Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that Boris bringing back the 'Right to buy' scheme from the 80s is a terrible idea

510 replies

somewhereoverthechipshop · 02/05/2022 14:00

Just this really. I think it's a slap in the face for all those private renters who cannot afford to buy a home, and just a horrible idea.
Boris Johnson mulls a new Right to Buy scheme as housebuilding hits the curb (cityam.com)

Not sure if link above works, but you can google it.
Evidently he is 'mulling over' the idea of bringing back Margaret Thatcher's scheme from the late 80s that decimated this country's council housing stock.
Just wondered what other people thought about it?

OP posts:
woodenwindchimes · 02/05/2022 17:09

itsjustnotok · 02/05/2022 14:31

It should not be allowed. It annoys me no end. I pay nearly triple what my friend does for a smaller house than hers and she’s banging on about how she’s honing to buy it and yet is too skint to pay for electric. The purpose of these houses is for those on lower income who cannot afford private rent. There are plenty of people who privately rent who would love the same opportunity who pay through the nose in comparison. There’s a housing shortage…I wonder why.

But what's your problem with it though? If you think her situation is so much better why didn't you take that route yourself?

woodenwindchimes · 02/05/2022 17:08

Getoff · 02/05/2022 14:31

HA houses and council houses are supposed to be for those who have no hope of buying. If they all get sold off on the cheap the poorest will have to fork out for extortionate private rental costs!

This comment illustrates why social housing should not exist, at least in its present form. People think the reason for it is to provide cheaper housing. The only purpose should be to provide good corporate landlords, and security of tenure that is better than the private sector is offering. Everyone should pay the market cost for housing. Those who can't afford housing can be assisted by housing benefit, regardless of what kind of landlord they have.

The way housing should work is that corporate landlords, whether local authorities, housing assoications or private companies, should offer their housing stock to the highest-bidder. There would be no waiting lists and the only filtering criteria would be whether the person was trusted to pay the rent. For the non-profit landlords, any excess revenues would be reinvested in building or acquiring more properties.

Housing benefit is a targeted benefit that helps those in need. Providing social housing, with below-market rents is a hugely wasteful way of subsidising people, because the subsidy doesn't change when their circumstances do.

Everyone should pay the market cost for housing?

Can I ask you why you believe this?

Also, what is the market cost for housing? Say, per month? (in your observation)

I'm interested why you hold these opinions and what exactly they mean in real terms.

JingsWullie · 02/05/2022 17:07

@FairyCakeWings so they could rent then couldn't they? That's what people on this thread think council tenants should do, even if it makes more sense for them to buy.

(And yes, I'm pointing out the absurdity rather than seriously suggesting it.)

HandlebarLadyTash · 02/05/2022 17:06

Why,
There a not enough property's in the first place.
We need social housing available to everyone who needs a affordable secure home.

FairyCakeWings · 02/05/2022 17:04

JingsWullie · 02/05/2022 16:36

People do what makes sense for them within the limits of policy according to the circumstance they're in.

How many homeowners turn down the extra money when they come to sell and they can get £100k more for their house than they paid for it? They're not exactly helping to resolve the housing crisis themselves, are they?

In most cases wouldn’t be able to afford to turn it down even if they wanted to. All the other properties have risen by the same amount and selling and buying houses costs money too.

Very few people benefit from house price rises in any real sense. The benefits all belong to the banks.

woodenwindchimes · 02/05/2022 17:02

goldfinchfan · 02/05/2022 14:18

It is a terrible idea. There will be less housing available that is affordable for people. The council house sell meant most of the decent properties vanished forever in the rental zone.
In some parts of the country there is almost no rental properties but there is still the need for them.
Low paid workers. Even average paid workers need a place to live that they can afford.
This sell off yet again suits the rich.

How does it suit the rich?

I do believe you have to actually live in the home you buy? You can't buy it at the discount and then rent it - you wouldn't be allowed.

balalake · 02/05/2022 17:02

My guess is that it is an idea being floated in advance of Thursday's local elections. Aside from very few council houses in any case, most of those in them or indeed 'generation rent' as a whole could not raise the deposit sufficient for a mortgage at a reasonable interest rate.

Dog whistle or dead cat politics. Might not happen.

JingsWullie · 02/05/2022 17:02

Sorry those comments were to @pixie5121.

JingsWullie · 02/05/2022 17:00

Although if you can afford to buy obviously it's not worth bothering. But then there's no issue is there really.

JingsWullie · 02/05/2022 16:58

Ok. I mean I think you have a number of misunderstandings about how housing allocation works. You just need to be in housing need. Which you are if you're being evicted. You'd be in more need if you were vulnerable in some way eg if you had a dependent child but you say you're disabled so you're vulnerable on that front. Income is irrelevant although it can help to be in employment for housing associations because they'll often ask for employer and previous landlord references and they like it if you've not been in arrears and have a good steady history.

It's worth giving it a go isn't it? You can still look for private rentals as well.

DD7Superstar · 02/05/2022 16:56

I live in a HA with a life time tenancy, I don't see why I need to buy it. At least when I'm done the property becomes available for someone else.

Abblebee · 02/05/2022 16:56

superplumb · 02/05/2022 16:53

Awful idea. no reason why people should be able to buy a heavily discounted house after being lucky to be given one, only to sell years later for a huge profit. I used to work in conveyancing and many were quids in after their 2 year wait...then I worked with dv victims and children who had nowhere to go and escape to because the council housing had been sold off!!

I know. It should be a safety net for those in their time of need.

Florrey · 02/05/2022 16:55

I grew up on an council estate. Decent sized 3 bed houses with gardens and a shared play area, ideal for families who couldn’t afford homes. We lived in the same house my entire childhood with no concerns about eviction etc, we were able to treat it as our own home. Eventually my parents moved to a council bungalow elsewhere and another family got the house.

Over the years all of the houses have been sold for a huge discount, so now they aren’t available for families any more. The available council housing in the village is flats, sheltered accommodation for the elderly, and a few scratty little houses with no gardens which were obviously not profitable enough for the tenants to have bothered buying. I don’t think it was a good idea to sell off all of the family homes because now other families can’t benefit from the secure tenancy and space that we had.

pixie5121 · 02/05/2022 16:53

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request.

superplumb · 02/05/2022 16:53

Awful idea. no reason why people should be able to buy a heavily discounted house after being lucky to be given one, only to sell years later for a huge profit. I used to work in conveyancing and many were quids in after their 2 year wait...then I worked with dv victims and children who had nowhere to go and escape to because the council housing had been sold off!!

JingsWullie · 02/05/2022 16:50

Also get your GP to write a letter in support - your housing situation is exacerbating your disability yadda yadda (it will be if you think about it) and see how you go. Get on the list, get bidding, contact your councillor and MP. Good luck.

Blossomtoes · 02/05/2022 16:49

Many of the properties are only available to buy via auction - what's all that about?

Possibly unmortgageable?

JingsWullie · 02/05/2022 16:49

@pixie5121 sorry to hear.

As you're being evicted you should be considered threatened homeless. Contact your council and housing associations and tell them you are threatened homeless and that you wish to be considered for housing.

woodenwindchimes · 02/05/2022 16:48

MissWired · 02/05/2022 14:22

The right to buy scheme never ended for council properties. I have a council flat and could buy it if I wanted to (and would if it wasn't leasehold.)

I assume this is an extension of the scheme to Housing Association properties, which has been discussed for some time?

A far better plan would be to implement strict rent controls and heavy taxation on BTL portfolios. Which is never ever going to happen, alas.

I don't understand because with many HAs you can buy. Must just be extending to more or all HAs, but don't see how it's that big of a change that it needs such headline coverage.

pixie5121 · 02/05/2022 16:46

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request.

woodenwindchimes · 02/05/2022 16:46

x2boys · 02/05/2022 14:03

I thought people still had the right to buy /acquire?

I'm confused also as if you have a HA or Council property yes, you can buy after five years at a discounted price.

JingsWullie · 02/05/2022 16:43

@MangyInseam I really don't know. It feels like we've gone through a bit of a sea change since 2008. Money doesn't mean the same, wages don't mean the same, economies don't work the same, since then. The global asset market is booming like never before - people like Christie's can't get stuff out fast enough, nor can property developers. Because of our laissez-faire attitude to the provision of housing in the UK and our baseline inequalities, we're seeing more people at the sharp end than more regulated flatter economies but it's a worldwide movement that has been going on for over a decade. Is it even possible to pull back from that now, especially in the UK when we are economically isolated?

MangyInseam · 02/05/2022 16:36

JingsWullie · 02/05/2022 16:29

@MangyInseam agree with you. On a macro level having more people with the economic choices that home ownership brings especially once past working age, has a lot going for it. Also on a personal level it works better for many, again especially once past working age.

It's the wider context that this is happening in - property as asset class in the era of deregulation and quantitative easing- together with the deliberate refusal to ringfence proceeds, that makes it problematic.

Yes, and it's your second paragraph that I wonder about. What to do about that? Is there a better model? One that is actually politically viable?

JingsWullie · 02/05/2022 16:36

People do what makes sense for them within the limits of policy according to the circumstance they're in.

How many homeowners turn down the extra money when they come to sell and they can get £100k more for their house than they paid for it? They're not exactly helping to resolve the housing crisis themselves, are they?

doublemonkey · 02/05/2022 16:35

If councils had used the right to buy money they got to build new housing there wouldn't be a problem.