Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that US states who want to ban abortion should be able to?

336 replies

allsorts1 · 04/05/2022 08:34

Abortion is such a fraught topic in the US. Would it really be so bad to just let the states who want to ban abortion do so, and leave it in the hands of the states themselves to decide? It seems that the Roe v Wade decision has caused a lot of tension in the context of the USA and the feeling that states should be independent and able to choose their own laws (e.g different laws on capital punishment).

Would it be a completely terrible thing for each state to decide on this, and then live with the consequences (as presumably many young people/liberals would relocate to different states where abortion is legal?). Maybe if they experience brain drain they will change their tune. People aren’t forced to live in a certain state.

Obviously I am completely aware this will have a huge negative impact on women in poverty as they have less options. So this is a key consideration and concern.

But I’m just really thinking out loud. I am very much pro-choice, but interested in views from people who understand US law and politics… could the overturning of Roe v Wade potentially be positive in that it settles the issues, states can decide, and everyone can talk about something else?

Or would it just mean that there is a gradual encroachment on women rights and then the pro-lifers start lobbying in pro-choice states and abortion rights are even further reduced. Another risk could be that abortion becomes a political issue every election in every state, and switches back and forth from being legal to illegal - causing massive headaches….

Interested to hear everyone’s thoughts!

OP posts:
iCouldSleepForAYear · 04/05/2022 23:16

I'll give you a hint: it ain't about the babies.

It never fucking was.

iCouldSleepForAYear · 04/05/2022 23:14

"This is an entitled year 7 in an independent school writing their first non-creative essay. The parents will pin it up with a fridge magnet."

Kind of agree here.

The people who are against abortions could do anything, literally anything, to try and reduce the rate of abortions required.

They could educate and promote birth control in their communities and consider it part of sensible family planning.

They could vote for social programmes that support vulnerable families more appropriately.

They could insist food stamps cover the costs of the most nutritious food.

They could vote for bringing jobs to their areas, and also vote to make enormous corporations pay their fair share, whether that's through local tax revenues or through appropriate wages and benefits for the work performed. They could vote to raise the minimum wage and make health insurance something everyone gets on a sliding scale. With a public option, and no Medicaid/Medicare gaps.

They could decriminalise drug possession and keep more parents out of jail and more families together.

They could support their local schools and libraries. They could support WIC and Head Start. They could support PBS.

They could work to convict domestic abusers, and support survivors psychologically and financially. They could educate their young people about the value of consent.

They could organize and vote for a health system that will not bankrupt someone for needing medical care; they could rewrite the law so that charging a woman $3,000 for a low-risk and uneventful pregnancy is consigned to the past.

They could vote for and then fund public housing that isn't ridden with mold and left to rot in neglected neighbourhoods where crime rates are allowed to remain high.

They could organize and vote for clean public water that isn't tainted with lead.

Instead, for approximately 50 years, they've organized only to ban abortions themselves.

Why do you think that is, Isabelle/Noah (OP)?

Dig deeper.

Gingernaut · 04/05/2022 20:41

Anne Coates (she/her) has got hold of this and Twitter are taking the piss out of the OP.

Nice going, OP.

twitter.com/setoacnna/status/1521777625416536064

Frankola · 04/05/2022 19:32

No. Just no.

As many have said, all that will happen is that safe, professional abortion will be illegal. And backstreet butchers will be the only option for women who have no other choice.

How has America gotten to a point where gun ownership is legal and abortion is potentially going to be illegal?! Insane

filo443 · 04/05/2022 19:23

I rather hope you wrote this thread as a sort of reverse to bring this to peoples attention.

American women need to be protesting to the max.

Under his eye indeed. Fucking frightening.

allsorts1 · 04/05/2022 18:57

@lljkk thank you. Definitely my own fault for writing the most accidentally click baitey title in history though. Will have to change username after this 🤣

@Wallaw thanks very much for taking the time to write that. I have heard about how f*cked the gerrymandering process is, which perhaps buries all chance of this topic being dealt with sensibly through policy. Given Trump’s extraordinary justice appointments I wonder what hope there is for Democrats to even get a chance to get some balance in coming years. Dark days for issues like gay marriage.

OP posts:
feellikeanalien · 04/05/2022 18:28

www.cbsnews.com/news/roe-v-wade-supreme-court-republican-gop-appointed-justices/

Roe v Wade is something that nominees for the Supreme Court are routinely asked about in their confirmation hearings. There is now suggestion being made that some of them may have lied during the hearings.

Maireas · 04/05/2022 18:27

AProperStinging · 04/05/2022 14:17

allsorts1 · 04/05/2022 12:24
FunnyTalks
My abortion was after rape. I was a teenager. I wouldn't have had the means to relocate.
I’m so sorry that this happened to you and I am thankful that you were able to access abortion.

What - before that poster shared their horrendous story, you genuinely had no concept of the idea that it might not be possible for a girl or woman with an unwanted pregnancy to immediately move thousands of miles away?

Exactly how stupid do you think we are?

Exactly this.

WibblyWobblyJane · 04/05/2022 18:06

@Musomama1 I would be shocked if they did not make the funds available regardless of state. There is extensive infrastructure in place in the US in the form of organizations like Planned Parenthood that would enable that.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planned_Parenthood

Any changes would hit the poor and particularly the AA community the hardest.

But there are extensive issues here already with respect to this community. Kermit Gosnell and the crimes he committed against women and girls seeking abortions in Philadelphia. This horrifying man did what he did in my state, Pennsylvania, and got away with it for quite a while, due to the unwillingness of the city and the state to address it and enforce any regulations on an abortion provider. I have a friend with firsthand insight into how this was allowed to happen. These were underage, poor, primarily African American girls that were victims of his horrific clinic, all just to line his pockets. What he was doing was not unknown - by the city nor by the state. And frankly I believe no one cared, because of the demographic and because regulating abortion in any way is highly unpopular.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kermit_Gosnell

lljkk · 04/05/2022 17:02

People are projecting onto OP things that OP didn't say.

Which is annoying & typical MN behaviour.

gwanwyn · 04/05/2022 16:49

fairlygoodmother · 04/05/2022 16:19

This is only the first step. There’s an ultimate agenda to give fetuses the same rights as people, which could make abortion illegal everywhere. That’s why California, for example, is introducing legislation to enshrine the right to abortion in its state constitution.

I think this is a worrying trend - then they can judge behavior in pg and imprison women if things go awry - I assume it would start with drugs and drinking then move on to other things.

Knittingchamp · 04/05/2022 16:40

newnamethanks · 04/05/2022 08:43

I refer you to Margaret Attwood. That should be sufficient for anybody.

True ... Under His Eye is the only response I can think of!

Triffid1 · 04/05/2022 16:32

Women in poor countries don't move because of visas but as that's not an issue within thr US you stand by your theory that women will just leave?

This must be a wind up. I will stop engaging. Many many people.have explained that wealthy women will spend money going to another state for abortions. Poor women can't move or travel for abortions.

And even if these mythical wocietal changes that you think might happen do in fact take place..
How quickly woll this happen?! So for years amd decades between you are OK with all the women who can't access abortions just sucking it up?!

You are not posting in good faith. Time for me to go.

fairlygoodmother · 04/05/2022 16:19

This is only the first step. There’s an ultimate agenda to give fetuses the same rights as people, which could make abortion illegal everywhere. That’s why California, for example, is introducing legislation to enshrine the right to abortion in its state constitution.

Musomama1 · 04/05/2022 16:15

WibblyWobblyJane · 04/05/2022 15:54

@Musomama1

The cost of abortion in the US varies. Some health plans cover it, including some Medicaid plans. (Medicaid is a Federally funded program that helps low income citizens with healthcare costs.)

There are also funds available to people through the National Network of Abortion funds. Planned Parenthood which is a no -profit that receives about 1/3 of its funding from federal tax dollars, does not turn anyone away regardless of ability to pay.

Thank you. I wonder if those funds will be available for any women, regardless of state, I hope so, or the Medicare can be used in a different state.

Then it would be transport costs. Maybe they'll be funding set up?

Mollymoo67 · 04/05/2022 15:57

Would it be a completely terrible thing for each state to decide on this, and then live with the consequences

Yes.

EllaVaNight · 04/05/2022 15:57

Obviously I am completely aware this will have a huge negative impact on women in poverty as they have less options. Fuck them though right? So this is a key consideration and concern. For who? Certainly not those trying to ban safe, legal abortions.

This shouldn't be up for "philosophical debate" or whatever you dress it up as. Even more women and girls will die because of unsafe abortions. These are real people (and yes, poor people are real people too).

WibblyWobblyJane · 04/05/2022 15:54

@Musomama1

The cost of abortion in the US varies. Some health plans cover it, including some Medicaid plans. (Medicaid is a Federally funded program that helps low income citizens with healthcare costs.)

There are also funds available to people through the National Network of Abortion funds. Planned Parenthood which is a no -profit that receives about 1/3 of its funding from federal tax dollars, does not turn anyone away regardless of ability to pay.

dollymuchymuchness · 04/05/2022 15:47

To think that US states who want to ban abortion should be able to?

Absolutely not. Termination of pregnancy should be available to any woman who needs it.

Musomama1 · 04/05/2022 15:44

So women can fly to a different state, a massive hassle and expense particularly if they have kids and if they need to do it discreetly, but at least it's an option. I'd imagine the waiting lists will go up though at the available clinics, or maybe more will open.

If you're a woman with not much money to fly to a legal state to get a safe abortion, what are your options now?

US pay for healthcare anyway so they have to pay regardless, doesn't this already throw barriers up for the procedure to the poorest or do they have healthcare help?

We're so lucky to live in this country and have some solid women's rights and access to free healthcare. I love America but I can't believe how wrong they can get things.

LuaDipa · 04/05/2022 15:25

CaptainMyCaptain · 04/05/2022 08:36

You can never ban abortion you can only ban safe, legal abortion.

This.

Plus you’ve said it yourself op:

Obviously I am completely aware this will have a huge negative impact on women in poverty as they have less options. So this is a key consideration and concern.

Women who are already poor and marginalised deserve to be afforded choice over their lives and bodies as much as any other woman. It’s criminal that this is being stripped away from them and we need to do everything in our power to stop it happening.

newyorker74 · 04/05/2022 15:21

allsorts1 · 04/05/2022 14:46

I don’t agree that states SHOULD ban abortions. I am questioning whether leaving it up to states and the issue to be a political issue (eg like in the UK) rather than decided by the courts could be a better long term approach that would settle the issue and stop galvanising the religious right around the perceived injustice of the Supreme Court ruling in Roe v Wade.

I’m looking at other western nations where abortion is no longer a political issue, all achieved without abortion being secured as a right by a court.

@AProperStinging where did I say that I had no concept this could happen? I was acknowledging her experience that she shared.

@Cinnabomb presumably because they can’t even get a visa to relocate out of their country so are completely trapped? Whereas people in US states face financial barriers to relocation, but do have free movement.

I'm laughing here at the idea that a person can have freedom to move even if they face financial barriers. Those are exactly the thing that stop woman being able to make choices and lead to forced birth. I really think you need to stop looking at this as some high level conversation about feelings and other soft stuff. If abortion is made illegal, woman will die. They will have babies they don't want or can't have in bad situations which keep them in poverty, abusive relationships and help to keep the poor population in this country from ever raising themselves out of poverty. It's a cycle that gets worse every generation and that the Republicans are trying to swing this as something positive is disgusting and just not true. You know some states have already said they will enact laws that ban abortion in the case of rape. You want to have a philosophical conversation with a woman in that situation and tell her she should just have moved to New York state? Of course you don't. Because for you - and all the woman and men who voted for trump because Hilary stayed with her husband- don't actually care about the ramifications of stuff like this for people who they have never met and would climb over if they were begging for help on that street. That's the result of all this actual situation that is going to happen. Not a book. Not a discussion but something that will happen.

iCouldSleepForAYear · 04/05/2022 15:20

allsorts1 · 04/05/2022 08:45

Obviously I don’t want Roe v Wade overturned! In an ideal world it wouldn’t be. However with the draft decision going in that direction I have been pondering the legal & political ramifications and the different context of the US and the states system. I don’t need my ass handed to me re:abortion (v v pro choice!) - I just wanted to discuss the various ramifications in the different context of the US that’s all.

Letting them get their way about returning abortion rights to individual states won't shut the anti-choice campaign up or make them go away. They won't be satisfied until it's illegal for everyone.

If abortion is okay to do in some states, but not others, then it's not murder.

If the right to choose what medical procedures take place in your body is a right granted only in some states, but not others, and is a right granted to men, but not to women ... then women do not have equal rights. Not with men, and not with each other.

There is really no squaring the circle, there is no compromise, no "both sides", no middle ground. Either women are equal or they are not. Either abortion is murder, or it is not. There is no people-pleasing our way out of the argument.

allsorts1 · 04/05/2022 14:52

@Wallaw I have been doing a lot of reading on the topic, but haven’t read the case law in question. It would be great if you could explain what I have got so wrong with the US system and justice nomination, as I admit it’s pretty bloody complex, but I understand that you may not have the time or will to do so. Contrary to popular opinion I’m genuinely interested in your view, and we really are fundamentally on the same side with regards to agreeing that women should have free and easy access to safe abortion.

OP posts:
Onlyforcake · 04/05/2022 14:52

It's a really bad idea for America to take a massive backwards step with regard to human rights. Its already a fucked up country that I wouldn't feel safe visiting. This is just proof of their backwards misogynistic mentality.

America sees itself as modern. But this shows how broken and hateful a place it is. Leader of the free world my arse.