Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it better to spoil your paper or just not vote?

178 replies

cremeeggsonboxingday · 04/05/2022 09:02

I am really struggling with deciding who to vote for tomorrow in the local election. To be honest, I can't bring myself to vote for any of them. I'm just wondering what would be the best way to make an impact. Would a low voter turn out send a message or would it be better to write exactly what I think of them all on my paper?

Yabu = don't vote
Yanbu = spoil your paper

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
Anonymous48 · 04/05/2022 14:55

I can't understand not voting. It's not a right that everyone in the world has, and it's not a right that everyone in the UK always had either.
You may not love any of the candidates, but pick the lesser evil and cast your vote for them.

amillionrosepetals · 04/05/2022 14:45

viques · 04/05/2022 12:59
Sorry, I think I have tagged the wrong poster, I am sure someone said they sometimes add themselves onto the ballot paper. I think I will add amillionrosepetals anyway, because I like the board name and it will cause a moment of confusion among the counting staff. ( one of whom is my DD, though not in my borough luckily)

Hello@viques . I'm glad you said that, I was baffled by your earlier post! Just in case - you are only a woman if you have XX chromosomes. This does not mean I am anti-TRANS by the way but the rights of biological women and girls are not something 'optional' that can be removed. I would be honoured to have your vote.😀

FourTeaFallOut · 04/05/2022 14:30

When you are faced political options which are different shades of the same shit then I think spoiling your paper is the least worst option.

AProperStinging · 04/05/2022 14:28

Ncwinc · 04/05/2022 13:58

I wasn’t aware of the Green Party’s record on antisemitism. Damn it. It’s back to finding independent candidates for me then.

Yeah, it is gutting for me too. They've always been my 'protest vote' and my mum's too.

SocratesSister · 04/05/2022 14:27

Local councils run vital services which children and families depend on and you are paying over a thousand pounds a year in council tax. Why would you not want a say in how your money is spent and what services you get. If there was no real difference between candidates they would not be fighting hard for your vote, your candidates are local people who want to make a difference, they get little money for what they do.

Racingadmin · 04/05/2022 14:26

Not read the whole thread but spoiling is slightly better than not voting .

Please , please do not get your ballot and then leave without putting it in the ballot box . It makes the count at 11pm an impossible nightmare as the amount of ballots issued must equal the amount counted when we open up the box .

In our borough all spoilt ballots (plain or with a message on ) are seen by the returning officer & candidates / agents for that ward when adjudicated. They will also be seen by those watching us count and sort as ballots are sorted face up

newbiename · 04/05/2022 14:25

"Women died for the right to vote."
Women died so we'd have the choice , not so we had to.

InMySpareTime · 04/05/2022 14:15

If you really, genuinely, can't bring yourself to vote for anyone, then spoiling your ballot is slightly "better" than not voting at all.

Only because the demographics of people who arrive to vote are collected, and policies are targeted at the sort of people who might vote.

If you want people in your demographic to count as "people who matter to politicians might vote" then you, and people like you need to turn up at polling stations en masse, and outnumber the other demographics.

The reason Govt policies favour the older and richer people is that they are the ones who rock up and vote.

But overall, staying home

FatOaf · 04/05/2022 14:14

I think I've only spoiled my ballot paper once. This was an election for a police & crime commissioner (which shouldn't exist anyway) and all of the candidates were representing political parties (who shouldn't be influencing policing) rather than independent candidates.

In all other elections I've been able to choose a best or least-bad candidate, although I haven't yet faced a ballot paper on which all candidates were totally unfit. If I absolutely couldn't vote for anyone I would spoil my paper, as this is at least an indication of discontent rather than apathy. Not bothering to turn up when you're capable of doing so is inexcusable.

comealongponds · 04/05/2022 14:06

Neither option achieves anything. Just vote for the least worst option.

elfycat · 04/05/2022 14:04

I have spoiled votes in the past. You have to make it obvious it's spoiled rather than mistakenly messing up the vote. My belief is that it would indicate to candidates that I was willing to turn up and spend my time in the process of voting - but not for any of you fuckers. My vote is here, you just have to show me why it's yours. It was up for grabs and you all failed.

But you have to be sure you want to do that. I'm a swing voter and if there is a pressing matter that I care about, more than I care for the minutiae of the other stuff I might otherwise not vote for a candidate for, then I vote for them. Not big stuff that I can't swallow on moral grounds - That's ruined ballot time.

Ncwinc · 04/05/2022 14:00

The Greens aren’t going to get in, outside of Brighton, so their policies being too green doesn’t bother me. Nor does their view on gender. I draw the line at racism though.

Ncwinc · 04/05/2022 13:58

I wasn’t aware of the Green Party’s record on antisemitism. Damn it. It’s back to finding independent candidates for me then.

tedgran · 04/05/2022 13:56

My understanding is that the Greens go along with Stonewall, so won't be voting for them. I will probably write "respect my sex if you want my x" on the ballot paper. It will be between Tories and Libdems here, won't vote Tory and Libdem canvasser declined to answer my question of what a woman is!

Badbadbunny · 04/05/2022 13:49

FoiledByTheInsect · 04/05/2022 13:18

Please don't spoil your vote, tempting as it may be. You can vent about the useless lying twats on here instead.

Vote Green, as the only way to force electoral change and get some degree of democracy is to vote for the party that can't get elected atm.

Fuck off Boris and Keir if you or your bots are reading.

I'd rather vote Tory than Greens as the local Green party are way too extreme to be taken seriously, such as wanting a complete ban on private cars in the wider city centre area (so you'd be unable to drive to the city hospital or the railway station or the shopping centres and supermarkets) - it would be delivery vehicles, buses and taxis only! That policy alone has alienated most car drivers.

AProperStinging · 04/05/2022 13:36

Ncwinc · 04/05/2022 10:31

I’d vote Green in your situation. The Green candidate is unlikely to win but it shows the other parties that there is a vote there to be won and that green issues matter to voters - all the parties need to improve in this area.

Local election turnout is so low that if you want to register a protest vote you need to spoil the ballot. In most areas about 60% of those eligible to vote don’t bother to.

Unfortunately, having been driven out of Labour by antisemitism, it seems that the Greens are even worse on this issue :(

Hillarious · 04/05/2022 13:27

SpindleInTheWind · 04/05/2022 12:46

I think some people claiming to have worked at election counts where spoiled ballots effectively just got cast aside either (a) didn't work at election counts and are just making that up for their own reasons, eg to scold women on MN; or (b) were part of the most badly run election counts in the UK, given the legal rules.

This with knobs on.

FoiledByTheInsect · 04/05/2022 13:18

Please don't spoil your vote, tempting as it may be. You can vent about the useless lying twats on here instead.

Vote Green, as the only way to force electoral change and get some degree of democracy is to vote for the party that can't get elected atm.

Fuck off Boris and Keir if you or your bots are reading.

ZarquonsSandals · 04/05/2022 13:14

PurpleDaisies · 04/05/2022 09:37

Pick the best of a bad bunch. Otherwise the only message you’re sending is you don’t care enough to make a decision and you’re happy with whoever. Somebody is going to win-why wouldn’t you try to influence that?

If you’re not happy with the current government, I’d be voting for whoever was most likely to deny them seats.

This will be my approach.

broccolibush · 04/05/2022 13:13

Pick any another candidate such as Greens and vote for them. It's unlikely they will win but they won't do much damage should they get some seats

Aside from to non-men’s rights.

I am finding it impossible to hold my nose and vote least-worst so spoiling is the only real option for me. I won’t stay home and not vote, I just can’t. But I can not vote in person. I’m quite fond of the idea of spoiling my ballot by leaving it completely blank. Then I’ve done what I can for my own conscience.

Not that it matters here, it’s so one party it’s almost comical. And as I said upthread no candidate has told us what they stand for. Were we not politically aware then it would be conceivable we wouldn’t know anything was going on local election wise.

FreddyVoorhees · 04/05/2022 13:06

Vote. Don't spoil your paper either. No one cares. Do you think that a candidate gives two shits that you've written "Tory scum" or whatever on your ballot? You're filed under "nutcase", nothing more.

Pick any another candidate such as Greens and vote for them. It's unlikely they will win but they won't do much damage should they get some seats.

ChrisReasBathEggs · 04/05/2022 13:03

I don't have a local election tomorrow, but in our last one (when the Brexit shitshow was in it's hayday with Teresa May) there was a lot of protest voting for independents or opposing party candidates. Tories did very shit and it is a Tory stronghold around here when it comes to the GE (not so sure about it next time though, my Tory MP has a terrible voting record and the one in my neighbouring town is such a massive right wing nob he is in danger of losing his seat at the next GE).

I don't think spoiling your vote really does anything unless it's a very coordinated effort across many people. Better off voting for the best option for your town. If it's a GE, I don't think spoiling your vote will do much either, just vote for the opposing party in your area and hopefully you get a hung parliament or a party without a strong majority. That will send a better message. I think we've all seen what a strong majority leads to in politics now...it's not the best option.

If you want to make a statement about the shitness if politics right now just write to the politicians.

Needsmorebeans · 04/05/2022 13:00

candidates and their agents always look at spoiled papers (in my experience) in the hope that they can claim the vote as theirs. i once saw one where the voter has drawn a clowns head next to every candidates name. it must have taken them ages.

viques · 04/05/2022 12:59

Sorry, I think I have tagged the wrong poster, I am sure someone said they sometimes add themselves onto the ballot paper. I think I will add amillionrosepetals anyway, because I like the board name and it will cause a moment of confusion among the counting staff. ( one of whom is my DD, though not in my borough luckily)

MNettersForNoahAndFiona · 04/05/2022 12:53

YANBU.

Some voters in Northern Ireland are planning to spoil their ballots as a protest against all the candidates. They are using their 'vote for Noah Donohoe' instead to call for a new and independent investigation and a public enquiry into 14 year old Noah's disappearance and death in June 2020. It is also to protest against the police application for a Public Interest Immunity certificate, (to keep over 600 pages of information secret), and a coroner's investigation only for Noah instead of a full and proper police investigation.

The lack of support from some candidates has been shocking. Others have been there wanting the photo opportunities with Fiona, (Noah's mother), and paying lip service to her campaign to get the truth about Noah's death and justice for him, but then failing to publicly commit to a new independent investigation and public enquiry.

Here's a current thread about it:
www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4537366-aibu-to-want-to-know-the-truth-about-this
You can find a link to the petition to support Fiona, currently with 305,988 signatures, in the OP of this thread:
www.mumsnet.com/talk/petitions_noticeboard/4525759--THREAD-2-Will-you-spare-five-minutes-to-help-the-lovely-Noah-Donohoe-get-the-justice-he-deserves-and-to-support-his-mummy-Fiona-in-getting-the-truth-about-what-happened-to-her-beloved-son

The person who will ultimately sign off the PII certificate is Brandon Lewis, MP for Great Yarmouth/Secretary of State for NI.

This isn't just an issue for Northern Ireland. The use of PIIs by the police has allowed serious offenders to murder again elsewhere. One example is Robert Howard, who was free to move between England, Scotland, the RO Ireland and NI for 40years, committing serious acts of sexual violence and the murder of women and children.

Is it better to spoil your paper or just not vote?
Is it better to spoil your paper or just not vote?
Is it better to spoil your paper or just not vote?