Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Is this racist?

582 replies

ToastedWaffle · 03/05/2022 21:51

Okay.... so my ex was over at my house tonight to see our kids (he often does this).

Eldest DC was brushing their teeth whilst the same time trying to ask my ex a question.

Because you couldn't make out the words DC was saying with the toothbrush in their mouth, ex then proceeds to imitate the 'sound' saying something like "wah sah wah ha insert random sound here Are you Chinese or something?"

I've just had my arse handed to me by my ex for pointing out it was casually racist and could he not say things like that.

He has kicked up a massive stink which involved shouting, swearing, in which I asked him to leave. Still, the kids overheard him as he was being deliberately loud in shouting at me.

I'm sat here confused as hell.

OP posts:
Indicatrice · 04/05/2022 13:50

vivainsomnia · 04/05/2022 13:41

I explained a concept and gave some examples
The problem is that tou started talking about the concept of white privilege as a whole.

That I totally agree with you. If you could.pare races, whites without a doubt have it and always had it better.

When it goes wrong in my view os when this is then applied on individual basis as you've had with your examples especially when not taking into consideration personal circumstances.

The whole is not the accumulation of all. That's not as evidence is based. Just as science has evidenced that breasfed babies have better health outcomes than bottlefed ones, doesn't mean all breasfed babies are healthier than bottledfed ones. That's not how factual interpretation works.

Being aware of ones' privilege as a race doesn't make that person more privileged as an individual.

How did Beware apply it on an individual basis? She's been arguing the opposite.

I honestly think you and some others are just bashing the keyboard without any logic at this point.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 04/05/2022 13:49

vivainsomnia · 04/05/2022 13:41

I explained a concept and gave some examples
The problem is that tou started talking about the concept of white privilege as a whole.

That I totally agree with you. If you could.pare races, whites without a doubt have it and always had it better.

When it goes wrong in my view os when this is then applied on individual basis as you've had with your examples especially when not taking into consideration personal circumstances.

The whole is not the accumulation of all. That's not as evidence is based. Just as science has evidenced that breasfed babies have better health outcomes than bottlefed ones, doesn't mean all breasfed babies are healthier than bottledfed ones. That's not how factual interpretation works.

Being aware of ones' privilege as a race doesn't make that person more privileged as an individual.

When it goes wrong in my view os when this is then applied on individual basis as you've had with your examples especially when not taking into consideration personal circumstances.

I genuinely don't think you're reading my posts properly.

I said when all else is equal, being white means someone hasn't also had to deal with racism on top of everything else.

Being white doesn't mean someone's life has been easy, it means their skin colour isn't one of the things that's made it harder. That's white privilege.

I'm confused as to why you're either unwilling or unable to recognise the validity of white privilege as a concept and don't understand why. as you seem to agree that when all else is equal white people don't have to tackle racism at a systemic level on top of anything else they're going through... which is the meaning of white privilege!

Binkybix · 04/05/2022 13:48

I would be mortified if my kids did this to someone in the playground (and we live in a country where white people are the minority).

Im sorry that racist hate speech happened to your DH, but surely you can understand that the two situations- OPs and your DHs are worlds apart and to compare them is in my opinion, a false equivalence?

Where do you think the adults who were doing this learnt it in the first place? I really don’t think they are worlds apart at all.

TheOldRazzleDazzle · 04/05/2022 13:48

It’s not picking and choosing, though, @vivainsomnia. Its looking at power structures, historic and present. It’s about whether your joke or stereotype is punching up or down - or across, in the case of Anglo-French relations.

You can only view the things you’ve mentioned in your posts as equally harmful / innocuous if you refuse to consider the context around them. In real life, context is everything.

BewareTheLibrarians · 04/05/2022 13:45

@Fieldsofdaffodils likewise, thanks for not tagging me.

Again, where in my posts have I mentioned white people? Did I say Asian people/East Asian people attacked by white people, or did you misread that/make it up? Did I mention what racial group my husband was harassed by? Have the courtesy to go back and check and stop making things up. It’s weird.

OneTC · 04/05/2022 13:45

you mention you can give numerous egs of asians being attacked by white people, what's your point other than implying the white race is more violent?

in guessing they mean it's statistically more relevant. Which is true. Not that white people are more violent.

I do think though, that in the realm of violent attacks, that power balances are temporarily suspended.

This also has little to do with a thread about a racist comment and the general attitude towards racism directed at Chinese people

vivainsomnia · 04/05/2022 13:41

I explained a concept and gave some examples
The problem is that tou started talking about the concept of white privilege as a whole.

That I totally agree with you. If you could.pare races, whites without a doubt have it and always had it better.

When it goes wrong in my view os when this is then applied on individual basis as you've had with your examples especially when not taking into consideration personal circumstances.

The whole is not the accumulation of all. That's not as evidence is based. Just as science has evidenced that breasfed babies have better health outcomes than bottlefed ones, doesn't mean all breasfed babies are healthier than bottledfed ones. That's not how factual interpretation works.

Being aware of ones' privilege as a race doesn't make that person more privileged as an individual.

Fieldsofdaffodils · 04/05/2022 13:39

I think the term " brown people " is what I have issue with as it is a silly phrase I haven't used.... so much for @BewareTheLibrarians not replying.

@BewareTheLibrarians you mention you can give numerous egs of asians being attacked by white people, what's your point other than implying the white race is more violent? Have you actually studied uk crime statistics or just under the misguided impression white people are vile characters purely targeting that 1 racial demographic? I don't really care what race anyone is, but you seem to be under the impression racial hatred is only one way- educate yourself and you may be in for a shock when looking at crime statistics in all areas per capita of the population.

BewareTheLibrarians · 04/05/2022 13:33

Ok @Fieldsofdaffodils But I didn’t directly quote your words. That’s very clear to anyone who read your posts. Did you perhaps think the quotation marks meant I was directly quoting your words (that didn’t exist) rather than paraphrasing? I do apologise though for the quotation marks if it wasn’t clear. Can you explain though why you raised that example if it wasn’t to show that brown people do bad things too?

And if we’re going for accuracy here, can you please find exactly where I referenced “white people” in either of my posts and then give me an apology for your previous rant?

OneTC · 04/05/2022 13:33

Fieldsofdaffodils · 04/05/2022 13:25

In future it's probably best not to ascribe offensive terminology in quotes to a poster who hasn't actually said it in the failed attempt to discredit them on a public forum. It's poor form and disingenuous.

There is nothing ridiculous in asking you to produce crime statistics backing up your claims or implied ones- you're just ranting. Racism is deplorable but exists on both sides of the racial divide yet frequently it only gets called out when it is one way

There's nothing offensive about saying brown people do bad things too

And you did just actually point out the obvious truth that brown people do bad things too

vivainsomnia · 04/05/2022 13:27

The use of ONE phrase, which comes from a time when the French were the enemy, had not resulted in their wholesale downfall. Unlike the behaviour towards black, Asian, south East
This really shows the unconscious bias that goes with discrimination. You are using history to justify it, talking about wholesale downfall. That's a typical British perception of it.

Most French will have no idea where this saying comes from, whether it's 400 years old or not. Most French people will certainly not associated it with the economy. Why should they. They will interpret it that they are seen as coming from a vulgar culture.

And yes, the French Most like have their ways to make fun of the Brits. I expect all nations do, all have their own stereotypes of other nations.

Either we accept it all together as part of life, culture etc...or we all practice what we preach without excuses. You don't pick and choose what is racist, offensive and decide that the e pressiontou use are mot when others might very much think that are.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 04/05/2022 13:26

@mustlovegin

Would you say that male privilege doesn't exist just because some companies choose to use positive discrimination or seek out female candidates in order to have a diverse and representative board / employees?

The gender pay gap still exists but some men are paid less than women. Male privilege still exists systemically in society.

Women are still more likely to suffer sexual violence than men but some men are sexually assaulted. Male privilege still exists systemically in society.

Recognising male privilege doesn't mean all men have an easy life, are better off than all women and never have any struggles. The same is true of recognising white privilege.

Fieldsofdaffodils · 04/05/2022 13:26

sorry double post

Fieldsofdaffodils · 04/05/2022 13:25

BewareTheLibrarians · 04/05/2022 13:19

@Fieldsofdaffodils
Yes, it was were you said “presumably you would agree this was also racist and vile?” Otherwise what was the point of raising that example?

Not even going to respond to the rest of your post. You accused me of attributing something to you that you didn’t say, then have gone on to attribute lots of things I didn’t say to me. That’s hypocritical, and I have absolutely no interest in getting involved in that kind of ridiculous “argument” so no need to keep @ ing me.

In future it's probably best not to ascribe offensive terminology in quotes to a poster who hasn't actually said it in the failed attempt to discredit them on a public forum. It's poor form and disingenuous.

There is nothing ridiculous in asking you to produce crime statistics backing up your claims or implied ones- you're just ranting. Racism is deplorable but exists on both sides of the racial divide yet frequently it only gets called out when it is one way

Butteryflakycrust83 · 04/05/2022 13:25

mustlovegin · 04/05/2022 13:14

White privilege = when all else is equal, a privilege exists when one is white

Would you say there's still 'white privilege' in 2022 when positive discrimination is rife in so many industries? (e.g. advertising, films, TV, government organisations, etc). Both in relation to hiring and also general attitudes.

Yes. Absolutely.

Fieldsofdaffodils · 04/05/2022 13:25

BewareTheLibrarians · 04/05/2022 13:19

@Fieldsofdaffodils
Yes, it was were you said “presumably you would agree this was also racist and vile?” Otherwise what was the point of raising that example?

Not even going to respond to the rest of your post. You accused me of attributing something to you that you didn’t say, then have gone on to attribute lots of things I didn’t say to me. That’s hypocritical, and I have absolutely no interest in getting involved in that kind of ridiculous “argument” so no need to keep @ ing me.

In future it's probably best not to ascribe offensive terminology in quotes to a poster who hasn't actually said it in the failed attempt to discredit them on a public forum. It's poor form and disingenuous.

There is nothing ridiculous in asking you to produce crime statistics backing up your claims or implied ones- you're just ranting. Racism is deplorable but exists on both sides of the racial divide yet frequently it only gets called out when it is one way

youvegottenminuteslynn · 04/05/2022 13:23

mustlovegin · 04/05/2022 13:14

White privilege = when all else is equal, a privilege exists when one is white

Would you say there's still 'white privilege' in 2022 when positive discrimination is rife in so many industries? (e.g. advertising, films, TV, government organisations, etc). Both in relation to hiring and also general attitudes.

Yes, I would absolutely say it still exists systemically in society as whole. 100%.

Because again, it doesn't mean white people don't ever face disadvantages.

I don't know how much more clearly I can explain the concept to you...

TalkingCat · 04/05/2022 13:20

vivainsomnia · 04/05/2022 13:10

Ah ok, so calling people conceited and self-centred is great debating? OK
Yes, people in general, not you specifically, not anyone here specifically.

And no, my posts were nowhere as condescending as yours and Talkingcat.

Er, yes, your posts were far more condescending than mine. At least don't lie. Even if you still choose to humiliate yourself on here.

BewareTheLibrarians · 04/05/2022 13:19

@Fieldsofdaffodils
Yes, it was were you said “presumably you would agree this was also racist and vile?” Otherwise what was the point of raising that example?

Not even going to respond to the rest of your post. You accused me of attributing something to you that you didn’t say, then have gone on to attribute lots of things I didn’t say to me. That’s hypocritical, and I have absolutely no interest in getting involved in that kind of ridiculous “argument” so no need to keep @ ing me.

vivainsomnia · 04/05/2022 13:17

Each country has derogatory stereotypes about the other. If there have been times ‘we’ have looked down on the French, there have also been periods that we have looked up to them. Speaking French has traditionally been viewed as a sign of being well educated, and French literature, fashion and food are esteemed
Oh I see. So if the Chinese have derogatory terms against the Bruts which might very well do then its OK to use derogatory terms about them too!

Because the French and British have 'history it makes it OK? If the French are viewed as well educated, why use that expression in the first place.

The reason why most French are not offended is because their culture is much less sensitive than ours. They can make fun of themselves without shouting 'discrimination'. Nit because uts any less offensive in its nearing.

Personally, I'd rather be insulted by imting I'm funny rather than vulgar.

mustlovegin · 04/05/2022 13:14

White privilege = when all else is equal, a privilege exists when one is white

Would you say there's still 'white privilege' in 2022 when positive discrimination is rife in so many industries? (e.g. advertising, films, TV, government organisations, etc). Both in relation to hiring and also general attitudes.

MrsH1983 · 04/05/2022 13:13

Some people think it was racist and that's fine. Others have a different perception and don't think a comment like that is racist and that's fine too. We are all entitled to our own perception and viewpoint and just because some of us don't think that this scenario reaches the threshold to be considered "racist" does not mean those people themselves are racist.

vivainsomnia · 04/05/2022 13:10

Ah ok, so calling people conceited and self-centred is great debating? OK
Yes, people in general, not you specifically, not anyone here specifically.

And no, my posts were nowhere as condescending as yours and Talkingcat.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 04/05/2022 13:09

mustlovegin · 04/05/2022 13:06

youvegottenminuteslynn

That is not to say that white person hasn't had a hard life but the specific experience of not having to experience racism / race related issues IS white privilege

How can you give such a convoluted pseudo lecture to a poster who has said that her family member has been attacked and had a brain haemorrhage for being white?

Please listen to yourselves, it's shocking!

A convoluted pseudo lecture?

I explained a concept and gave some examples.

I hardly dressed it up as a Ted Talk mate.

Nobody should ever be bullied, assaulted, abused or victimised. Ever.

My point is, the concept of white privilege doesn't claim those things don't happen to white people. It doesn't claim that when they do happen to white people, it matters less than if it happens to non white people. It simply describes the fact (and it is a fact) that white people don't ALSO have to deal with specific issues faced by non white people on top of whatever else happens to them.

Tsuni · 04/05/2022 13:09

You knew it was racist before you posted. What's your AIBU?