Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DS Bullied By Child with SEN

446 replies

ellie21 · 03/05/2022 21:11

My son who is at a mainstream Primary School is being bullied by another child who is undergoing assessment for ADD.
Initially this was low level bullying ( name calling etc) but has developed into threats of violence. In the last two weeks he has been physically assaulted three times by this child. The school have confirmed that this is one sided and is happening to other students too.
I have been into school a number of times to talk to staff and whereas they are sympathetic they say they have a duty of care to the child with SEN as he is struggling to cope at school.
AIBU to think that this is separate issue? I am absolutely furious my child is being hurt.

OP posts:
Stabbitystabstab · 04/05/2022 07:40

Everydayisabadhairday · 04/05/2022 07:19

Bullying is about the victims perception, not the bully's.

Her child perceived that they got thumped?
Hmmm
How does that work?

Morph22010 · 04/05/2022 07:36

drspouse · 04/05/2022 07:29

And if the only choices of schools to move to were schools where my child would be terrified of the other pupils (and hence more aggressive), and likely to be assaulted by them?
I have looked at such a school for my DS yesterday. We are told he needs an SEMH school but they are all like this.

The police won't "keep a record" for a child under 10, unlikely for any primary school child.

Have you looked at all schools in your local area including specialist independents? It is very variable by area unfortunately. Does he have asd as I’ve found the asd schools seem better suited than semh. But I definately accepted your point I know of a violent autistic 5 year old girl who got put in a unit with teenagers and got beat up on first day by much older children then had to be locked in a room on her own every day for safety . Obviously those children also had sen but it was not the the right placement

drspouse · 04/05/2022 07:29

TyrannosaurusRegina · 03/05/2022 21:27

Personally I'd be taking my kid out of school if they persisted in bullying and physically assaulting other children and look into a school more suited to their needs. It would break my heart to know that other children were going into school terrified and being hit at the hands of my child.

And if the only choices of schools to move to were schools where my child would be terrified of the other pupils (and hence more aggressive), and likely to be assaulted by them?
I have looked at such a school for my DS yesterday. We are told he needs an SEMH school but they are all like this.

The police won't "keep a record" for a child under 10, unlikely for any primary school child.

Morph22010 · 04/05/2022 07:23

Everydayisabadhairday · 04/05/2022 07:19

Bullying is about the victims perception, not the bully's.

Yes but the solutions will be different.

Indoctro · 04/05/2022 07:22

ihmlsnwidhks · 03/05/2022 21:16

Im a mum of a violent sen child at mainstream. What would you like to see?

If you can't stop your child being violent then the child needs removed from school

It's not fair on other kids to be physically assaulted.

If that's means home education so be it. Your child's needs aren't more important than other kids

Kids should feel and be safe at school.

Morph22010 · 04/05/2022 07:21

Zigzog · 04/05/2022 07:13

"SEN has slways existed but the violence hasn't. Its remarkable how violence is tolerated or explained away due to SEN."

You are wrong. People with my son's needs have always existed but were put in institutions at an early age. He has a 100k a year package at a specialist school. My experience is that people do not want that sort of money spent on people with disabilities but then moan about the consequences when it isn't provided.

That is true there was a thread the other day moaning that sen kids get more resources. People can’t have it both ways.

shrunkenhead · 04/05/2022 07:20

@Shakeitshakeitbaby "ableist bingo"???! What even IS that??

Everydayisabadhairday · 04/05/2022 07:19

Newrumpus · 03/05/2022 23:11

No - I didn’t suggest that. That doesn’t make much sense. However, behaviour which may look like and feel like bullying could well be something very different such as a highly anxious child’s response to a stressful, inappropriate and ill-managed environment. Encouraging children to escalate violence in these circumstances could well have catastrophic consequences.

Bullying is about the victims perception, not the bully's.

Zigzog · 04/05/2022 07:13

"SEN has slways existed but the violence hasn't. Its remarkable how violence is tolerated or explained away due to SEN."

You are wrong. People with my son's needs have always existed but were put in institutions at an early age. He has a 100k a year package at a specialist school. My experience is that people do not want that sort of money spent on people with disabilities but then moan about the consequences when it isn't provided.

KangFang · 04/05/2022 07:04

DeeCeeCherry · 03/05/2022 21:19

Remind school that they have a duty of care to your child too.

I had similar and went to the local authority Education Department, because school and governors werent listening.

They soon listened after that

Yes.

That's the way to do it.

Shakeitshakeitbaby · 04/05/2022 07:03

The abelist bingo on this thread is rife as usual.

SEN is over diagnosed (no idea how difficult the assessment/diagnosis process is! It takes years for many and involves multiple observations by multiple people, they don't just take one look at a child and give them a diagnosis. Plus you are not qualified to decide whether a child has SEN or not)
These children are violent through choice
These children shouldn't be in school, send them home for the parents to educate
The violence didn't exist back in my day

Seriously? Have a word with yourselves. This is the fault of government cuts and a misguided attempt to plonk all children with SEN in a mainstream school, whether it is suitable or not. These children are overwhelmed by an unsuitable environment and cannot cope.

Of course the OP needs to talk to the school and find out the plan to keep her child safe, absolutely unacceptable that a child is in harms way. The school need to look af putting additional supports in for the child. However, some of the attitude on here are quite frankly archaic.

Mrsmch123 · 04/05/2022 06:58

I would be furious. The child with SEN needs does not trump your boys needs. Honestly keep him of school until they can make a to keep your child safe.

Louise0701 · 04/05/2022 06:57

@caringcarer that school sounds awful

Bananarama21 · 04/05/2022 06:54

ihmlsnwidhks if he's has a one to one and is still prone to violence against other kids then he shouldn't be in that school and need to be in the appropriate environment. My ds is undergoing assessment for adhd albeit hes non violent but can have outbursts so I understand it's hard. But other children should be entitled to come to school and work and learn in a safe space.

Oblomov22 · 04/05/2022 06:50

OP going in and having a chat isn't serious enough. You really need to email so that there is a paper trail. And get tough, quick, politely.

Summersuniscoming · 04/05/2022 06:49

SEN has slways existed but the violence hasn't. Its remarkable how violence is tolerated or explained away due to SEN. However, it does depend on the school. The child needs excluding. OP, if they mention the other child, keep coming back at them with your child. KCSIE is the document you need to look up - peer on peer abuse. Keep the focus on your child not being kept safe.

Morph22010 · 04/05/2022 06:47

I think this thread is a prime example of why ALL parents should get themselves over to the pinned thread where you can questions for the mp on the Send green paper. Parents think send changes don’t effect them but they do. The paper proposes to require early intervention which sounds great in theory but we all know this will be an excuse for the la not to provide extra funds until the school has done the early intervention which won’t happen as the school can’t provide it as they don’t have the funds. It’s proposing to try and cut down send tribunals which most parents have to go through to get suitable provision by introducing mandatory mediation which will drag things out even longer. It’s also proposing to take away parent choice of school by reading the parents to choose from a list provided by the la. These changes are going to make the situation for all children worse.

Zigzog · 04/05/2022 06:42

"I'd suggest removing the SEN child if the school is failing to keep your child safe"

It is pointless suggesting that. Children don't get removed on other parents say so. In this situation you concentrate on continually pressing the school about keeping your own child safe, following the correct process for this.
The school shouldn't have given any details about the other child and in doing so they have shown themselves to be a poor school.
Those saying the child should be removed for parents to home educate - no parent can be forced to home educate. That is known as off rolling and is unlawful.

cocktailclub · 04/05/2022 06:37

Two of my kids have been hurt in the past by sen children lashing out at them or using force to get what they want. I regret not doing more. The teachers said the sen kids didn't understand and needed support but ignored the violence towards others. One of them was just an aggressive bully as were his parents and I doubt any actual sen. He eventually got excluded but only after seriously injuring another child.
All children have a right to feel safe at school.

OnTheGoAlways · 04/05/2022 06:33

This is harrowing reading, not only for your child OP who absolutely deserves to go to school without fear of being hurt, but also because I am the Mother of such a child.

My ds2 is 7, has had violent outbursts in private nursery and now school (although not in the outdoor school he attended for half a day before starting school, so environment obviously has an impact). OP I am in turmoil over my sons behaviour and i cant imagine what its like to be a child in his classroom or a parent of those children, I'm waiting for the day i am stopped by parents and shouted at. I WFH when as much as I can so I can have him over lunch, I instigate school meetings, I pushed for an ed psych, I make GP appointments, I have a quiet, stable home. Ds2 has tourettes and is on the waiting list for CAHMs which is over 2 years long here. He has punched teachers and children, he swears, throws resources...but when he's with me he's calm, articulate, he cries at nature documentaries, hes a great reader...its like jekyll and Hyde.

There is not enough support for children struggling OR those struggling to cope with those children. It's not as easy as just removing a child from school, and I suppose hope isn't a strategy but i do hope things change for your child.

Morph22010 · 04/05/2022 06:30

My Sen child used to get violent at school although it was lashing out rather than targeted bullying of anyone. I was quite lucky in that most of the children and parents in the class were quite understanding but we did have issues with some children in other classes deliberating winding him up as they knew he’d lash out and always get the blame as was less articulate and wasn’t able to explain what had happened they like could. Again we were fairly lucky as some of the children in his own class reported back what was happening. Whilst a found the individual teachers good and sorted out to an extent the slt weren’t interested and just wanted to put the blame on my son. We had a lot of exclusions even though he had an ehcp with 32.5 hours which the school didn’t put consistently in place. To cut a very long story short i eventually got him into a specialist school which is the best thing we ever did but it was incredibly difficult and until you’ve been through the Sen system I don’t think you can appreciate how difficult it is to navigate and it’s not just a case of asking for specialist and getting, you will prob have to go to tribunal and represent yourself unless you have thousands of pounds spare to pay for legal representation. Preparing a case takes hundreds of hours and some parents just don’t have that time to spare due to other commitments or just don’t have the capability. That said I’m not sure why the school aren’t excluding as that is good evidence for the child/ parents that the school aren’t meeting need.

phlebasconsidered · 04/05/2022 06:21

Years ago there actually was a middle road between being "locked up" and in a classroom. Most schools had a "unit" where kids with needs who couldn't be in a classroom would go. They would learn basic skills, gardening, house care, self care, etc and they would join in with whole school activities. A couple of teachers would run it. Ours was called the "love to learn" group.

But then cuts, and inclusion policies made it necessary to have them back in a classroom where now the teacher must often provide, as I do, work from the p scales up to year 7 in.one class whilst trying to get some kids through sats. With no TA and no help and a full third of my class with needs of some sort.

People have no idea what cuts have done to schools. When I first started teaching the idea of an 11 year old lobbing a laptop at me and calling me a cunt would have been appalling. Now it's just a form filled, incident logged and a chat with mum about his behaviour and adhd medication.

It isn't ok.

shrunkenhead · 04/05/2022 06:12

I'd suggest removing the SEN child if the school is failing to keep your child safe. The school have admitted he's struggling to cope and it's happening to other children as well. Maybe he'd be happier in a special school that can keep him and his fellow pupils safe.
And I'm sure removing him isn't practical for the parent of the violent child but that's not the OP's problem. And the OP shouldn't have to arrange for her son to change schools because he isn't the problem here.

Maybebabyno2 · 04/05/2022 06:11

Sen or not, it is not acceptable to just accept child is violent and let other children pay the price. You wouldn't accept sen as a reason for being regularly assaulted in the work place, why is school any different?

They can't manage this child's violent outbursts towards other children to the extent that multiple children are being assaulted 3 times a week, it's ridiculous!

MrsH1983 · 04/05/2022 06:08

XelaM · 03/05/2022 23:38

I am not suggesting a specific specialist school. I am suggesting expelling the violent child to protect the majority of the children at the school. Whether the violent child then has to be home educated should not be the concern of the children who are being assaulted on a daily basis. Would you accept being assaulted every day at work?! Would you be concerned about whether the attacker has SEN? Why is it ok to subject children to this?

The problem the school then comes up against if they exclude someone on the grounds of their disability is prosecution based on discrimination. They are in a tough position.