Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Is this racist?

582 replies

ToastedWaffle · 03/05/2022 21:51

Okay.... so my ex was over at my house tonight to see our kids (he often does this).

Eldest DC was brushing their teeth whilst the same time trying to ask my ex a question.

Because you couldn't make out the words DC was saying with the toothbrush in their mouth, ex then proceeds to imitate the 'sound' saying something like "wah sah wah ha insert random sound here Are you Chinese or something?"

I've just had my arse handed to me by my ex for pointing out it was casually racist and could he not say things like that.

He has kicked up a massive stink which involved shouting, swearing, in which I asked him to leave. Still, the kids overheard him as he was being deliberately loud in shouting at me.

I'm sat here confused as hell.

OP posts:
TheOldRazzleDazzle · 04/05/2022 14:18

Again, if you say this to a French person, and they tell you they find it very offensive, would you apologise -so admit it was wrong to say it- or are you going to give them a lecture that context is everything, that it's part of history and therefore they are wrong to be offended?

Yes, if I offended someone I’d apologise, I’d refrain from saying it again to them and I wouldn’t be lecturing anyone. I don’t want to upset people. However, if their offence really was just a response to me saying ‘pardon my French’ I’d not be admitting it was wrong. Because I think it’s difficult to make a sensible case for it being something to be reasonably offended by.

Let me be clear - I think your offended French person is purely fictional. I don’t think any rational French person is offended by this. I think it’s actually absurd that you’re typing out a scenario where a French person finds the phrase pardon my French ‘very offensive’.

You must know this is ridiculous.

You may as well draw a false equivalence between outright racist slurs and causing someone mortal offence by saying their favourite band or football team is crap. We all know some people take things like that very personally - it’s not reasonable or on a par with racism though, is it?

Is evidencing the context more important than how the person feels about our behaviour?

Not sure it’s about evidencing anything. I’m saying context dictates why it’s reasonable to treat offence at some things as more serious than others.

Lunar27 · 04/05/2022 14:18

In this context, acknowledging white privilege accomishes what?

Change your attitude perhaps?

I was talking to a policeman recently who openly complained about the inconvenience caused by Sarah Everard. I couldn't quite believe my ears.

He was describing how police (on call) now have to pass a woman a phone so they can call a centre to tell them who the male officer is and their location. What a rigmarole he said.

I relayed this disturbing encounter with a female friend about a week later, having had ample opportunity to advise her of this change in procedure before but it not really registering.

I think there are two instances of male privilege there. One clear and another less so but two instances nonetheless.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 04/05/2022 14:15

mustlovegin · 04/05/2022 14:06

I note you didn't address my question re male privilege and whether you think that just because some women are paid more than men or some companies specifically want to have more women on their board, that means male privilege no longer exists?

No, I will not answer you question because we are discussing race, not sex on this thread. Also how do you know that my answer will be what you want to hear?

I don't! I don't know what your answer will be and I don't 'hope' it will be anything, I just asked a question as I was interested in your answer and this is a discussion forum. Obviously you don't have to answer.

This is a forum, conversations and discussions develop and analogies / other applications of a similar theory can be a useful way of understanding each other's points of view.

You don't have the authority to tell people they have to stick to a certain topic when they ask a question. You have the right not to answer it but to it's silly to say other people can't reference any other relevant concepts when talking about other examples of discrimination / privilege.

vivainsomnia · 04/05/2022 14:12

So if a uni specifically looks to engage young women to study STEM subjects, or was to offer a grant specifically to a number of female students each year, you think that's wrong unless there is also a recruitment drive for young men specifically and the exact same number of scholarships are offered to males?
Again, when you discuss the issue of jalrs domination in these jobs, it's a very good initiative.

When your son, who has worked very hard at his local comp, managed 3 A* when the average is a C, has work e patience etc...gets turn down to allow your neighbour girl, going to private school, getting Bs, no work experience to have the one place left, then yes, there is certainly an element of injustice.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 04/05/2022 14:11

vivainsomnia · 04/05/2022 14:05

My examples were literally if the elderly woman was the same person but not white, she would have faced all the same hardships AND racism in her life. And that if I was the same child I was in care but hadn't been white, I would have faced all the same hardships AND racism in my life
But that's not forcibly true though. Not everyone not white faces racism as individuals. That's my point.

Even if we assume that these people did, that doesn't forcing mean they had it worse than the other. They might have faced some racism but stayed with nicer, more caring foster families than the white kid who has never faced racism but was unlucky and stayed with horrible families. The latter might have ended up much more traumatised by the system. Its not fair to make assumptions on individuals just because of statistics.

You're saying the same things as me but acting as if you're arguing something different to me... it's utterly bizarre at this point!

You seem determined to argue but you're agreeing with my points and I'm glad you have now said you accept the definition of white privilege I shared earlier and that you just don't understand how defining it helps anyone.

I'm not sure what else I can say to you really as I can't see how you're engaging in good faith.

mustlovegin · 04/05/2022 14:10

Equity is important

What is Equity in your view and how do you go about achieving it?

Fieldsofdaffodils · 04/05/2022 14:08

I'd love to be the metaphorical fly on the wall in an interview room when a virtue signaler about positive discrimination who could be a hard working white woman with debts and kids is told " well you are the best candidate but sorry we can't hire you because you're white".

Using skin tone to hire regardless of supposed moral agendas is disgusting for the alleged "greater good"

mustlovegin · 04/05/2022 14:08

I understand someone has explained the theory of the term of which I fully understand but this still does not detract from it being offensive and racist to some people

Yes, but they will shout you down because you are not allowed to engage your brain and exercise any critical thinking apparently

mustlovegin · 04/05/2022 14:06

I note you didn't address my question re male privilege and whether you think that just because some women are paid more than men or some companies specifically want to have more women on their board, that means male privilege no longer exists?

No, I will not answer you question because we are discussing race, not sex on this thread. Also how do you know that my answer will be what you want to hear?

MrsH1983 · 04/05/2022 14:06

MrsH1983 · 04/05/2022 14:05

Someone earlier in the thread stated that something is racist if the person perceived it to be racist. Based upon that reasoning, I find the term "who're privilege" to be racist. I understand someone has explained the theory of the term of which I fully understand but this still does not detract from it being offensive and racist to some people.

That meant to say "white privilege". Phone autocorrect.

vivainsomnia · 04/05/2022 14:05

My examples were literally if the elderly woman was the same person but not white, she would have faced all the same hardships AND racism in her life. And that if I was the same child I was in care but hadn't been white, I would have faced all the same hardships AND racism in my life
But that's not forcibly true though. Not everyone not white faces racism as individuals. That's my point.

Even if we assume that these people did, that doesn't forcing mean they had it worse than the other. They might have faced some racism but stayed with nicer, more caring foster families than the white kid who has never faced racism but was unlucky and stayed with horrible families. The latter might have ended up much more traumatised by the system. Its not fair to make assumptions on individuals just because of statistics.

MrsH1983 · 04/05/2022 14:05

Someone earlier in the thread stated that something is racist if the person perceived it to be racist. Based upon that reasoning, I find the term "who're privilege" to be racist. I understand someone has explained the theory of the term of which I fully understand but this still does not detract from it being offensive and racist to some people.

Katya213 · 04/05/2022 14:05

TheOldRazzleDazzle · 04/05/2022 11:36

@vivainsomnia - one taps into a long-standing cruel stereotype of funny-looking, funny-sounding people that has been used to dehumanise and other. The others do not.

Any characteristic could be used to bully or upset - someone could laugh at my taste in music or poke fun at how I look, for example, and depending on the circumstances this could be very upsetting - but not all characteristics link back to systematic oppression and prejudice on the societal level.

@Katya213 - if you’re talking about white people, I am one. I expect this makes me a virtue signaller.

nah, more of a do gooder wanting a bit of praise.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 04/05/2022 14:03

Either we are all equal or we aren't

This is such an incredibly simplistic way of thinking. Bafflingly so. Equity is important. Opportunity is important.

If there was never a push for girls and women in STEM, there would be (even) fewer females represented in STEM.

So if a uni specifically looks to engage young women to study STEM subjects, or was to offer a grant specifically to a number of female students each year, you think that's wrong unless there is also a recruitment drive for young men specifically and the exact same number of scholarships are offered to males?

mustlovegin · 04/05/2022 14:02

My examples were literally if the elderly woman was the same person but not white, she would have faced all the same hardships AND racism in her life

The elderly, poor white woman would have experienced hardship AND racism in other places as well (maybe China or Africa?). Why are you ignoring this?

Going about shouting 'white privilege' as a mantra without any context or time references makes no sense

Fieldsofdaffodils · 04/05/2022 14:02

Regardless of legality, positive discrimination stopping people applying for jobs purely for being white or male is disgusting and both sexist/ racist. You don't replace one set of discrimination issues with another.

Foxglovers · 04/05/2022 14:01

I can’t believe posters are saying this isn’t racist!!! It’s extremely racist and I would be furious

vivainsomnia · 04/05/2022 14:01

Its looking at power structures, historic and present. It’s about whether your joke or stereotype is punching up or down - or across, in the case of Anglo-French relations
Again, if you say this to a French person, and they tell you they find it very offensive, would you apologise -so admit it was wrong to say it- or are you going to give them a lecture that context is everything, that it's part of history and therefore they are wrong to be offended?

Is evidencing the context more important than how the person feels about our behaviour?

Being white doesn't mean someone's life has been easy, it means their skin colour isn't one of the things that's made it harder. That's white privilege
OK, happy with that, but then so what? It sounds like saying to someone who is struggling to get a job, worried about feeding their kids and being told 'well at least you're white, so consider yourself lucky, if you were black, it would be much worse.

In this context, acknowledging white privilege accomishes what? Does it make it any easier for a black person?

I'm much more outcome focus than concept minded. I much rather fight to ensure that anyone has a fair chance to be offered a job based on their ability to carry out the job than going in about the fact that a white person hasn't got it harder because they are white.

Fieldsofdaffodils · 04/05/2022 14:00

Indicatrice · 04/05/2022 13:53

Racism occurs in all countries , you have stated you can give numerous egs of asians being attacked... Ive no doubt you could but what's your point? The problem isn't white people/ black people or the Uk but the human race in general which has vile individuals in it living worldwide.

Well, what was your point with giving an example of Asians attacking a white man?

It wasn't an eg, it was a fact illustrating how absurd some of the comments in the thread of for eg

" If you think it isn't racist you must be white ".

" Who are you to say you’re not offended? You’re not Chinese or even East Asian! Fuck off! Oh, and most children who get shit English grades are white."

"I'm not east asian, yet I can feel every word in your post. Most white people never have to endure this so find it hard to understand what it is like."

"The media kept hush hush about the dramatic increase in racial attacks against East Asians during the past couple of years.

"French isn't a race. They are also anglo saxon. Not African, Asian or Middle Eastern. So your false equivalence doesn't even pass the first hurdle.

And don't dare tell a non-white person to lighten up"

youvegottenminuteslynn · 04/05/2022 14:00

mustlovegin · 04/05/2022 13:54

youvegottenminuteslynn

Look, I think you need to stop going by political rhetoric and try and form a more critical and up-to-date view of what's happening in the UK in 2022.

'white-privilege' as a concept is at worst flawed and at best lacking geographical and situational context and outdated.

Also I hold very little intellectual regard for those who have no objection to positive discrimination. Either we are all equal or we aren't

Positive discrimination is illegal. Positive action is legal. If positive action was never used, women and minorities would be under represented on an even wider level than they already are. I hold little regard for people comfortable with that.

Also you don't seem to understand the difference between equality and equity. I note you didn't address my question re male privilege and whether you think that just because some women are paid more than men or some companies specifically want to have more women on their board, that means male privilege no longer exists?

youvegottenminuteslynn · 04/05/2022 13:55

When it goes wrong in my view os when this is then applied on individual basis as you've had with your examples especially when not taking into consideration personal circumstances.

My examples were literally if the elderly woman was the same person but not white, she would have faced all the same hardships AND racism in her life. And that if I was the same child I was in care but hadn't been white, I would have faced all the same hardships AND racism in my life.

I've done the exact opposite of what you've claimed and said if the personal circumstances WERE exactly the same and only race was different, absence of white privilege would have meant the person had to deal with all the same hardships AND racism on top.

You either didn't read my posts properly or are being wilfully disingenuous in misrepresenting what I've said.

mustlovegin · 04/05/2022 13:54

youvegottenminuteslynn

Look, I think you need to stop going by political rhetoric and try and form a more critical and up-to-date view of what's happening in the UK in 2022.

'white-privilege' as a concept is at worst flawed and at best lacking geographical and situational context and outdated.

Also I hold very little intellectual regard for those who have no objection to positive discrimination. Either we are all equal or we aren't

Indicatrice · 04/05/2022 13:53

Racism occurs in all countries , you have stated you can give numerous egs of asians being attacked... Ive no doubt you could but what's your point? The problem isn't white people/ black people or the Uk but the human race in general which has vile individuals in it living worldwide.

Well, what was your point with giving an example of Asians attacking a white man?

Fieldsofdaffodils · 04/05/2022 13:51

BewareTheLibrarians · 04/05/2022 13:45

@Fieldsofdaffodils likewise, thanks for not tagging me.

Again, where in my posts have I mentioned white people? Did I say Asian people/East Asian people attacked by white people, or did you misread that/make it up? Did I mention what racial group my husband was harassed by? Have the courtesy to go back and check and stop making things up. It’s weird.

Racism occurs in all countries , you have stated you can give numerous egs of asians being attacked... Ive no doubt you could but what's your point? The problem isn't white people/ black people or the Uk but the human race in general which has vile individuals in it living worldwide. The idea that the Uk is a disproportionately racist country when compared to other countries is ridiculous- how do you think for eg a small number of white Christians would get on living in various African/ middle eastern countries? I suppose it would be all peaches and cream with them wandering the streets in complete safety

Indicatrice · 04/05/2022 13:51

I mean @youvegottenminuteslynn not Beware