Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that Boris bringing back the 'Right to buy' scheme from the 80s is a terrible idea

510 replies

somewhereoverthechipshop · 02/05/2022 14:00

Just this really. I think it's a slap in the face for all those private renters who cannot afford to buy a home, and just a horrible idea.
Boris Johnson mulls a new Right to Buy scheme as housebuilding hits the curb (cityam.com)

Not sure if link above works, but you can google it.
Evidently he is 'mulling over' the idea of bringing back Margaret Thatcher's scheme from the late 80s that decimated this country's council housing stock.
Just wondered what other people thought about it?

OP posts:
newnamethanks · 02/05/2022 14:38

Vote buying and bribery. Worked fine for Thatcher would probably work for Big Dog. Meanwhile, in tent city . . .

Babyroobs · 02/05/2022 14:37

How is all this in any way fair to young people who stand no chance of ever getting a HA property. Between bloody greedy people buying up multiple properties and this kind of thing they don't stand a chance.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 02/05/2022 14:36

Getoff · 02/05/2022 14:31

HA houses and council houses are supposed to be for those who have no hope of buying. If they all get sold off on the cheap the poorest will have to fork out for extortionate private rental costs!

This comment illustrates why social housing should not exist, at least in its present form. People think the reason for it is to provide cheaper housing. The only purpose should be to provide good corporate landlords, and security of tenure that is better than the private sector is offering. Everyone should pay the market cost for housing. Those who can't afford housing can be assisted by housing benefit, regardless of what kind of landlord they have.

The way housing should work is that corporate landlords, whether local authorities, housing assoications or private companies, should offer their housing stock to the highest-bidder. There would be no waiting lists and the only filtering criteria would be whether the person was trusted to pay the rent. For the non-profit landlords, any excess revenues would be reinvested in building or acquiring more properties.

Housing benefit is a targeted benefit that helps those in need. Providing social housing, with below-market rents is a hugely wasteful way of subsidising people, because the subsidy doesn't change when their circumstances do.

Working people don't get housing benefit though. And housing benefit is capped at well below market value. Housing benefit for a 2 bed property in my area is around £520pm, the cheapest private rental for a 2 bed is around £695pm.

PurassicJark · 02/05/2022 14:36

It's a shit idea and always has been. If you're in council housing, you're supposed to be needing the help, not getting a cheap way onto the property ladder.

Unfortunately not everyone will own a home, as much as that sucks, that's life. We can't all be directors, surgeons, solicitors, financial advisors etc. We aren't all going to earn the same or even a decent amount sometimes.

To allow those that got a cheaper house because they are struggling to buy it, and leave those who earn outwith that scheme but not enough to buy to have nothing, that's disgraceful. You're giving a leg up to those who probably can't afford any issues that go wrong with the house and so end up with a damaged house or having to sell it, and ignoring the middle ground people are too 'rich' to qualify for any help, but too poor to afford a house.

Doesn't surprise me though that he'd want to extend it or whatever to get votes. Not that he needs to, the public are going to vote him back in regardless of what he does.

naughty40me · 02/05/2022 14:36

As a private renter who is now waiting for court proceedings from my new landlord this really is a bad idea.

Through no fault of my own I am being made homeless.

The council have awarded us a Housing Duty but the council houses are few and far between.

We will end up in temporary miles away whilst my son is in the middle of his GCSEs.

All because I can't get another private rental as I am on housing benefit and disability benefit. I'm deemed not worthy despite paying every bill ever for the 10 years I've been here.

Oh and the new landlord who is a millionaire investor with a huge amount of properties and new build projects.

He wanted to increase my rent by £210 pcm. My contract says he couldn't so eviction it is then.

I didnt used to be poor, I'm not a bad person. But myself and my children are at the mercy of such ruthless people.

He even removed the dining room doors as the council deemed them a hazard. Instead of using safety glass or a protective film he removed the doors completely.

So we've spent winter with a curtain up to keep warm.
The place is mouldy and needs a rewire. It's dated. The carpets are threadbare. No underlay.

But the guy wants an extra £210pcm for this standard. He's a local man, been in the shops bragging about how much he can get away with charging people.

I've got the MP involved. He is being investigated.

There is a need for social housing. LHA rates do not cover local rental prices either. It's soul destroying.

People need homes.

Neverreturntoathread · 02/05/2022 14:35

I know two people (perfectly well off afult homeowners) who made a LOT of money buying their parent’s council home on the basis that they once lived there. Very unfair.

If they do anything like this it should be for the current occupant only, not their children.

ilovesooty · 02/05/2022 14:35

AnyFucker · 02/05/2022 14:02

What on earth for ????

Because he thinks it will make him popular. He doesn't care about whether it benefits people or addresses the housing crisis.

lollipoprainbow · 02/05/2022 14:33

@Basketet same it's infuriating

JanetPluchinsky · 02/05/2022 14:32

It’s a horrible idea.

The HA houses on my estate are beautiful and well maintained, the tenants benefit from much lower than market rent and secure tenancies. If they can then buy them at 30% less than the almost identical privately owned houses next door, I think that’s a huge slap in the face. It would be a more than 100k saving.

itsjustnotok · 02/05/2022 14:31

It should not be allowed. It annoys me no end. I pay nearly triple what my friend does for a smaller house than hers and she’s banging on about how she’s honing to buy it and yet is too skint to pay for electric. The purpose of these houses is for those on lower income who cannot afford private rent. There are plenty of people who privately rent who would love the same opportunity who pay through the nose in comparison. There’s a housing shortage…I wonder why.

Getoff · 02/05/2022 14:31

HA houses and council houses are supposed to be for those who have no hope of buying. If they all get sold off on the cheap the poorest will have to fork out for extortionate private rental costs!

This comment illustrates why social housing should not exist, at least in its present form. People think the reason for it is to provide cheaper housing. The only purpose should be to provide good corporate landlords, and security of tenure that is better than the private sector is offering. Everyone should pay the market cost for housing. Those who can't afford housing can be assisted by housing benefit, regardless of what kind of landlord they have.

The way housing should work is that corporate landlords, whether local authorities, housing assoications or private companies, should offer their housing stock to the highest-bidder. There would be no waiting lists and the only filtering criteria would be whether the person was trusted to pay the rent. For the non-profit landlords, any excess revenues would be reinvested in building or acquiring more properties.

Housing benefit is a targeted benefit that helps those in need. Providing social housing, with below-market rents is a hugely wasteful way of subsidising people, because the subsidy doesn't change when their circumstances do.

maddening · 02/05/2022 14:29

We still have a right to buy policy currently in practice- my friend has it for her council house if she chose to do it?

AnyFucker · 02/05/2022 14:28

*rents

AnyFucker · 02/05/2022 14:28

When people say there should be a “hefty” tax on income from 2nd homes etc what exactly do you mean ? More than that already applied which equates to the same taxation as any other income ?

or what ? 50% ?

then private landlords will sell in their droves, reducing the pot of private rentals, thus increasing demand pushing up tents even further

be careful what you wish for

Fidodidit · 02/05/2022 14:25

Ah, cross post

MangyInseam · 02/05/2022 14:25

I think it would depend on how it was structured and also what other policies went along with it.

Theoretically I think that, just as there is something to be said for taking low income rental housing out of the hands of developers, there may be something to be said for taking the creation of housing to be purchased by lower income people out of the hands of developers.

Either way though it depends on there being enough housing.

Fidodidit · 02/05/2022 14:25

Maybe a scheme where private renters could have the right to buy their property after a period of time - with restrictions on reasons they could be served notice and how much rents could be raised by to stop those being a tool that prevent it.

CounsellorTroi · 02/05/2022 14:23

There should be a hefty tax on all properties owned that are not primary residences including rented out, second and holiday rentals.

Remainiac · 02/05/2022 14:22

How about introducing a right to buy your privately rented property from your landlord subject to certain conditions- length of lease / occupancy not being one of them?

MissWired · 02/05/2022 14:22

The right to buy scheme never ended for council properties. I have a council flat and could buy it if I wanted to (and would if it wasn't leasehold.)

I assume this is an extension of the scheme to Housing Association properties, which has been discussed for some time?

A far better plan would be to implement strict rent controls and heavy taxation on BTL portfolios. Which is never ever going to happen, alas.

Muckymaisonette · 02/05/2022 14:21

He must be desperate for votes!

Waxonwaxoff0 · 02/05/2022 14:20

Far better to bring in a cap on how much rent a LL can charge and a cap on how many properties someone can own. No one should be allowed to own more than 2 properties. I don't want to hear any "poor landlord" sob stories either, if you own a house that you rent out you are in a position that's WORLDS away from most people, you are not someone to be sympathised with.

Alexandra2001 · 02/05/2022 14:19

Babyroobs · 02/05/2022 14:13

Can't imagine HA wanting to sell off stock ? Why would they?

They'll be forced too, with the tax payer subsidising the cost of the property.

This idea was looked at in 2015 and rejected as unworkable and unfair, so no surprise BJ is looking at it.

Is this really his answer to millions of families who cannot afford to heat themselves and face rising food costs too?

goldfinchfan · 02/05/2022 14:18

It is a terrible idea. There will be less housing available that is affordable for people. The council house sell meant most of the decent properties vanished forever in the rental zone.
In some parts of the country there is almost no rental properties but there is still the need for them.
Low paid workers. Even average paid workers need a place to live that they can afford.
This sell off yet again suits the rich.

HRTQueen · 02/05/2022 14:17

I agree with capping how many properties you can own

and the taxes to increase