Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Or is my brother a CF

108 replies

Potentiallytakenforaride · 03/05/2022 16:57

Quick context (it’s relevant, I promise). My older brother is a bit of a ne’er-do-well. Had all of life’s opportunities - top private school education etc etc, but has ended up making very poor decisions, smoking lots of weed and generally being a bit of a user and very selfish. Eg lives in a family owned flat for 1/4 of what it’s worth and still complains/is the victim, quits his job frequently to go travelling then wonders why his gf of the time isn’t there when he returns after 9 months, constantly agrees to meet me for lunch and then doesn’t want to pay so I have to.

Anyway my father (who DB doesn’t speak to) bought me my first car a few years ago. A shitty little run around but I loved it! I had a child and needed a larger car (it’s 2 door and was a disaster with car seat) and I’m pretty financially comfortable so I gave it to DB as he wanted to learn to drive. This was on the agreement he didn’t just sell it but actually use it (if I wanted to sell it I would have sold it myself but wanted it to go to my brother to use if that makes sense).

3 years later he has not passed his test, has broken up with another gf and has decided to give her the car. He hasn’t talked to me first, offered it back to me (would be quite useful with 3 children to have a second car) or anything - my mother just came and told me he’s given it to her.

AIBU to think he could have discussed it first? I appreciate I gave him the car so some (or most) people will say it’s his to do what he wants with, it just feels a bit shitty.

TLDR: I gave my brother my old car and he’s now given it to his ex as some sort of parting gift.

OP posts:
CurlyhairedAssassin · 03/05/2022 18:15

OP, there are some unhealthy dynamics at play here tied up with some assumptions about certain things instead of proper clear communication of expectations. To be honest, you sound a bit wet where your brother is concerned. Why do you let him take advantage of you? It's horrible behaviour - time to grow some balls and to tell him what's what.

I mean, this: constantly agrees to meet me for lunch and then doesn’t want to pay so I have to.

No, you DON'T have to. For most people, they'd let someone do this once and give them the benefit of the doubt the first time. If it happened again they'd either make them pay their share, that was first agreed as part of the discussion about the lunch arrangements, in very clear terms about expectations of who was paying, and if they refused to pay or came up with an excuse they would simply not go to lunch with them again. It's freeloading. No-one likes these people. Well, that's clear, because none of his girlfriends like him, they get the measure of him quite quickly and don't hang around.

It sounds like your dad has told him straight that he needs to stop sponging off him, and that's why your brother doesn't talk to him, because he doesn't like what he's been told. Your mum and you pussyfoot around him, and he takes advantage of that, particularly your desire to continue a relationship with him. Your mum probably wants to try to keep the sibling relationship going hence all these suggestions of keeping things secret from your dad.

Really, really unhealthy, OP. You do need to grow a pair.

FeetupTvon · 03/05/2022 18:07

I wouldn’t worry.
You are financially stable so if you required a second car you could purchase one.
He has owned the car for 3 years, so up to him what he does with it. It’s not as though he’s made financial gain from selling it on.
You don’t need a licence to be the registered keeper.

Idontevenknow · 03/05/2022 18:02

Did you tell your dad you were giving it to your brother after he bought it for you? As its basically the same scenario

CurlyhairedAssassin · 03/05/2022 18:00

Sally872 · 03/05/2022 17:12

Your brother is annoying but in this instance it was a shitty little run around, he kept it for 3 years and hasnt sold it so I would say at this point he doesn't have to check with you.

If it was a few months ago you gave him it or he sold it then I would say yanbu.

Likely his girlfriend used the car more as brother doesnt drive, and considers it hers now as she paid for other things and brother didn't feel he should or didn't care enough to argue for it back.

shock You can't just go through life considering something belongs to you just because you've had use of it for quite a while! Even squatters have to live in a house for 10 years before they can even think of claiming squatters' rights.

It's more likely that the brother hasn't told the girlfriend the circumstances of how he came to have the car. OP isn't clear whether she literally gave him ownership of the car or just changed the registered keeper to be her brother. She's probably still the legal owner so god knows what the brother thinks he's trying to do.

TheCatterall · 03/05/2022 17:55

3 years…. He’s had it for 3 years. You were never going to get the car back. You should have asked for it back after 6 months.

grow some boundaries etc. Accept who he is. Don’t take him out for meals etc or tell
him in advance hes paying.

Nanny0gg · 03/05/2022 17:53

Potentiallytakenforaride · 03/05/2022 17:03

@RubyRubyRubyDiamond

well there’s nothing I can do about it anyway I just want to know if IABU because that will alter what I say to him when he eventually mentions it to me (if he does?! My mother told me not to tell him I know…)

You knew what he was like so I have no idea why you gave it to him in the first place

Cut your losses and don't do it again

Cervinia · 03/05/2022 17:52

So when you handed him the car did you let the DVLA know? Aren’t you supposed to tell them you’ve passed it in and him to say he’s the new owner? If you never assigned ownership to him and he never accepted it’s still yours isn’t it? Ask for it back.

Indoorcamping · 03/05/2022 17:49

Potentiallytakenforaride · 03/05/2022 17:35

I’m actually amazed he’s given it to the ex because he’s so mean with money!

He probably owes her money

AProperStinging · 03/05/2022 17:44

My older brother is a bit of a ne’er-do-well. Had all of life’s opportunities - top private school education etc etc, but has ended up making very poor decisions, smoking lots of weed and generally being a bit of a user and very selfish. Eg lives in a family owned flat for 1/4 of what it’s worth and still complains/is the victim, quits his job frequently to go travelling then wonders why his gf of the time isn’t there when he returns after 9 months, constantly agrees to meet me for lunch and then doesn’t want to pay so I have to.

  1. You knew all this and decided to give him the car. Why are you surprised that he has given it away?

  2. You describe yourself as 'financially comfortable' and you already have a (better) car. Why do you begrudge his girlfriend having it?

Potentiallytakenforaride · 03/05/2022 17:39

*tell me

OP posts:
Potentiallytakenforaride · 03/05/2022 17:35

I’m actually amazed he’s given it to the ex because he’s so mean with money!

OP posts:
Potentiallytakenforaride · 03/05/2022 17:35

Now I’m annoyed that I’ve given him
the perfect opportunity to tell him by asking re the ownership and he hasn’t!!!

OP posts:
dworky · 03/05/2022 17:32

You know, if others didn't facilitate cf's like this, they couldn't continue to get away with it.

Eddielizzard · 03/05/2022 17:31

Well it's how your brother operates. I wouldn't be doing something like that for him again!

Sally872 · 03/05/2022 17:21

Potentiallytakenforaride · 03/05/2022 17:19

@Sally872

Another way of looking at it is did you ask your dad before giving it to brother?

I did, yes!

In that case I can see why you felt brother should have. But I do think it is unusual to expect that after this amount of time.

Sally872 · 03/05/2022 17:19

It is important to make sure you aren't owner so good to get paperwork sorted. I just wouldn't waste the headspace being annoyed about it.

Potentiallytakenforaride · 03/05/2022 17:19

@Sally872

Another way of looking at it is did you ask your dad before giving it to brother?

I did, yes!

OP posts:
Sally872 · 03/05/2022 17:18

Another way of looking at it is did you ask your dad before giving it to brother? If he wanted to give his son he doesn't speak to a car surely he would have done it?

GarethSouthgatesWaistcoat · 03/05/2022 17:16

If it's in your name can you get it back? Hard luck on the gf but that's life.

DadsTrilby · 03/05/2022 17:15

You don’t need a licence to be a registered keeper.

Potentiallytakenforaride · 03/05/2022 17:14

@Sally872

i don’t really begrudge the GF the car as I think the situation is exactly as you describe and she’s come out badly out of their relationship because he’s a massive CF who has wasted her time.

OP posts:
Potentiallytakenforaride · 03/05/2022 17:13

I’ve just messaged him
to ask if he sorted out the ownership issue. He said “I believe so”.

I have now asked if he’s sure as I think you need a licence to be the owner (thanks PP for the info) and I need to know if it’s in my name as I’m liable.

OP posts:
Sally872 · 03/05/2022 17:12

Your brother is annoying but in this instance it was a shitty little run around, he kept it for 3 years and hasnt sold it so I would say at this point he doesn't have to check with you.

If it was a few months ago you gave him it or he sold it then I would say yanbu.

Likely his girlfriend used the car more as brother doesnt drive, and considers it hers now as she paid for other things and brother didn't feel he should or didn't care enough to argue for it back.

Potentiallytakenforaride · 03/05/2022 17:12

@AchatAVendre

funnily enough he messaged me 2 weeks ago out of the blue asking something about the logbook and car ownership and I was surprised as I had told him at the time to deal with it/how to deal with it. So perhaps it’s in my name still? Or perhaps he put it in her name? I have no idea.

I agree with everyone I’ve been a bit naive about this I just tried to do something nice for my brother but have instead ended up giving a car I could have used to his ex…

going to stop going along with his general CF too.

@KettrickenSmiled
she just enjoys shit stirring but doesn’t want anything to come back to bite her…

OP posts:
FawnFrenchieMum · 03/05/2022 17:09

Is it something I would have done, no as it’s CF but in context of your brother it sounds pretty standard so I wouldn’t lose sleep over it. Just don’t allow him the opportunity to do something like that again.