Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that Boris bringing back the 'Right to buy' scheme from the 80s is a terrible idea

510 replies

somewhereoverthechipshop · 02/05/2022 14:00

Just this really. I think it's a slap in the face for all those private renters who cannot afford to buy a home, and just a horrible idea.
Boris Johnson mulls a new Right to Buy scheme as housebuilding hits the curb (cityam.com)

Not sure if link above works, but you can google it.
Evidently he is 'mulling over' the idea of bringing back Margaret Thatcher's scheme from the late 80s that decimated this country's council housing stock.
Just wondered what other people thought about it?

OP posts:
Waxonwaxoff0 · 09/05/2022 06:59

Blossomtoes · 09/05/2022 06:55

Yup. They’re certainly not persuading me.

Just making themselves look worse with every post. So desperate to prove they're not bad people and then start in with the "lazy people on benefits" trope. True colours always show.

JustAnotherPoster00 · 09/05/2022 06:58

The people on here defending landlords are just proving my point to be honest. A bunch of selfish, privileged, "I'm alright Jack" types looking down on people worse off than themselves. No wonder no one has any sympathy for landlords.

The people on here defending landlords parasites just proving my point to be honest. A bunch of selfish, privileged, "I'm alright Jack" types looking down on people worse off than themselves. No wonder no one has any sympathy for landlords parasites.

Fixed it for you

Blossomtoes · 09/05/2022 06:55

Yup. They’re certainly not persuading me.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 09/05/2022 06:47

The people on here defending landlords are just proving my point to be honest. A bunch of selfish, privileged, "I'm alright Jack" types looking down on people worse off than themselves. No wonder no one has any sympathy for landlords.

itsgettingweird · 09/05/2022 06:47

MangyInseam · 02/05/2022 14:25

I think it would depend on how it was structured and also what other policies went along with it.

Theoretically I think that, just as there is something to be said for taking low income rental housing out of the hands of developers, there may be something to be said for taking the creation of housing to be purchased by lower income people out of the hands of developers.

Either way though it depends on there being enough housing.

Agree with this.

I live in a HA flat. Lived in it from when it was built. Assured tenancy.

So technically although it's HA stock officially I can live in it until death and then ds can take it on.

I wonder if it'll benefit the economy more if I bought it and paid interest on the mortgage?

but I do think it's not as simple as it reducing the stock as once occupied it's not "available" anyway.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 09/05/2022 06:41

Acidburn · 08/05/2022 20:13

@Waxonwaxoff0 SOME people on benefits barely get by, and SOME successfully cheat the system. Denying it is ridiculous.
Or how about people like Bob Crow, ex TFL boss? He was on 145k a year, but he wouldn't move out of his council flat until the day he died! How is that fair? Or it is ok because he was entitled to it?
Every single person has a unique set of circumstances and the reasons why they are barely getting by, you can't just generalise. Some people are disabled and can't work, some people don't have high aspirations, and some have adopted a lifestyle of being lazy and relying on benefits because it's easier than working full time. People are different! Landlords can be different too.

You clearly do not understand the benefits system. You cannot just "choose" to stay on benefits and not work full time, unless you are a single parent with a young child that needs childcare, and a single parent looking after a young child with no help is hardly lazy, unless you think SAHPs are lazy.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 09/05/2022 06:39

Zeus44 · 08/05/2022 22:27

Fundamentally the benefits system allows for people to only work a little and claim a lot. It doesn’t make sense for people to go and work as they can do 16 hours and get the rest of their benefits.

I mean seriously, why would anyone do 40+ hours a week for the same money as doing 16 when the difference is given to you for free?!

The whole ‘best the landlord’ gets so boring. Self help or no help is the only way forward.

Cut all the benefits down and make it impossible to make it better off on them than actual work. Then we will see all these vacant positions filled instead of people taking and not giving.

You don't get the same in benefits as you do working a 40 hour week. Benefits are always LESS. You clearly don't understand the system.

Blossomtoes · 09/05/2022 04:53

Zeus44 · 08/05/2022 22:27

Fundamentally the benefits system allows for people to only work a little and claim a lot. It doesn’t make sense for people to go and work as they can do 16 hours and get the rest of their benefits.

I mean seriously, why would anyone do 40+ hours a week for the same money as doing 16 when the difference is given to you for free?!

The whole ‘best the landlord’ gets so boring. Self help or no help is the only way forward.

Cut all the benefits down and make it impossible to make it better off on them than actual work. Then we will see all these vacant positions filled instead of people taking and not giving.

The ignorance here is mind blowing. Benefits - apart from the state pension - are already set at levels whereby claimants would be better off working full time for minimum wage.

Between exploiting renters and benefits bashing, you’re doing a stellar impersonation of a “grind the faces of the poor” Dickens character.

mmmmmmghturep · 09/05/2022 02:39

@Zeus44 Bet you expected them to wear a mask to protect you though, oh yes it was "we are all in this together" then. Different now eh. Back to the default setting.

Zeus44 · 08/05/2022 22:28

‘Beat the landlord’

Zeus44 · 08/05/2022 22:27

Fundamentally the benefits system allows for people to only work a little and claim a lot. It doesn’t make sense for people to go and work as they can do 16 hours and get the rest of their benefits.

I mean seriously, why would anyone do 40+ hours a week for the same money as doing 16 when the difference is given to you for free?!

The whole ‘best the landlord’ gets so boring. Self help or no help is the only way forward.

Cut all the benefits down and make it impossible to make it better off on them than actual work. Then we will see all these vacant positions filled instead of people taking and not giving.

Acidburn · 08/05/2022 20:13

@Waxonwaxoff0 SOME people on benefits barely get by, and SOME successfully cheat the system. Denying it is ridiculous.
Or how about people like Bob Crow, ex TFL boss? He was on 145k a year, but he wouldn't move out of his council flat until the day he died! How is that fair? Or it is ok because he was entitled to it?
Every single person has a unique set of circumstances and the reasons why they are barely getting by, you can't just generalise. Some people are disabled and can't work, some people don't have high aspirations, and some have adopted a lifestyle of being lazy and relying on benefits because it's easier than working full time. People are different! Landlords can be different too.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 08/05/2022 18:50

Acidburn · 08/05/2022 18:17

@Waxonwaxoff0 and that is very noble of you, honestly. But these landlords are not doing anything illegal, they are not "exploiting people", that is overly dramatic of you to word it like that. If we say that people should do what they are entitled to - even if it's morally wrong - then anyone can buy as many properties as they wish to, same as claiming any benefits that are there to be claimed. You can't have it both ways. Again, this is capitalism. Because if you are going to punish landlords - then we need to rework the benefits system too, so those ones who cheat it will not be able to get away with it. You know, those who pretend to live alone but actually have their partners living with them, those who purposely cut their working hours so they don't loose any UC.

No. It's not remotely comparable. Because having to rely on benefits is a punishment in itself. People on benefits are barely getting by. You can hardly say the same about a landlord with 10 properties.

Acidburn · 08/05/2022 18:17

@Waxonwaxoff0 and that is very noble of you, honestly. But these landlords are not doing anything illegal, they are not "exploiting people", that is overly dramatic of you to word it like that. If we say that people should do what they are entitled to - even if it's morally wrong - then anyone can buy as many properties as they wish to, same as claiming any benefits that are there to be claimed. You can't have it both ways. Again, this is capitalism. Because if you are going to punish landlords - then we need to rework the benefits system too, so those ones who cheat it will not be able to get away with it. You know, those who pretend to live alone but actually have their partners living with them, those who purposely cut their working hours so they don't loose any UC.

Zeus44 · 08/05/2022 13:57

Spot on.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 08/05/2022 11:35

Acidburn · 07/05/2022 21:48

@Waxonwaxoff0 you don't wish you had an extra income that made your live a little easier? Ok, each to their own. But some people do, that's why they buy multiple properties, if they can afford them. They are entitled to it, it's a free market.

Of course I do. But I don't wish to have the extra income through multiple properties. I don't want extra income through exploiting people. The same way I wouldn't want to do a MLM for extra income, because to me it's morally bankrupt.

SomePeopleAreJustIdiots · 08/05/2022 09:47

Ex council in our block are generally more sought after than the private nearby. Much lower service charges, much better maintenance. The most expensive are £1million which is on par with other blocks. There are new builds private that are several million but they seem to be struggling to sell (they have a river view and we do not)

Blossomtoes · 08/05/2022 07:14

Villagewaspbyke · 07/05/2022 22:27

@Blossomtoes there are lots of people desperate for housing but either they don’t want to live in those areas or the council are not renting to them. Properties are boarded up and demolished. It’s the same up and down the country (although not in London anymore).

of course lots of ex council housing is popular too. But it will almost always have a discount to private housing. Partly it’s the areas, sometimes it’s other things. But as I said, it’s generally poor value to the taxpayer.

Sadly, you’re wrong again. The ex council properties I described sell at a premium, they’re better built with bigger rooms and huge plots. They go for way more than the new builds that are being thrown up.

There’s no taxpayer involvement, I explained to you that social housing is financed commercially. If there are boarded up social housing properties it’s because the council or housing association that owns them is negligent in its duty to refurbish them and get them occupied. I flatly refuse that people turn down a secure tenancy to a property they can make a real home because they don’t fancy it.

Villagewaspbyke · 07/05/2022 22:27

Blossomtoes · 07/05/2022 06:41

If that were true, it would be be because all the great post war council stock is now in private hands. Where I live those are solidly built houses on huge plots. On the rare occasion they come on the market they sell in a matter of days. People are desperate for homes, you won’t find people on who have been on a waiting list for years turning their nose up at what they’re offered.

@Blossomtoes there are lots of people desperate for housing but either they don’t want to live in those areas or the council are not renting to them. Properties are boarded up and demolished. It’s the same up and down the country (although not in London anymore).

of course lots of ex council housing is popular too. But it will almost always have a discount to private housing. Partly it’s the areas, sometimes it’s other things. But as I said, it’s generally poor value to the taxpayer.

Acidburn · 07/05/2022 21:48

@Waxonwaxoff0 you don't wish you had an extra income that made your live a little easier? Ok, each to their own. But some people do, that's why they buy multiple properties, if they can afford them. They are entitled to it, it's a free market.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 07/05/2022 21:39

Acidburn · 07/05/2022 20:58

This is kind of funny actually. Whenever someone posts benefits bashing thread - there is a brigade saying "if people are entitled to these benefits, they should claim them". So how is this any different? Council tenants are entitled to buy their houses via RTB, the end of story. Yes, it might not be a good thing long-term for the social housing stock, but it might be the only chance for someone to own their home, so obviously they will go for it, and no one should be blaming them.
And all this landlord bashing comes from envy. We all wish we had multiple properties to rent without having to go to work everyday - I definitely do. But I am not a landlord, so I have to make my own way to make money. This is capitalism. If you are not smart or lucky enough to own assets - that is unfortunate, but that is life, and keeping resentment towards someone who is more fortunate is just not productive.

No, we do not all wish we had multiple properties. I do not wish I had multiple properties. Don't speak for other people.

Rosebel · 07/05/2022 21:25

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 07/05/2022 06:30

I don't agree with right to buy at all. If they do, they shouldn't be able to sell it for full market value. Its a slap in the face to those who've brought homes at full price.

So only those on good wages deserve to own a house? People on minimum wage should just shut up and be grateful for whatever crumbs they get from the rich man's table.

Acidburn · 07/05/2022 20:58

This is kind of funny actually. Whenever someone posts benefits bashing thread - there is a brigade saying "if people are entitled to these benefits, they should claim them". So how is this any different? Council tenants are entitled to buy their houses via RTB, the end of story. Yes, it might not be a good thing long-term for the social housing stock, but it might be the only chance for someone to own their home, so obviously they will go for it, and no one should be blaming them.
And all this landlord bashing comes from envy. We all wish we had multiple properties to rent without having to go to work everyday - I definitely do. But I am not a landlord, so I have to make my own way to make money. This is capitalism. If you are not smart or lucky enough to own assets - that is unfortunate, but that is life, and keeping resentment towards someone who is more fortunate is just not productive.

Alexandra2001 · 07/05/2022 08:09

Villagewaspbyke · 07/05/2022 06:20

@Alexandra2001 also council housing didn’t really work all that well in terms of actual housing. A lot of housing where I grew up has actually been demolished as people don’t want to live there no matter how desperate

Sure, nothing is perfect and big problems with some of the v large council estates but the UK didn't have the homelessness it has now.

The large estates in nr me got demolished too, more to do with the quality of the build,/reputation of the area, the smaller more localised estates in villages and small towns used to work well, all sold off now and DesRes.

Equally has the move to almost 100% private rental sector working? maybe we need a more mixed rent sector?

Blossomtoes · 07/05/2022 06:45

The government give billions of subsidies each year to housing associations and councils to provide or maintain social housing. It is subsidized (not saying whether or not it should be, but it is)

That isn’t the case.

Housing associations borrow money to pay for new homes and improvements. After the Housing Act 1988, the proportion of the cost of new homes met by capital grant was scaled back by the Government, so borrowing became the primary source of funding for investment. Much of this was simply borrowed from banks and building societies, but after the late-2000s financial crisis these institutions ceased to offer long-term loans, so developing associations are increasingly turning to corporate bonds to raise funds for expansion.[12]