Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that US states who want to ban abortion should be able to?

336 replies

allsorts1 · 04/05/2022 08:34

Abortion is such a fraught topic in the US. Would it really be so bad to just let the states who want to ban abortion do so, and leave it in the hands of the states themselves to decide? It seems that the Roe v Wade decision has caused a lot of tension in the context of the USA and the feeling that states should be independent and able to choose their own laws (e.g different laws on capital punishment).

Would it be a completely terrible thing for each state to decide on this, and then live with the consequences (as presumably many young people/liberals would relocate to different states where abortion is legal?). Maybe if they experience brain drain they will change their tune. People aren’t forced to live in a certain state.

Obviously I am completely aware this will have a huge negative impact on women in poverty as they have less options. So this is a key consideration and concern.

But I’m just really thinking out loud. I am very much pro-choice, but interested in views from people who understand US law and politics… could the overturning of Roe v Wade potentially be positive in that it settles the issues, states can decide, and everyone can talk about something else?

Or would it just mean that there is a gradual encroachment on women rights and then the pro-lifers start lobbying in pro-choice states and abortion rights are even further reduced. Another risk could be that abortion becomes a political issue every election in every state, and switches back and forth from being legal to illegal - causing massive headaches….

Interested to hear everyone’s thoughts!

OP posts:
JanisMoplin · 04/05/2022 10:48

My sister lives in Texas with my niece. If my niece gets pregnant tomorrow and travels to a neighbouring state, what liberal neighbouring states would allow an abortion? Oklahoma? Nope. Arkansas. Nope. Lousiana? Nope.

So she has to trek to California or Massachussetts?

allsorts1 · 04/05/2022 10:47

I guess when law is handed down on high, like in the case of Roe v Wade, it makes it very vulnerable to the whims of particular judges. Hot topics get shifted from political debate to the space of “human rights” and debate shut down altogether. The religious right is outraged and galvanised. They lobby for their own representatives on the Supreme Court. The consequence is that the judiciary is made political and this is bad news for everyone.

By handing the power to states, in the short term this will be absolutely disastrous and a tragedy for women. In the long term there is the potential for a strengthened political movement to change hearts and minds in red states and increase access to abortion through democracy. Maybe this won’t happen. But on the ground, in places like Texas, poor women already struggle to get abortions anyway. At least by repealing Roe v Wade the issue will be made very clear, and perhaps feminists rather than the religious right will be galvanised.

Or perhaps we are heading to New England.

OP posts:
PermanentTemporary · 04/05/2022 10:44

Restricting abortion rights affects everyone. The shitty restrictive law that Poland brought in has meant not only that Polish women are forced to give birth but also that Ukrainian women who've been forced to flee their homes are struggling to access abortion. I'm not even mentioning the war rapes (ok I am) because I don't believe in a 'rape exemption' - the criterion for abortion should be, does the woman want one, is it medically achievable? But for some people women are allowed more rights if they have been tortured first.

eyeofthebeerholder · 04/05/2022 10:42

Oh fuck the fuck off and fuck off some more.

take your goady “just thinking out loud” thread and piss off.

Don you really need strangers on the internet to tell you what a decimation of women’s rights this is?

go back under your stone.

ByTheSea · 04/05/2022 10:40

SpiderVersed · 04/05/2022 08:36

It won’t prevent abortion. It will outlaw safe abortions.

Women and girls will die.

This

Housetreecar · 04/05/2022 10:39

This move is one of the most shocking and terrible things I have heard in a very long time. This is a western country in the 21st century. It is truly abhorrent to take away a fundamental human right of a women to have control over her body

MrsMariaReynolds · 04/05/2022 10:39

The whole point of Roe v Wade is that it supersedes any state ban on abortion and secures a woman's right to choose on a NATIONAL level. Weakening or reversing it altogether would undermine 50 years of progress and women's rights. Giving power back to the states is exactly what Republicans want, and is very dangerous, slippery territory.

Hoowhoowho · 04/05/2022 10:38

Kelly’s pregnant, she’s 15. She doesn’t want to continue her pregnancy but she knows her mom who is pro life would not be supportive of her ending this pregnancy. She goes to her local clinic, receives counselling and has a termination she decides not to tell her mother about
But if Kelly lives in a state that bans abortion, it’s not going to be easy for her to fly/drive out of state and access an abortion privately so likely she’ll be torn between attempting to end the pregnancy herself or continuing with a pregnancy she doesn’t want.

the same goes for Shirley who lives with an abusive partner who claims to be pro life

Then there’s Betsy who is a single parent of five children and works three jobs. She can access the clinic round the corner but getting childcare and leave for a trip from Alabama to the nearest state with legalised abortion is near impossible.

or there’s Ruby who took her first job at age 21 in a state that has criminalised abortion and then found herself unexpectedly pregnant. She has the money to access another state for abortion but not the leave in a new job in a fire at will state.

these are the women at risk and this is why federal law needs to guarantee abortion rights.

Heronwatcher · 04/05/2022 10:36

Thing is, safe abortion is a basic human right for women. I’m all for allowing local discretion where possible but not in these cases where basic/ fundamental rights are involved- there has to be a baseline below which no one state can sink which is protected by the government, even where public opinion may differ. Otherwise where does it end- if a state decided to cull all disabled people, or people over a certain age, would we be fine with this on the basis that those groups of people could “just move”?

MangoBiscuit · 04/05/2022 10:32

If states want to ban abortion, then they also need to provide full healthcare for the mother, at least up to a year post partum, and for any related issues for life, including any therapy. Full healthcare for the child until they reach adulthood. A year's paid maternity leave. Full time childcare to allow the mother to still work. Additional benefits to cover the cost of housing, feeding, clothing the child. They also need to offer free contraception, and make big changes to the law around rape, so that it is actually a deterant.

Until they're prepared to do all that, they can fuck off.

TheVanguardSix · 04/05/2022 10:32

So from a strictly philosophical view, trying to look impartially at all sides, maybe removing the much hated top down ruling of Roe v Wade, which seems to be seen very much as “elite liberal interference” would take some heat out of it in a political sense for the deep red states and allow them to formulate their own laws, which could end up being more balanced and a bit like Texas plus.

Nope. It would just be caving to the malignancy of radical states and perpetuating America's radical right, a force hellbent on eroding women's rights and therefore human rights. The minority rule (evangelical asswipes) have gained the upper hand, radicalising America, giving strength to the voices that were, in my childhood, the voices of the nutty fringe element but have now gained so much momentum, they are side sweeping and worse, silencing the majority voice. We American women may as well use the pages of Our Bodies, Ourselves as bog roll. It is a clusterfuck what is happening in America.
Balanced is a word that doesn't even belong here, OP. There is nothing balanced about 26 states banning abortion with several others following suit in the next 12 months.

Balanced like Texas is a wonderful oxymoron!

Texas considers itself its own republic, always hollering 'federal rule!'
Well, just take a look at its power crisis in 2021. It relies on its own deregulated power grid, rather than the national ones in place. That Texas power crisis is a perfect example of why you can't just hand individual states total federal rule... and what a disaster it would be to do this with regards to abortion laws.

You suggest it might take the heat out politically but have you considered how much this would crank it up by several notches socially?

Hellospring22 · 04/05/2022 10:29

Yes it would be. We are living in 2022 women, all women regardless of any other factors deserve the right to choose. It doesn’t matter how careful you are, pregnancy is a potential outcome every single time you have sex and anyone who thinks otherwise is misguided. All women should have access to safe, legal termination if they decide they don’t want to go through with a pregnancy.

WDTABNONONO · 04/05/2022 10:28

The people the worst effected will be those who will suffer the most from it being banned.

Richer women can go to another state/get expensive pills etc but poorer women, disabled women, rape victims etc - they'll be unlikely to be able to access it.

It's haemorrhage/ sepsis waiting to happen and all because some self righteous apparent 'Christian' thinks it's wrong.

Sirius3030 · 04/05/2022 10:26

US States are big… A relocation could take you a long long way from friends & family.

Triffid1 · 04/05/2022 10:24

But the UK is a secular country, while large parts of the USA are not. In those parts of the USA, if the majority favour a ban then shouldn't the majority prevail?

No, because there are all kinds of things that are considered "okay" according to some religious people that other people (including different religions or less conservative versions of the same religion) do not consider okay. And individual states are not supposed to be making decisions for their entire population based on the religious beliefs of a few. If your religion states that you cannot have an abortion for any reason, that is YOUR choice. You don't get to impose that choice on me. Or perhaps we should agree that stoning a thief to death is okay? Or whipping a wife? Or child marriage?

Youdoyoutoday · 04/05/2022 10:23

What utter bullshit!!

WDTABNONONO · 04/05/2022 10:22

Why should anyone but the person carrying the foetus have a say

None of their business.

I can't see any argument that could change that fact.

Sirzy · 04/05/2022 10:19

The majority aren’t being ask to have an abortion. They shouldn’t be allowed to block access to them for the minority for whom that is the best choice.

lljkk · 04/05/2022 10:18

What I will say about the leaked opinion...

Alito is considered by many court watchers to be an intellectual lightweight. My guess is that Gorsuch etc. are going to hugely rewrite this opinion (can you imagine the tracked changes on that document), and try to frame the decision as one about state rights vs. federal rights. This would create the stronger position for individual anti-abortion states going forward, too, and without seeming to completely undermine all precedent (Roe v. Wade). Alito has been quoted for emotional proclamations in the leaked draft but cooler heads (eg. ACB, Kavanagh, yeah really) will temper it.

Breyer or Elena Kagan's dissent will be powerful, too.

However, the precedent of states giving power to citizens to prosecute other people for things they did in another state : it's weird. I'm not sure how that principle can stand long term. It's like, if smoking pot in TX is illegal, then should I be prosecuted if I smoked pot in Netherlands and then visited TX a week later. How can ordinary residents of TX have such sweeping powers. I am optimistic this idea will be wiped out by supreme court. It's the most enormous can of worms if left standing. A persecution charter.

I also have a gut feeling that this is seismic in American politics. It's longshot to fruition, but I would not be surprised if the west coast/CA secessionist movement makes a lot of ground on back of this seemingly inevitable ruling.

Rosehugger · 04/05/2022 10:16

In those parts of the USA, if the majority favour a ban then shouldn't the majority prevail?

What if the majority wanted to bring back slavery and racial segregation, would that also be ok? 🙄

CapMarvel · 04/05/2022 10:16

"But the UK is a secular country, while large parts of the USA are not. In those parts of the USA, if the majority favour a ban then shouldn't the majority prevail?"

No, because the vunerable minority are usually the ones with the smallest voices and the smallest ability to impact change or defend their rights.

MorrisZapp · 04/05/2022 10:13

This thread misses the point. I'm personally very pro choice, I've had a termination myself. I wouldn't feel safe or comfortable living in a country with no safe access to abortion.

But the UK is a secular country, while large parts of the USA are not. In those parts of the USA, if the majority favour a ban then shouldn't the majority prevail?

If huge issues such as the death penalty vary from state to state then it seems logical that abortion could be governed similarly. I'd be personally disgusted, but I'm not a Christian.

Hallyup89 · 04/05/2022 10:12

Banning abortion doesn't stop abortion.

Anyone that thinks that banning safe abortions is the way to go obviously struggles to see past the end of their nose.

This will be a disaster for women, children and the state. I can't believe such a supposedly civilised society could be so backward.

Rosehugger · 04/05/2022 10:06

It's like with same sex marriage, if you don't agree with it, don't marry someone of the same sex. If you don't agree with abortion, don't have one.

sashh · 04/05/2022 10:06

OP

Just look at the horror stories from Ireland, a country that shares a border with the UK. A flight from NI or Ireland is about an hour to a UK city.

Women and girls still died.

Women and girls still need to travel to get safe legal abortion.