Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Mumsnet doesnt deserve its reputation

113 replies

pebimo6 · 02/05/2022 09:29

Used to post on the feminism board here a few years ago but moved on.

Was reading a thread just about Mumsnet and I think more specifically about aibu. Thought I'd check in again and can't really find any of the silly threads, all seems boringly normal

To think Mumsnet doesnt deserve its reputation
To think Mumsnet doesnt deserve its reputation
To think Mumsnet doesnt deserve its reputation
OP posts:
ThreeLocusts · 02/05/2022 11:08

I think of mumsnet as an endless online garden fence - such a fence being, in my mother tongue, the classical site for women 'tattling', 'gossiping' etc, in short, engaging in conversation classified as trivial. For sexist reasons, obviously.

I find it fascinating because it's really the only place I know where women treat men with the same kind of off-hand dismissiveness that men very often apply to women, especially in professional contexts. Whereas on mn men are dismissed with regard to parenting and household skills.

It's an upside down world and full of evidence of how far we still are from anything approaching equality between women and men.

JanisMoplin · 02/05/2022 10:57

The keeping horses thread was bonkers! But again, those threads are quite rare. The majority of threads are quite sensible and often even eye-opening, like the threads about Ukraine or other world affairs. The press never talk about those. Probably because it is assumed that mums do only two things: potty train and try to drum up hate against transpeople.

Changechangychange · 02/05/2022 10:56

LovelaceBiggWither · 02/05/2022 10:46

Bless, you have not ventured very far on reddit if you 'like the rest of reddit'. All of reddit?

Ok, “some other parts of Reddit”! I just meant I don’t have a problem with Reddit itself (which plenty of people do). There are obviously horrible parts of it, which are easy to avoid. Much like Facebook and Twitter.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 02/05/2022 10:52

What adds to MN's batshit reputation is the fact people can name change as often as they want (something a lot of other forums will ban you for). So people can basically 'be whoever they want' at any given time, to back their argument.

Yes I agree. I do think name changing should be kept though for privacy reasons. It's just something you need to bear in mind when you interact with anon people online.

TheKeatingFive · 02/05/2022 10:50

I always enjoy the following threads ...

Loo brush
Shoes on/off
Money as wedding presents
Anything regarding hot tubs

sadly they are not as plentiful or bitterly contested as they used to be 😂

worraliberty · 02/05/2022 10:46

What adds to MN's batshit reputation is the fact people can name change as often as they want (something a lot of other forums will ban you for). So people can basically 'be whoever they want' at any given time, to back their argument.

One minute they can be single and living a busy executive lifestyle in London, giving Russian Oligarchs a run for their money and the next, they're living in a tent and farming tortoises with their husband in Bolton.

MNHQ simply can't go through everyone's hidden history and ban the bullshit.

LovelaceBiggWither · 02/05/2022 10:46

Changechangychange · 02/05/2022 10:27

Honestly I like that fact that a really broad range of people post here. Most I don’t agree with, but I like that fact there’s no groupthink on here (outside of the JKR Twitter wars stuff, which is easily swerved).

it does mean that 50% of the posts claim they are richer than Rishi Sunak and 50% claim they live in the workhouse, but I assume those are two different groups of posters, not one person fibbing. Could also be fibbing of course, there are a lot of made up threads. Don’t really care as long as they are fun.

Tattle on the other hand always seems really bitter and mean spirited. Not a big fan of the “let’s all sneer at Mumsnet” Reddit either - I like the rest of Reddit, but that particular sub again just seems very bitter.

Bless, you have not ventured very far on reddit if you 'like the rest of reddit'. All of reddit?

CorsicaDreaming · 02/05/2022 10:43

I agree with you re JKR @JanisMoplin - her essay seems very carefully thought out and informed to me...

TheKeatingFive · 02/05/2022 10:42

I see MN criticised a lot on Twitter, and often I think there is quite a bit of ageism and sexism behind that.

Absolutely, nothing worse than a woman of a certain age having an opinion.

As for the trans discussion, I have seen the very occasional anti-trans comment on here, but very occasional. Unless you're of the view that stating you can't change sex is anti-trans, in which case god help us.

Basketet · 02/05/2022 10:39

Personally, I love reading the MC threads. The blissful ignorance I read always cheers me up. I may be poor, but I'm not thick.

LaburnumAlpine · 02/05/2022 10:36

I have never understood why MN is considered middle class, I find it very much not the case. Lower-middle at a push, the language used by majority of regular posters is a dead giveaway.

JanisMoplin · 02/05/2022 10:34

I see MN criticised a lot on Twitter, and often I think there is quite a bit of ageism and sexism behind that. A lot of arrogant young men who think there is something wrong in being a mum. However, I am drifting towards GC feminism and think JK talks a lot of sense; others can call that transphobic if they like.

TheKeatingFive · 02/05/2022 10:34

I notice that other forums are way more concerned with what's happening on MN than MN cares about what's happening on them.

Feckingfeck · 02/05/2022 10:33

Changechangychange · 02/05/2022 10:29

And yes the miscarriage, SEN and DV/coercive control support on here is amazing. Worth reading for that alone, and then you also get the parking threads!

👍🏻

Im only here for the parking threads 😂and humor of course.

But you need thick skin if you are willing to give an opinion!

medicmummm · 02/05/2022 10:31

I think sometimes people on here can be plain mean.

I got told to F**k off?! Not something u have been told to do in real life nor would i say to others.

There seems to be a huge divide of swimming pool owners (most appear ot be fake wannabes as class don't talk cash) to those on the bread line worrying about social services reacting to how the act?!

Not really the middle class place it was made out to be.

Changechangychange · 02/05/2022 10:29

And yes the miscarriage, SEN and DV/coercive control support on here is amazing. Worth reading for that alone, and then you also get the parking threads!

JanisMoplin · 02/05/2022 10:28

Ha ha yes!

Anyway I am now fully WFH after the pandemic, plus so many of my friends have drifted away or are too busy in midlife, so I find MN an absolute godsend. Also really helping me with anxiety in peri-menopause.

I agree the cost of living and saving energy thread was ill-advised. I rolled my eyes a bit at that.

Changechangychange · 02/05/2022 10:27

Honestly I like that fact that a really broad range of people post here. Most I don’t agree with, but I like that fact there’s no groupthink on here (outside of the JKR Twitter wars stuff, which is easily swerved).

it does mean that 50% of the posts claim they are richer than Rishi Sunak and 50% claim they live in the workhouse, but I assume those are two different groups of posters, not one person fibbing. Could also be fibbing of course, there are a lot of made up threads. Don’t really care as long as they are fun.

Tattle on the other hand always seems really bitter and mean spirited. Not a big fan of the “let’s all sneer at Mumsnet” Reddit either - I like the rest of Reddit, but that particular sub again just seems very bitter.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 02/05/2022 10:23

I love your typo Janis Grin

JanisMoplin · 02/05/2022 10:22

I think AIBU is often very weird but I have found fantastic help and wonderful people in other sections. I need to be on other social media a lot for my job, and believe me the larger MN site has the most intelligent and sensible women out there.

Perhaps it is overy middle class at times. But even the middle class have MH problems, or relationship problems, or parenting problems.

KeepYaHeadUp · 02/05/2022 10:20

Reading those screenshots made me literally facepalm. "Everyone is middle class but then also everyone talking about their poverty..." almost as though it mightn't be EVERYONE being one or the other and it's really just a combination of very well off, not very well off and people really struggling financially.

Tattlelife passing any sort of judgment on the behaviour of people on other websites is rich - I was a member a while ago and still go on there occasionally. I'm not easily offended but it's fucking nasty!

JenniferBarkley · 02/05/2022 10:17

NippyWoowoo · 02/05/2022 10:10

And then someone always comes along saying, wide-eyed, 'WHERE is there transphobia? You should get that reported, it's not allowed, I NEVER see it here!'

And I think they think that's clever.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 02/05/2022 10:17

Plus from a different angle, there is incredible access to support here. If you are going through something or even have some thing you need help or support with, there will be someone here with some experience. It's amazing for that, but nobody really reports on that.

Yes, this. Women support other women, frequently. Most of the criticism is founded in misogyny.

NippyWoowoo · 02/05/2022 10:17

That being said, TattleLife is awful

stilldumdedumming · 02/05/2022 10:16

@PacificState I agree with all you've said!

Plus from a different angle, there is incredible access to support here. If you are going through something or even have some thing you need help or support with, there will be someone here with some experience. It's amazing for that, but nobody really reports on that.