Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Or is my brother a CF

108 replies

Potentiallytakenforaride · 03/05/2022 16:57

Quick context (it’s relevant, I promise). My older brother is a bit of a ne’er-do-well. Had all of life’s opportunities - top private school education etc etc, but has ended up making very poor decisions, smoking lots of weed and generally being a bit of a user and very selfish. Eg lives in a family owned flat for 1/4 of what it’s worth and still complains/is the victim, quits his job frequently to go travelling then wonders why his gf of the time isn’t there when he returns after 9 months, constantly agrees to meet me for lunch and then doesn’t want to pay so I have to.

Anyway my father (who DB doesn’t speak to) bought me my first car a few years ago. A shitty little run around but I loved it! I had a child and needed a larger car (it’s 2 door and was a disaster with car seat) and I’m pretty financially comfortable so I gave it to DB as he wanted to learn to drive. This was on the agreement he didn’t just sell it but actually use it (if I wanted to sell it I would have sold it myself but wanted it to go to my brother to use if that makes sense).

3 years later he has not passed his test, has broken up with another gf and has decided to give her the car. He hasn’t talked to me first, offered it back to me (would be quite useful with 3 children to have a second car) or anything - my mother just came and told me he’s given it to her.

AIBU to think he could have discussed it first? I appreciate I gave him the car so some (or most) people will say it’s his to do what he wants with, it just feels a bit shitty.

TLDR: I gave my brother my old car and he’s now given it to his ex as some sort of parting gift.

OP posts:
DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 03/05/2022 20:43

I guess it’s become more of a “family joke” but actually this thread and writing this down has made me realise how unfunny it is and how much it fucks me off. And actually why do I feel bad about him saying he can’t afford a salad when he inherited 21k last year?! Sometimes someone can be so shameless you feel their shame for them

I feel that this is what texting is designed for. He is a CF extraordinaire.

Next time the subject of lunch crops up text to say you are still waiting for your birthday lunch which never arrived and that if you do meet for lunch you will not be paying for him as you have already done that too many times. Tell him he can afford his own salad.

Tell him you know about the car. Say you offered him the car because you thought he needed it, but its annoying that he gave it away and swore your mother to keep it a secret from you. It means he knew it would annoy you to find out. say that you would prefer him to be honest with you. Copy them both in.

I guess both these texts would be a bit explosive...to say the least LOL! and maybe this is more wishful advice than advice you should act on in real life but clearly you are fed up with this so its either carry on putting up with it or put the cat amongst the pigeons a bit and see whether it changes anything. In anycase, I think you need to put some boundaries in place with this CF and also with your DM who is enabling him and treating him as a special case who must be protected.

Olsi109 · 03/05/2022 20:38

I think it's a bigger issue for you maybe because of how much of a dick he is on so many occasions and it's just the icing on the cake of how selfish he is. On this basis I think you're right to be annoyed as I'd probably get fed up too.

However, looking at it as an isolated incident,you've been gifted a car from your dad, you've regifted that car to your brother and after 3 years he's gifted it to his ex. Although a bit of a shitty thing to do it is just that, a bit shitty and probably something you're going to have to let go.

But please stop letting him take advantage of your good nature. If he invites you for lunch, make sure he can afford it - are you sure you can afford? Then he knows he's expected to at least by his own x

toddlingabout · 03/05/2022 20:35

Why don't you just play dumb and ask for it back, being as he's not used it in 3 years.

Potentiallytakenforaride · 03/05/2022 20:35

But one tip she does have is “return the embarrassment to sender” - when someone does something appalling, you don’t need to run around mitigating that. They can feel the embarrassment of the moment. You don’t need to feel embarrassment on their behalf

I need to learn how to do this!

OP posts:
BronwenFrideswide · 03/05/2022 20:32

this is it! 💪🏻 (I’m actually a pretty assertive person I guess I just feel sorry for him and it’s all muddled up in my mother’s enabling and our childhood)

Good for you, you can do this. I did wonder if there was some messed up family dynamic at play. Value yourself OP don't let that be undermined by whatever went on in the past. Good luck, onwards and upwards.Flowers

Hutchy16 · 03/05/2022 20:27

You gave him an old car, three years ago? Your brother didn’t use it for three years, and now you are mad because he gave it away.

if he had kept it you still wouldn’t have use of it. I think that you dislike him for other reasons, and are just using the car as a final straw.

but you are being unreasonable about the car (but not about the other stuff)

Changechangychange · 03/05/2022 20:22

And actually why do I feel bad about him saying he can’t afford a salad when he inherited 21k last year

Exactly - just keep reminding yourself he absolutely can afford it and does have money, he is just trying to manipulate/embarrass you into paying for him. If he chooses not to buy himself any lunch, there is no reason for you to feel embarrassed.

You might like the Captain Awkward advice blog (or you might not, she can be quite American). But one tip she does have is “return the embarrassment to sender” - when someone does something appalling, you don’t need to run around mitigating that. They can feel the embarrassment of the moment. You don’t need to feel embarrassment on their behalf.

Potentiallytakenforaride · 03/05/2022 20:11

I’m going to use this as a jumping off platform to address the issues. I’ve really had enough. He has mentioned seeing the children and i Am going to be extremely blunt that we either always come to my place where I host him and provide refreshments, or go out somewhere where he then doesn’t pay. ONCE in 3 years he has had us to theirs. He didn’t so much as think to get snacks or drinks for the children (luckily we brought our own!)

this is it! 💪🏻 (I’m actually a pretty assertive person I guess I just feel sorry for him and it’s all muddled up in my mother’s enabling and our childhood)

OP posts:
BronwenFrideswide · 03/05/2022 20:08

Ah, okay, @Potentiallytakenforaride. Are you being blinded by the fact is your brother, i.e., your flesh and blood so you have to forgive him his foibles, or are you doing it not to rock the boat within the family? You surely wouldn't accept this treatment from anyone else.

He's proven time and time again he won't change, realistically why would he? He's onto a good thing.

It isn't funny, you are right, he has no shame why should you. It's time to stop enabling him. Yes he's your brother and no doubt you love him but you can dislike him and the way he behaves. Stand up for yourself and show you won't be a pushover for him anymore, he'll soon get the message. Put your mother straight too if you have to.

StScholastica · 03/05/2022 20:01

Ampleforth by any chance?
They seem to have form for turning out these types.

iRun2eatCake · 03/05/2022 20:01

So what are you going to do about it?

Potentiallytakenforaride · 03/05/2022 19:52

@BronwenFrideswide

it sounds crazy because of how much of a CF is but honestly I am surprised time and time again/I always think he will be different somehow.

It is like for my birthday. This year he said he would take me for lunch.lovely. I’m pregnant so he said he will wait until after the baby is born so I can drink. I explained I don’t want to drink and I would rather go now than when the baby is here as I would have to take the baby which wouldn’t be relaxing for me, or wait until the baby was quite a bit older. This was 3 months ago and nothing more has been said. He inherited 21k last year and from what I’ve seen he has spent it all on himself; nothing went to the gf. She bought a cat and he was supposed to pay half but said “she’s bought it already so what’s the point”.

I guess it’s become more of a “family joke” but actually this thread and writing this down has made me realise how unfunny it is and how much it fucks me off. And actually why do I feel bad about him saying he can’t afford a salad when he inherited 21k last year?! Sometimes someone can be so shameless you feel their shame for them!

OP posts:
BronwenFrideswide · 03/05/2022 19:46

You must have had an inkling that your brother would do what he has done with the car, why are you surprised that he has indeed done just that.

BangtanLove · 03/05/2022 19:44

Oh dear. Well at least now you know that he will take whatever he's given and won't return either what he's given or the favour. It's up to you what you now do with this information. If I were you I would take care to ensure that you never lend or give him more than you are happily prepared to lose, even if it makes you feel a bit mean. He's an adult, he can take care of himself.

BronwenFrideswide · 03/05/2022 19:43

this is unfair and untrue - I generally just feel embarrassed and ashamed. I feel like I would be mean not to pay for him when I can, although it does then make me feel used and like a total sucker as I know he is just expecting it.

Why do you feel ashamed? He is using you and has done so often yet you keep allowing him to do so which is why I came to the conclusions I did. You know what he will do/say yet you still blithely go along with it instead of saying something when he suggests going out and pre-empting the "I've no money" bollocks.

longwayoff · 03/05/2022 19:37

If you dare not speak in front of your mother and are not supposed to know he's given it away just ask him to return it to you. Preferably with mama to hand. You sound as if you all live in a kindergarten.any grown ups around to help you out?

Potentiallytakenforaride · 03/05/2022 19:36

This looks like he is actually the owner though so we must have transferred ownership 3 years ago and neither of us remember

Or is my brother a CF
OP posts:
Potentiallytakenforaride · 03/05/2022 19:34

You didn't lend the car. You gave it to him, so title has passed. He can do what he likes with it. It probably isn't worth much anyway

it’s not worth much but it’s not about the money.

I agree he can do what he likes with it. I get that. I still just don’t think it’s what I would have done (and isn’t when I gave it to my brother as I asked my father).

OP posts:
BadNomad · 03/05/2022 19:33

There can be a car owner and a registered keeper. The person whose name is on the document is the keeper, they are responsible for taxing it and paying any fines. They are not necessarily the owner. Whoever paid for the car originally (your dad?) was the owner. He gave you ownership. You can tell your brother you did not give him the car to keep, which means he does not have permission to give it away.

Potentiallytakenforaride · 03/05/2022 19:32

How often do you fall for this? If it keeps happening then either a) you don't mind/actually enjoy being seen as the bountiful one and enabling his behaviour or b) you like moaning about it and feeling hard done by afterwards

this is unfair and untrue - I generally just feel embarrassed and ashamed. I feel like I would be mean not to pay for him when I can, although it does then make me feel used and like a total sucker as I know he is just expecting it.

Your brother should have spoken to you before disposing of it but had you agreed anything when you gave him it?

the agreement was he wouldn’t sell it; but there wasn’t really a long term plan if you see what I mean. I do absolutely see the point re how long he’s had it etc it just almost feels to me as he never passed his test he has barely even used it! I know it sounds silly I think it would be different if he had used it himself for 3 years and then sold it but it’s like his gf has used it for 3 years and now has it and none of that was my intention - I gave it to him as my brother. I suppose also it’s that if he’s just giving it to her and he doesn’t give a shit about it/he’s not even selling it then again I don’t see why if he didn’t care he couldn’t give it back to me.

but perhaps PPs are right that he’s settling a debt or something…

OP posts:
Dillydollydingdong · 03/05/2022 19:32

You didn't lend the car. You gave it to him, so title has passed. He can do what he likes with it. It probably isn't worth much anyway.

NotMushroomInEre · 03/05/2022 19:32

I think you were kind to gift your brother the car. I think hoping that someone may take some responsibility, learn and gain a bit of independence from your kindness is priceless. Sadly, it wasn't to be in this case.

I think yabu to be upset by this as it was 3 years ago. That is a long time and it certainly doesn't sound like this car will have a significant monetary value. I know that isn't your point, but I couldn't let this bother me if this was my situation. I probably wouldn't think twice about trying to help my sibling again either.

My main priority would be trying to find out if the V5 form had been completed correctly and that I was no longer the registered keeper. If penalties are broken, I'm pretty sure the fines will come your way if it wasn't finalised initially with your brother.

user1471447863 · 03/05/2022 19:27

Very top of the V5 it very clearly states "This is not proof of ownership". Whose name is on the V5 is irrelevant as regards who owns what. It merely defines who is responsible for dealing with legal matters (speeding/parking tickets, tax, insurance, who is allowed to drive etc) and for that reason alone you should have transferred it to his name when you gave him the car - and you as the keeper are responsible for notifying the DVLA (the new keeper/owner has little incentive to do so if they intend to pick up speeding tickets etc as it will be you who will have to answer for them). You should have received a letter of confirmation from the DVLA shortly after.

Your brother should have spoken to you before disposing of it but had you agreed anything when you gave him it? If nothing was agreed and he's had it for 3 years now I'm kind of thinking it's more or less his to do with as he sees fit.

BronwenFrideswide · 03/05/2022 19:24

we arrange to do something and on the way there he says “by the way I don’t have any money”.

most recent example is this:
he says let’s take the children for lunch
I get to the place and order for them and for me
he arrives, orders nothing and comments 4 times on how amazing my food looks. I tell
him after 4th time to get what I’m having then. He says “I don’t want to spend any money because I’m getting a crown put in this afternoon and that’s expensive” and looks at me expectantly. I feel embarrassed and say he can go and order the salad I’m having and I will pay. He goes and orders a completely different, far more expensive dish with a drink and then wants a coffee too.

How often do you fall for this? If it keeps happening then either a) you don't mind/actually enjoy being seen as the bountiful one and enabling his behaviour or b) you like moaning about it and feeling hard done by afterwards.

On the first instance, you should say "We/You might as well go back home then because I'm not funding you".

On the second instance "You shouldn't have said to take the children for lunch then should you?" "If you are not prepared to spend any money then you'll have to go without".

I actually think you enjoy being taken advantage of by him.

Potentiallytakenforaride · 03/05/2022 19:23

@whynotwhatknot

i do not have this but also it was 3 years ago so I don’t really remember what we did and apparently he doesn’t either

OP posts: