Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that US states who want to ban abortion should be able to?

336 replies

allsorts1 · 04/05/2022 08:34

Abortion is such a fraught topic in the US. Would it really be so bad to just let the states who want to ban abortion do so, and leave it in the hands of the states themselves to decide? It seems that the Roe v Wade decision has caused a lot of tension in the context of the USA and the feeling that states should be independent and able to choose their own laws (e.g different laws on capital punishment).

Would it be a completely terrible thing for each state to decide on this, and then live with the consequences (as presumably many young people/liberals would relocate to different states where abortion is legal?). Maybe if they experience brain drain they will change their tune. People aren’t forced to live in a certain state.

Obviously I am completely aware this will have a huge negative impact on women in poverty as they have less options. So this is a key consideration and concern.

But I’m just really thinking out loud. I am very much pro-choice, but interested in views from people who understand US law and politics… could the overturning of Roe v Wade potentially be positive in that it settles the issues, states can decide, and everyone can talk about something else?

Or would it just mean that there is a gradual encroachment on women rights and then the pro-lifers start lobbying in pro-choice states and abortion rights are even further reduced. Another risk could be that abortion becomes a political issue every election in every state, and switches back and forth from being legal to illegal - causing massive headaches….

Interested to hear everyone’s thoughts!

OP posts:
WibblyWobblyJane · 04/05/2022 12:00

kimberly489 · 04/05/2022 11:41

The problem is that the states want to ban people that go to other states for an abortion and give them jail sentences. So it's not really the same.

I do not see how this would be possible under US law.

We are allowed freedom of movement and a state cannot govern what someone does outside of their own boundaries. There is no mechanism for that.

ferretface · 04/05/2022 11:56

Even if it were feasible for everyone to move to a state that supported their personal stance on abortion (which its clearly not for reasons explained by PP), it wouldn't be desirable imo - the US already has a highly polarised political culture (unfortunately increasing polarisation seems to be a feature of Western democracy) and polarisation feeds off insularity of views. Whatever political persuasion you are, it's good to have exposure to views outside your bubble. Federalism pulls itself apart if it's allowed to devolve into silos.

WibblyWobblyJane · 04/05/2022 11:55

I am American and believe abortion must be safe and legal and the law needs to be consistent across all States.

I also believe Roe v Wade was a flawed decision and was based on the idea that the end justifies the means. Congress should act.

The problem in the US is that, much like proposed gun laws and proposed voting laws, the suggestion of putting any governance at all around abortion will be seen by a vocal minority as a mechanism meant to prevent it completely. The people that want AR-15 rifles to be legal; the people that believe asking anyone to produce ID to vote; the people that believe abortion should be legal up to the moment of birth. They have more in common with one another than they do with most Americans.

ChildDLA · 04/05/2022 11:54

Hoowhoowho · 04/05/2022 10:38

Kelly’s pregnant, she’s 15. She doesn’t want to continue her pregnancy but she knows her mom who is pro life would not be supportive of her ending this pregnancy. She goes to her local clinic, receives counselling and has a termination she decides not to tell her mother about
But if Kelly lives in a state that bans abortion, it’s not going to be easy for her to fly/drive out of state and access an abortion privately so likely she’ll be torn between attempting to end the pregnancy herself or continuing with a pregnancy she doesn’t want.

the same goes for Shirley who lives with an abusive partner who claims to be pro life

Then there’s Betsy who is a single parent of five children and works three jobs. She can access the clinic round the corner but getting childcare and leave for a trip from Alabama to the nearest state with legalised abortion is near impossible.

or there’s Ruby who took her first job at age 21 in a state that has criminalised abortion and then found herself unexpectedly pregnant. She has the money to access another state for abortion but not the leave in a new job in a fire at will state.

these are the women at risk and this is why federal law needs to guarantee abortion rights.

Don’t any of these examples use contraception?

withgraceinmyheart · 04/05/2022 11:53

Triffid1 · 04/05/2022 11:32

The only way that you can see abortion as something states should decide rather than it being "imposed" at a federal level is if you don't believe that abortion and bodily autonomy are human rights. And it's not clear to me how anyone who is pro choice (supposedly) doesn't believe this.

There are all kinds of things that states are not allowed to "decide for themselves" because they are considered fundamental. Abortion should be one of them.

I’m pro legalised abortion in that I believe abortion should be safe and legal up to birth. I’m pro choice in that I don’t think women should have to give any reason or justification for seeking abortion, or face any stigma or shame for doing so. ‘I do not want to continue this pregnancy’ is all a woman should have to say.

I don’t believe that abortion is a human right. I’ve never heard that as a prerequisite for being pro choice. Holding a particular view doesn’t have to mean that I think those that disagree are evil.

Geezabreak82 · 04/05/2022 11:44

If every woman who lived in those states voted in favour of a ban on abortion then I'd say it would be reasonable to go ahead. That's never going to happen though. The problem with saying 'if a state wants to...' is that the state is not a sentient being and so it doesn't it doesn't have an opinion on abortion, nor does it feel the impact of whether or not they are available. These bans are being driven by men who hold power (and some conservative women too no doubt whose views have been shaped by living in a patriarchal society). Ensuring that safe, legal abortions are available protects women against further marginalisation. Don't forget that in the USA pregnancy and childbirth attracts a hefty healthcare bill and there's very little welfare support for women who may struggle to support their children. The pro-life movement doesn't challenge this - they seem quite happy for many of the babies they fight to bring into this world to be brought up in abject poverty.

Bunnyfuller · 04/05/2022 11:43

How about the US allowing women the independence of their own bodies?

Theunamedcat · 04/05/2022 11:42

They don't even understand what an ectopic pregnancy is ffs why should we be supportive of them banning legal abortion when they can't even get the basics right

withgraceinmyheart · 04/05/2022 11:42

Thanks, this is helpful as it’s not the understanding I had as an outsider. It doesn’t seem to be the way it’s working in practice though, as it is about to be overturned.

Gingernaut · 04/05/2022 11:41

This is sinister.

It's not just about individual states, apps and trackers could be used to track period data and the movements of individuals

mobile.twitter.com/nandoodles/status/1521581893438754817

kimberly489 · 04/05/2022 11:41

The problem is that the states want to ban people that go to other states for an abortion and give them jail sentences. So it's not really the same.

90sBritPop · 04/05/2022 11:41

Just saying

To think that US states who want to ban abortion should be able to?
pigsDOfly · 04/05/2022 11:40

That's fine for all the young liberals that you envisage moving out of those states that outlaw abortion.

No doubt, the sort of people who will cause a 'brain drain' can afford to up sticks and go where they choose and get another job where they decide to take themselves and their 'brains'.

Not so great for those women living in poverty in the same states, desperate because they've got another potential mouth to feed but they've got no money, no way of making any and can't afford to move to a more liberal state.

Have you actually thought this through OP.

Of course it's not up to the individual states to have that sort of control over women's bodies.

Clearly, you're pro choice for a certain section of the population. The poor part, that has no choice can just go back to back-street abortionists and death in your world it seems.

TheVanguardSix · 04/05/2022 11:38

While it is not unheard of for the court to make changes to an easier decision, it has always previously been in the direction of expanding rights. To have it happen in the opposite direction is absolutely extraordinary (in a terrible way).

And this, right here, is the absolute crux of the matter and so well put by an American who understands the implications of this, as a lawyer, better than any of us on this thread.
This is indeed extraordinary in the most terrible of ways... and I'm fairly certain, unprecedented in my lifetime.

CanofCant · 04/05/2022 11:34

"Interested to hear everyone’s thoughts!"

Aye, I bet you are.

TheVanguardSix · 04/05/2022 11:32

By handing the power to states... In the long term there is the potential for a strengthened political movement to change hearts and minds in red states and increase access to abortion through democracy. Maybe this won’t happen. But on the ground, in places like Texas, poor women already struggle to get abortions anyway. At least by repealing Roe v Wade the issue will be made very clear, and perhaps feminists rather than the religious right will be galvanised.

You can't play a long game with this, especially considering Maybe this won’t happen is the likely outcome. It's not even worth considering taking thousands of social steps backward in the vague hope that some silenced minority might eventually emerge from an engineered decades-long social trauma and come out swinging.

Triffid1 · 04/05/2022 11:32

withgraceinmyheart · 04/05/2022 11:21

I understand what you’re saying OP. I’m also pro choice but I can understand the argument that the states need to decide rather the Supreme Court imposing legalised abortion. As you’ve said, Supreme Court rulings are always vulnerable to being overturned, so they don’t solve the problem.

I also agree with what you’ve said about access issues. If the current law allows states to make abortion impossible, it’s hard to see what will actually change in terms of the lives of the women affected. They’re already being forced to carry children they don’t want.

This needs to be a hearts and mind argument imo.

The only way that you can see abortion as something states should decide rather than it being "imposed" at a federal level is if you don't believe that abortion and bodily autonomy are human rights. And it's not clear to me how anyone who is pro choice (supposedly) doesn't believe this.

There are all kinds of things that states are not allowed to "decide for themselves" because they are considered fundamental. Abortion should be one of them.

Discovereads · 04/05/2022 11:32

JanisMoplin · 04/05/2022 11:09

This. Faux innocence. Why can't women just move state because old white men want control over their bodies?

It’s not just old white men. I was looking at voting statistics by state senators on some of these recent awful state abortion laws and there was definitely proportional representation of white women, non-white men and non-white women of all age ranges voting for abortion bans or further restrictions. It’s not a problem in the US that can be solved by simply not voting for old white men.

CanofCant · 04/05/2022 11:32

CBA to read the whole thing but your OP sounds as though you want us to write your opinion piece for you.

You don't sound too pro choice to me if you think it's okay to take the choice away from other women.

FrankLampardsBrokenHand · 04/05/2022 11:26

Erosion of rights is never a good thing and should never be supported.

withgraceinmyheart · 04/05/2022 11:21

I understand what you’re saying OP. I’m also pro choice but I can understand the argument that the states need to decide rather the Supreme Court imposing legalised abortion. As you’ve said, Supreme Court rulings are always vulnerable to being overturned, so they don’t solve the problem.

I also agree with what you’ve said about access issues. If the current law allows states to make abortion impossible, it’s hard to see what will actually change in terms of the lives of the women affected. They’re already being forced to carry children they don’t want.

This needs to be a hearts and mind argument imo.

JanisMoplin · 04/05/2022 11:21

EdgeOfSeventeenAndThreeQuarter · 04/05/2022 11:17

@JanisMoplin … and a powerful message from you that a “super nation” will be looking up to India in terms of women’s rights.

Oh not for a moment suggesting that India does well in this area at all, but it's just very surreal to see how far the US has slid.

ApplesAndChalk · 04/05/2022 11:21

DuncinToffee · 04/05/2022 11:12

Because they are not pro-life, they are anti-abortion (and anti-woman)

Agree. If these men cared about unborn children, they would surely support measures to a) prevent pregnancy (such as free contraceptives, compressive sex education etc), and b) ensure that poor women have every chance to raise their children (welfare etc). But they don't. So I refuse to believe they are pro-life, pro family or pro-child. They just want to control women.

ApplesAndChalk · 04/05/2022 11:19

There are many people who can not leave their state, or not easily anyway.
Jobs, family support. Cost of living varies hugely by state. California, for instance, one of the most liberal states, is very expensive, while the more conservative states tend to be cheaper.

And having it dependent on state means it can change with each governance change. A federal right means that it's more likely to be a constant right, rather than one which can come and go depending on who is in power.

PermanentTemporary · 04/05/2022 11:18

Roe v Wade wasn't 'handed down from on high'. It was a legal case. This time round the Supreme Court was asked to rule on a law made in Mississippi. I hate the idea that law and politics are some highfalutin pursuit that only elites care about. This is real people, real lives.