Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

About gymnastics training hours for 6 year old

113 replies

Helpel · 04/05/2022 10:54

This is quite specific and not strictly AIBU so sorry posting a bit for traffic...
My DD is in year 2 but is not 7 until the summer. She is part of a gymnastics development squad and currently trains twice a week for a total of 5.5 hours. I've just had an email from the coach to say from June this is increasing to 3 times a week for a total of 9 hours. Twice a week the sessions finish at 8.30pm which would mean a 9.30pm bedtime before we are home and settled.
AIBU to think this is too much for a 6 year old? I am tempted to ask if we can stick with the current pattern until she starts yr 3 in September but don't want it to affect my daughter's chances at competing if that's what she eventually wants to do. They start competing in May next year - I am thinking it wouldn't affect her that much to delay increased training by a few months...
My DD enjoys gymnastics and loves being good at it, but sometimes she grumbles about going to the training sessions as it is. Do we just give it a go and see if her passion increases? I think the logistical and late night issue would be easier to swallow if she became absolutely dedicated to it!
Has anyone been in this position? It would be great to hear from other parents of development squad gymnasts!

OP posts:
pixie5121 · 06/05/2022 01:04

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request.

nolongersurprised · 06/05/2022 00:37

Swimming, football, ice skating, skiing

not swimming - two of my DC swim competitively and for the younger kids their coach has a number of sessions shouldn’t be more than half your age rule.

I listen to Ross Tucker’s Science of Sport and there was a good podcast on over specialisation and over training of children. Talked about “survivorship bias” and how parents get sucked into the excessive training narrative, with stories of all the training elite athletes did at a young age. And omitting swimmers like Adam Peaty and Ian Thorpe who have said they didn’t get seriously into training until early teens, Roger Federer and Ash Barty who played a lot of sports before committing to tennis.

The problem of course, is over investment in the sport as part of the child’s identity and where you go when they don’t end up at elite level.

TimeForGouter · 06/05/2022 00:14

Does anyone know what other activities/sports ask a primary school age child to practise for that many hours?

Swimming, football, ice skating, skiing - DD has friends in all of these that do similar hours at her age (8). Of course these kids aren’t all destined to make it. They do it because they enjoy it.

WhenTheNightFalls · 05/05/2022 23:41

I developed eating issues too. Running up and down the stairs at home to lose weight, feeling anxious about eating 'bad' foods and begging my parents to take them away so I wasn't tempted to eat them. Witnessed other gymnasts being shouted at if they had gained weight and all of us encouraged to cut back on food as in 'Try not to eat much at dinner time tonight.'
Yay for being an elite gymnast in the 90's

L1ttledrummergirl · 05/05/2022 23:14

user1506328491 · 05/05/2022 22:54

So many people have replied saying their kids do this level of training.... surely they can't all be destined to 'make it' or am
I missing something?!

That's what I think. I know dd sport is different but one of the older club players went through the same hours of training and is currently placed as GB3.

Does anyone know what other activities/sports ask a primary school age child to practise for that many hours?

Rookiemistake · 05/05/2022 23:13

Gymnastics is an early specialisation sport. If they're lucky they might make it to their late teens as a gymnast but then what? It's not like there are many recreational adult gymnastics classes around. It is great for developing strength, flexibility and co-ordination but you don't need to train for 9 hours per week for that.

TurquoiseDress · 05/05/2022 23:01

Also 9.30pm bedtime is way too late for a 6 year old!

UndertheCedartree · 05/05/2022 23:00

A 9.30pm bedtime is too late, I meant!

UndertheCedartree · 05/05/2022 22:59

A 9.30,pm for a primary school DC is too late in my opinion. They need their sleep.

TurquoiseDress · 05/05/2022 22:57

9 hours a week sounds a huge amount, for any recreational/sports activity especially when you're not even 7 yrs old.

Personally, I wouldn't do it for my DC, but I know with gymnastics the 'peak' is often in the early teens so huge sacrifices must be made in the pre-teen years...

I know this because I did competitive gymnastics from around the age of 7. In the end it got too intense and taking up disproportionate amount of time

I stopped aged 11 and then pursued other team and individual sports which I really enjoys and excelled at

Also, during the gymnastics years I developed what I now recognise to be an eating disorder- starving myself, getting up early to exercise, lying to my parents about having eaten at school, hiding food & throwing it away.

I was obsessed with my weight and losing more...I remember this so clearly during my last year at primary school...

Thank god I stopped these behaviours after giving up gymnastics and ate normally ever since, but looking back it was scary how I was showing all the signs of anorexia

This is just my experience, but for my DC, we're encouraging them to do other sports instead

MarJau26 · 05/05/2022 22:56

Wow, that might be normal for gymnastics, but there is not a cat in hell’s chance I’d allow a six year old to spend 9 hours a week on any hobby, no matter how much she liked it.

Same, this is insane. Not forgetting a late bedtime every alternate night.

user1506328491 · 05/05/2022 22:54

So many people have replied saying their kids do this level of training.... surely they can't all be destined to 'make it' or am
I missing something?!

kungfupannda · 05/05/2022 22:54

That’s a late finish for a 6 year-old. I have a DS who did gym to national level. He didn’t train later than 7.30 until he was about 9. He was doing 15 hours at that age, but the sessions finished at a decent time. He has a couple of 8.30 finishes now, although he’s no longer training all that seriously, and it’s a massive pain, even at secondary school age.

JulesRimetStillGleaming · 05/05/2022 22:49

I was a gymnast and I wouldn't recommend it. She's too young for that much commitment and there is too much potential for physical and emotional harm in the sport.

WhereHaveAllTheTwigletsGone · 05/05/2022 22:45

Just google British gymnastics abuse and you’ll see what you need to be aware of. The difficulty is that a lot of the abuse ramps up from the age of 10. By that stage these kids have already invested so many hours and the gym is their friends and family - which outs pressure on them and parents to overlook poor behaviour from coaches for fear of losing their place in the squad. From there the situation can deteriorate into a very very toxic one. At that stage you feel damned if you do damned if you don’t and it’s impossible to work out what’s for the best.

I think you’ll have to be guided by your DD really on this but please also inform yourself of the issues to be aware of as she gets older. I did gymnastics to a very high level and I wouldn’t do it again given what happened to me and what I witnessed in the sport.

Samedaysameshit · 05/05/2022 22:38

She’s doing it because she thinks it makes you happy.

Samedaysameshit · 05/05/2022 22:32

Why?
so she might end up winning a medal maybe?
it’s ridiculous.
how about those poor Russian ice skaters at the olymipics, all for the glory of Russia.
what a load of shite.
why would you think this is even close to acceptable.

WhenTheNightFalls · 05/05/2022 22:24

Every training session I was literally sat on by a coach and stretched. For example, one sat on my back and lifted both legs up high. Couldn't even walk in a straight line afterwards. No use crying or shouting out. They would just have done it harder.

JoanDarc · 05/05/2022 22:20

I work within sport and have experience with gymnastics. Most clubs are set up as a business with owner coaches profiting from increased participation - it’s in their interests to encourage parents to up the hours and therefore money. Is a very different model from other sports with volunteer coaches. There are exceptions, but generally this is the set up. I have a pretty negative view of it for this reason, also so many coaches, IME, seem to focus on getting their throughput of gymnasts instead of what’s best for the individual child.
Kids should be experiencing a wide range of activities, I would fear this much would leave no time for other activities, friendships, downtime to play and relax.
My two kids wouldn’t have coped at that age with such late finishes, it will be a long day mid week.
My advice would be to stick with what you think is best for your daughter and a healthy balance for her and not be pressured into over committing her time at such a young age.

L1ttledrummergirl · 05/05/2022 22:18

Bloody hell, that sounds like torture to me.
Dd started her sport when she turned 5. She started with 45 mins before school at the school club and 1hr on a Saturday morning. This gradually increased to 2 hours on the Saturday and 1 hr midweek plus the school club.

When she started secondary school these slowly increased to 3 hrs midweek and 5 hrs on the sat plus gym work (strength, conditioning, fitness) twice a week for an hour.

This left plenty of time for other things- friendships, schoolwork, hobbies, martial arts free time. She would have trained more but we didn't feel it would be healthy.

If that's what gymnastics coaches are promoting, maybe they need to take a long hard look at themselves.

TimeForGouter · 05/05/2022 22:00

the 6 year old was in a squad and we signed a contract meaning she couldnt go to friends parties if they clashed with training

Blimey! Again nothing like that at DD’s club.

OutlookStalking · 05/05/2022 21:09

Yup it wasnt that long ago my the 6 year old was in a squad and we signed a contract meaning she couldnt go to friends parties if they clashed with training.. I regret that. We were anxious to even say we were going on holiday!

NerrSnerr · 05/05/2022 20:42

There is a movement starting in many sports to stop the over training of young kids. Becky Downie has said some bits about it and after lockdown was very vocal about how gymnasts of all ages have been lied to about how they can't ever have time off training as they'll lose their skills as after lockdown when they could all only do home training they've all still been able to maintain their skills.

Just because 6 year olds have always done many hours of sports training doesn't make it right and a 6 year old cannot understand the impact all the training will have on their bodies over the years. I don't know many elite gymnasts who are still competing in their 20s who haven't had multiple operations.

My 7 year old is in a development squad for a different sport but it's only a couple of hours a week. We tell the coaches when they've had a growth spurt and they do easier work for a couple of weeks due to their growing bones and they are advised not to do extra training when still young to protect their bodies. She also does gymnastics but one 45 minute class a week.

If your child is doing sport where you are not present when they train you need to be really vigilant. Sexual abuse still happens, coaches are being found out in many different sports. Also poor nutritional advice, weighing, bullying. Just because a coach seems 'lovely' does not mean anything. I grew up doing athletics in the 90s and it was bloody grim from the inside and parents need to be aware of the risks.

Oinkypig · 05/05/2022 20:41

@edwinbear i can’t believe that’s still happening! I remember we had two Russian coaches who were Olympic medal winners and the male coach sat on my back as a 10 year old to get my body flat on the floor. I didn’t realise things like that are still happening, I wouldn’t put my child through what happened to me as a child, and I loved gymnastics… looking back at the conditioning and effort not so much

Bunnycat101 · 05/05/2022 20:36

It’s normal for gymnastics unfortunately but is a hell of a lot for a 6/7 year old. I think you have to think about what next and when the hours shoot up from 9 to 15 or 20. Unless she has the perfect physique, temperament etc to progress I personally wouldn’t go down the gymnastics route as so much is required of the girls so young.

i used to watch some of the elite girls train at the club my daughter went to for preschool classes. They tended to be taken out of school to prep for big competitions. It can’t have been that regularly but was enough that I recognised them. Their schedule must have been immense and I looked them up and they were no-where the top 10 in their age group. At that point, the chances of making the Olympics are so small you have to wonder if giving up 30 plus hours is worth it when there are other spots you can get to a good level at a later age on fewer hours.