to be around dogs?
I do not have or intend to get a dog, I am just curious as I don't know very much about them.

In my opinion young kids should never be left alone with a dog, and certainly never expected to ‘play with them’ as op suggests ie basically to entertain each other. An adult should be the one in charge/in control of all interactions between young kids and dogs, for the dog and the child’s safety.

I don’t necessarily think it’s wrong to have a a dog with a young child (did it myself) but to expect them to ‘play together’ and entertain each other or for the dog to act as a companion to the four year old child is inappropriate and lazy. It’s a lot of work managing a puppy and a preschooler, and it’s not for everyone. I certainly wouldn’t do it again, and our dog wasn’t even a puppy!

Kanaloa · 05/05/2022 09:52

And I don’t see how your child is missing out on baking and crafts and that’s somehow the dog’s fault. How is it managing to chew up all the baking and crafts equipment when surely an adult is supervising a young dog and preschooler? So the dog is surely then moved away/put behind a baby gate while these activities happen.

Of all the reasons to get rid of a dog ‘my child can’t possibly bake’ is the silliest one I’ve heard.

Kanaloa · 05/05/2022 09:51

It sounds like you’ve been very silly. Saying you’re surprised you ‘can’t go out preplanned’ and expected your preschooler and the dog would ‘play together.’ It’s a really immature view on it and sounds like you just did no research or preparation and sort of expected you’d get a ‘sitcom dog’ like the golden retriever on Full House that sits at the bottom of the girls’ beds as they monologue, appears for cutesy shots of Michelle dressing it up, then conveniently disappears when the family have days out and holidays.

No, preschoolers and dogs don’t generally ‘play together.’ Yes, of course you need to organise something for your dog when you want to go out. These shouldn’t be crazy shocks, it’s basic stuff anyone with common sense knows when they get a dog. And I’m all for rehoming in certain situations, like a dog that doesn’t get on with kids and would be happier in an adults only house, or an emergency, but this is just a normal dog doing normal dog behaviours with someone who was too lazy and selfish to consider whether they could cope with a dog before they got one.

Swipe left for the next trending thread