Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Mumsnet doesnt deserve its reputation

113 replies

pebimo6 · 02/05/2022 09:29

Used to post on the feminism board here a few years ago but moved on.

Was reading a thread just about Mumsnet and I think more specifically about aibu. Thought I'd check in again and can't really find any of the silly threads, all seems boringly normal

To think Mumsnet doesnt deserve its reputation
To think Mumsnet doesnt deserve its reputation
To think Mumsnet doesnt deserve its reputation
OP posts:
Marvellousmadness · 03/05/2022 13:39

This site is like a train wreck indeed... like a pp mentioned

Tsuni · 03/05/2022 13:24

What are all these mumsnetters who "aren't like the other mumsnetters" like?

HRTQueen · 02/05/2022 18:04

That’s funny on Tattle about the candles 😆

MN can be really supportive at times

other times it’s just ridiculous though this is amusing (the number of posters that would punch someone/or find something rude that in real life most wouldn’t give a second thought about)

sometimes it gets nasty,
cliquey and there certainly is bullying

and it’s left wing but strangely closed minded at times

and yes very mc and many wanting to informing others that they are mc

but it’s often an enjoyable way to pass the time

and it’s always been this way just there are more posting now

BoredZelda · 02/05/2022 17:44

Whenever I see “MN is…” it strikes me that people only see it from their own lense and biases.

Any thread by anyone with any amount of money is soundly rounded on and has people falling over themselves to point out how poor they are. But people say MNetters are all MC wealthy.

Fat or food threads are full of people telling us how we’ve all lost sight of normal weight.

Everyone’s kids are fat, lazy, stupid, but nobody has fat, lazy, stupid kids.

It’s full of “woke” and you “aren’t allowed” to make any comment about trans stuff but every other thread will have someone commenting about trans stuff.

This site has a large number of people who use it, and it is the site everyone sees it as.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 02/05/2022 14:28

roarfeckingroarr · 02/05/2022 14:04

And that's all the feminism board says - men cannot become women (it's biologically impossible) but let's respect everyone's identity without riding roughshod over Women's rights.

Agreed. It's the last six words which present the problem. This is what's identified by some of the (people or groups) obsessively monitoring this site, as 'transphobia'. For this reason MN has no option but to police the FWR boards extremely rigorously, imposing a distinct set of rules for those boards which are stricter than elsewhere on the site, and why some of the threads end up resembling Swiss cheese.

On the whole, MN are navigating choppy waters and have a difficult task, but at the very least they provide one of the few spaces on the internet in which it's possible to have such a discussion without the axe of the censors falling or the usual threats flying around. The policing is necessary if women are to have such a space at all, and there are some groups online (Twitter has at least one designated account) in which men get REALLY angry at the idea of women actually talking to one another about the issues that affect us.

Women, know your place.

perfectstorm · 02/05/2022 14:26

Mumsnet, and the people I met on here, is in large part the reason my 2 disabled kids have fantastic provision via EHCPs. I had no idea what their rights were, nor how to secure them. I do now, and I've done it. I will always owe it for that.

SpindleInTheWind · 02/05/2022 14:19

TheKeatingFive · 02/05/2022 10:34

I notice that other forums are way more concerned with what's happening on MN than MN cares about what's happening on them.

That's a bloody good point

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 02/05/2022 14:14

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 02/05/2022 12:23

And then someone always comes along saying, wide-eyed, 'WHERE is there transphobia? You should get that reported, it's not allowed, I NEVER see it here!

That depends how you define 'transphobia'. If there are suggestions that trans people should be fired from their jobs for being trans, or of mocking them and ridiculing their choice of external presentation, or suggesting they deserve the abuse and censure they receive (generally at the hands of men), or of 'outing' them against their will, I'd agree that all these are indeed transphobic and that MN would be wrong to provide a channel for the exchange of such views (just as much as another forum-which-can't-be-named for their inclusion of red pill material).

If your interpretation extends to include discussion of what happens when the rights of two groups conflict (or even acknowledging that there are times they do conflict), or fears that a particularly vociferous group of male rights activists are hitching to the trans wagon for nefarious reasons, or concerns that a rape victim can't get a single sex support group in a crisis centre (albeit there are separate provisions made for trans people; it's only natal women who can't claim this place of safety), or that women are losing out in sporting categories to male-bodied people with all the physical advantage that brings - then granted, yes. You'll see 'transphobia' everywhere.

The era of #NoDebate has passed. People do have a right to discuss these issues.

👏🏼 When people have genuine concerns and want to protect womens rights / safe spaces, are called transphobic, it just makes the word lose its meaning. Those things are not transphobic.

MarshaBradyo · 02/05/2022 14:13

roarfeckingroarr · 02/05/2022 14:04

And that's all the feminism board says - men cannot become women (it's biologically impossible) but let's respect everyone's identity without riding roughshod over Women's rights.

I agree with you too and the previous post. Mn is one of the few spaces that allow the conversation so it gets attacked regularly. I appreciate we can discuss it though.

re other stuff there’s a fairly wide range, lots of cost of living crisis stuff atm but now other things creeping back (skiing, Chanel etc)

VladmirsPoutine · 02/05/2022 14:11

roarfeckingroarr · 02/05/2022 13:55

I really don't think it is transphobic to not believe gender trumps sex and to want to preserve female only spaces

I agree with this but I am also acutely aware of the narrow definition within which femininity and womanhood is defined and I know I am the sort of person who might find herself outside the line once we start going down the road of strict rules and policing of who is and isn't a woman. For me it's a lot deeper than a man in a dress and a wig changing their name from John to Judy.

roarfeckingroarr · 02/05/2022 14:04

And that's all the feminism board says - men cannot become women (it's biologically impossible) but let's respect everyone's identity without riding roughshod over Women's rights.

TheKeatingFive · 02/05/2022 14:00

I really don't think it is transphobic to not believe gender trumps sex and to want to preserve female only spaces

Me neither

roarfeckingroarr · 02/05/2022 13:55

I really don't think it is transphobic to not believe gender trumps sex and to want to preserve female only spaces

SpindleInTheWind · 02/05/2022 13:21

JenniferBarkley · 02/05/2022 10:17

And I think they think that's clever.

Not really. I think it's more about grey rocking obvious sea lions

endofthelinefinally · 02/05/2022 13:19

MN is a huge site. It isn't reasonable to generalise IMO. The bereavement board absolutely saved my mental health when my son died and still provides a source of support. I joined another online group, but there is no comparison tbh.
The relationships board has helped lots of women escape abusive, dangerous relationships. I read some statistics here a few weeks ago and I am sure it was thousands.
The health boards are also excellent.
It all depends what you are looking for and what you read.
It is perfectly easy to avoid the bits you don't like. IMO it is more important to have a space where women can speak fairly freely and get information and support, than to police and censor so that nobody is offended.

Bunty55 · 02/05/2022 13:10

Deadringer
I agree with you. I don't think I fit into anybody's demographic. I'm older and have lived a life so cleanliness in the home threads leave me cold.. too much living going on out there to be bothered about what is acceptable and what is not...
The silly threads where somebody ate the children's Easter Eggs. What does the poster want from the responses I wonder? To brandish the thread in front of the offending dad ??

The kindness offered to me on here beats real life hands down and the help and advice I have received is heartwarming.

OrangutanLibrarian · 02/05/2022 13:06

And Tattle and the people who use tattle definitely deserve their reputation.

CorsicaDreaming · 02/05/2022 13:06

@worraliberty

Farming tortoises in Bolton 😂

Love it!

Youcansaythatagainandagain · 02/05/2022 13:05

VladmirsPoutine · 02/05/2022 13:02

@Youcansaythatagainandagain I agree the site has definitely become a lot more diverse. But I always have a stock phrase I write on certain threads: "You wouldn't join a vegan forum to extol the virtues of a bacon sandwich" in other words I know there is always going to be a very different view taken by the majority demographic on here so I accept it for what it is. But alas, I'm here because I love the threads where women will talk about their VERY IMPORTANT dh's hobbies and jobs Grin

Please do write your opinion though. It’ may make readers see from a different perspective and you may find many nodding along in agreement to your posts too and writing posts in solidarity.

RosesandMoonshine · 02/05/2022 13:03

I am always surprised that nobody i bump into or meet irl ever seems to have heard of MN. I've been on and off here forever so it does puzzle me Grin

In terms of 'reputation', sadly I have only ever heard insults or 'madhouse' references.

VladmirsPoutine · 02/05/2022 13:02

@Youcansaythatagainandagain I agree the site has definitely become a lot more diverse. But I always have a stock phrase I write on certain threads: "You wouldn't join a vegan forum to extol the virtues of a bacon sandwich" in other words I know there is always going to be a very different view taken by the majority demographic on here so I accept it for what it is. But alas, I'm here because I love the threads where women will talk about their VERY IMPORTANT dh's hobbies and jobs Grin

growinggreyer · 02/05/2022 13:01

Oh no, are women demanding rights again? And on the internet of all places. For the very shame of it.

MayorDusty · 02/05/2022 12:59

I'd agree that the users now are very much different to the ones tattle implies.
It did used to be dominated by wealthier types with a certain idea of life but over the years and despite itself I think it's probably one of the most balanced sites.

(That's my excuse for breaking my SM rule anyway)

Rubyroseyposey · 02/05/2022 12:58

Pyewhacket · 02/05/2022 12:54

*I think it's a bit of a weird place to be honest.

There's a few wise posters but by and large I find a lot of hypocritical shrieking of the same tired old guff.

You can tell from an opening post exactly how it's going to go and what the responses are bound to be, which is rarely how any normal person would behave in real life.

However the blatantly inane advice does have entertainment value*

Agree with this.

I also agree.

Plus the classics thread is hilarious 🤣

Rubyroseyposey · 02/05/2022 12:56

I avoid the feminism threads. It just isn't what I'm looking to engage in which is a shame, but not for me.