Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that US states who want to ban abortion should be able to?

336 replies

allsorts1 · 04/05/2022 08:34

Abortion is such a fraught topic in the US. Would it really be so bad to just let the states who want to ban abortion do so, and leave it in the hands of the states themselves to decide? It seems that the Roe v Wade decision has caused a lot of tension in the context of the USA and the feeling that states should be independent and able to choose their own laws (e.g different laws on capital punishment).

Would it be a completely terrible thing for each state to decide on this, and then live with the consequences (as presumably many young people/liberals would relocate to different states where abortion is legal?). Maybe if they experience brain drain they will change their tune. People aren’t forced to live in a certain state.

Obviously I am completely aware this will have a huge negative impact on women in poverty as they have less options. So this is a key consideration and concern.

But I’m just really thinking out loud. I am very much pro-choice, but interested in views from people who understand US law and politics… could the overturning of Roe v Wade potentially be positive in that it settles the issues, states can decide, and everyone can talk about something else?

Or would it just mean that there is a gradual encroachment on women rights and then the pro-lifers start lobbying in pro-choice states and abortion rights are even further reduced. Another risk could be that abortion becomes a political issue every election in every state, and switches back and forth from being legal to illegal - causing massive headaches….

Interested to hear everyone’s thoughts!

OP posts:
Triffid1 · 05/05/2022 10:34

JanisMoplin · 05/05/2022 09:14

Yes, that seemed unlikely.🙄

I'm almost positive that this argument, hauled out to explain why pro abortion types just can't be trusted.... was a rabbit hole that has been surprisingly effective for people who already have low levels of practical reasoning.

I vaguely remember people shouting about this. IIRC, the argument was that Pro Choice types who want abortion to be legal with no limits are, apparently, super happy for abortion to take place at, for example, 39 weeks. The suggestion being that women get to 39 weeks and then just randomly decide to terminate (obviously, accompanied with lots of heartfelt images of very pregnant women).

The next step in the argument was that many many babies are born way before this and survive just fine.

Ergo (apparently), we may as well allow the murder of 1 month old infants because that's what abortion is.

It was a ridiculous and spurious argument then. But clearly effective if people like that poster think it was true. Sigh.

pigsDOfly · 05/05/2022 10:23

This can be argued back and forth and it's unlikely anyone's opinion is going to be changed on here.

The fact is that abortion is about women having rights over their own bodies. It's got nothing to do with a clump of cells having the 'right to life' it's all about women's autonomy or lack thereof.

What anti-abortionist are voting for is their 'right' to keep women in their 'place'.

Chikapu · 05/05/2022 10:18

I am not anti abortion but believe there should be very strict time limits - the second a baby could survive outside of the womb, I think that should be the cut off point. Ideally much before that point - I personally think that no later than 8-10 weeks is most ethical. In some states there was talk of changing the rules so that abortion could continue up until the baby was 1 month OUT of the womb. Up until 1 month old, you can leave a baby to die and it would be considered abortion. That, to me, is far more grotesque and evil than banning abortion altogether. So America is very divided to the extremes on this issue

You really honestly don't believe that anyone has ever advocated for allowing a month old baby to die do you? That's the most stupid thing I've ever read on here and that's saying something.

sashh · 05/05/2022 10:14

Butteryflakycrust83 · 04/05/2022 10:51

Abortion is illegal in NI, I have not seen a mass exodus of women moving from there?

It isn't.

commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/cbp-8909/

There may be no mass exodus on a permeant basis but Abortion clinics in England are quite busy with NI and Irish women, you can pay for a coffee in Euros if you are waiting for a friend.

BashfulClam · 05/05/2022 10:03

even Thinking this is not pro choice. A woman should always have full and final say over her body. Marital rape was still legal a few decades ago, domestic violence was ‘just a domestic’ and women fad to either have unwanted children
or resort to desiderata measures to end a pregnancy. Drink a full bottle of gin whilst sitting in a scalding bath, throwing themselves downstairs, pushing a knitting needle or coat hanger up through the cervix or using a back street clinic…,let’s all go back in time to those with regular days where women were not safe!

Whatwouldscullydo · 05/05/2022 09:59

Think that there aren't enough babies to adopt/traffic? Rape women

Given the fact that fostered/abused/traumatised /chikdren growing up in.poverty, children have far poorer outcomes amd are far more likely to end up running away or falling victim to sex traffickers it is indeed ensuring a steady supply of victims to feed one of the most profitable set ups in the world.

But yay the kids alive. What a bloody low bar 😢

Kpo58 · 05/05/2022 09:46

Won't banning abortion make rape a very attractive option to some people as the victim won't be able to do anything about it?

Want children, but not to have to raise them yourself? Rape a woman

Want to bankrupt a poor woman? Rape her

Think that women shouldn't be in the workforce? Rape them repeatedly so that they cannot afford childcare to work

Think that there make be a drop in prison population/slave labour? Rape women to make the numbers go back up

Think that there aren't enough babies to adopt/traffic? Rape women

I just don't see how any of this can be seen as ethical.

JanisMoplin · 05/05/2022 09:42

Women are the only disadvantaged group it is still ok to hate and discriminate against, it seems. So fucking annoyed at all the times "cis privilege" is hurled at women on social media. Some privilege to be a woman in this world.

PlanBea · 05/05/2022 09:39

Let's also outlaw appendectomies too. They're both healthcare procedures. Don't want to die from appendicitis? Should have thought of that before deciding to live in America 🙃

sarcasm, just in case it wasn't entirely obvious

If this was about protecting life, then there would be an exception for ectopic pregnancy, which will never result in a baby and will almost certainly kill the mother. But this is all about keeping women in subservience and poor people in poverty.

Sceptre86 · 05/05/2022 09:34

Not everyone can just up and move state. Poverty, childcare, family support, jobs, friends, all reasons why it is not easy to just up and move on incase you do need to have an abortion one day. Outlawing it reintroduces shame because you are doing something 'illegal'. They have absolutely shit maternity leave in the US and its dependent on the employer. Im on a Facebook group for babies born at the same time as mine and so many mothers had to go back so much more quickly than they wanted too because their employer didn't need to keep their jobs secure. They do not have a generous benefit system or support mothers once they have the children yet some States want to force women into keeping unwanted pregnancies.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 05/05/2022 09:30

BuanoKubiamVej · 05/05/2022 09:27

@Thehundredthnamechange
Of course they should be allowed to ban abortion in certain states, if this is what the majority want in that state. That's simply how democracy works isn't it. I didn't want Brexit to happen but apparently the majority of people did so it did.

If a state composed of 70% white racists, 20% white non-racists and 10% black people wanted to vote to reintroduce segregation, slavery and other measures to deprive the 10% black population of their rights to equality, would that be totally ok with you? It would be a majority opinion in that state of course. Free and fair elections for all voters in this state including all the black voters and all the non-racist white voters would nevertheless be outnumbered by the majority view.

Is this ok with you?

If not, why don't the reasons why not apply when the disadvantaged category being outvoted is a different group than black people?

This. Interested in your answer @Thehundredthnamechange

Stardust2022 · 05/05/2022 09:28

If you all remember a few years ago Ireland finally lifted there ban, was so happy for them (I am pro choice as well) so sad that so many had to jump over to liverpool to be helped. The sad thing is though, I bet the majority of women will still come to liverpool, even though the ban has been lifted as soo many will be judged if they do decide abortion is their option-the same could happen in the US too. It is right or fair to dictate to women what they can or can't do with their own bodies

BuanoKubiamVej · 05/05/2022 09:27

@Thehundredthnamechange
Of course they should be allowed to ban abortion in certain states, if this is what the majority want in that state. That's simply how democracy works isn't it. I didn't want Brexit to happen but apparently the majority of people did so it did.

If a state composed of 70% white racists, 20% white non-racists and 10% black people wanted to vote to reintroduce segregation, slavery and other measures to deprive the 10% black population of their rights to equality, would that be totally ok with you? It would be a majority opinion in that state of course. Free and fair elections for all voters in this state including all the black voters and all the non-racist white voters would nevertheless be outnumbered by the majority view.

Is this ok with you?

If not, why don't the reasons why not apply when the disadvantaged category being outvoted is a different group than black people?

Flavourflava · 05/05/2022 09:23

God, I hate new Mumsnet.

Apologies for the quote (main point remains)

Flavourflava · 05/05/2022 09:22

allsorts1 · 04/05/2022 08:34

Abortion is such a fraught topic in the US. Would it really be so bad to just let the states who want to ban abortion do so, and leave it in the hands of the states themselves to decide? It seems that the Roe v Wade decision has caused a lot of tension in the context of the USA and the feeling that states should be independent and able to choose their own laws (e.g different laws on capital punishment).

Would it be a completely terrible thing for each state to decide on this, and then live with the consequences (as presumably many young people/liberals would relocate to different states where abortion is legal?). Maybe if they experience brain drain they will change their tune. People aren’t forced to live in a certain state.

Obviously I am completely aware this will have a huge negative impact on women in poverty as they have less options. So this is a key consideration and concern.

But I’m just really thinking out loud. I am very much pro-choice, but interested in views from people who understand US law and politics… could the overturning of Roe v Wade potentially be positive in that it settles the issues, states can decide, and everyone can talk about something else?

Or would it just mean that there is a gradual encroachment on women rights and then the pro-lifers start lobbying in pro-choice states and abortion rights are even further reduced. Another risk could be that abortion becomes a political issue every election in every state, and switches back and forth from being legal to illegal - causing massive headaches….

Interested to hear everyone’s thoughts!

Are you high?

BuanoKubiamVej · 05/05/2022 09:16

It's impossible for there to be a stable union of democratic states wherein some states have equality between the sexes and others have state control of women's bodies, forcing women to surrender their bodily autonomy and dignity in order to bring into the world a child she doesn't want and can't afford, risking her life and her lifelong health the the process at the same time as not providing free healthcare so that she has to pay for these consequences herself. Its simply unsustainable long term for a country to exist where half the population are regarded as second-class citizens on one side of arbitrary lines - especially as some legislations being drafted will attempt to stop their residents from travelling to procure an abortion.

But it's possible that the overthrow of RvW will lead to better, more comprehensive legislation being passed which enshrines the rights of women properly and explicitly. It's always seemed a little odd that women's rights in the USA are based on the precedent of a particular fight between Roe and Wade rather than by primary legislation.

I think they could make a start by creating federal legislation that said that any state which bans abortion must be required to simultaneously enact measure to provide free healthcare, education and a minimum income guarantee for life for both the woman and the baby, in every circumstance where a pregnancy would otherwise have been ended by abortion. Being pro-life only as far as forcing the birth to happen without making provision for supporting the life created and restoring the life damaged in that process shouldn't be possible.

JanisMoplin · 05/05/2022 09:14

Yes, that seemed unlikely.🙄

isthisit83 · 05/05/2022 09:11

Absolutely not. I'm American. This is scary. And as many have already pointed out, outcomes for the least well off will be worse. They can't just upsticks and move and perhaps they don't have the money to travel to a different state. The USA has almost no safety net for the poor as well so it's not like having a baby gets you a house and income like it seems to over here! (I'm actually pro-welfare but thought this was worth pointing out).

OurChristmasMiracle · 05/05/2022 09:10

How about we allow women to make their own choices in regard to their own bodies and provide them with the information and resources/medical care in order for them to do this in the safest possible way (I say safest because any medical procedure has a risk attached)

iCouldSleepForAYear · 05/05/2022 09:06

Of course they should be allowed to ban abortion in certain states, if this is what the majority want in that state. That's simply how democracy works isn't it.

By that logic, slavery should remain openly legal.

By that logic, segregation should remain legal.

By that logic, apartheid should remain legal.

Because that's how democracy worked. Those states were dragged kicking and screaming into emancipation and integration. It took a civil fucking war to do it.

Was it wrong to drag them onto the side of human rights for human beings? Are you sure?

Abortion isn't "political", for God's sake. You are not discussing some remote philosophical essay question in RMPS. You are talking about human rights. Human rights. Women are human. Fully human. Not livestock.

SpindleInTheWind · 05/05/2022 09:05

The anti-abortion arguments being promulgated on this thread are bordering on the insane.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 05/05/2022 09:03

@Thehundredthnamechange

I am not anti abortion but believe there should be very strict time limits - the second a baby could survive outside of the womb, I think that should be the cut off point. Ideally much before that point - I personally think that no later than 8-10 weeks is most ethical.

So you think a foetus can survive outside the womb at 8-10 weeks? Gosh.

dottiedodah · 05/05/2022 08:59

No one wants an abortion. They often have little choice .Young girls unable to care for a child .women who have been raped .women having an affair .the list goes on .poor women will be affected most ,in the past wealthy women would seek help privately. The rest at the mercy of a back street butcher. How is this being discussed even .50 years later?

pigsDOfly · 05/05/2022 08:58

Everyone's always like "if you don't like abortion don't get one" but it's not as simple as that. Imagine if Putin turned round like "Guys if you don't like the invasion of Ukraine then just don't invade Ukraine?"

That has got to be one of the most ridiculous ways of putting the argument against abortion that I've ever encountered.

So you're equating Putin's invasion and destruction of another country along with the murder, torture and rape of many of the population of that country with the rights of women over their own bodies?

Really?

Regularsizedrudy · 05/05/2022 08:57

Wow that was one of the stupidest things I’ve ever read.