Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that US states who want to ban abortion should be able to?

336 replies

allsorts1 · 04/05/2022 08:34

Abortion is such a fraught topic in the US. Would it really be so bad to just let the states who want to ban abortion do so, and leave it in the hands of the states themselves to decide? It seems that the Roe v Wade decision has caused a lot of tension in the context of the USA and the feeling that states should be independent and able to choose their own laws (e.g different laws on capital punishment).

Would it be a completely terrible thing for each state to decide on this, and then live with the consequences (as presumably many young people/liberals would relocate to different states where abortion is legal?). Maybe if they experience brain drain they will change their tune. People aren’t forced to live in a certain state.

Obviously I am completely aware this will have a huge negative impact on women in poverty as they have less options. So this is a key consideration and concern.

But I’m just really thinking out loud. I am very much pro-choice, but interested in views from people who understand US law and politics… could the overturning of Roe v Wade potentially be positive in that it settles the issues, states can decide, and everyone can talk about something else?

Or would it just mean that there is a gradual encroachment on women rights and then the pro-lifers start lobbying in pro-choice states and abortion rights are even further reduced. Another risk could be that abortion becomes a political issue every election in every state, and switches back and forth from being legal to illegal - causing massive headaches….

Interested to hear everyone’s thoughts!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BackflandedCondiment · 09/05/2022 08:47

As others have said, this isn't about the sanctitiy of life at all - it's about full and total control:

www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-61347934

www.vox.com/2019/10/31/20939890/missouri-abortion-clinic-hearing-periods-roe-wade

"At a hearing over an investigation of Missouri’s lone abortion clinic, a state official testified to something that has disturbed reproductive health advocates in the state and beyond: With the help of state medical records, his office had created a spreadsheet tracking patients’ menstrual periods.

The goal, according to the Kansas City Star, was to investigate “failed” abortions, instances in which the patient needed to return a second time to complete the procedure. The idea was apparently that, by gathering data on patients’ periods, state officials would know who was still pregnant after a scheduled abortion."

AntsMarching · 08/05/2022 20:49

@allsorts1 sorry, I didn't get a notification that you'd responded.

You can lobby in your state, but as most politicians are funded by PACs and large corporate donors, the don't tend to listen to "the people". Lobbying as an individual has become less effective since the Citizens United case allowed money into politics.

Kpo58 · 08/05/2022 15:35

Could the banning of abortion be the American way of implementing Eugenics by stealth? Maybe it's their way of eradicating poor women who have health issues around being pregnant and a new way to create a "Master race".

Implantation in the wrong place? Death

Not rich enough to afford maternity health care, but need it? Death

Pregnancy is hazardous to your health? Death

Couldn't fight off your male attacker whilst being raped? You will most likely end up passing on the genes for physically stronger males and weaker (more subservient) females as it's easier to force weaker physically females to produce more offspring than those who can fight back.

sashh · 08/05/2022 14:05

Shamoo · 05/05/2022 20:57

Don’t be so stupid OP. Seriously.

Actually, are people really this stupid? Or is it just a post intended to inflame?

Some people are that stupid.

A couple of women on twitter who had experience pre R v Wade have told what happened to, in most cases, their mothers.

One woman had come home from school to find her mother collapsed and bleeding heavily, she had miscarried but the foetus had not been expelled.

She went to a neighbour, got an ambulance and her father and sibling.

Mum was being transfused with blood constantly but dad had to take his two daughters to a meeting with the hospital governors to bed them to treat his wife.

72 hours after admission the foetus was surgically removed.

The 'pro life' twitterverse just said, "that won't happen, that is life saving".

PeekAtYou · 06/05/2022 09:20

That's an excellent quote,

I've seen some posts point out that if fetuses have rights because they are living from the moment of conception then all foreign pregnant women in the US are carrying US citizens which gets the extremists twitchy because of the immigration angle.

Desperately hoping this is all a mistake because all rights not mentioned in the constitution are under threat - gay rights, children's rights, women's rights....

Rainbowqueeen · 06/05/2022 09:04

I know @knittingaddict I messed up and use ‘live the unborn’ instead of ‘love the unborn’ in the middle

I love the way it so eloquently says that pro life supporters have chosen to be pro life so that they can feel like good people for supporting a cause while at the same time making sure nothing changes for them

knittingaddict · 06/05/2022 07:58

That's a powerful quote Rainbowqueeen. Thank you for posting it.

Rainbowqueeen · 06/05/2022 03:04

Methodist Pastor David Barnhart quote:

“ The unborn are a convenient group of people to advocate for. They never make demands on you, they are morally uncomplicated, unlike the incarcerated, addicted or the chronically poor, they don’t resent your condescension or complain that you are not politically correct; unlike widows they don’t ask you to question patriarchy; unlike orphans they don’t need money, education or childcare; unlike aliens they don’t bring all that racial, cultural and religious baggage that you dislike; they allow you to feel good about yourself without any work at creating or maintaining relationships; and when they are born, you can forget about them, because they cease to be unborn. You can live the unborn and advocate for them without substantially challenging your own wealth, power or privilege, without re-imagining social structures, apologising or making reparations to anyone. They are, in short, the perfect people to love if you want to claim you love Jesus but dislike people who breathe. Prisoners? Immigrants? The sick? The poor? Widows? Orphans? All the groups that are specifically mentioned in the Bible? They all get thrown under the bus for the unborn”

And women are thrown under the bus more than anyone.

Another issue is that a ban is going to lead to poor maternal care for women. There are already stories circulating of women who have had miscarriages that require D and Cs being unable to find doctors who will perform that procedure, women who have eptopic pregnancies being able to have their lives saved as doctors are scared of being charged with perming an abortion.

There are also concerns that IVF will no longer be an option because unused embryos are disposed of but some advocates of abortion consider these to be live. Amy Coney Barrett is apparently of this view.

If Roe v Wade is overturned the future is bleak for women.

ExistentialApathy · 05/05/2022 23:11

@allsorts1 I think you're getting a lot more abuse here than you deserve.

I think if you'd framed it as a question about process rather than topic you might have fared better!

If I understand your questions correctly, they are based on the (seemingly innocuous) argument that decisions on abortion (or other significant policy decisions) should rightly sit with democratically elected representatives (the legislature) and not (largely politically) appointed judges (the judiciary).

On the face of it, no bad thing.

But you need to take account of the peculiarities of the US system of government. And the deeply political views held on what should be acceptably decided at a federal versus a state level. That without significant interventions from the judiciary, you wouldn't have had advances like the de-segregation of schools.

Contentious issues are very hard to get legislated for at a federal level for a number of reasons (filibuster, super majority etc)

The pro-life lobby has done an exemplary job over the last few years of developing their arguments to appear more reasonable and even progressive. The "it's anti-democratic for SCOTUS to decide" is genius. Guaranteed however they will now shift their significant resources to lobbying at state level to erode abortion laws completely. And their efforts to block voting rights are part of this same strategy.. Limit who can vote so "your guy" always wins... Their end game is total ban and they have the resources to achieve that.

So in some senses you are right. If the decision comes out as currently drafted, then yes pro-choice efforts will have to do the same and go to state level. But it shouldn't have to be that way. Roe V Wade was presented untouchable, settled law. Almost akin to federal law. But it's not.

The alternative is senate has to find a way to legislate federally.. and overcome all the other obstacles out in their way by Republicans to allow that.

Gilead · 05/05/2022 23:10

No, no, no,no. This is not Gilead.

Choopi · 05/05/2022 22:59

Women die when abortion is illegal. I would have died if abortion was illegal. Abortion is necessary health care.

AprilMae · 05/05/2022 22:56

I’ve never seen such a ridiculous post

AprilMae · 05/05/2022 22:56

If you were a pregnant young girl with no money, how would you manage to travel to another state confidentially?

motogirl · 05/05/2022 22:53

The USA is a huge country, allowing states to choose will effectively mean that vast swathes of the centre won't have access, areas with high levels of poverty. Also if parents/ partners don't approve, also in abuse situations you cannot go across 3-4 states unnoticed, it takes a long time especially if you have to go by Greyhound bus, all assuming you have the money. It's bad enough that contraception is often restricted in these states. I lived on the west coast where abortion was available on demand covered by health insurance at the normal drs, quite a difference

BillyNoLates · 05/05/2022 22:48

Yabu no one plans for an abortion. You can't move states 'in case' you'll need one.

DomesticatedZombie · 05/05/2022 22:48

CaptainMyCaptain · 04/05/2022 08:36

You can never ban abortion you can only ban safe, legal abortion.

Yes. Women will die if you ban abortion. For various reasons.

Maybebabyno2 · 05/05/2022 22:43

Kpo58 · 05/05/2022 09:46

Won't banning abortion make rape a very attractive option to some people as the victim won't be able to do anything about it?

Want children, but not to have to raise them yourself? Rape a woman

Want to bankrupt a poor woman? Rape her

Think that women shouldn't be in the workforce? Rape them repeatedly so that they cannot afford childcare to work

Think that there make be a drop in prison population/slave labour? Rape women to make the numbers go back up

Think that there aren't enough babies to adopt/traffic? Rape women

I just don't see how any of this can be seen as ethical.

It absolutely will!

If a woman gets pregnant from rape and then aborts it, the new rules state something like the rapists family can each sue the woman for 20k!

If you wanted to rape someone, the idea you could make some serious cash off it would make it even more appealing. Plus the min prison sentence for abortion is suggested to be 10 years. Rape? 5 years!

Maybebabyno2 · 05/05/2022 22:37

Ahhhh this is what people were talking about on tiktok!

What a load of ol bollocks!

Maybebabyno2 · 05/05/2022 22:34

You can't say 'I'm pro choice, but.....' there should be no limitations. This situation in the states is terrifying, if it goes through it will be a quick slippery slope for women in America which will have serious consequences.

Plus, don't believe for a minute that this won't trickle into the UK too eventually.

HesterAndPearlInBrightSunshine · 05/05/2022 22:29

And it's not just an issue in the US. We should all care:

www.theguardian.com/global-development/2022/may/03/erosion-of-abortion-rights-gathers-pace-around-the-world-as-us-signals-new-era

HelloViroids · 05/05/2022 21:05

I haven’t RTFT because the removal of women’s rights is making me feel sick and I can’t bear reading 13 pages on it. But one thing I hadn’t realised until recently is that obviously American healthcare is not free (at point of service, like the NHS) so people have to pay for abortions - and the later the procedure is performed the more complex and therefore expensive it is. So as a poor woman, if you find your pregnant and start saving for abortion, by the time you’ve saved enough you might be further gone and so need more money…adding the cost of travelling to another state is just going to amplify this already horrific issue.

Shamoo · 05/05/2022 20:57

Don’t be so stupid OP. Seriously.

Actually, are people really this stupid? Or is it just a post intended to inflame?

HesterAndPearlInBrightSunshine · 05/05/2022 18:58

RestingPandaFace · 04/05/2022 08:59

All that will happen is that those states with larger religious influence and right leaning legislatures will ban abortion and those with centrist or left leaning politics will not. Women trapped in right leaning states, which trend towards higher levels of deprivation anyway will be trapped with no means to access out of state healthcare.

If you earn below minimum wage and have no health insurance in Louisiana abortion being legal in California New York or Oregon might as well be the other side of the world.

^^ this

I think many people outside the US don't realise how vastly different individual states are from one another and how many people in fact never leave their home states.

UnCivil · 05/05/2022 18:44

georgarina · 05/05/2022 08:47

And what about when you're miscarrying and haemorrhaging litres of blood and doctors refuse to perform a D&C because there's still a heartbeat so you bleed out? (Happened to my mum, thankfully she was treated.)

What about when you're diagnosed with an ectopic pregnancy and threatened fallopian tube rupture?

What about when you're diagnosed with a septic miscarriage like Savita Halappanavar?

You're going to hop in the car and drive for days to whichever state is nearest to get treatment?

Oh dear lord I remember the Savita Halappanavar story. Utterly heartbreaking. An non viable pregnancy but the mother being allowed to die in what was probably excruciating pain because of confusion about how the law in Ireland related to this case.

loveisanopensore · 05/05/2022 11:05

The problems in Ireland(the Republic) is getting access to a Dr who will prescribe the abortion pill and the ridiculous 3 day waiting period.