Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that US states who want to ban abortion should be able to?

336 replies

allsorts1 · 04/05/2022 08:34

Abortion is such a fraught topic in the US. Would it really be so bad to just let the states who want to ban abortion do so, and leave it in the hands of the states themselves to decide? It seems that the Roe v Wade decision has caused a lot of tension in the context of the USA and the feeling that states should be independent and able to choose their own laws (e.g different laws on capital punishment).

Would it be a completely terrible thing for each state to decide on this, and then live with the consequences (as presumably many young people/liberals would relocate to different states where abortion is legal?). Maybe if they experience brain drain they will change their tune. People aren’t forced to live in a certain state.

Obviously I am completely aware this will have a huge negative impact on women in poverty as they have less options. So this is a key consideration and concern.

But I’m just really thinking out loud. I am very much pro-choice, but interested in views from people who understand US law and politics… could the overturning of Roe v Wade potentially be positive in that it settles the issues, states can decide, and everyone can talk about something else?

Or would it just mean that there is a gradual encroachment on women rights and then the pro-lifers start lobbying in pro-choice states and abortion rights are even further reduced. Another risk could be that abortion becomes a political issue every election in every state, and switches back and forth from being legal to illegal - causing massive headaches….

Interested to hear everyone’s thoughts!

OP posts:
georgarina · 05/05/2022 08:47

BritWifeInUSA · 05/05/2022 02:16

Why would people need to move? You don’t have to be a resident of California, for example, to have an abortion in California.

I’m in the US. I’d rather laws were decided by our state representatives and senators (voted for by us, the people of the state) then 9 unelected judges in DC. That way I have done say in the matter and will consider carefully who I vote for.

And what about when you're miscarrying and haemorrhaging litres of blood and doctors refuse to perform a D&C because there's still a heartbeat so you bleed out? (Happened to my mum, thankfully she was treated.)

What about when you're diagnosed with an ectopic pregnancy and threatened fallopian tube rupture?

What about when you're diagnosed with a septic miscarriage like Savita Halappanavar?

You're going to hop in the car and drive for days to whichever state is nearest to get treatment?

PermanentTemporary · 05/05/2022 08:09

I find it depressing that there are so many women who would celebrate this ban as well.

Lex345 · 05/05/2022 08:08

I am personally struggling with any narrative that suggests this should be decided by majority vote.

We could compare this to Brexit, as a PP suggests, but since Brexit didn't happen inside anyone's body it is a moot point. Don't get me wrong, I didn't want Brexit either, but I can accept that this kind of decision could be an appropriate one to take to majority vote. Deciding on what individual people have to have happen to their bodies IS NOT. I find it extremely worrisome that this will be led in a significant majority by men, who are enforcing rules on women's bodies. This is a huge step backwards and abhorrent.

I would be very worried about the direction of travel that overturning R v W takes the US. It is criminalising women for wanting to have body autonomy. A number of states in the US have a significant core of extreme fundamentalists, where women's rights are already compromised. Some women are already seen as the husband's or father's chattel. A decision to overturn R v W would galvanise this opinion and standpoint.

If this goes through, expect a landslide of conservative states challenging other accepted rights and liberal states scrambling to protect them. This will be a pivotal and polarising moment for the US IMO. Whilst the negative implications for women and girls will be the most immediate outcome, especially the vulnerable, poor and disadvantaged, there will be far reaching consequences of this for minority groups, LGBTQ+ rights etc.

Gentlelentils · 05/05/2022 07:47

"Casual" abortion over unwanted babies any day. And women over foetuses.

Banning abortion at 8 to 10 weeks? Many women might not even know they were pregnant by then if they had irregular periods or were in peri menopause.

Squillerman · 05/05/2022 07:38

It’s effectively banning a sometimes life saving medical procedure. Without legal abortion, some desperate women turn to horrendous methods to terminate pregnancies which sometimes result in them losing their lives. It doesn’t make sense to ban it, it’s 2022.

QuebecBagnet · 05/05/2022 07:27

@Thehundredthnamechange I completely disagree with you. The only thing you’re right about is that things affects other people.

banning abortion would affect other people - women. While protecting unborn fetuses. Which is more important? I’d argue that women should be more important than a fetus.

Why aren’t women allowed to have control over their bodies? Why should they be forced to give birth to a baby they don’t want? Who is going to pay for the upkeep of this child? I’ll give you a hint, it’s unlikely to be state benefits. Not in at any meaningful level anyway. What if children’s homes are overrun?

I don’t think democracy should just be about doing what the majority want. A civilised country should also be looking at what’s the right thing to do overall. If you have a state with 51% men plus a number of religious, brain washed women why should they make decisions for the majority of women? Maybe because it’s a female issue only women should have a say. I’m sure the majority of women want to keep abortion.

I live in a very racist town. I’m sure the majority of people would want a lot of things passed in law which thankfully they’re not allowed to have a say in.

Thehundredthnamechange · 05/05/2022 07:07

Of course they should be allowed to ban abortion in certain states, if this is what the majority want in that state. That's simply how democracy works isn't it. I didn't want Brexit to happen but apparently the majority of people did so it did.

The opinion about abortion very much varies between states and several states are very heavily against abortion and I think it's good that this discussion is being had because I find it quite frankly horrifying how casual abortion has become.

I am not anti abortion but believe there should be very strict time limits - the second a baby could survive outside of the womb, I think that should be the cut off point. Ideally much before that point - I personally think that no later than 8-10 weeks is most ethical. In some states there was talk of changing the rules so that abortion could continue up until the baby was 1 month OUT of the womb. Up until 1 month old, you can leave a baby to die and it would be considered abortion. That, to me, is far more grotesque and evil than banning abortion altogether. So America is very divided to the extremes on this issue.

We are trying to downplay that abortion is killing a baby. We have made ourselves cold to this fact. But some people aren't cold to this fact and they feel very strongly that these babies deserve defending, just as we defend living children. We don't just ignore child abuse if it doesn't affect us, do we?

Everyone's always like "if you don't like abortion don't get one" but it's not as simple as that. Imagine if Putin turned round like "Guys if you don't like the invasion of Ukraine then just don't invade Ukraine?" Things affect other people. People defend each other. And some people want to defend these babies. And if this is what the majority want then that's the price we pay for democracy.

Choufleurfromage · 05/05/2022 07:03

allsorts1 · 04/05/2022 08:52

I want to make it clear that I don’t think banning abortions is a good thing.

I was hoping for some law/political/sociology philosophers to reply with some perspectives on the difference with the US states system and the impact that this issue being handled by the Supreme Court vs left to individual states to decide (in a democracy fyi) has had on the discussion around this in the US.

That perhaps the shift to individual states would take some of the heat out of the argument for pro-lifers as a lot of their outrage appears to be due to it being “decided by the Supreme Court” rather than the states themselves.

Perhaps AIBU wasn’t the place for a balanced philosophical chat. Lesson learnt.

Most of us in UK won't be able to pholosophically discuss state legislation vs federal legislation as we don't work/live in such a system

QuebecBagnet · 05/05/2022 06:55

BritWifeInUSA · 05/05/2022 02:16

Why would people need to move? You don’t have to be a resident of California, for example, to have an abortion in California.

I’m in the US. I’d rather laws were decided by our state representatives and senators (voted for by us, the people of the state) then 9 unelected judges in DC. That way I have done say in the matter and will consider carefully who I vote for.

How does someone living on the breadline in Texas for example afford to get to a state which offers abortion? No car and can’t afford a plane?

how does an abused wife get one behind her husbands back?

how does a 16yo get one without her parents finding out?

how does a woman with five kids already find the time/childcare to travel out of state for a trip which may well take a few days.

Indicatrice · 05/05/2022 05:48

Would it be a completely terrible thing for each state to decide on this, and then live with the consequences (as presumably many young people/liberals would relocate to different states where abortion is legal?). Maybe if they experience brain drain they will change their tune. People aren’t forced to live in a certain state.

I’m an educated, high-earning woman who has lived in the same 5 mile radius all my life. Moving to the next town is anathema for me, let alone moving thousands of miles away, all so that I can be a statistic for OP in 30 years’ time.

BritWifeInUSA · 05/05/2022 02:16

Why would people need to move? You don’t have to be a resident of California, for example, to have an abortion in California.

I’m in the US. I’d rather laws were decided by our state representatives and senators (voted for by us, the people of the state) then 9 unelected judges in DC. That way I have done say in the matter and will consider carefully who I vote for.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 05/05/2022 01:04

iCouldSleepForAYear · 05/05/2022 00:51

You waded into a debate thread. No one made you write a post. I asked a question about the logic of your statement, because I found that logic lacking.

I'm American too. ;-)

Great, then you can share a different American perspective, if you haven’t already…(I mostly skimmed the responses).

youvegottenminuteslynn · 05/05/2022 00:52

People aren’t forced to live in a certain state.

The poorest people essentially are as they can't afford to leave. They're also the most likely to be in need of an abortion statistically.

Your post is short sighted and fails to address the fact that a voting population that comprises of 50% men and 50% women is not a fair population to vote on choices that only directly affect 50% of those people - the women. It removes their bodily autonomy.

That can never be ok.

iCouldSleepForAYear · 05/05/2022 00:51

saltinesandcoffeecups · 05/05/2022 00:32

@iCouldSleepForAYear

”Not up for debate but I’ll share 1 American’s perspective.”

You waded into a debate thread. No one made you write a post. I asked a question about the logic of your statement, because I found that logic lacking.

I'm American too. ;-)

Marvellousmadness · 05/05/2022 00:49

Blah blah. You are just trying to get heated discussions started

saltinesandcoffeecups · 05/05/2022 00:32

@iCouldSleepForAYear

”Not up for debate but I’ll share 1 American’s perspective.”

iCouldSleepForAYear · 05/05/2022 00:30

I’m not happy with the government getting involved with very personal and fundamental decisions about my life and health

Well, that's kind of the status quo under Roe v Wade. The government (state? federal? local town meeting?) is not involved in your decision to terminate a pregnancy.

Overturning Roe v Wade gets governments involved.

You're really comparing the enforcement of measures that will save someone else's life (wearing a seatbelt, so you're not a human projectile in a car accident and taking out others while you fly 500 ft through your windshield) ... with restricting medical procedures that could very well save your own?

Really?

Shedcity · 05/05/2022 00:27

Yeah people love uprooting their entire lives, thousands of miles away from everything they’ve ever known, on the off chance they need an abortion. Poor women especially, they love moving, it’s totally accessible to them.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 05/05/2022 00:15

Weird.. ignore the bold formatting

saltinesandcoffeecups · 05/05/2022 00:14

@allsorts1 Not up for debate but I’ll share 1 American’s perspective.

RoeV.Wade was a flawed ruling from the start, as it allowed abortion on a nonexistent privacy right which is not a stated constitutional right, which is why SCOTUS is assumed to be on the brink of the leaked decision. Nobody had the political will to do anything about it for 50 years. Lately (past 10 years or so) states have been challenging the decision in both way; Laws that severely restrict abortion and laws that skirt existing homicide laws and laws somewhere in the middle. These state laws have been passed to test the waters with SCOTUS on RoeV.Wade*

The overturning of RoeV.Wade sends the decision back to states to manage and pass laws, unless a federal law is passed which would supersede any state laws. Then based on the constitutionality of the law would stand or fall. The other thing that could be done is to pass an amendment that would codify abortion rights int law. The bar is really really high to accomplish that.

Now here’s my personal opinion…

Abortion is complicated and should be a complicated issue. I’m not happy with the government getting involved with very personal and fundamental decisions about my life and health (FTR- this goes for abortion as much as it does for seatbelts and vaccine mandates). That being said, that ship has obviously sailed, so as it’s already a gov’t issue fundamentally I’m not opposed to states having control and passing state laws. I think the federal legislature needs to commit and pass a laws that put framework in place for more local decisions to be made.

I do have suspicions that this has been allowed to be a shitshow for so long, because each political party uses it when they need to drum up support and votes.

*See my personal opinion in the last paragraph

calmlakes · 04/05/2022 23:47

This is the tweet.

To think that US states who want to ban abortion should be able to?
calmlakes · 04/05/2022 23:45

Not just women. Anyone
I think the word Ms Harris is looking for is men.

I'm not that keen on this way of expressing the people who aren't women.

iCouldSleepForAYear · 04/05/2022 23:37

NamelessNancy · 04/05/2022 23:22

When you chose where to live what do most people base it on? Access to employment, cost of living, family. Abortion rights? Seriously? The idea that if women want the right to abortion they should think carefully about where to live is fundamentally mysogynist.

Exactly.

Are women equally human, or not?

Either we are or we aren't. If we are, then our rights are the same everywhere.

On a more philosophical "I got mine bruh" angle:

When you ban the rights of the people between US states in one area (abortion/bodily autonomy/privacy), that quickly creates a precedent to remove rights in other areas.

Right to bear arms? Now there's a case to ban gun ownership completely at the state level. And set up interstate borders and checkpoints (unheard of since pre-ratification, IIRC) to ensure that ban is being enforced.

Right to free speech? Banned in some states but not others.

Right to assemble? Banned in some states but not others.

Right to a lawyer and a fair (in theory) trial? Why should some states that don't particularly like those rules have to maintain them. 🤷🏻‍♀️

The Equal Protection clause in the 14th amendment of the Constitution doesn't just protect US citizens. It protects the Constitution itself. When you remove rights for some people living in some states, you don't have a United States anymore.

Hope you get a A on your essay, kid. You're getting an awful lot of content for free. Remember to rewrite in your own words: teachers will copy-paste sentences into Google and these posts will show up if you use them word-for-word. Wink

NamelessNancy · 04/05/2022 23:23

Choose not chose. Sorry!

NamelessNancy · 04/05/2022 23:22

When you chose where to live what do most people base it on? Access to employment, cost of living, family. Abortion rights? Seriously? The idea that if women want the right to abortion they should think carefully about where to live is fundamentally mysogynist.