Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not tell family the babies sex

60 replies

Crumpetloveliness · 02/05/2022 18:34

I do feel a bit bad about this and ultimately it’s not like they won’t find out when baby is here. However, I’ve not told my family the sex of baby but DHs family know (different country so no chance of speaking) and our close friends.

It’s exactly what my DM wants and she’ll crow about it (she informed both of my siblings I was pregnant despite me asking her not to so I could tell them) and buy a whole load of colour associated crap for baby.

I do realise writing that out it seems petulant, so I probably am unreasonable here. My DH doesn’t get it and thinks I’m being mean when it would make her happy. Would or has anyone else done this?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
surreygirl1987 · 03/05/2022 20:47

I must admit I do find it odd when people at work who don’t know you or even randomers ask the sex and expect to be told

Really? Jeez, it's not a national secret! It's just someone making conversation- they couldn't care less. It's just polite to seem interested, even if you're not!

TolkiensFallow · 02/05/2022 21:20

Personally I don’t think you should tell one family and not the other. It just creates more of an issue.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 02/05/2022 20:31

I must admit I do find it odd when people at work who don’t know you or even randomers ask the sex and expect to be told it’s a way of acting interested - Jesus it’s only one of two options and regardless the response is “awww”.

Giraffesandbottom · 02/05/2022 20:30

What's ridiculous is that people think they have a right to know the ins and outs of other peoples lives

the sex of a baby is water cooler conversation - it’s pretty neutral as a PP said. It’s certainly not “the ins and outs of other peoples lives”.

sex scans are pretty accurate, it’s so unlikely to be wrong. sex blood tests are 99.9% accurate too. It’s not really a reason to not disclose.

toastofthetown · 02/05/2022 20:25

I must admit I do find it odd when people at work who don’t know you or even randomers ask the sex and expect to be told

That's a really weird way of phrasing it. I've asked colleagues before, not because I feel I have a right to know nor because I particularly care, but because small talk is a thing, it seems strange not to acknowledge a pregnancy and 'when are you due?" 'do you know what you're having?" seems fairly neutral territory. Not like asking about your birth plan or if you're struggling with constipation.

iheartmybeachhut · 02/05/2022 20:25

Pfb I guess, but still your choice.

Olsi109 · 02/05/2022 20:17

Giraffesandbottom · 02/05/2022 20:11

I must admit I do find it odd when people at work who don’t know you or even randomers ask the sex and expect to be told

but why do you find it odd?! It’s not private, or shameful or a secret? Why would it be a secret, unless you want to build up some bizarre level of suspense over your own baby? Would you also try to keep it a secret when the baby is out? It’s as ridiculous not to tell someone if you know when it’s in your uterus, what’s the difference? It’s a baby boy or a baby girl.

What's ridiculous is that people think they have a right to know the ins and outs of other peoples lives. Obv she won't try to keep it a secret when baby's born but I've never heard of a baby being confirmed a boy at birth then suddenly becoming a girl. Gender scans aren't 100% and in any case it's up to the parents to decide if/who they tell.

Olsi109 · 02/05/2022 20:13

If you're sure she won't hear it from anyone else then I would just tell her you don't know and if she keeps asking you'll give over speaking to her.

Or you could tell your siblings then her last and if she says anything say well I wanted to be able to tell people my own exciting news - I do this with my dad now because we could never tell people our own news if we told him first.

And I don't think not wanting coloured crap is wrong. I knew the colour palette I wanted for my baby (I didn't want a lot of clothes and wanted capsule wardrobes for each age to keep their wardrobes minimal). You could make it clear if she asks by saying it doesn't matter what sex it is as we will not put baby in any gender specific/pink/blue clothes anyway so I hope nobody wastes their money on them. As parents we know what we want and it's frustrating when people do the opposite and do their own thing.

Giraffesandbottom · 02/05/2022 20:11

I must admit I do find it odd when people at work who don’t know you or even randomers ask the sex and expect to be told

but why do you find it odd?! It’s not private, or shameful or a secret? Why would it be a secret, unless you want to build up some bizarre level of suspense over your own baby? Would you also try to keep it a secret when the baby is out? It’s as ridiculous not to tell someone if you know when it’s in your uterus, what’s the difference? It’s a baby boy or a baby girl.

parietal · 02/05/2022 20:07

no need to tell her. I didn't tell anyone the sex of my babies until they were born.

Crumpetloveliness · 02/05/2022 20:06

*can’t trust

OP posts:
Crumpetloveliness · 02/05/2022 20:06

To be fair I’m grateful for everyone’s thoughts, it’s made me realise that’s it’s not necessarily about baby. I’m disappointed that I can trust my DM

OP posts:
Crumpetloveliness · 02/05/2022 20:04

I am of course grateful for the thought but it’s somehow worse when it’s intentional, not sure that makes any sense!

OP posts:
ExtraOnion · 02/05/2022 20:04

How much gossip can you get out of the sex of a baby ?

It’s only news once .. and then it’s chip paper

Crumpetloveliness · 02/05/2022 20:04

@LightningAndRainbows you’re no doubt right in that she’ll just buy stuff later. I’m probably a bit sensitive but when you ask your DM to not get something explicitly and then she does exactly that it does make you question whether she’s gives a f**k or is doing to make herself happy

OP posts:
Noodledoodledoo · 02/05/2022 20:02

Could you tell your siblings first, if that was the main issue, take the sting out of her telling others. Get in there first.

Crumpetloveliness · 02/05/2022 20:01

I must admit I do find it odd when people at work who don’t know you or even randomers ask the sex and expect to be told. I do completely get not caring either way, especially when someone says they know but won’t say as though it’s a national secret. I disagree with it being narcissistic is this instance though.

OP posts:
BeaLola · 02/05/2022 20:01

Tell her when you want to but perhaps you tell your siblings first and then her

To be honest it's either a boy or a girl - only 2 choices- but a new baby - exciting

mummywithtwokidsplusdog · 02/05/2022 19:51

I can understand why you haven’t told her. Yes, some people might think you are being unkind, but it’s your news to share with who you wish- not hers.

surreygirl1987 · 02/05/2022 19:51

Hiding the sex of your baby when you know it yourself is strangely narcissistic IMO - like it’s such vital information it needs to be controlled. You aren’t Kate Middleton and the people asking aren’t the Daily Mail!

I fully agree, @Giraffesandbottom - I find this really bizarre. My old boss was pregnant and I asked if she knew the sex, just to be polite. She replied that they did know but they were keeping it a secret so "you'll just have to wait and see". I didn't tell her that I literally could could not care less and I found her really strange for thinking that it was important to anyone other than her, but there you go!

Maytodecember · 02/05/2022 19:48

Your baby, your choice. I’m a gran of 3 and it was my DD’s & partners choice what they told me and when.

LightningAndRainbows · 02/05/2022 19:43

She'll find out at some point and buy you loads of crap then. Just let her get it out her system you might like some of it. The rest you can sell.

Giraffesandbottom · 02/05/2022 19:40

Hiding the sex of your baby when you know it yourself is strangely narcissistic IMO - like it’s such vital information it needs to be controlled. You aren’t Kate Middleton and the people asking aren’t the Daily Mail! Just tell them - it’s pretty nasty given that many other people know.

baby names I still think are silly but I do understand as people can be rude. But the sex?!

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 02/05/2022 19:40

Ridiculous- I knew a family where the mil didn’t want to know and it slipped out regardless.
Honestly in not wanting to make it a big deal you are actually doing the opposite. Just tell her and move on.

WhatsHoppening · 02/05/2022 19:36

I do find it a bit weird about people who are weirdly cagey/sensitive about the sex of their baby. A good friend thought she was ‘winding me up’ as she knew and I didn’t (her baby’s sex) and she thought I was desperate to know. Didn’t have the heart to tell her I literally couldn’t give a hoot and made absolutely no difference to my life 🥴