Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that US states who want to ban abortion should be able to?

336 replies

allsorts1 · 04/05/2022 08:34

Abortion is such a fraught topic in the US. Would it really be so bad to just let the states who want to ban abortion do so, and leave it in the hands of the states themselves to decide? It seems that the Roe v Wade decision has caused a lot of tension in the context of the USA and the feeling that states should be independent and able to choose their own laws (e.g different laws on capital punishment).

Would it be a completely terrible thing for each state to decide on this, and then live with the consequences (as presumably many young people/liberals would relocate to different states where abortion is legal?). Maybe if they experience brain drain they will change their tune. People aren’t forced to live in a certain state.

Obviously I am completely aware this will have a huge negative impact on women in poverty as they have less options. So this is a key consideration and concern.

But I’m just really thinking out loud. I am very much pro-choice, but interested in views from people who understand US law and politics… could the overturning of Roe v Wade potentially be positive in that it settles the issues, states can decide, and everyone can talk about something else?

Or would it just mean that there is a gradual encroachment on women rights and then the pro-lifers start lobbying in pro-choice states and abortion rights are even further reduced. Another risk could be that abortion becomes a political issue every election in every state, and switches back and forth from being legal to illegal - causing massive headaches….

Interested to hear everyone’s thoughts!

OP posts:
Triffid1 · 04/05/2022 10:03

No, each state should not have the right to decide. Because abortion rights for women should be fundamental human rights. It's like saying, "okay, well, we're not going to have a national policy on slavery - every state can choose for themselves."

Abortion is NOT the same as, for example, a state deciding what its road speed limits are or how they will implement social services. It should be a fundamental right based on the belief that everyone has the right to bodily autonomy and that NO one should be forced to sacrifice their physical, mental or financial well being for someone else.

gwanwyn · 04/05/2022 09:57

Comedycook · 04/05/2022 09:07

If they must go ahead with this hideous idea and women in certain states won't be able to access legal and safe abortions, then surely they should improve their healthcare system so that all women have free and easy access to contraception?

I don't think that is the case - they already have very high maternal deaths

Why do so many US women die giving birth?

I don't know if the situation has changed since BBC report above - but 2017 Texas had highest maternal death rate - higher than some thrid world countries - and I bnelive they're one of the states that wants to ban abortion.

Plus I think there have been moves to make access to contraceptives harder recenetly over there - allowing it not to be included in health care plans or something.

I suspect what will happen in what the situation was here before legalisation - richer more connected women will be able to access relative safe illegal abortions and everyone else will have unwanted children or highly dangerous illegal abortions and then eventually they'll start facing prospect of prosecution and then women who've had miscarrages will also get swept up in that.

A campaigner I was listening to last night did say if they lose Roe v Wade they will then start the campaigning state by state for better laws - they're not going to just stop. So I don't think the debate would stop at the national level either as polticians do move up from state to national level and it will still be there as a controversial subject still.

CharSiu · 04/05/2022 09:56

Women will die, more children will face neglect and eventually crime will increase. I have read peer researched journal articles on just this subject but year ago and can’t remember the specifics and don’t have access to Jstor anymore as retired.

oakleaffy · 04/05/2022 09:55

CaptainMyCaptain · 04/05/2022 08:36

You can never ban abortion you can only ban safe, legal abortion.

Very true.
Also, what happens to the children born of women who would otherwise terminate an accidental pregnancy early?

A Catholic friend many years ago was forced to give up her baby as a young teenager, some sort of ghastly home for unmarried mothers.

I just hope she was able to reunite with her child later, when he was 18.

oakleaffy · 04/05/2022 09:54

CaptainMyCaptain · 04/05/2022 08:36

You can never ban abortion you can only ban safe, legal abortion.

Very true.
Also, what happens to the children born of women who would otherwise terminate an accidental pregnancy early?

A Catholic friend many years ago was forced to give up her baby as a young teenager, some sort of ghastly home for unmarried mothers.

I just hope she was able to reunite with her child later, when he was 18.

allsorts1 · 04/05/2022 09:52

@Hiphopopotamus philosophical debate to me doesn’t mean anything arty farty, it just means discussing the issues at hand without attacking the person who proposes the two sides of the argument. Probably AIBU is a unwise place to do so as the whole premise is about the author of the post being personally unreasonable.

For the record, I think this is an awful thing and wish there was some way to just force all US states to make abortion safe free and easy forever and ever the end. But that’s not very democratic.

OP posts:
Whisp3r · 04/05/2022 09:52

Instead of leaving it up to each state to decide how about we all keep our noses out and leave it up to each woman to decide whether she carries a child and gives birth or not.

Choufleurfromage · 04/05/2022 09:48

allsorts1 · 04/05/2022 08:45

Obviously I don’t want Roe v Wade overturned! In an ideal world it wouldn’t be. However with the draft decision going in that direction I have been pondering the legal & political ramifications and the different context of the US and the states system. I don’t need my ass handed to me re:abortion (v v pro choice!) - I just wanted to discuss the various ramifications in the different context of the US that’s all.

Discuss the various ramifications? Nothing to discuss, it is a shit idea bought in by pale, stale and male lawmakers, along with some pretty feckin disgusting women whio support it.
Do you think women are able to move states that easily? You have no idea...

allsorts1 · 04/05/2022 09:47

@Clymene yes my title was absolutely bloody rubbish I admit! Don’t mumsnet while half distracted getting ready for work. Oops.

OP posts:
Forresttheout · 04/05/2022 09:47

Agree with those saying this will only lead to unsafe abortions, I live in a country where abortion is illegal (with the exception of if the baby must be delivered to save the mothers life). It does not stop abortions all it does it make safe abortions inaccessible to those without the money to fly elsewhere or pay the fees of a doctor in an expensive private hospital who will forge documentation saying it was done to save your life etc. everyone else is left with backstreet clinics or diy attempts or left to feed and care for children they cannot afford.

allsorts1 · 04/05/2022 09:42

BalladOfBarryAndFreda · 04/05/2022 09:31

How can you be ‘v v pro-choice’ but advocate for repealing the law that gives women pregnancy choices?

I don’t get it.

When did I “advocate” repealing anything? The draft response suggests that it will be repealed. I was just pondering what the long term impacts might be with this issue in state hands and driven by elected reps, state by state.

Probably the impacts will be all bad, but I wondered if there was any potential long term positive with regards to state independence. It’s already basically impossible to get an abortion in many states like Texas even with Roe v Wade in place. So from a strictly philosophical view, trying to look impartially at all sides, maybe removing the much hated top down ruling of Roe v Wade, which seems to be seen very much as “elite liberal interference” would take some heat out of it in a political sense for the deep red states and allow them to formulate their own laws, which could end up being more balanced and a bit like Texas plus. People seem to be forgetting that the US is a democracy, and people can vote for the people who make these laws.

Or could be a handmaid’s tale dystopian nightmare!

Probably the latter.

My title on re-read is a bit click baitey but I didn’t intend that.

OP posts:
cushioncovers · 04/05/2022 09:41

The lives of the unwanted children that women would be forced to have will be awful in many many cases leading to generations of dysfunctional adults which in turn will cost the state far more than abortions ever would.

Discovereads · 04/05/2022 09:40

what about the option that people use their political power to lobby their representatives to increase access to abortion in their state?

The regular voters have next to no political power at all in the US. Corruption and voter suppression is rife. For example, there’s no law saying employers have to give you time off work to vote. And voting stations are usually open during business hours and are so few and far between that it’s not unusual to have to wait in a queue for 1-2hrs to vote. So many people in the service industry -which is predominantly women- cannot get the time off work to actually vote. Even when they do vote and so and so who made promises x,y,z gets elected, that politician can and often does break those promises and vote on laws opposite to what they promised. So many people are disaffected and think why bother voting in the face of no real choice?

The only promises US politicians tend to keep are those made to the wealthy contributors to their campaign funding. The US is the Wild West compared to the U.K. in that a wealthy person can literally buy a senator and have them in their pocket to vote as they dictate in return for a few million in funds for their election.

bluefairylights · 04/05/2022 09:38

Until v recently you couldn't get an abortion in parts of the UK!

What is does is forced women to go to where they can get one. Women here are still having to travel to England to access abortion because the services are very bad in NI.

Luckily there are very cheap flights to England and has been for many years. I wouldn't fancy living in potentially 1000s of miles away from a boarder into a state where abortion is legal. But even with it being relatively easy to get to Manchester or somewhere for an afternoon for an abortion it is a horrendous experience. Also I do worry about younger women/ girls accessing drugs online from god knows where to do it at home.

GrendelsGrandma · 04/05/2022 09:38

You mean they still have a choice because they could move across the country. That's like saying you could move to France or Ireland if they banned abortion here. Fuck that. Abortion is a basic right and should be available to all women, everywhere on demand.

Do you ever stop to think why abortion has been made such a big issue? Apparently it was only picked up in the 70s and 80s as a political hot potato. There are right wingers who want to dismantle everything to do with the state, taxes, etc - basically living in a wild west where a few people are rich and powerful and the plebs fight for the scraps. That's not going to attract many voters. So you use abortion as an electoral tool to get people worked up and voting for you.

If they genuinely cared about foetuses, babies and children they'd be campaigning for contraception, better welfare, free healthcare. They do the opposite.

alwayscrashinginthesamecar1 · 04/05/2022 09:36

No. Its an awful idea. I'm from NI where abortion was only legalised in 2019. I know plenty of women and girls who were forced to get the boat to England to get an abortion, and it was awful and traumatising for all of them. But at least they could afford to do it, many others were not so fortunate and ended up with babies they didn't want and ruined lives instead. But I'm not sure if that is an intellectual or philosophical enough level of debate for you. For god's sake, cop yourself on.

lljkk · 04/05/2022 09:35

OP said something like "Let the state live with the consequences"

Problem with that is that it's the most vulnerable who suffer in meantime, the teenagers who can't move away from families yet, the people tied to a place for economic reasons, the disabled reliant on public benefits. They lose choice to just move away. And since when have the political powers in Mississippi, Kansas or Kentucky cared about brain drain, anyway?

allsorts1 · 04/05/2022 09:32

@AntsMarching Thank you for this and that definitely puts the just move option into massive perspective. I stand corrected.

My just move comment was a bit facetious. I was more wondering if over time, young people would desert these states and the states would have a problem on their hands with regards to GDP etc.

I agree that banning abortion is fundamentally bad. I am pro choice all the way and think access should be free, easy and safe.

However, from your perspective - what about the option that people use their political power to lobby their representatives to increase access to abortion in their state? Is the US not a democracy? Or is this just completely out of the realms of possibility in many states, do the pro-lifers really have so much power?

OP posts:
BalladOfBarryAndFreda · 04/05/2022 09:31

How can you be ‘v v pro-choice’ but advocate for repealing the law that gives women pregnancy choices?

I don’t get it.

tootiredtoocare · 04/05/2022 09:29

Have you read any of the arguments from the USA? For many women it would be a minimum of an overnight trip and sometimes even a weekend to get out of their own state to a 'safe' place, for some of them involving a flight. If, of course, they could afford it, which most of them can't. Don't forget they also have to pay for the procedure. In the UK, we have no concept of the size of the USA and what distances they have to travel to get out of their own states. Texas is around 800 x 750 miles. They will only be banning safe abortion - they'll go back to backstreet butchers and women dying of infection and blood loss.

Hiphopopotamus · 04/05/2022 09:29

This reply has been deleted

Accidental duplicate

Hiphopopotamus · 04/05/2022 09:28

I’m sorry we’re not reaching the levels of philosophical debate that you are wanting on the intellectual pros and cons of US statehood vs federal law 🙄

Its an incredibly emotive subject and women are going to react emotionally about it. It’s terrifying to see women’s rights stripped away like this and the real life ramifications for real people will be devastating. Women will die.

While people are dealing with a lot of real feelings on this issue, I’m not sure you should be scolding us for not wanting to engage with your ‘philosophical debate’. (And the debate between states rights and federal law has been ongoing for decades now - plenty of stuff out there you can read if you choose to)

Clymene · 04/05/2022 09:28

If you wanted a balanced philosophical chat, perhaps you should have chosen a title which wasn't about denying women and girls access to safe and legal abortion.

Clymene · 04/05/2022 09:28

If you wanted a balanced philosophical chat, perhaps you should have chosen a title which wasn't about denying women and girls access to safe and legal abortion.

Clymene · 04/05/2022 09:28

If you wanted a balanced philosophical chat, perhaps you should have chosen a title which wasn't about denying women and girls access to safe and legal abortion.