Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I haven’t seen a thread yet? Supreme Court to overturn legal right to abortion in the US.

93 replies

AlternativePerspective · 03/05/2022 10:40

Roe v Wade: US Supreme Court may overturn abortion law, leak suggests www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-61302740

And if this is successful, how long before similar decisions are made over here and elsewhere where women still have the right to bodily autonomy.

OP posts:
KimikosNightmare · 03/05/2022 12:29

Rosehugger · 03/05/2022 12:20

I don't think countries should be allowed full membership of any international organisations such as the UN or the EU until they have abortion legal to at least 20 weeks and contraception and morning after pill available widely and free of charge, particularly large economies such as the US and Ireland.

Most of the EU /Europe sets it at 12 weeks, with the UK being one of the outliers.

That's actually shorter than some US States which have legislation on the books awaiting this decision which will set it at 15 weeks.

www.statista.com/statistics/1268439/legal-abortion-time-frames-in-europe/

Rosehugger · 03/05/2022 12:20

I don't think countries should be allowed full membership of any international organisations such as the UN or the EU until they have abortion legal to at least 20 weeks and contraception and morning after pill available widely and free of charge, particularly large economies such as the US and Ireland.

StrychnineInTheSandwiches · 03/05/2022 12:20

This tweet shows where things could turn next...

No Lie with Brian Tyler Cohen
@NoLieWithBTC
NEW: The draft majority opinion overturning Roe v. Wade that just leaked also explicitly criticizes Lawrence v. Texas (which ended laws that banned gay sex) and Obergefell v. Hodges (which legalized same-sex marriage). Alito claims they are not “deeply rooted in history.”

Blossomtoes · 03/05/2022 12:07

It's horrific, like they've watched the Handmaid's Talk and thought it was an instruction manual. My heart breaks for the women of America.

This. I couldn’t believe what I was reading this morning. There’s not even any pretence that women aren’t second class citizens any more.

Rosehugger · 03/05/2022 12:05

Yes, I know it's making it up to certain states. Like Alabama, Texas, Tennessee who will probably jump at the chance to ban abortion outright as if they are fucking El Salvador or something. 😡

The US seems to be using The Handmaid's Tale not as a warning but as a cut-out-and-keep guide to women's rights.

Sharrowgirl · 03/05/2022 12:03

America is a unique country with its own particular set of societal problems and political divisions. I don’t think we can extrapolate it’s experience to ourselves or other countries. Thankfully.

Frogslegsbigfeet · 03/05/2022 12:01

I think that people need to remember that this is removing federal law and leaving it up to individual states to decide. States often then let the counties decide. In America some counties are still dry and alcohol is banned, in others weed is legalised. It’s not always the ones you’d think either, so for example Florida has two counties that are totally dry it is both illegal to sell or possess alcohol within their territory. There is eight dry I think in New York.

this change has not made abortion illegal across America, but it does mean some states, who are deeply religious may ban it or leave it to the individual county to decide their own law by public referendum.

is it a step back, yes, but it’s not like the uk and can never be compared as such and nor is it a blanket ban on abortion. It’s now going to be state and county specific sadly like booze or weed.

RelationshipOrNot · 03/05/2022 11:59

Fishwishy · 03/05/2022 11:51

So at the outset I defend women's rights to abortion this move sickens me. but specifically around contraception isn't this simply putting women back in the same state as men, for years on Mumsnet women have told men that when they consent to sex there is a risk of pregnancy and the only choice is for men to wear a condom. men have no access to a male coil or hormonal contraceptives. Whenever a woman gets pregnant and the man isn't happy (contraceptive failure) the response is a condescending diddums he shouldn't have had sex. Well isn't this the state women now find themselves in with access to contraceptives?

I think it's more important for women to have access to highly effective birth control (i.e. something better than condoms) than men, because we're the ones at risk of pregnancy. A man's potential financial commitment to an unwanted child doesn't even begin to be comparable to the physical and psychological damage of an unwanted pregnancy (not to mention that women also get the financial cost, way more than child support payments). I don't think women's vs men's access to contraception can be meaningfully compared because of that basic difference that one carries the pregnancy and one doesn't.

gwenneh · 03/05/2022 11:58

men have no access to a male coil or hormonal contraceptives
Men have access to all male coils and hormonal contraceptives that have been medically approved. The fact that there are none is what prevents these options from being used, not that someone is controlling men's access to them.

This is not the same at all as restricting access to a viable medical procedure.

JaninaDuszejko · 03/05/2022 11:56

This decision is barbaric. But it is specific to America and their attacks on women's rights. Ireland and Argentina both recently liberalised their abortion laws, and there is no public appetite in this country to change the law. We should look to the rest of Europe who we share a political history with.

Rosehugger · 03/05/2022 11:56

This makes me so angry. These right wing bastards wanting to ban abortion don't either want to pay additional taxes to pay for all these additional children or provide freely accessible contraception or healthcare for women in poverty.

If I were a women of childbearing age in the US I would be organising a sex strike with as many other women as possible. No sex with a man until I get my fundamental reproductive rights back.

Men supporting these measures can literally go fuck themselves.

MedusasBadHairDay · 03/05/2022 11:56

Fishwishy · 03/05/2022 11:51

So at the outset I defend women's rights to abortion this move sickens me. but specifically around contraception isn't this simply putting women back in the same state as men, for years on Mumsnet women have told men that when they consent to sex there is a risk of pregnancy and the only choice is for men to wear a condom. men have no access to a male coil or hormonal contraceptives. Whenever a woman gets pregnant and the man isn't happy (contraceptive failure) the response is a condescending diddums he shouldn't have had sex. Well isn't this the state women now find themselves in with access to contraceptives?

The two are not equivalent. An unwanted pregnancy for a man does not have any impact on his body or his health, he does not need to take time off work to give birth/breastfeed. It carries no risks to him.

So no, this doesn't in any way put men and women on an even footing.

KimikosNightmare · 03/05/2022 11:55

LunaLovegoodsNecklace · 03/05/2022 11:22

I'm not saying it on the horizon or that it's been considered, I'm just saying that our government are not exactly paragons of virtue and that they'd sell over their own grandmother if they thought it would benefit them. If it was ever put to them that they could gain something from rolling back abortion laws then I'd put money on them taking that offer.

I don't actually see the point in every single thread on here becoming an opportunity to have a go at the tories for something that they haven't and wouldn't do. Yes they're crap. But I don't think there is a chance they would do something like this. They know how it would go down here. I don't think it's within Boris' politics to do this. And politics here are very different to the US.

There is no appetite in UK politics to go down this route. Westminster has just had the vote on whether to continue with telemedication and decided yes. Whilst it was the opposition who carried it a significant number of Tories also supported it.

Of the Tories who didn't support it, there were several who did so because of concerns about the telemedication process, not abortion- e.g Andrea Leadsom who was a supporter of Stella Creasey's campaign about NI.

LangClegsInSpace · 03/05/2022 11:54

Aimee1987 · 03/05/2022 11:09

I think it's horrible and a massive step back for womens right.

Your other concern of it happening in the UK is not something I see happening. American politics is very embedded in religion in a way not seen here.

I'm Irish and it was the Catholics churches influence over the government that lead to it taking so long for the abortion referendum to take place in Ireland. But when put to the public it was massively favoured.

It's worth keeping a very sharp eye on what's happening in the UK

www.mumsnet.com/talk/feminism/4289660-Late-term-abortion-high-court?page=34&reply=115699067

www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/4539125-more-institutional-capture-pro-lifers-this-time

Snowflakes1122 · 03/05/2022 11:52

Feels like there is a war on women these days.

Fishwishy · 03/05/2022 11:51

endofthelinefinally · 03/05/2022 11:36

They have already removed access to contraception for poor women, unemployed women and any woman whose employer decides they are against it. Access to contraception is tied to health insurance. So many women are left with the only option being to buy condoms (so the cost will go up). We all know the problems and complications there.

So at the outset I defend women's rights to abortion this move sickens me. but specifically around contraception isn't this simply putting women back in the same state as men, for years on Mumsnet women have told men that when they consent to sex there is a risk of pregnancy and the only choice is for men to wear a condom. men have no access to a male coil or hormonal contraceptives. Whenever a woman gets pregnant and the man isn't happy (contraceptive failure) the response is a condescending diddums he shouldn't have had sex. Well isn't this the state women now find themselves in with access to contraceptives?

Fishwishy · 03/05/2022 11:43

Huge step backwards for women (and men who may not want the child either) I am so angry about this. The government shouldn't be removing bodily autonomy from people be it abortion, sex work or pornography. I am outraged and this is a slippery slope we don't want to end up like Poland here.

endofthelinefinally · 03/05/2022 11:36

They have already removed access to contraception for poor women, unemployed women and any woman whose employer decides they are against it. Access to contraception is tied to health insurance. So many women are left with the only option being to buy condoms (so the cost will go up). We all know the problems and complications there.

LittleMy77 · 03/05/2022 11:36

@EvilPea yes. They changed the law so employer provided healthcare plans (which is how most ppl get it) could refuse to offer contraception and abortion services as part of the plan, due to religious or similar grounds. Lots of of catholic based companies, a lot of which are hospital and healthcare providers, have made this change

the only way you can get it otherwise is to pay out of pocket - I.e. your insurance doesn’t cover it and you pay privately or try and get to a planned parenthood or simliar clinic.

MaitreKarlsson · 03/05/2022 11:32

Shocking, am really upset.

EvilPea · 03/05/2022 11:25

StrychnineInTheSandwiches · 03/05/2022 11:15

They'll go for contraception next.

America is turning into an Evangelical theocracy. They want women subjugated and they want men in control.

Didn’t they change something recently about employers health insurance and contraception?
i have a very very vague recollection of them restricting it or controlling it in someway.

MedusasBadHairDay · 03/05/2022 11:25

StrychnineInTheSandwiches · 03/05/2022 11:15

They'll go for contraception next.

America is turning into an Evangelical theocracy. They want women subjugated and they want men in control.

It's horrific, like they've watched the Handmaid's Talk and thought it was an instruction manual. My heart breaks for the women of America.

Hospedia · 03/05/2022 11:25

It was posted in agreement with the idea that it makes it easier for other governments to rolls back rights as it sets a precedent, it wasn't intended to derail the thread.

LunaLovegoodsNecklace · 03/05/2022 11:22

I'm not saying it on the horizon or that it's been considered, I'm just saying that our government are not exactly paragons of virtue and that they'd sell over their own grandmother if they thought it would benefit them. If it was ever put to them that they could gain something from rolling back abortion laws then I'd put money on them taking that offer.

I don't actually see the point in every single thread on here becoming an opportunity to have a go at the tories for something that they haven't and wouldn't do. Yes they're crap. But I don't think there is a chance they would do something like this. They know how it would go down here. I don't think it's within Boris' politics to do this. And politics here are very different to the US.

Hospedia · 03/05/2022 11:18

LunaLovegoodsNecklace · 03/05/2022 11:16

Rubbish. Boris is a clown but I don't believe he'd allow interference in UK women's access to abortion for a trade deal.

I'm not saying it on the horizon or that it's been considered, I'm just saying that our government are not exactly paragons of virtue and that they'd sell over their own grandmother if they thought it would benefit them. If it was ever put to them that they could gain something from rolling back abortion laws then I'd put money on them taking that offer.

Swipe left for the next trending thread