Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that US states who want to ban abortion should be able to?

336 replies

allsorts1 · 04/05/2022 08:34

Abortion is such a fraught topic in the US. Would it really be so bad to just let the states who want to ban abortion do so, and leave it in the hands of the states themselves to decide? It seems that the Roe v Wade decision has caused a lot of tension in the context of the USA and the feeling that states should be independent and able to choose their own laws (e.g different laws on capital punishment).

Would it be a completely terrible thing for each state to decide on this, and then live with the consequences (as presumably many young people/liberals would relocate to different states where abortion is legal?). Maybe if they experience brain drain they will change their tune. People aren’t forced to live in a certain state.

Obviously I am completely aware this will have a huge negative impact on women in poverty as they have less options. So this is a key consideration and concern.

But I’m just really thinking out loud. I am very much pro-choice, but interested in views from people who understand US law and politics… could the overturning of Roe v Wade potentially be positive in that it settles the issues, states can decide, and everyone can talk about something else?

Or would it just mean that there is a gradual encroachment on women rights and then the pro-lifers start lobbying in pro-choice states and abortion rights are even further reduced. Another risk could be that abortion becomes a political issue every election in every state, and switches back and forth from being legal to illegal - causing massive headaches….

Interested to hear everyone’s thoughts!

OP posts:
JanisMoplin · 04/05/2022 13:25

Savita Hallapanavar. Enough said. Philosophical erudite discussions about abortion while women die. Highly educated well off women at that. As for the poorer ones....

alwayscrashinginthesamecar1 · 04/05/2022 13:19

DownNative · 04/05/2022 13:05

I don't know a single woman who left Northern Ireland due to the abortion laws. Pretty much all the ones I know are still in Northern Ireland. One is in Scotland and one in the Republic after years of living in London.

Jobs, university courses and relationships are the main drivers for people leaving Northern Ireland for other parts of the British Isles.

Abortion isn't one of them for a clear majority.

Is there a mass exodus of women leaving Northern Ireland due to abortion laws?

Well, I've seen no empirical evidence for that.

Well as I already said, it was certainly one of the drivers of why I left NI in the 90s and never moved back, and I know quite a few others who did too. I also know people who had babies they didn't want and ended up stuck in locations and situations they didn't want. But certainly quite a few of my friends who 'got the boat' as they used to say, got the fuck out of there after graduating and never went back. So we must have mixed in different circles. Obviously if you stayed in NI, you aren't going to know so many of the people who chose to leave as someone who did move away would. Obviously this is all anecdata though.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 04/05/2022 13:14

The whole US setup seems a little odd to outsiders I imagine. Roe vs Wade wouldn't have happened in the UK (at least not in the same way) as we don't a written constitution to measure people's (women's) rights against. The situation in NI has always been an anomaly but that was masked by the relative ease of seeking an abortion elsewhere in the UK.

The US States often seem resentful of Federal laws - and it's weird (IMHO) that there's disparity on the death penalty (which is allowed by Federal law) between states.

Then again it seems illogical that many of the same far right nutjobs declaring abortion bans are about "the right to life" also support the death penalty.

It's very obvious that if Federal law is reversed it's a step backwards - and it appears illogical as a constitutional position - the parallel with the handmaids tale is scary.

BackflandedCondiment · 04/05/2022 13:09

imo ALL rights must be defended at all costs. At no point should we allow any right to be taken away - temporarily or otherwise.

Growing up, I thought the rights that had been fought for were safe and could not be taken away again; that the world I lived in would keep evolving. The last few years have shown me how naive I was. Rights can always be taken away and there are always people waiting to do so. The world can devolve as well as evolve and we should never take anything for granted.

American banning abortion will give credit to theose in other countries wishing to do the same. Just as voter supression through mandatory ID there has led to people here paving the way to do the same.

It's comforting to think we would never allow that here, or that no one here would want to do that. But I no longer think that is true. If this passes in the US, then it's an illustration of how rights can be supressed even when doing so has minority support.

DownNative · 04/05/2022 13:05

alwayscrashinginthesamecar1 · 04/05/2022 12:22

Well it was certainly one of the factors I got the hell out of NI as soon as I was able. And many of my friends did the same. I'm not saying it was the only reason but it was certainly one of them. So you don't know what you are talking about.

I don't know a single woman who left Northern Ireland due to the abortion laws. Pretty much all the ones I know are still in Northern Ireland. One is in Scotland and one in the Republic after years of living in London.

Jobs, university courses and relationships are the main drivers for people leaving Northern Ireland for other parts of the British Isles.

Abortion isn't one of them for a clear majority.

Is there a mass exodus of women leaving Northern Ireland due to abortion laws?

Well, I've seen no empirical evidence for that.

newyorker74 · 04/05/2022 12:58

allsorts1 · 04/05/2022 12:47

@newyorker74 okay sorry, I totally see your point there now re: gay marriage and other Supreme Court rights. I hadn’t thought that far ahead. Feck.

Glad to have you on board! Of course the irony is that the constitution doesn't mention guns or the filibuster or how many supreme court judges there should be but the Republicans won't touch those non constitutional rights...

randomsabreuse · 04/05/2022 12:55

Yes it is bad. Banning abortion is about control, not about life, because if life actually mattered outside the womb the red states would not be so vehemently against affordable (let alone free at point of use) healthcare, vaguely relevant periods of maternity leave and employment rights/living wage. All of which affect the life of the child once born... Might also be nice if women didn't risk bankruptcy to pay for maternity care...

A child's life is supposedly super important in the womb but once the child is born, if they get a childhood cancer, they're not important if their parents can't afford the substantial copays or don't have insurance?

How is the life of an unborn child more important than that of a 2 year old with leukaemia? In a moral sense to a "pro lifer" who the opposes other things that improve the life of children once born...

So it must be about controlling lower income women - as those who are well off have the ability to travel as required...

daisyjgrey · 04/05/2022 12:47

You are being both unreasonable and ignorant.

As has been said before, you cannot ban abortion, only safe and legal abortion.

Women will die, don't be an advocate for that..

allsorts1 · 04/05/2022 12:47

@newyorker74 okay sorry, I totally see your point there now re: gay marriage and other Supreme Court rights. I hadn’t thought that far ahead. Feck.

OP posts:
C152 · 04/05/2022 12:45

OMG, are you actually serious???? YES, it WOULD "really be so bad" for ANY state, let alone multiple states, to ban abortion. I'm so flabbergasted and angry I don't even know where do begin.

Youreatragedystartingtohappen · 04/05/2022 12:45

CaptainMyCaptain · 04/05/2022 08:36

You can never ban abortion you can only ban safe, legal abortion.

This. This all day long

JanisMoplin · 04/05/2022 12:43

Can't believe this thread and some of the suggestions. Which yes are faux innocent. That's misogynist but suggesting that women move en masse to other states is not? Lol. As for the ppl who suggested contraception words fail me.

Why not just say you don't care about poor women and just want to make academic points to sound clever?

God MN is infested wt MRAs these days.

newyorker74 · 04/05/2022 12:35

allsorts1 · 04/05/2022 12:16

But those examples aren’t civil rights. Civil rights include the right to vote and the right to free speech. It’s up to us as a society to use our vote to create the society we want - including laws that allow same sex marriage, contraception etc. These things are elements that make a great and fair society for all, but they aren’t rights in the same sense.

How have the UK, NZ, much of Europe etc managed to pretty much take abortion off the table in terms of a political issue? Abortion isn’t a “right” in any of these places. It’s something that society has worked towards acceptance based on evidence and logic about the harm that abortion bans cause.

Maybe it’s still such a galvanising topic in the US because they haven’t been able to go through this process.

To the PP claiming I’m being “faux innocent” for considering this, maybe you should check your own misogyny that you would use a sexist girlish trope to shut down a discussion.

The point is that the argument that the surprise court is making is that because abortion is not in the constitution, it's not a right. The right to marry who you want, the right to contraception are not in there either. That's why they are at risk. What would you describe them as if not civil rights?

allsorts1 · 04/05/2022 12:24

FunnyTalks · 04/05/2022 12:11

My abortion was after rape. I was a teenager. I wouldn't have had the means to relocate.

I’m so sorry that this happened to you and I am thankful that you were able to access abortion.

OP posts:
alwayscrashinginthesamecar1 · 04/05/2022 12:22

Butteryflakycrust83 · 04/05/2022 10:51

Abortion is illegal in NI, I have not seen a mass exodus of women moving from there?

Well it was certainly one of the factors I got the hell out of NI as soon as I was able. And many of my friends did the same. I'm not saying it was the only reason but it was certainly one of them. So you don't know what you are talking about.

allsorts1 · 04/05/2022 12:16

newyorker74 · 04/05/2022 12:02

As a woman living in a blue state in the US that has already protected abortion rights and is pretty much past child bearing age, this thread makes me want to scream. You can't have a philosophical discussion about taking away a fundamental right that the overwhelming majority of Americans support - and that's red states, blue states and everything in between. A small group of fundamentalists have been working towards this for years and took advantage of bad political systems (hi Mitch McConnell) to stand in the way of democracy. And this is where we end up. A slippery slope towards the removal of civil rights. Want to marry someone from a a different race? Want to marry someone of the same gender? Want access to contraception? All of those rights are at risk now.

But those examples aren’t civil rights. Civil rights include the right to vote and the right to free speech. It’s up to us as a society to use our vote to create the society we want - including laws that allow same sex marriage, contraception etc. These things are elements that make a great and fair society for all, but they aren’t rights in the same sense.

How have the UK, NZ, much of Europe etc managed to pretty much take abortion off the table in terms of a political issue? Abortion isn’t a “right” in any of these places. It’s something that society has worked towards acceptance based on evidence and logic about the harm that abortion bans cause.

Maybe it’s still such a galvanising topic in the US because they haven’t been able to go through this process.

To the PP claiming I’m being “faux innocent” for considering this, maybe you should check your own misogyny that you would use a sexist girlish trope to shut down a discussion.

OP posts:
CHIRIBAYA · 04/05/2022 12:14

Do you think the opinions of people who 'understand' American politics and law carry more weight than those who don't? The choices women have over the body they alone inhabit, transcends politics. You make it sound so easy to up sticks and away, it's a very naive world view. Have you never read the Grapes of Wrath? & it's not the 'state' that lives with the consequences is it?? It is women and children who will suffer and we all know who good American society is at extending compassion and support to those in suffering. Americans have a bizarre relationship with life and death; not so pro-life when it comes to the criminal justice system. God forbid any more of their fucked up 'values' make it over here.

twinklystar23 · 04/05/2022 12:14

www.theguardian.com/us-news/2021/nov/29/us-abortion-supreme-court-roe-v-wade

This link outlines some chilling impact in the event RvW is overturned.

this specific extraction leads on from the ability for crime agencies to track evidence of those who may also have assisted someone to seek an abortion.

More than 2,000 police agencies across the US have already purchased “mass extraction” technology that allows them to download, organize and archive a phone’s entire contents. The technology is sometimes called a “window into the soul”. This digital evidence has then been used to identify search queries for abortion pills, including in the prosecution of Latice Fisher, a mother of three in Mississippi.
Fisher gave birth to a stillborn child. The child was pronounced dead at Fisher’s home by emergency responders. Prosecutors used Fisher’s cell phone records to show she had searched for abortion pills online before her child was stillborn, and brought charges against her twice.
Prosecutors dropped the first case amid criticism of an archaic test used to determine whether an infant is born alive. Prosecutors then tried to indict Fisher again, but a grand jury refused to indict her when presented with scientifically accurate information.

Dixiechickonhols · 04/05/2022 12:13

ChildDLA there’s no nhs providing free contraception. Even if you have health insurance providers don’t have to cover contraception.

Abstinence sex education.
Issues like access to clinics, poor public transport, few employment rights/no annual leave.

FunnyTalks · 04/05/2022 12:11

My abortion was after rape. I was a teenager. I wouldn't have had the means to relocate.

Goodnewsbadnews · 04/05/2022 12:10

withgraceinmyheart · 04/05/2022 11:53

I’m pro legalised abortion in that I believe abortion should be safe and legal up to birth. I’m pro choice in that I don’t think women should have to give any reason or justification for seeking abortion, or face any stigma or shame for doing so. ‘I do not want to continue this pregnancy’ is all a woman should have to say.

I don’t believe that abortion is a human right. I’ve never heard that as a prerequisite for being pro choice. Holding a particular view doesn’t have to mean that I think those that disagree are evil.

I agree with you. Abortion doesn’t have to be a “constitutional right” to be accessible and legal - see UK, NZ, Australia, EU…

The Supreme Court made abortion a constitutional right in the US, but this has always been on shaky ground and depends entirely on the makeup of the US Supreme Court.

  • taking abortion away from politics means that abortion rights supporters have never had to win public opinion in the US, so there has been no natural evolution in law like in the UK, NZ etc
  • Pro-lifers feel that they have never had a democratic say and therefore feel a powerful grievance - this has backfired IMO as we see a huge surge in this group in the US vs other western states.
  • I read that c.80% of Americans support access abortion in some form - from relaxed to limited cases.
  • politicians courting the pro-life vote have so far been able to make wild promises about legislation to win votes - legislation which if passed would probably be pretty unpopular (eg the trigger laws to totally ban abortion).
  • The repeal of Roe v Wade might just call them on their bluff and let them all be voted out once voters see the reality of a total ban on abortions as some states promise/at least force them to enact laws that please the majority of voters, you know, like politicians usually do.
I hope the draft ruling doesn’t turn into the final ruling, I really do. However there is a potential for it not to be the end of the world in the long term.
L1ttledrummergirl · 04/05/2022 12:09

I wonder what would happen if every women (and men who wish to in solidarity)who disagreed with this law change left those states that plan on banning safe abortion to stay in one that still allows their right to choose.

Even if it was for a week it would make a point that this is unwanted. They could stay with women in those states. A way of showing solidarity.

It would give employers food for thought if half the workforce left.

barms90 · 04/05/2022 12:03

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

newyorker74 · 04/05/2022 12:02

As a woman living in a blue state in the US that has already protected abortion rights and is pretty much past child bearing age, this thread makes me want to scream. You can't have a philosophical discussion about taking away a fundamental right that the overwhelming majority of Americans support - and that's red states, blue states and everything in between. A small group of fundamentalists have been working towards this for years and took advantage of bad political systems (hi Mitch McConnell) to stand in the way of democracy. And this is where we end up. A slippery slope towards the removal of civil rights. Want to marry someone from a a different race? Want to marry someone of the same gender? Want access to contraception? All of those rights are at risk now.

ApplesAndChalk · 04/05/2022 12:02

Don’t any of these examples use contraception?

You do realise that:


  1. Contraceptives fail

  2. American conservatives have pushed for abstinence only sex education for years?