Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Pranks

69 replies

OrlaOrchid · 04/05/2022 08:58

As a kid, I used to play pranks, sometimes on friends or my sisters or cousins. They all pranked me too, it was fun and everyone did it. Ds seems to take after his me and loves to hatch an elaborate plan for a prank. AIBU to think that planning and playing pranks is a pretty normal part of growing up and harmless?

OP posts:
OrlaOrchid · 04/05/2022 14:35

This is making me feel bad but I can see everyone's point of view. Any ideas how to get DS to stop his fixation on pranks? I'd hate I'm to become unpopular or annoy his mates. I honestly have no idea how to explain this to him, his confidence isn't the best at times, he's not into football like most boys in his class and this is maybe a way for him to feel 'big' and part of a friendship gang. Because he's not harming or setting out to embarrass, I'm not sure he'll see what's wrong with it. All this paints him as a bit of a joker / fool Sad I guess he's quite silly.

OP posts:
user1745 · 04/05/2022 14:07

It's not ok to play a prank where the purpose is to humiliate or degrade someone else.

I don't think the fake injury prank is particularly nice, even if he doesn't mean harm by it, because it only really serves to amuse him and the other boy involved. Doing that kind of thing all the time will annoy other children and may cost him friends. I also don't see that it's particularly funny to see someone worried and concerned over a child apparently injured. It's a childish thing to be amused over, and yes he is a child so it's understandable and natural for him to be amused by it, but it probably shouldn't be encouraged by adults.

Joke/tricks where everyone ends up laughing, not just the prankster are ok, in moderation (people who are constantly joking around and playing pranks can become really tiresome though they might not realise it).

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 04/05/2022 14:03

I loathe pranks. But I guess if you are amongst consenting friends....
I don't prank anyone since I don't appreciate it.

BlossomWind · 04/05/2022 13:44

WB205020 · 04/05/2022 13:27

Im on the Fence about pranks but having said that i usually find things like Ant & Dec's pranks funny. When they dress up and go undercover to prank other celebrities. Do people not consider thi s the same?

I was thinking about Ant and Dec, except I can't watch that kind of thing, I just find it so cringey and awful. DS laughs like a drain though.

BlossomWind · 04/05/2022 13:42

OrlaOrchid · 04/05/2022 12:51

So IABU, I take that.

A boy at school has told ds that he is weird because DS loves to plan harmless pranks in minute detail and get his friends involved, it's like a fun game to him. DS has 100% no ill intentions and or ill feeling against the people he pranks, he simply enjoys the planning and imagining how fun it will be. It's stuff like 'let's make Ollie believe that Max has hurt himself by putting red paint on his face, Max has to lie on the floor and cry and shout' stuff like that.

If it's so bad and kids think DS is a bit weird Hmm what shall I tell DS? He's 10, a bit immature for his age and really cannot see the harm in this as no-one gets hurt and nothing gets damaged, it's entertaining to him. What he finds most fun is the planning. He should probably be a film director for action movies 😂.

Well, it is basically lying, isn't it? It is very elaborate lying, getting someone to believe something that isn't true.

I can't understand why it is so funny to make someone believe something that isn't true. DH's family are a bit like this without the elaborate set up - someone will come in the room and they will say something that isn't true but could be, accompanied by winks and grins to the other people in the room. I mean, if I am told something I tend to believe it as I don't go round thinking people are lying for no reason, so I don't think it's a huge gotcha or hilarious to be "caught out".

OrlaOrchid · 04/05/2022 13:37

And it's not like the boy who cried wold, he is not a lier! He's pretend playing.

OP posts:
OrlaOrchid · 04/05/2022 13:36

I honestly thought it's completely normal and common for kids to prank each other . There is so much of this on TikTok and YT too. Ds doesn't have a phone yet but his cousin who is a year older does and shows him lots of funny clips and memes.

OP posts:
Wheelz46 · 04/05/2022 13:34

Then what happens if Ollie calls 999 because Max has hurt himself?

WB205020 · 04/05/2022 13:27

Im on the Fence about pranks but having said that i usually find things like Ant & Dec's pranks funny. When they dress up and go undercover to prank other celebrities. Do people not consider thi s the same?

Ifitdoesntmakesense · 04/05/2022 13:24

The kids who play pranks are generally not popular with their classmates, my son has a few in his year at school & they are not well liked

OrlaOrchid · 04/05/2022 13:19

godmum56 · 04/05/2022 13:02

So hecwants Ollie to be scared/upset? Or he wants Ollie to rush for a teacher and be humilated? I don't call any of that harmless and would be redirecting his creativity, also talking to him about how he would feel if he was the butt of the "prank" If he doesn't learn to moderate his humour I fear that one of his bictims will haul off and thump him.

No way, he doesn't want Ollie to get upset, he wants Ollie to find it funny.

OP posts:
godmum56 · 04/05/2022 13:19

OrlaOrchid · 04/05/2022 13:16

The boys involved (names changed obv.) all take part in planning various pranks that they play on each other, they find it funny and spend ages planning these things although my ds is probably the one who is most into it. It's like they are bonding over these pranks or maybe they're just killing time. But they all find it hilarious. The boy who said ds is weird is not part of this group but hasn't been pranked either. I really wouldn't know how to get him to stop, if he and his mates are into it.

Well that's a drip feed! That sounds more to me like a private drama club than pranking.

LibrariesGiveUsPower · 04/05/2022 13:18

OrlaOrchid · 04/05/2022 12:51

So IABU, I take that.

A boy at school has told ds that he is weird because DS loves to plan harmless pranks in minute detail and get his friends involved, it's like a fun game to him. DS has 100% no ill intentions and or ill feeling against the people he pranks, he simply enjoys the planning and imagining how fun it will be. It's stuff like 'let's make Ollie believe that Max has hurt himself by putting red paint on his face, Max has to lie on the floor and cry and shout' stuff like that.

If it's so bad and kids think DS is a bit weird Hmm what shall I tell DS? He's 10, a bit immature for his age and really cannot see the harm in this as no-one gets hurt and nothing gets damaged, it's entertaining to him. What he finds most fun is the planning. He should probably be a film director for action movies 😂.

That example is classic boy who cried wolf territory. Maybe you should teach him that story and explain if he actually gets badly hurt one day no one will believe him.

Sahmnomore · 04/05/2022 13:16

The problem is that pranks, even "harmless" ones, always make someone feel stupid.

Have you not read the boy who cried wolf? He risks not bring believed when something is really wrong.

OrlaOrchid · 04/05/2022 13:16

The boys involved (names changed obv.) all take part in planning various pranks that they play on each other, they find it funny and spend ages planning these things although my ds is probably the one who is most into it. It's like they are bonding over these pranks or maybe they're just killing time. But they all find it hilarious. The boy who said ds is weird is not part of this group but hasn't been pranked either. I really wouldn't know how to get him to stop, if he and his mates are into it.

OP posts:
MarJau26 · 04/05/2022 13:11

I don't think your son is funny with those pranks.

sanityisamyth · 04/05/2022 13:09

7Worfs · 04/05/2022 09:15

Pranking is prioritising your own amusement at other people’s expense. At best lacks empathy, at worst it’s sociopathic.

This!

AmbushedByCake1 · 04/05/2022 13:04

The issue for me with pranks is that it's having fun at someone else's expense. I find them really mean spirited.

MatildaTheCat · 04/05/2022 13:04

When my elderly DM was a child she was left at home with her three siblings while their parents went to church. The youngest was about 6. Her brothers made a vaguely life sized stuffed child made of old bits of clothing and the 6 year olds clothes on top. As the parents returned and were walking down the street the naughty bothers threw the fake child out of the upstairs window.

sorry, I know it was a horrible thing to do but we still laugh about it 70 odd years later.

There have been several family pranks over the years mostly quite elaborate but never malicious. There is a fine line though from reading some examples on here.

godmum56 · 04/05/2022 13:03

"Victims"

godmum56 · 04/05/2022 13:02

OrlaOrchid · 04/05/2022 12:51

So IABU, I take that.

A boy at school has told ds that he is weird because DS loves to plan harmless pranks in minute detail and get his friends involved, it's like a fun game to him. DS has 100% no ill intentions and or ill feeling against the people he pranks, he simply enjoys the planning and imagining how fun it will be. It's stuff like 'let's make Ollie believe that Max has hurt himself by putting red paint on his face, Max has to lie on the floor and cry and shout' stuff like that.

If it's so bad and kids think DS is a bit weird Hmm what shall I tell DS? He's 10, a bit immature for his age and really cannot see the harm in this as no-one gets hurt and nothing gets damaged, it's entertaining to him. What he finds most fun is the planning. He should probably be a film director for action movies 😂.

So hecwants Ollie to be scared/upset? Or he wants Ollie to rush for a teacher and be humilated? I don't call any of that harmless and would be redirecting his creativity, also talking to him about how he would feel if he was the butt of the "prank" If he doesn't learn to moderate his humour I fear that one of his bictims will haul off and thump him.

LittleScottieDog · 04/05/2022 12:58

"it's entertaining to him"

It says it all, really. It may entertain him, but is he entertaining other people or embarrassing them?

I hated pranks being played on me when I was younger. I still do, really, but I've learnt to force myself to smile because otherwise you're viewed as being a spoilsport or too sensitive.

I think you need to help your DS see that not everyone likes having pranks played on them, and that by continuing to do so, he is perhaps upsetting them. Maybe if he has a friend or family member who doesn't mind and pays them back, he could continue to prank them. But only if they really don't mind.

Does your DS like it when people play pranks on him? Maybe you could do it to him and he could do it within the household only?

OverByYer · 04/05/2022 12:54

7Worfs · 04/05/2022 09:15

Pranking is prioritising your own amusement at other people’s expense. At best lacks empathy, at worst it’s sociopathic.

This 100%.
i like a laugh and a joke but pranks are laughing at someone else’s expense.

I can’t bear all the internet ‘pranksters’, just grow up.

OrlaOrchid · 04/05/2022 12:51

So IABU, I take that.

A boy at school has told ds that he is weird because DS loves to plan harmless pranks in minute detail and get his friends involved, it's like a fun game to him. DS has 100% no ill intentions and or ill feeling against the people he pranks, he simply enjoys the planning and imagining how fun it will be. It's stuff like 'let's make Ollie believe that Max has hurt himself by putting red paint on his face, Max has to lie on the floor and cry and shout' stuff like that.

If it's so bad and kids think DS is a bit weird Hmm what shall I tell DS? He's 10, a bit immature for his age and really cannot see the harm in this as no-one gets hurt and nothing gets damaged, it's entertaining to him. What he finds most fun is the planning. He should probably be a film director for action movies 😂.

OP posts:
LemonDrizzles · 04/05/2022 11:46

Really really not harmless