Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that US states who want to ban abortion should be able to?

336 replies

allsorts1 · 04/05/2022 08:34

Abortion is such a fraught topic in the US. Would it really be so bad to just let the states who want to ban abortion do so, and leave it in the hands of the states themselves to decide? It seems that the Roe v Wade decision has caused a lot of tension in the context of the USA and the feeling that states should be independent and able to choose their own laws (e.g different laws on capital punishment).

Would it be a completely terrible thing for each state to decide on this, and then live with the consequences (as presumably many young people/liberals would relocate to different states where abortion is legal?). Maybe if they experience brain drain they will change their tune. People aren’t forced to live in a certain state.

Obviously I am completely aware this will have a huge negative impact on women in poverty as they have less options. So this is a key consideration and concern.

But I’m just really thinking out loud. I am very much pro-choice, but interested in views from people who understand US law and politics… could the overturning of Roe v Wade potentially be positive in that it settles the issues, states can decide, and everyone can talk about something else?

Or would it just mean that there is a gradual encroachment on women rights and then the pro-lifers start lobbying in pro-choice states and abortion rights are even further reduced. Another risk could be that abortion becomes a political issue every election in every state, and switches back and forth from being legal to illegal - causing massive headaches….

Interested to hear everyone’s thoughts!

OP posts:
TheGrinchsDog · 04/05/2022 14:50

OP: Why can't it be like this?
Everyone else: easy to understand explanation

OP: But then why can't people move
Everyone else: Poverty

OP: But... asks same questions again
Me: facepalm

SaggyBlinders · 04/05/2022 14:46

allsorts1 · 04/05/2022 08:34

Abortion is such a fraught topic in the US. Would it really be so bad to just let the states who want to ban abortion do so, and leave it in the hands of the states themselves to decide? It seems that the Roe v Wade decision has caused a lot of tension in the context of the USA and the feeling that states should be independent and able to choose their own laws (e.g different laws on capital punishment).

Would it be a completely terrible thing for each state to decide on this, and then live with the consequences (as presumably many young people/liberals would relocate to different states where abortion is legal?). Maybe if they experience brain drain they will change their tune. People aren’t forced to live in a certain state.

Obviously I am completely aware this will have a huge negative impact on women in poverty as they have less options. So this is a key consideration and concern.

But I’m just really thinking out loud. I am very much pro-choice, but interested in views from people who understand US law and politics… could the overturning of Roe v Wade potentially be positive in that it settles the issues, states can decide, and everyone can talk about something else?

Or would it just mean that there is a gradual encroachment on women rights and then the pro-lifers start lobbying in pro-choice states and abortion rights are even further reduced. Another risk could be that abortion becomes a political issue every election in every state, and switches back and forth from being legal to illegal - causing massive headaches….

Interested to hear everyone’s thoughts!

My thoughts are:

  • Your posts are goady.
  • No one would move state over an abortion. They would either travel outside of their state for an abortion if they had the money and means to do so. If they didn't have the means to do so, and didn't want to be pregnant, they would potentially buy pills online, go to a backstreet abortion clinic, or try it themselves. Abortion has existed for a long long time. Banning it will only stop access to safe and legal abortion. I hope that if it is banned, then underground organisations will spring up to offer still women the choice and support. Like the Jane collective:

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jane_Collective

I will be so sad and angry if it comes to that though. As a healthcare professional who has worked in abortion care, I feel so strongly that every woman should have the right to choose for themselves. It is not up for debate in my opinion.

allsorts1 · 04/05/2022 14:46

I don’t agree that states SHOULD ban abortions. I am questioning whether leaving it up to states and the issue to be a political issue (eg like in the UK) rather than decided by the courts could be a better long term approach that would settle the issue and stop galvanising the religious right around the perceived injustice of the Supreme Court ruling in Roe v Wade.

I’m looking at other western nations where abortion is no longer a political issue, all achieved without abortion being secured as a right by a court.

@AProperStinging where did I say that I had no concept this could happen? I was acknowledging her experience that she shared.

@Cinnabomb presumably because they can’t even get a visa to relocate out of their country so are completely trapped? Whereas people in US states face financial barriers to relocation, but do have free movement.

OP posts:
chisanunian · 04/05/2022 14:26

The Star Spangled Banner includes the words 'the land of the free'.

Freedom for some and not others, clearly. Hypocrites.

lljkk · 04/05/2022 14:22

a state has a regressive abortion ban...population migration out of their state to more progressive states and suffer economically for it?

is it ok for the people left behind who can't leave to suffer in meantime, to be denied bodily autonomy?

Note that migration goes both ways: my creationist "Obama is evil" California relatives settled in the south just so they could find a sympathetic environment for the beliefs they already had.

whether returning this issue to democracy and leaving it up to voters to decide, with their feet or with their actual votes, could be a better thing long term.

All the President('s') Lawyers was an excellent podcast that often addressed legal process vs. political process. However, re the overlap zone, I suggest people read up on the difference between Majoritarianism and Democracy.

Also the effects of gerrymandering in state legislatures.

Neverreturntoathread · 04/05/2022 14:21

SpiderVersed · 04/05/2022 08:36

It won’t prevent abortion. It will outlaw safe abortions.

Women and girls will die.

This. We know where it goes OP. It was legalised for a reason.

FrancescaContini · 04/05/2022 14:20

Cinnabomb · 04/05/2022 14:01

@allsorts1 again, gently, but that view is one of immense privilege.

why don’t the women of other oppressed countries just leave/ emigrate? In places like the DR of Congo, or Venezuela, where rape is a weapon and means of control, and there is abominable healthcare….. why don’t they just leave?

Yeah, this would be laughable if it weren’t so appalling for the women involved.

FrancescaContini · 04/05/2022 14:19

I really don’t understand your OP. How can you agree with whole states banning abortions, yet be pro-choice?

AProperStinging · 04/05/2022 14:18

JanisMoplin · 04/05/2022 14:15

Beginning to think this is a wind-up or a journalist or an MRA. Can see no other explanation for why the OP continues to urge women to "vote with their feet" and wait patiently for abortion to be not "politically or economically viable". 233 posts- including some very good ones by Americans- explaining why this is inhumane, but no.

It's absolute nonsense, isn't it.

AProperStinging · 04/05/2022 14:17

allsorts1 · 04/05/2022 12:24
FunnyTalks
My abortion was after rape. I was a teenager. I wouldn't have had the means to relocate.
I’m so sorry that this happened to you and I am thankful that you were able to access abortion.

What - before that poster shared their horrendous story, you genuinely had no concept of the idea that it might not be possible for a girl or woman with an unwanted pregnancy to immediately move thousands of miles away?

Exactly how stupid do you think we are?

JanisMoplin · 04/05/2022 14:15

Beginning to think this is a wind-up or a journalist or an MRA. Can see no other explanation for why the OP continues to urge women to "vote with their feet" and wait patiently for abortion to be not "politically or economically viable". 233 posts- including some very good ones by Americans- explaining why this is inhumane, but no.

Cinnabomb · 04/05/2022 14:01

@allsorts1 again, gently, but that view is one of immense privilege.

why don’t the women of other oppressed countries just leave/ emigrate? In places like the DR of Congo, or Venezuela, where rape is a weapon and means of control, and there is abominable healthcare….. why don’t they just leave?

MsMD · 04/05/2022 13:55

allsorts1 · 04/05/2022 13:39

I’m not arguing that, I’m wondering whether returning this issue to democracy and leaving it up to voters to decide, with their feet or with their actual votes, could be a better thing long term. Especially given what you’re saying about the calibre of the Supreme Court nominees!

If most of the American population are against overturning Roe and in support of abortion rights in some form, then perhaps it might be cleaner, and better in the long term, to just remove the constant spectre of Supreme Court nominees for or against Roe, and let the American population decide directly whether abortion should be legal where they live?

It would be great if Roe v Wade wasn’t overturned after all - but my fear is that if the US avoids it this time it might just be kicking the bucket down the road and delaying the inevitable. Won’t the next republican president just nominate even more conservative justices than they have now?

Because as I said, states are NOT only made up of the one party that is in charge. If 100,000 registered voters live in State A, and 51,000 vote for the Republican nominee, that leaves 49,000 people with no voice and therefore no right to abortion.

And remember this isn't a referendum on abortion, people will vote on all kinds of issues. The big ones are gun rights and Christians being 'persecuted' - the Republican party has spent decades pretending Democrats are anti gun and pro persecution. People - especially men and those women not affected by an abortion ban - will vote Republican for THOSE things and not care that it means the raped teenager cannot access abortion because it doesn't affect THEM.

On the other side of this, for Republicans who live in Democratic states, should Dems there be allowed to force a republican into an abortion? If enough democrats live in the state to vote for that, would that be ok? Of course not and yet you're advocating for that to happen to other women.

We need to codify the right to an abortion in Federal law. It NEEDS to be a right for every woman, not just those lucky enough to be born in one area.

And we also need to stop caring about the EXACT WORD of the Constitution which was written hundreds of years ago by old white men who had slaves and raped the women around them, but that's an argument for another day.

backtobusy · 04/05/2022 13:53

States are often the size of a country.

If England banned abortions realistically how could everyone move to Scotland or Wales?

I live a a liberal state that will keep abortion rights, in a sea of states that will ban them.
Wealthy women will just fly or drive here. The most vulnerable will not.
Overturning access to abortions will impact the most vulnerable women the hardest.

In time some states may soften their anti abortion laws but how many women will die trying to manage their own abortions in the meantime?

allsorts1 · 04/05/2022 13:50

@AuntieMorag I hear you. I was referring to the political consequences on state politicians of enacting an unpopular policy that they have only so far had to threaten to gain the pro life vote. Having to actually implement it might result in the loss of everyone else’s votes.

OP posts:
allsorts1 · 04/05/2022 13:47

@Cinnabomb I accept that criticism and your point about moving, especially in the short to medium term.

But over time, if a state has a regressive abortion ban, is it not possible that they could experience a population migration out of their state to more progressive states and suffer economically for it?

Eventually this might mean than their bans are not politically or economically viable.

OP posts:
AuntieMorag · 04/05/2022 13:42

Would it be a completely terrible thing for each state to decide on this, and then live with the consequences

It's WOMEN who will live with the consequences, not the states. What about the 15 year old who can't just move to a different state? The actually much wanted pregnancy but there are serious complications? The woman who loves living near her family who help support her three kids under 5, but has just found out she's pregnant again and knows she cannot cope with another baby?

allsorts1 · 04/05/2022 13:39

MsMD · 04/05/2022 13:29

I cannot believe what I just read.

What you're arguing for is that that only women in half of US States have access to safe abortion. Well, those women and the ones in Republican states who are rich.

The US is not a democracy insofar that we have gerrymandering which leaves millions of voters voices unheard and voter suppression which actively targets the votes of minorities.

And most importantly we do not govern by popular vote. Donald Trump LOST the 2016 election in that more people voted for the other candidate. He then nominated 3 justices - 3 of the 5 or 6 who are voting to outlaw abortion. The first of those justice nominations was supposed to be Barack Obamas, but again minority rule decided out of nowhere that he couldn't do so in an election year. The 2nd of those judges is a rapist. The 3rd? Replacing a judge who died 2 months before the election and yet, conveniently, the Republican party forgot their OWN RULE about no nominees in an election year.

You seem to be under the illusion that only anti-choice people live in Red states which is completely untrue. Millions of women will be affected and of course they don't all have the option of just moving to another state! The answer to the abortion issue is simple - if you don't like abortion, don't get one.

Signed, a liberal, pro-choice doctor in a red state.

I’m not arguing that, I’m wondering whether returning this issue to democracy and leaving it up to voters to decide, with their feet or with their actual votes, could be a better thing long term. Especially given what you’re saying about the calibre of the Supreme Court nominees!

If most of the American population are against overturning Roe and in support of abortion rights in some form, then perhaps it might be cleaner, and better in the long term, to just remove the constant spectre of Supreme Court nominees for or against Roe, and let the American population decide directly whether abortion should be legal where they live?

It would be great if Roe v Wade wasn’t overturned after all - but my fear is that if the US avoids it this time it might just be kicking the bucket down the road and delaying the inevitable. Won’t the next republican president just nominate even more conservative justices than they have now?

OP posts:
BackflandedCondiment · 04/05/2022 13:36

Fair @Hellospring22

Also adding to that, it is a deliberate tactic of (some) abusive partners is not to use contraception: to use pregnancy and children as form of control over their partners. Futher ties to deter them from leaving.

Hellospring22 · 04/05/2022 13:32

ChildDLA · 04/05/2022 11:54

Don’t any of these examples use contraception?

Contraception can fail including in those who are careful. Never assume it won’t happen to you or someone close to you, despite using contraception. I hate this assumption that if you use contraception you’ll never accidentally get pregnant. Those who fall pregnant without contraception have a right to choose too. This is about choice and rights over your own body.

allsorts1 · 04/05/2022 13:32

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 04/05/2022 13:14

The whole US setup seems a little odd to outsiders I imagine. Roe vs Wade wouldn't have happened in the UK (at least not in the same way) as we don't a written constitution to measure people's (women's) rights against. The situation in NI has always been an anomaly but that was masked by the relative ease of seeking an abortion elsewhere in the UK.

The US States often seem resentful of Federal laws - and it's weird (IMHO) that there's disparity on the death penalty (which is allowed by Federal law) between states.

Then again it seems illogical that many of the same far right nutjobs declaring abortion bans are about "the right to life" also support the death penalty.

It's very obvious that if Federal law is reversed it's a step backwards - and it appears illogical as a constitutional position - the parallel with the handmaids tale is scary.

Yes the set up seems needlessly complicated and doesn’t appear to be doing them any favours as far as I can see! I too am seeing parallels with the flashbacks in the Handmaids Tale - eg going to a “abortion clinic” which turns out to be a pro life organisation giving you pamphlets, which already happens in certain US states right now.

OP posts:
MsMD · 04/05/2022 13:29

I cannot believe what I just read.

What you're arguing for is that that only women in half of US States have access to safe abortion. Well, those women and the ones in Republican states who are rich.

The US is not a democracy insofar that we have gerrymandering which leaves millions of voters voices unheard and voter suppression which actively targets the votes of minorities.

And most importantly we do not govern by popular vote. Donald Trump LOST the 2016 election in that more people voted for the other candidate. He then nominated 3 justices - 3 of the 5 or 6 who are voting to outlaw abortion. The first of those justice nominations was supposed to be Barack Obamas, but again minority rule decided out of nowhere that he couldn't do so in an election year. The 2nd of those judges is a rapist. The 3rd? Replacing a judge who died 2 months before the election and yet, conveniently, the Republican party forgot their OWN RULE about no nominees in an election year.

You seem to be under the illusion that only anti-choice people live in Red states which is completely untrue. Millions of women will be affected and of course they don't all have the option of just moving to another state! The answer to the abortion issue is simple - if you don't like abortion, don't get one.

Signed, a liberal, pro-choice doctor in a red state.

Triffid1 · 04/05/2022 13:28

I'm not sure why "faux innocence" is considered a misogynist term - will have to look that up. But I stand by my comment that all these so-called questions don't really ring true to me from someone who is genuinely pro choice.

Triffid1 · 04/05/2022 13:27

I don’t believe that abortion is a human right. I’ve never heard that as a prerequisite for being pro choice.

No, but bodily autonomy is, I believe, a human right. And abortion is, ultimately, about bodily autonomy.

Cinnabomb · 04/05/2022 13:26

@allsorts1 I think your original
post is viewing this from a place of privilege. Ultimately this will effect vulnerable and deprived women the most, who don’t have the option of ‘just moving’