Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want my children around a violent man?

36 replies

BigYellowElephant · 04/05/2022 09:30

So my DSS (stepsister) had her children removed by social services last year. Was a huge shock to all of us as we'd had no idea there were issues. She's never told us what happened and doesnt want to talk about it - all we know was that she had been warned on numerous occasions never to leave the children alone with their dad and she did so. They were in the care of a family member (her side) for around 4 months and have now been returned to her care. Her mum has told us dad is "a psycho" and referred to domestic violence and also him being arrested for assault of someone outside the home. That's all we know.

So we've just had an invite to my nieces birthday at the end of the month. I asked DSS if dad would be there, and said if so we wouldn't make it but would plan a fun day out on another occasion (on me) to celebrate DNs birthday. She's absolutely hit the roof. Said I have no idea what's happened and need to stop sticking my nose in. I said that without knowing the full reasons for what happened, I didn't feel comfortable having my kids around him. She then said he's now allowed unsupervised contact anyway (first I've heard of it and no idea if true) so I need to leave the past in the past. She said she's not telling me anything and I'm a nosy parker. She's now not speaking to me.

We usually get on well so I'm a bit startled by this reaction. I think shes probably a bit stuck between a rock and a hard place but unless she's happy to give me more information, and it turns out dad isn't dangerous at all (seems unlikely) then on the limited info I have, he doesnt seem a safe person to have my children around. Just to be clear I'm not being nosy - I don't need to know anything if hes not going to be around my kids. AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
NeverDropYourMooncup · 04/05/2022 19:36

PumpkinsandKittens · 04/05/2022 10:44

Hmm the fact the kids were removed from her, returned and dad is now allowed unsupervised contact all within 4 months does suggest he could have been wrongly accused, it does happen and ss do make mistakes

Or she convinced them she wouldn't have anything to do with him, they signed off and the first thing she did after they stepped back was let him back into her life, thinking that lying about it would mean nobody would say a word to SS.

PumpkinsandKittens · 04/05/2022 16:37

MarJau26 · 04/05/2022 16:25

And wouldn't you then very openly tell your sister about it? She and her dh sound dodgy. Good call op. She also needs to realise that when she hides dodgy stuff like this, people are not going to support her.

She is the ops step sister not sister so no I probably wouldn’t tell my step sister! Depends on the relationship but they don’t sound close given that the op said her self she had no idea any of it was going on.

PeterpiperpickedapeckofpickledPEPPAS · 04/05/2022 16:33

YADNBU.
If she brings it up again, tell her the offer of a day out on you (without the dad present obviously) still stands - if she doesn’t take you up on it immediately then make it an ongoing open invitation. She may eventually come to respect your point of view or she may need you in the future if her ex’s behavior gets worse again.
She’s in a difficult position. She will likely have to comply with whatever contact has been ordered by the family court. Minimizing whatever happened may be a coping mechanism. The cognitive dissonance of someone you love/once loved or someone important to your kids doing something most people consider unforgivable is very difficult for to live with.
Stand firm but don’t get drawn into discussions about it or speculate on what might have happened. Forgiveness and ´the past is the past’ is vastly overrated in my opinion.

MarJau26 · 04/05/2022 16:25

PumpkinsandKittens · 04/05/2022 10:44

Hmm the fact the kids were removed from her, returned and dad is now allowed unsupervised contact all within 4 months does suggest he could have been wrongly accused, it does happen and ss do make mistakes

And wouldn't you then very openly tell your sister about it? She and her dh sound dodgy. Good call op. She also needs to realise that when she hides dodgy stuff like this, people are not going to support her.

BHX3000 · 04/05/2022 15:58

It’s sad to see how 15% of posters think the OP should have her children around someone she isn’t sure is a safe, responsible person.

Are there really that many women out there who wouldn’t put their kids first in a situation like this?

billy1966 · 04/05/2022 15:42

Aquamarine1029 · 04/05/2022 09:35

Your stepsister clearly has very, very poor judgment. I wouldn't have my children around her, never mind that man.

This.

Legrandsophie · 04/05/2022 14:58

You are completely reasonable. We don’t see MIL and her partner for the same reason. They are both violent drunks who hit each other and are completely in denial that there is a problem. We decided that DD doesn’t need to spend time with them until she is big enough to defend herself.

MIL is also a manipulative narcissist who like to make up things about people she doesn’t like. So best all round her my child not to be exposed to her.

Remember that toxic people don’t deserve your time, even if they are related to you. And you can save your child the heartache of having to cut themselves off from them later on life.

KettrickenSmiled · 04/05/2022 14:54

Shes now saying he's allowed unsupervised access but brought that up mid argument so I'm not sure its true

Even if it is true, SS/family court systems have a very low bar for allowing violent & otherwise unsuitable fathers unfettered access to their DC, even in the face of vocal misgivings from the DC's mother.
So it hardly gives him the guaranteed seal of approval that some maliciously woman-doubting naive PP's are imagining.

KettrickenSmiled · 04/05/2022 14:49

No it wouldn't, which is why it is far more likely that she is lying about him having unsupervised access, isn't it?

Thank you @MissusMaisel I couldn't have fielded that level of handmaidening without attracting a ban. Gin

Herejustforthisone · 04/05/2022 13:01

She may not be putting her kids’ safety first but that didn’t mean you have to do the same. I’d politely decline and then reduce my contact with them.

BigYellowElephant · 04/05/2022 11:25

@petalsandstars I've been thinking about that but I'd have to use her address as I don't know his new one. If she found out she really would think I'm a nosy Parker! And I actually don't need to know, I just don't want him around my kids and don't see any reason he needs to be, but she seems to disagree

OP posts:
Elseaknows · 04/05/2022 11:17

YANBU. Any woman who picks a man over her kids doesn't deserve the kids. End of.

BigYellowElephant · 04/05/2022 11:16

@PumpkinsandKittens sorry, maybe I didn't explain that well. This all happened around a year ago, and the kids were in care for 4 months (ish). They then went back to mum where they've been for the last 6/7 months. Dad lives elsewhere and last I heard was having contact centre visits every other week (that was months ago tbf). Shes now saying he's allowed unsupervised access but brought that up mid argument so I'm not sure its true.

OP posts:
MissusMaisel · 04/05/2022 11:16

PumpkinsandKittens · 04/05/2022 11:06

And yet This all happened in 4 months, kids removed, kids returned, him allowed unsupervised visits?? All sounds very odd, that wouldn’t have happened in the space of 4 months!

No it wouldn't, which is why it is far more likely that she is lying about him having unsupervised access, isn't it?

PumpkinsandKittens · 04/05/2022 11:08

In other words something is not adding up and yes ss do make mistakes. The op said it came as a huge shock and they never knew there was any issues

PumpkinsandKittens · 04/05/2022 11:06

KettrickenSmiled · 04/05/2022 10:59

"Hmm" sure Pumpkin, it's really MUCH more likely that SS made a mistake than a man committed domestic violence, innit.

And yet This all happened in 4 months, kids removed, kids returned, him allowed unsupervised visits?? All sounds very odd, that wouldn’t have happened in the space of 4 months!

KettrickenSmiled · 04/05/2022 10:59

PumpkinsandKittens · 04/05/2022 10:44

Hmm the fact the kids were removed from her, returned and dad is now allowed unsupervised contact all within 4 months does suggest he could have been wrongly accused, it does happen and ss do make mistakes

"Hmm" sure Pumpkin, it's really MUCH more likely that SS made a mistake than a man committed domestic violence, innit.

KettrickenSmiled · 04/05/2022 10:55

BigYellowElephant · 04/05/2022 09:42

Oh I was always going to be at the party with them, sorry if that wasn't clear. And it's vanishingly unlikely he would start a fight or whatever in the middle of his daughters party. Its more the principle of knowingly bringing my kids around someone I know is unsafe. Setting a precedent that he's their family. Potentially having them develop a relationship with him so they see him as a "safe" person. All of that stuff. She thinks I'm an over thinker but I think it matters

You are not overthinking this.

If she wants to condone his violence by allowing him into her home & playing happy families, there's not much you can do, apart from avoid.

What a desperate shame. Given the SS involvement & child-removal, this was her shot at getting a violent man out of all of their lives for good, barring supervised contact centre visits - if he insisted.

MissusMaisel · 04/05/2022 10:54

I wouldn't just not go, I'd also report to social services. Sounds like he's supposed to stay away from them and is ignoring this.

petalsandstars · 04/05/2022 10:54

You could do a Sarah’s law application re their dad as he’s potentially in contact with your DC. It would perhaps give you peace of mind or a good reason to stick to your guns.

MrsSkylerWhite · 04/05/2022 10:54

Of course you are not BU.

KettrickenSmiled · 04/05/2022 10:52

She's now not speaking to me.

Leave that ball in her court. Do nothing to pick it up. I understand that she is defensive & probably managing all kinds of misplaced anger & hurt, but projecting it onto you is out of order.

She didn't prioritise her own kids over a violent man.
No way can you trust her to prioritise yours.

She's also lying to you.
Nobody gets their DC removed for 4 months on a whim.
Again - understandable, & I appreciate there are complex factors underlying how women are unable to extricate themselves from abusive & violent relationships ... but unless she opens up to you, you cannot trust her.

And I doubt she is going to open up. The "nosy parker" comment - when you were nothing of the sort, just admirably plain-speaking - shows that there is a whole heap of mess she's covering up. Again - understandable. The shame & humiliation of living with a tyrant are horrible, & abuse thrives in the secrecy it creates.

But unless she can be honest with you - not your problem, & certainly not your children's problem.

FAQs · 04/05/2022 10:45

I guess the man sadly is winning at isolating her from her family, a well known ploy, your step sister is a victim of DV and it might take her a while to recognise that and accept it, I’d attend to offer her support, but depending on the age of your children, without them.

PumpkinsandKittens · 04/05/2022 10:44

Hmm the fact the kids were removed from her, returned and dad is now allowed unsupervised contact all within 4 months does suggest he could have been wrongly accused, it does happen and ss do make mistakes

dogsonrollerskates · 04/05/2022 10:39

You are completely reasonable- but be prepared for a your step sister (and possibly other family members) to think that you are in the wrong and quite possibly keep pushing the issue in future.

I had a similar issue with my own brother. I got on well with my SIL and was happy for my DC to have a relationship with her and with her children but did not want my brother around them. Similar reasons- domestic abuse, violence and extreme drinking (part of my reasoning for maintaining a relationship with SIL was so that she had someone to turn to when she was ready to leave him). Like you, as well as the risk of violent behaviour in front of them, I did not want my DC to see him as someone 'safe' to be around or to be influenced by him (he was very good at appearing to be fun and charming at first).

I am glad that stuck to my decision for my DC never to be around him but it did make my relationship with SIL and my niece/nephew difficult (DNs repeatedly asked why I wouldn't let my DC stay at their house and why they couldn't bring Dad when they came to visit- I suspect he prompted this). It also caused arguments with my parents who for years pretended that he was just a lovely but misunderstood person. Looking back, I think my SIL and parents were trying to pretend everything was OK so by refusing to go along with this narrative I became the bad guy. He also denied/minimised his behaviour and encouraged wider extended family and friends to see me as a liar and trouble causer- which many believed until they witnessed his violence themselves.

Swipe left for the next trending thread