Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Is this racist?

582 replies

ToastedWaffle · 03/05/2022 21:51

Okay.... so my ex was over at my house tonight to see our kids (he often does this).

Eldest DC was brushing their teeth whilst the same time trying to ask my ex a question.

Because you couldn't make out the words DC was saying with the toothbrush in their mouth, ex then proceeds to imitate the 'sound' saying something like "wah sah wah ha insert random sound here Are you Chinese or something?"

I've just had my arse handed to me by my ex for pointing out it was casually racist and could he not say things like that.

He has kicked up a massive stink which involved shouting, swearing, in which I asked him to leave. Still, the kids overheard him as he was being deliberately loud in shouting at me.

I'm sat here confused as hell.

OP posts:
vivainsomnia · 05/05/2022 13:39

Some commentators have observed that the "academic-sounding concept of white privilege" sometimes elicits defensiveness and misunderstanding among white people, in part due to how the concept of white privilege was rapidly brought into the mainstream spotlight through social media campaigns such as Black Lives Matter.[17] As an academic concept that was only recently brought into the mainstream, the concept of white privilege is frequently misinterpreted by non-academics; some academics, having studied white privilege undisturbed for decades, have been surprised by the seemingly sudden hostility from right-wing critics since approximately 2014
Quite from Wikipedia.This is exactly the problem. White privilege being an academic term that's been around for a long time now being branded by media fanatics who think it arose recently and think of themselves as the educated one for using in every possible context nowadays.

I will say it again! I have no issue with the social philosophical concept. Its spit on. The way it used to shout 'racist' at white people who dare having a different definition or opinion of racism to them, who shout they only they are right and know the facts (non science academic never refer to their philosophy as facts!), and attack them by implying they lack intelligence are in no interpreting the concept as it was originally developed.

You can keep on insulting and insulting, this is only a reflection of you as a person. So my views are simar to your ex OP (even though I have never made fun of Chinese people or any race and be we would, but ok), so what?

You are different, you don't have the same values, you made the error to build a life with him. That doesn't make you a perfect person and him the evil. You have principles, with different interpretations. That's how the world goes round.

I don't have any issues with anyone views here, I don't appreciate being belittled, my intelligence and values questioned, just because I might not agree with your definition of racism. That does NOT make racist.

Gilead · 05/05/2022 13:14

I read that it is actually illegal for a teacher to use that term as a fact in their teaching.
Not true, try reading in context, it’s tremendously helpful.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 05/05/2022 12:23

@vivainsomnia

Ok, so I was a bit fast and picked the wrong quote and indeed, I'm not prepared to waste 1/2 h or more to troll back to find a real example.

But you are willing to keep posting making the same claim you can't back up.

It's embarrassing.

You've already conceded that it's not 'only ever' used as an insult to white people which is what you claimed.

Now you won't concede that you were lying when you said that's happened on this thread.

When I said earlier you won't face uncomfortable truths you said I was being unfair.

Thanks for proving I wasn't.,;

ToastedWaffle · 05/05/2022 12:02

Indicatrice · 05/05/2022 11:55

@ToastedWaffle

It's not almost gaslighting, it is gaslighting.

Some things @vivainsomnia has said

"time to lighten up!"

"people like you seem to get some innner pleasure at pointing out that others are racist that is really not healthy."

And yet when when privilege is called out, that is 'insulting' and 'belittling' to white people.

Same behaviours exhibited by my ex. Not just about race topic but literally anything you point out to him. Precisely why he is an ex, nobody could put up with this for sustained periods of time.

OP posts:
Indicatrice · 05/05/2022 11:55

@ToastedWaffle

It's not almost gaslighting, it is gaslighting.

Some things @vivainsomnia has said

"time to lighten up!"

"people like you seem to get some innner pleasure at pointing out that others are racist that is really not healthy."

And yet when when privilege is called out, that is 'insulting' and 'belittling' to white people.

ToastedWaffle · 05/05/2022 11:44

It's responses like this that totally undermine your views. How do you expect people to take your views seriously when all you can do is through insults.

This is my ex to a tee. Everything is taken as an insult and from that point he just deflects the conversation. I'm beginning to think it is deliberate.

OP posts:
BewareTheLibrarians · 05/05/2022 11:41

@vivainsomnia teachers also aren’t allowed to say “I support the Conservatives and think everyone should vote for them.”

Does that mean the Conservative party is inherently bad?

ToastedWaffle · 05/05/2022 11:40

vivainsomnia · 05/05/2022 11:14

I wonder how much avlack of understanding is down to a general lack of comprehension, both written and verbal. Genuinely, not being goady
Believe ne, I wish I'd read it more carefully. Certainly wrong choice, but the above poster also believes it is often used as an insult and they are not the only one because it IS often thrown as an insult to belittle someone's view.

I read that it is actually illegal for a teacher to use that term as a fact in their teaching. I wonder why if it indeed only ever used as described here ...because it isn't and indeed isn't an appropriate educational tool. So much for telling strangers to educate themselves!

The irony here is that people who get offended by the term 'white privilege' are the very same people who tell people like me not to go so offended over a racist joke.

"God people are so easily offended these days. They really should lighten up!"

Also: "White privilege is a term used to belittle white people, it's so insulted and I'm affronted".

You couldnt make this up. I feel almost gaslighted. Again my ex uses these techniques and I'm not sure its purposeful or he genuinely lacks comprehension and your arguments @vivainsomnia sound like the same logic. Either way, it's not great.

To add a further point, considering my family on my fathers side are white, I have no vested interest in being racist either intentionally or non intentionally to white people, since surely that would only mean being racist towards myself. I'm half white after all.

To add to that point, I have no interest in being racist at all. I have a vested interest in making people aware of when they are being though.

OP posts:
vivainsomnia · 05/05/2022 11:14

I wonder how much avlack of understanding is down to a general lack of comprehension, both written and verbal. Genuinely, not being goady
Believe ne, I wish I'd read it more carefully. Certainly wrong choice, but the above poster also believes it is often used as an insult and they are not the only one because it IS often thrown as an insult to belittle someone's view.

I read that it is actually illegal for a teacher to use that term as a fact in their teaching. I wonder why if it indeed only ever used as described here ...because it isn't and indeed isn't an appropriate educational tool. So much for telling strangers to educate themselves!

vivainsomnia · 05/05/2022 11:10

Ok, so I was a bit fast and picked the wrong quote and indeed, I'm not prepared to waste 1/2 h or more to troll back to find a real example. It doesn't take away the fact that indeed 'white privilege' is very often - and no, not always- used as an insult.

You're not the sharpest tool in the box are you?
It's responses like this that totally undermine your views. How do you expect people to take your views seriously when all you can do is through insults.

It does exactly the opposite. It makes you come across as aggressive, self-rightful and inconsiderate. Not the type of person I care to listen to and believe.

ToastedWaffle · 05/05/2022 11:00

vivainsomnia · 05/05/2022 08:36

White privilege, get off your high horse, spreading hatred and divide
OP, you don't think the term has been used as an insult on this forum? I only had to go one page back and found this and I know there were more earlier.

It's all good to strongly believe in a cause and accusing others of being blind but you have to be honest and open-minded. Its easy to not see what you don't want to see.

You've completely misinterpreted that quote. It was meant for someone else and was a dig at how white privilege isn't a thing.

I wonder how much avlack of understanding is down to a general lack of comprehension, both written and verbal. Genuinely, not being goady.

OP posts:
stopthepain · 05/05/2022 10:55

@Lunar27 I didn’t see your Centre Parcs story but that’s horrible, but not surprising. Children are racist and abusive because their parents are their “role models.”

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 05/05/2022 10:48

I think that "white privilege"is a bit like "toxic masculinity". Both are pithy terms which are very useful for identifying a particular type of societal poison. They're both very helpful terms to use for people on the pointy end of things (and both, I think, coined by people on that pointy end?), and can, if understood properly, be helpful to people in the groups being centred by the term too (white people, men). But both terms have the potential to be misunderstood (or deliberately misunderstood) as an insult, and can provoke a defensive response. It would be better if white people and men could push past that instinctive defensiveness to understand what the terms are intended to mean, but these are groups that are not used to being challenged in this way.

I had a very similar discussion to this
"white privilege" one with my male DP about "toxic masculinity", and we agreed that while the intended meaning of something like "a societal idea of what constitutes masculinity that does harm to both women and men" is fine, what comes across to a bloke who hasn't heard the term before can be something like "men are toxic, masculinity is bad, I'm being criticised for something I can't help".

I tend not to use "toxic masculinity" around men who aren't already versed in the non-accusatory meaning of it because starting out by getting people's backs up is a difficult place to move on from towards a productive discussion. However, those using the term "white privilege" may well have different strategies in mind, or not feel like treating white people with kid gloves in this way all the time, or whatever, which I can understand.

OneTC · 05/05/2022 09:43

I should have known even that would be argued. I'm not going to go back 21 pages. It is regularly used on MN as an insult to white people

You find the concept of it insulting to you, for some reason, therefore it sounds like an insult. It is used to pull people up on a train of thought. It is not in itself an insult.

You just don't like having your own intentions or perceptions questioned

OneTC · 05/05/2022 09:39

OP, you don't think the term has been used as an insult on this forum? I only had to go one page back and found this and I know there were more earlier.

You're not the sharpest tool in the box are you?

youvegottenminuteslynn · 05/05/2022 09:25

vivainsomnia · 05/05/2022 09:12

You'll need to try to find another example of 'white privileged ' being used as an insult towards white people / being used in a derogatory way to white people on this thread, which is how you claim the phrase is only ever used...
I should have known even that would be argued. I'm not going to go back 21 pages. It is regularly used on MN as an insult to white people. Mind you, that's the only place I've ever heard it and it is because it is used for that purpose mainly that I, like many, misunderstood what it truly means.

You might not use it in that context, but many many do.

So you claim white privilege is 'only ever' used to insult white people, including on this thread.

Then you're asked to provide an example.

The example you provide is in fact someone using the term in a post insulting a person who uses the term in a non derogatory way (which you concede is true).

Then when confronted with the fact you got it so wrong... you now can't be arsed to back up your false statement. Got it.

vivainsomnia · 05/05/2022 09:12

You'll need to try to find another example of 'white privileged ' being used as an insult towards white people / being used in a derogatory way to white people on this thread, which is how you claim the phrase is only ever used...
I should have known even that would be argued. I'm not going to go back 21 pages. It is regularly used on MN as an insult to white people. Mind you, that's the only place I've ever heard it and it is because it is used for that purpose mainly that I, like many, misunderstood what it truly means.

You might not use it in that context, but many many do.

Indicatrice · 05/05/2022 09:02

vivainsomnia · 05/05/2022 08:36

White privilege, get off your high horse, spreading hatred and divide
OP, you don't think the term has been used as an insult on this forum? I only had to go one page back and found this and I know there were more earlier.

It's all good to strongly believe in a cause and accusing others of being blind but you have to be honest and open-minded. Its easy to not see what you don't want to see.

This is hilarious 😂

That poster was insulting those who believe white privilege exists.

Yet more proof that those who refuse to acknowledge racism (I.e. you) just don’t even bother reading.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 05/05/2022 08:53

vivainsomnia · 05/05/2022 08:36

White privilege, get off your high horse, spreading hatred and divide
OP, you don't think the term has been used as an insult on this forum? I only had to go one page back and found this and I know there were more earlier.

It's all good to strongly believe in a cause and accusing others of being blind but you have to be honest and open-minded. Its easy to not see what you don't want to see.

That poster was talking to me, someone who does use the term in a non derogatory way.

They used it to insult in a sentence insulting someone who uses the term (me)... so it's clearly not an example of people who believe in the concept of white privilege using it as an insult to white people.

You'll need to try to find another example of 'white privileged ' being used as an insult towards white people / being used in a derogatory way to white people on this thread, which is how you claim the phrase is only ever used...

Lunar27 · 05/05/2022 08:48

@stopthepain

I'm not sure if you read my experience at Center Parcs earlier but I had a kid making these stupid garbled Chinese sounds while his father stood right next to him. He did nothing at all.

If people can't equate a father in a bathroom, actively making the same garbled BS with my experience, it's not really worth engaging. Many people here can, irrespective of their skin colour, but a small minority will continue to deny as it's their purpose to argue the toss.

It all starts with parents doing seemingly 'innocent' things like this and kids then learn that it's ok to make stupid noises. Obviously because it's not racist 🤦 it's then ok for that same father to just stand there, while their kid racially abuses some random Chinese guy at a holiday resort.

vivainsomnia · 05/05/2022 08:42

These days I'm mostly alienating my very wealthy/ middle aged acquaintances by not letting things lie
And yet these are the ones who would need 'educating' as it's been called here. Your approach is not working.

Anger, insults, accusations, undermining, is really not the way to get people to listen. It has the exact opposite effect.

vivainsomnia · 05/05/2022 08:36

White privilege, get off your high horse, spreading hatred and divide
OP, you don't think the term has been used as an insult on this forum? I only had to go one page back and found this and I know there were more earlier.

It's all good to strongly believe in a cause and accusing others of being blind but you have to be honest and open-minded. Its easy to not see what you don't want to see.

stopthepain · 05/05/2022 08:08

worriedatthistime · 04/05/2022 14:29

@Discovereads exactly and a chinese person has said they wouldn't be offended also yet everyone is offended for them anyway ?
Not a clever comment and a simple don't speak with your mouth full as I can't understand you would be better

I’d compare that to when women are like “I’m not like other girls” and laugh at misogyny. Or people saying “I can say that because my friend is black.” I’m British Chinese and the racism starts with children mocking the Chinese language (as though we’re uncivilised), then the eye pulling, then the explicit racist phrases and words, and then the physical abuse.

I applaud OP for telling her dc that racism is not ok. It’s shocking (but not surprising) that so many people in this thread think racism against East Asians is ok.

lborgia · 05/05/2022 04:36

@Indicatrice - does it matter? Surely you're either supportive, or your not?

Or do you think "they've taken it too far", because now it's finally getting pretty difficult to ignore, and they should just be grateful to have got this far, and stay in their lane?

I've shut down racist larks at a bbq, and now we don't get invited to dh's friends anymore. I'm just SO rude! Apparently.

I've worked on election campaigns as a volunteer and got someone asking me what's it got to do with me by a white constituent, when I was supporting a Labour candidate who happened to be a POC (so that's on the street and politics - full house there!).

I'm not sure if your interest is for anecdotes or theory. Problem is, I'm very bad at keeping my mouth shut, so my theory ends up being practice.

What I don't want, is to imply that "these poor people need my help". More that i'd like to do whatever is helpful. These days I'm mostly alienating my very wealthy/ middle aged acquaintances by not letting things lie. It can be racism, sexism, most of the isms. It's amazing what crap people come out with when they think you're one of them.

Thanks to others who replied, I think I misunderstood the first post. It actually meant patronising middle class racists saying something's not racist. Not white middle class people agreeing it's racist, and trying to shout down the minimisers Grin

Gilead · 05/05/2022 02:33

Meh. I wouldnt consider it racism.
Him screaming is wrong though

wrong.
try again.

Swipe left for the next trending thread