Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Godchildren you don't see

60 replies

Spoldge45 · 02/05/2022 17:19

I was just wondering if anyone else has any godchildren, they don't see or spend time with, as i'm feeling a bit conflicted about a situation & wondered if I'm handling it the right way.

My oldest friend from school married & had children very young, I am Godmother to her eldest. At the time I was only in my early 20's, working full time with a busy life. I whole heartily admit I probably wasn't the greatest of godmothers back then. Tbh her pregnancy really took me by surprise, I had very busy life working & commuting at the time, I didn't have any experience of young children & In all honestly I wasn't really ready to take on such a role, something I now feel a little guilty about.

In hindsight I should have made more time and effort to see them at weekends etc..but my friend and I lives had gone in such different directions, she married a man who can be quite controlling (He didn't really like her going out/would always talk over her or answer questions for her etc..) and I used o feel very uncomfortable going to see her, that couple with the fact that our lives were on such different paths we kind of lost touch over the years that her children were small.

In more recent years I have made much more of an effect, I send all 3 of her children either a small gift or mostly as they are older now I give them money at Christmas, but I don't really 'see' them as such. I only see my friend 2/3x a year, usually just for a coffee & nearly always during the week when both our children are at school & I feel as though it would be a bit awkward meeting her children as they are all teens now and I haven't seen her husband for probably 10 years plus. I must add that despite his nature they are very happily married.

I think looking back if her husband hadn't made me feel so awkward and unwelcome back when the kids were little I may have developed more of a relationship with them, but I honestly don't know.

I have a daughter now also, myself but as we are not religious we didn't do the whole Godparents thing as we felt it was a bit hypocritical, so I've never experienced this from the other side.

I just wonder how common this whole situation is? Does anyone else have a similar situation? I often feel as though I'm not doing enough. I give them a present every Christmas, but for their birthdays, I just send a card, but then my husband will say 'well they don't give anything to our daughter' which is true, but that's not point and I'm not giving to receive.

Another issue I feel a bit confused/unsure of the etiquette is only one of my friends son's is my actual Godchild, but I've always felt that I can't give a present or money to just one, so I've always given to all 3? Is the norm also? Do other do this.

I'm probably reading far too much into the whole situation, I think what makes it harder, is my friend and her husband are both very religious, something I only really discovered a few years ago as my friend wasn't religious or ever went to church when we were younger & much closer friends and so to them the whole godparents situation, probably has much more significance than people who don't go to church etc..

I would really appreciate any views!! Thanks:)

OP posts:
Pickabearanybear · 03/05/2022 03:12

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

ThePoorWeeDonkey · 03/05/2022 03:03

I have the opposite situation. 3 of my child's godparents never bother. One is my brother and we are very close so spend a lot of time together as a family anyway but the other 3 (2 cousins and 1 of their dh) never bother at all. Even on the day of Baptism the couple didn't even get a card for my DC.
It makes me really sad as if I was ever lucky enough to be asked to be a godparent I'd like to think I'd play a role in that child's life.

teezletangler · 03/05/2022 02:57

I think this is the norm tbh. Only one of my DCs' godparents lives locally. She is a friend of mine and I see her regularly but usually during school hours so she doesn't see the child to whom she is godmother much at all.

One of my sister's godmothers was a great presence in our lives growing up, all the others not as much since they lived far away. But now as an adult I have quite a nice, although infrequent and mostly e-mail based relationship with all my godparents.

I come from quite a religious C of E family (we were very active, regular churchgoers) and none of my GPs, despite all being religious themselves, played any role whatsoever in my religious upbringing or ever spoke to me about religion! It's really a ceremonial role in practice.

TheLovleyChebbyMcGee · 03/05/2022 02:32

I'm not a god mother, but I dont see my godmother at all, aged 40. I remember going to see her as a child, but my mum chose her good friend, rather than someone who may be a good choice for the role. My god mother has never been close to me or maternal, I didn't even want to invite her to my wedding simply because I hadn't seen her in such a long time I'd forgotten she was my god mother, plus I'm not religious in any way!!

waitingpatientlyforspring · 03/05/2022 02:17

I think this is the risk when you choose non family god parents. When we had children I asked friends and colleagues who either their own godparents were or who did they choose for their children and were they still in touch with them/part of their lives. The majority of people whose god parents were friends, were either no longer in lives or played a very small part in their lives.

So you are by no means unusual to be in this situation.

In terms of presents. It would be strange to only give presents to one child. My husband's, sisters godmother (an exception to my rule above), always gave presents to both sil and dh, even though she was just godmother to sil. I think your friend is the weird one not reciprocating with your child.

1stTimeMama · 03/05/2022 00:54

I am Godmother to a niece and nephew, but have no relationship with them. I couldn't tell you the last time I saw my own Godparents, maybe when I was 6, and I'm nearly 40 now.
2 of my children have guardians, we had a thanksgiving instead of a christening, but we haven't seen them for about 4 or 5 years now.

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 02/05/2022 22:02

One believes men can be women

Is there anything on this site that doesn’t come back to the anti-trans agenda?

AlternativelyWired · 02/05/2022 21:12

My dcs' godparents are great. We message daily and see each other regularly. We consider them family. My own godparents are crap. They bought me a selection box one Christmas and that was it. I was really happy about it but my parents thought it was rubbish of them. They are both weird people and are actually family but might as well not be. My dcs' are a non-related aunt and uncle and much loved. They come to every birthday and share in all their achievements and help us through the tough times. They were shielded as was I but we still saw each other at the permitted distance on the doorstep and later on the garden as well as keeping in touch by phone. I've adopted them as my own godparents too as they have been like a second mum and dad to me.
The other godparents I chose are crap. The Catholic ones. The "real" ones (in the eyes of the Church). One believes men can be women, one is an alcoholic who put my dc at risk once, and the other just never bothered beyond the Baptism day even though we were close. I made poor choices with the Catholic ones but the others are perfect.

ENoeuf · 02/05/2022 20:56

I love being a godparent. I rarely see them but I do birthdays, postcards from holiday and random gifts so they know there is an adult thinking of them. My children benefit from the same relationship with their godchildren. I do believe in god and am willing to maintain a relationship incl residency if it was ever necessary if my godchildrens parents died / obviously hoping not.

greyinganddecaying · 02/05/2022 20:51

We've not seen our godchildren for many years - kept trying to arrange something but each time it was cancelled (not by us), so eventually gave up.

Keep sending cards for birthdays and Christmas but it's difficult as we don't really know them/know what to buy. Have decided to stop once they reach 18/21.

When we were asked to be godparents (for different children/families) we were both single and childless. We now have children (who don't have godparents as we've decided against infant baptism). None of the godchildren's families have acknowledged their birthdays/Christmas. Which is sad and feels a bit one-sided.

Mangogogogo · 02/05/2022 20:42

I adore my goddaughter but I mean, she’s my friends kid so I would anywya!

my daughters godparents are non existent. They do not give a shit and now they have their own kids I also do not give a shit

my sons godmother took on the role instead and she is fucking fantastic and I adore her kids too

bevelino · 02/05/2022 20:38

I am a godmother to a friends dd and we go to church regularly. I spoil her and love her to bits.

PowerhouseOfTheCell · 02/05/2022 20:33

My godfather was a crackhead and my godmother moved away without telling anyone in the middle of the night 15 years ago Hmm so don’t worry about setting the bar too low

FilthyforFirth · 02/05/2022 19:58

My one godchild so far is my neice, so I see her all the time. It is why I mainly picked family for my sons godparents. My best friend is very engaged with my eldest. I made the mistake of making another close friend godparent to my youngest on the basis she was living abroad but coming home soon. She has of course decided to stay now (its not close!) so I cant see her having any relationship to be honest.

littlesnowdropfairy · 02/05/2022 19:49

My aunt is my godmother, she is my fathers sister. I haven't seen her since I was 14, probably only met her a handful of times. She sent me a card with money in it when I was 12. She has never sent me a birthday card/Christmas card, ignored my communion, confirmation and my wedding too.
You are doing enough. Circumstances don't always allow for more than you've done. Don't beat yourself up.

Forgothowmuchlhatehomeschoolin · 02/05/2022 19:24

My Godchildren live 100 miles away so not easy to be a presence in their lives and l am friends with their dad more than their mum who seems to be the one who arranges things. If l ever suggest meeting up they are always too busy so l just make sure l always send a card and a gift on birthdays and Christmas. Maybe one day it will change.

GeorgiaGirl52 · 02/05/2022 19:20
  I am Godparent to one "child" who is now 37.  As a child I sent her birthday and Christmas gifts, but none to her two brothers - they had other godparents.  Also had her to visit for a week every summer, until they moved to another continent.
  As you are not very religious, perhaps you did not understand that the purpose of a Godparent was to help lead the child to the teachings of God.  When they reach the age of reason, your job is officially over.  Whether you continue contact or not is a personal decision between the two of you.  I have kept in touch and see her at least twice a year.
Cherrysoup · 02/05/2022 18:54

I’m godmother to my oldest school friend’s children, but we’re in pretty regular contact despite living 5 hours apart. We used to have the 3 dc every summer. One of them me it was ‘halcyon days’, made it all worth it.

However, my dh’s oldest friend’s child is his godchild and we barely see them, maybe once a year. The god child is 19 now, he literally puts his head round the door to say hello when we’re there then disappears. We’re godparents to other children but no longer in touch with the family. Life moves on.

Youhaveyourhandsfull · 02/05/2022 18:18

We are godparents to a friends daughter who’s about 15 now I’d guess. Our friends moved so didn’t see them, then divorced unfortunately and our lives just drifted completely. I think we last saw them (pre divorce) in 2012. Friends move on and that’s fine, but I admit this is a friendship I miss quite a lot.

Squealier · 02/05/2022 18:14

@breakdown19 yes in my mind very very similar. It's about binding someone to you (or trying to) and in my case it was fairly exploitative. People who ask you to do these roles want the same things - your time, money, energy etc. and I give all that freely but now only to the people I love.

Wombat98 · 02/05/2022 18:14

I lost touch with mine. Got them presents and stuff for years but realised their mum was a bit of a CFer, wanting to stay when here on holiday and stuff bought for them. Mysteriously was always awol if I needed support. She was also abusive to her DH, who was a bit nasty to her back and I got fed up of the drama.

Moomeh · 02/05/2022 18:11

Squealier · 02/05/2022 18:00

I am godparent to a few kids just as I was bridesmaid to a few brides. I've not been a good godmother (and wasn't a good bridesmaid) but I also wish I had said no to all of the requests. I was not good at protecting my boundaries when I was younger.

Now I prioritise my family and a very small number of very good friends. If I had infinite time and energy I would've done more.

I was just about to say something comparing godparents to bridemaids too.

When you ask someone to be your bridesmaid, they're important in your life at that moment in time. They're helping celebrate your marriage. I think asking someone to be a godparent is similar: they're important to your family at that moment, helping celebrate your baby. I don't think it's reasonable to hold them to a lasting obligation to your child, especially if they're not related in any other way!

So yanbu to withdraw gradually from this family. It doesn't sound as if they make an effort with your dd.

lightand · 02/05/2022 18:10

You are doing better than I did.
Sadly my Godchild has died.
Her parents were on again, off again, relationship wise. Sometimes mum and children were unreachable for a couple of years for example.
I perhaps should have done more. I dont know. They all practically became estranged from all their relatives for a lot of the time.

You seem to be doing well to me, op.

HandlebarLadyTash · 02/05/2022 18:09

God children is a load of bollocks. The parents want a party & attention. The only godchild I am involved with hasnt been into a church since the day of the christening.

ParkheadParadise · 02/05/2022 18:05

I see ALL my Godchildren. I'm related to most of them. 😀😀
5 of them are my nieces and nephews.

Swipe left for the next trending thread