Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Obese daughter 14 years old

281 replies

MochaShots · 02/05/2022 03:44

As the title says, my 14 year old daughter is obese. She weighs 17 stone and I am so desperately sad for her.

I take full responsibility for letting it get this bad, but because of her poor mental health, I've struggled to be strict enough to see through any health changes we've tried to implement.

I know what a healthy diet looks like, what portion size she should be having, good fats, bad fats, enough protein etc. It is not that I am not educated. The problem I have is the lack of will power to stick it out. She is on the CAMH'S waiting list regarding her mental health, and I've requested a nutritionist, but the waiting list is so long.

She is so fragile mentally, that I always cave in and allow her bigger portion sizes or treats. But, even when I've tried to make adjustments to her diet, I cannot get her to increase her activity. Realistically now, she has gotten so big that she genuinely struggles to walk more than 10 mins without her legs chafing or her feet hurting. I cannot afford paid activities, and she also lacks the confidence. I've tried encouraging slow walks to build herself up to gradual fitness, but she refuses as I know she knows she will feel pain or discomfort.

Until she gets help with her mental health, I feel I'm fighting a losing battle.

Given that I eat a reasonably healthy diet, and am active and that I know about healthy eating and cooking- what can i do to help my daughter take steps to get healthy?

I've tried every approach I can think of including a delicate conversation - a blunt conversation about the negative effects on her heart (I try not to make it about her appearance). I've tried to make things fun and take the emphasis off of weight, but she doesn't like any activities at all. She goes to school, then comes home and sits around while I'm at work. Weekends she refuses to join us on bike rides, walks etc.

I have to be careful not to make it a battle by issuing sanctions as her mental health is incredibly fragile.

Please help!

OP posts:
Pointblank2 · 02/05/2022 13:12

Just to echo what a previous poster put on about the right shoes. I’m overweight and following a walking holiday I had severe tendonitis in my ankles and was referred to a podiatrist. I was wearing sketchers at my appointment and he said however light and padded they were they were completely the wrong thing for my feet as the support was just not there. I was told to buy running shoes that will not squish in when you squeeze the back of the heel and are solid. I was told to get a slight incline rather than completely flat and to buy slightly bigger and get an orthotic insole to support my arch. I buy ASICS trainers and orthotics from Boots. I cannot tell you what a revelation this has been I can now walk several miles without any pain and have had no reoccurrence of the tendonitis

runnerswimmer · 02/05/2022 13:10

*aargh weak enamel

runnerswimmer · 02/05/2022 13:09

Changing a diet is hard at that age and enforcing it, espcially with MH. My situation wasnt the same but when I was a pre-teen I had a raft of fillings due to weak enanel and basically the dentist forced me to go sugar free. My parents went a bit OTT with sugary foods / processed foods due to ignorance (this was 25yrs ago).

I was a very active child so that is probably why I didnt gain weight but it affected my teeth considerably. It was a shock to the system at first (no museli bars, jam, pop, chips etc) but I remember my mum taking me around the supermarket and I could decide (within reason) what healthy snacks I could eat, I started to learn home made baking and cook healthy foods. So my advice would be if you could start making meals together, even if its not everyday becuase you have other DC but it could help her see the benefits in healthy heating and cooking / baking skills.

These healthy habits have stayed with me for life and I am a good cook.

It sounds like you have had a tough few years Flowers

berryfull · 02/05/2022 13:08

As a lifetime long obese woman who was as large as your daughter at her age , do not make it about food, about how she looks, about health, about self esteem. Instead get her Cognitive Behavioural Therapy and treated for depression. Get her assessed for neurodiversity.

to help her feel more comfortable and confident I’d reccomend looking at the clothes on www.mannersldn.com . Made from great quality stretchy thick cotton, which supports your body without constricting.

look at the body positivity movement and Genuinely love her for who she is regardless of her weight.

MochaShots · 02/05/2022 13:07

FabFitFifties · 02/05/2022 12:45

Hi OP, some harsh comments here, regarding your parenting. Have you asked school for the contact details for the school nurse? Sounds like you need support to be able to support your daughter. School nurses can support with both physical and emotional wellbeing, and should be aware of and able to refer to other local services. Tackling obesity is definately high on school nurse agenda. You don't need to shoulder all the responsibility, without support. Also, what about your emotional wellbeing - have you considered seeking support for that? You usually self refer for talking therapies, there are also some free online services, for both teenagers and adults.

Thank you :-)

I have spoken with the school at length regarding her emotional wellbeing, weight and the bullying. They've been very supportive but their in school services are overstretched since the pandemic, so my daughter hasn't had any input from them yet.

I've had counselling and it has helped, but I think I'd benefit from more. Like most parents, I tend to put myself at the bottom of the pile, but I guess if I'm the root of the problem I should really look at getting more help.

OP posts:
GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 02/05/2022 13:06

You need to be the strong one here and change the meals you cook and her potions sizes. Get rid of all 'treats' in the house and do this as a family.

Italyanyday · 02/05/2022 12:58

Does she like animals? What about asking around to see if any rescue centres need help walking dogs on their land and volunteer the two of you on a weekend? This might give her some purpose, build up her self esteem and get some physical activity in. Alternatively, would the GP prescribe something to help her? I don't know enough about appetite suppressants etc. to know if they are safe.

MochaShots · 02/05/2022 12:56

CocoCactus · 02/05/2022 12:18

It sounds like you have been through so much and you sound like an amazing mum. It seems that you and your daughter have trauma to process, but sounds you have the awareness and determination.

Could she possibly be encouraged to join NCS the challenge when she turns 15? They are pretty hot on ensuring it is a safe, respectful environment. It’s a few weeks part-residential with fun outdoor stuff, is self esteem boosting and social. Lots of the young people who do it have their own issues.

wearencs.com

Thank you so much for your kindness:-)

I will look into that now. I think it would definitely help her to make friends, which would make me equally happy.

OP posts:
Tomatobowl · 02/05/2022 12:52

@MochaShots - you sound like a wonderful mother.

I've been heavier and lighter and what has been really strange is how little conscious effort or even my day-to-day happiness has determined my weight.

I gained a lot of weight when breastfeeding - I was just so hungry. It wasn't post-natal depression, just an urge to eat as much as I could.

I have been thinner when I had more time and resources to do exercise I liked and prepare vegetables - which takes a lot of time for them to be enjoyable to eat. This morning I prepared a large spicy salad and then peeled a bunch of carrots for soup. And it is messy. People who don't live in small flats, working long hours, don't understand.

OP - I have lost about a stone over the past year without conscious effort after being prescribed ADHD medicine. It is also prescribed for Binge Eating Disorder. The meds switch off the urge and compulsion to eat mindlessly. With ADHD people have a drive to get dopamine into their system and for many that is via food. The meds aren't diet pills and I don't take them to control my weight - it's just been a side-effect. I've also been a bit surprised how little it mattered to me either way.

If your daughter has an undiagnosed condition then something like this might just be a good kick-starter.

Sweepingeyelashes · 02/05/2022 12:52

Could she get properly fitted for sports shoes? I'm not not in the UK but there are specialist sports shoe shops that have a lot of different shoes and probably a treadmill type thing to analyse your gait (no - you run for about 30 seconds or so it's not a workout.) My sons and I all have a genetic disorder affecting the way the bones in our feet develop and we have very narrow heels that can just slip about in some some shoes and a specialist shop went to a lot of trouble and had a lot of different styles so we could get something that fitted. The only thing is that those sorts of shoes and shops tend to be expensive.

I'm wondering if she has a decent bra. Being on the small side I never bothered with a sports bra but I understand that it can make a real difference to stop everything swinging about. Again a proper fitting would be best but I can understand that she may be a bit shy but perhaps you could measure up and order something. She might be a bit embarrassed about saying something to you about this.

I suspect it's a vicious cycle and it must be very tough not having a friend to do things with. I don't know whether it's practical or not or what you faith is but could some faith based youth thing be more accepting. (You don't have to be super devout to join most of these things.) Or even a charitable group that helps others.

tootiredtoocare · 02/05/2022 12:52

@NeverDropYourMooncup you just described my feet and ankle problems in full detail. Thank you. I have orthotics which really do help, but I think I might have to bite the bullet and find a gym kind to fatties.

tootiredtoocare · 02/05/2022 12:45

Chub rub shorts are an absolute must. Comfy wide fit trainers, plus size sites sell them. Don't make it a 'walk'. Go to the a garden centre, a large DIY store, a shopping centre, anywhere she'll be walking without it being 'exercise' and without food being the focus of the outing. If she won't come food shopping, you're responsible for what is there for her to eat. Ration treats to one a day. I think at this point it's better to just reduce her bad habits than try to enforce good ones. The hardest thing of all is to remain firm, and not give in. Good luck, I hope she gets the help she needs soon.

FabFitFifties · 02/05/2022 12:45

Hi OP, some harsh comments here, regarding your parenting. Have you asked school for the contact details for the school nurse? Sounds like you need support to be able to support your daughter. School nurses can support with both physical and emotional wellbeing, and should be aware of and able to refer to other local services. Tackling obesity is definately high on school nurse agenda. You don't need to shoulder all the responsibility, without support. Also, what about your emotional wellbeing - have you considered seeking support for that? You usually self refer for talking therapies, there are also some free online services, for both teenagers and adults.

Midlifemusings · 02/05/2022 12:37

Upamountain43 · 02/05/2022 12:19

Just to say to the 'if you do not buy it she can't eat it' brigade

Been there and tried it and came down one morning to find my DGS sound asleep on the trampoline surrounded by empty jars - peanut butter and honey but also mint sauce, apple sauces, olives - he had abandoned the horseradish but other than that every single jar of food had been eaten. regardless of sweet/savoury. Luckily he is left handed and could not manage the can opener he had tried.

He has drunk entire bottles of undiluted squash and even cooking oil, milk powder is a favourite, and healthy stuff like nuts and seeds anything. I know he is extreme - and we have to be careful as he will resort to non food stuff which can be life threatening but people need to get away from the idea that this is a child sat in front of the TV crying because they cannot have a 5th packet of crisps.

If we had nothing else in our lives but dealing with his eating i am sure we would be much more successful but with other children, adults with health issues and everything else life throws at you as the OP has mentioned.....it is really not that simple.

OP - look at the Harvey Price range of clothes - these have been great for us. Also DB shoes they have very 'granny' styles but also some younger more modern ones. There is a factory shop in Northamptonshire if that is close enough where she can try them on.

Your DGS has PICA which is a little different from OP who is loading up her daughter's plates with extra portions and giving her extra treats and junk food.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 02/05/2022 12:34

She's never full because she isn't eating to not be hungry. She's eating to change the way she feels and to swallow down her anger, fear, loneliness and to drown out the words of her father. Or to make them real, depending upon the things he would say ('you're fat and greedy and this is why everybody hates you' were the words I heard as a child. I visualised this as a little person on my shoulder nagging in my ear - and then pinged the irritating little shit off, which took away the power of their words - thanks to DP making the suggestion).

If she were 3 and demanding to go and play hopscotch in the middle of the A3, you'd stop her. If she wanted to ride her tricycle around the hanger Lane Gyratory, you'd have said no even she cried and screamed. If she had a bottle of vodka, a box of matches or a packet of pills, you'd say no and take them away.

You need to see that she is begging you to hurt her. She's asking you to abuse her. Like her father did. And for the sake of a heaped tablespoon of body weight a day over 4 years, you can and must be her parent, no matter what tears, what tantrums, no matter how much she tries to pretend that it isn't happening and you're a really cruel Mum to prevent her from self harm. You're not cruel in not giving her the means to ensure she never has a happy or healthy life and the one she does have is cut short by obesity related diseases and disability. You're doing what is right for her whilst she is still a vulnerable and dependent child.

You can do things to take a lot of the physical pain away. Take that and some of the emotional side will lessen - not all, but some of it, the bits about not being able to do anything, of being self conscious, uncomfortable in clothes, being picked on at school for her appearance. And the change in dynamic, rather than being the guilty and manipulated woman, becoming the calm, strong and dependable parent who is doing what is right for her, will also increase her feelings of security and safety. She knows that you are hurting her through caving to her demands, which contributes towards her insecurity and unhappiness. She needs to know that you are still protecting her, even when it's difficult.

Seaweed42 · 02/05/2022 12:33

Can you afford private therapy for your daughter? A psychologist or a therapist trained with adolescents? Your daughter's mental health is your first concern.
If she can find a therapist that she likes and will stay with, that will be a great support to her. The fixing of the weight may follow when her mental health is better supported. The therapist needs to be experienced with children and adolescents, your DD probably won't respond to traditional 'sit down and tell me everything' therapy.

She may like art therapy for example, could you arrange some sessions of that for her? Make sure the Art Therapist has done a specialist degree in Art Therapy and is experienced with children, and is a member of an art therapy psychotherapy association. You'd be very surprised how a supportive relationship outside of the home can have a very very beneficial effect. It will also teach that other people, besides her family, do like and accept her.

Notimeforaname · 02/05/2022 12:27

Locks on the fridge and cupboard if food is being stolen.

me4real · 02/05/2022 12:27

Wait to see the dietitian or pay for one privately if you can afford it.

The qualifications for a nutritionist aren't as advanced @MochaShots . In fact in theory, anyone can call themselves one.

MochaShots · 02/05/2022 12:26

NeverDropYourMooncup · 02/05/2022 12:05

Hope it's OK to drop in some practicals as well.

Queenieke highwaisted leggings in 2XL will fit her and be supportive and comfortable without causing the blistering that cotton leggings do. They're on Amazon and cost around the £20-25 mark. The shorts may be a little too short to avoid the just above the knee bit catching and rubbing (Snag shorts might be better if she doesn't want to wear tights with dresses). The high waist is brilliant for reducing the 'slap', as are full briefs rather than little cotton things that catch under her tummy or disappear up her behind/contribute to friction burns in the fold of her legs. They're more appealing to teenagers as they are more like the things worn by influencers on TikTok, nicer colours and, in all, they actually feel pleasant to wear rather than something to hide in and still be uncomfortable.

She's quite likely to be functionally flatfooted and vulnerable to plantar fasciitis due to the weight, lack of muscle strength and the alterations to posture and gait that the additional weight is causing - the weight of her abdomen alone will drag her forward and cause her lower back to arch, creating anterior pelvic tilt, which also affects her legs, spine, knees and ankle/foot. If you compound this with little slip on shoes or cheapie trainers from Primark, her ankles will be dropping inwards with every step and her arches will be collapsing (or tearing, as per the PF reference). This alteration in gait then means that she'll be dropping due to gravity the equivalent of a family saloon car onto her heel and up her legs and overarched spine with every step she takes. Her feet are also likely to be broader than standard width fitting due to the length of time she has been significantly larger. The entire weight will be focused upon her heel, the inside of her ankles and the inside edge of her foot. No wonder she says her feet hurt - they do and that can cause problems way beyond just a little discomfort.

Going to a specialist sports shop and getting properly fitted shoes in a size that allows her to wear orthotics - so larger than you would normally get - will enable better biomechanics and her foot to work as nature intends, which means she won't be in as much pain and it'll require less effort to move in the first place whilst ensuring that she will have less pain after activity AND also reduce the chances of injury. Brooks are a common choice, as are On shoes. They may not be Airforce Ones, but they will protect her body just on everyday activities. She'll also need orthotics for school shoes - again, the shoes have to be decent quality to prevent pain and injury.

If she chooses to exercise, other things she could consider are indoor rowing - many gyms have sessions where teenagers can attend - a cheap machine for home is likely to not be able to support her weight, whereas the limits for Concept IIs in the gym are somewhere around twice her weight. Recumbent cycling might work for her, but in all honesty, I found rowing to be far more agreeable and useful in terms of all over strength as well as cardio/fat burn activities; 10 minutes on the rower is far, far easier whilst still having good effects than a bike, treadmill or stair climber/elliptical (those buggers always strain my knees, I have no idea how people can use them, but I do have stumpy little legs). If she wanted to - and gym stuff is only if she wants to at a later point - useful resistance exercises would include the leg adduction and abduction machines, as they will strengthen muscles that she needs to walk upright. And it's sitting down again - which is a good thing when you're obese. Then she could, rather than doing squats, which are foul at any weight but damn near impossible when you're 17 stone, use the leg press so that she isn't having to shift her entire weight against gravity. This strengthens her thighs and glutes. The combination of just these three, just doing 3 sets of ten (or 8, 6, 4 if that works better for her) of a manageable weight - people often start at very small weights - would show huge results in just a month, not just in the shape of her legs, but in her strength and ability to move around.

Whilst you will hear that exercise does nothing for weight loss, it's important - it increases the number of calories she burns just existing, it reduces pain, it can make you feel better, it absolutely can make the whole process far more agreeable. And unlike school sports halls, they have aircon and in the ones I've gone to, are certainly much nicer for people of all ages and sizes than the bearpit that is school and PE teachers shouting at you.

This is beyond helpful. Thank you so much!!! I feel like if I can make her as comfortable as possible, she will be more willing to increase activity which at the very least will provide some distraction from wanting to eat,and hopefully make her feel happier.

OP posts:
Notimeforaname · 02/05/2022 12:25

I know I shouldn't, and I know the responsibility to stick to healthy eating lies solely with me

At least you're fully aware of this. OP have you been getting some counselling or anyone to talk to ?

You clearly need some help setting boundaries. I understand you feel guilty if you do not give into her wants.

Can you stop yourself from buying the unhealthy foods in the shops or are yous struggling with this too?

Its horrible to hear a child complain they are hungry 😔 but this is what's needed. Also I would stick more to food than excersice until she some loses weight as you say its painful for her moving with all that weight on her.

It has to start somewhere.

Make sure she is filling up in water all day too.

Upamountain43 · 02/05/2022 12:19

Just to say to the 'if you do not buy it she can't eat it' brigade

Been there and tried it and came down one morning to find my DGS sound asleep on the trampoline surrounded by empty jars - peanut butter and honey but also mint sauce, apple sauces, olives - he had abandoned the horseradish but other than that every single jar of food had been eaten. regardless of sweet/savoury. Luckily he is left handed and could not manage the can opener he had tried.

He has drunk entire bottles of undiluted squash and even cooking oil, milk powder is a favourite, and healthy stuff like nuts and seeds anything. I know he is extreme - and we have to be careful as he will resort to non food stuff which can be life threatening but people need to get away from the idea that this is a child sat in front of the TV crying because they cannot have a 5th packet of crisps.

If we had nothing else in our lives but dealing with his eating i am sure we would be much more successful but with other children, adults with health issues and everything else life throws at you as the OP has mentioned.....it is really not that simple.

OP - look at the Harvey Price range of clothes - these have been great for us. Also DB shoes they have very 'granny' styles but also some younger more modern ones. There is a factory shop in Northamptonshire if that is close enough where she can try them on.

CocoCactus · 02/05/2022 12:18

MochaShots · 02/05/2022 11:37

Thank you so much for all of your replies. I'm overwhelmed by the responses, and grateful to those who have offered genuine advice/tips (which I've screenshot and will look into). It's unfortunate that there are still a few that have either not fully read the OP, or are telling me that it is as simple as reducing calories/portion size, or that I'm enabling - I do realise this. But there has been more kindness, so thank you.

To answer a few questions and give some more background...

I have three children, she is the middle child. The two boys are healthy weights. The eldest is very health conscious and regulates his weight well. The youngest is slim, but has ASD and is fussy to the extent that he only eats certain foods and not very much of it - so a whole other issue I'm dealing with.

8 years ago, we fled my from my ex, their dad, and I put all of my energy, money and what little mental strength I had into starting a new life for us and somewhere new to live. We live in a run down estate in a less than desirable part of London. We don't have a garden, or friendly neighbour's who would want their dog walked, and we couldn't afford a dog of our own, nor would we have the space.

A lot of my daughter's mental health I believe, stems from her relationship with her dad, and the horrible environment we lived in where we would all walk on eggshells. There was no physical violence, just emotional. I finally had the courage to leave, and in many ways, life is better for us all. I did plead with social workers in the early days for involvement, and to my surprise, they said I didn't qualify as in their eyes, the children still have one fit and able parent.

The boys are thriving now (although they've had their problems with mental health in the early days), but my daughter keeps a lot in. I too have struggled, which I guess is a reason I've not been able to effectively get a grip on my daughter's weight.

My daughter has no friends, and has endured bullying since primary school. She has no one to go places with, and this adds to her MH problems. She has no confidence to join free afterschool clubs, and is definitely a few years younger mentally and struggles to fit it. Obviously I've tried to address this, and have tried to help, but I think its deep rooted and will take a professional to unpick.

My daughter is in denial about her weight. I know she knows, but she won't admit it, which makes it very difficult then, for me to get her on board. She will say things like "ah mum you've shrunk my clothes again" or, "I need a bigger size as I'm getting taller".

I've taken her to the GP who recommended Slimming World. We attended for a couple of months, but on the times she gained or stayed the same, she would be heartbroken and have meltdowns. I decided I didnt want to fixate on weighing her, and the group was just making her feel more of a failure when she would see the other people achieving awards etc.

She does eat veg, and fruit, but just never seems full. So even if her plate consisted of mostly vegetables and proteins, she would still be hungry.

I'm thinking if I can make her as comfortable as possible, then I may be able to convince her to get more active. Is there anywhere I can get specialist shoes made? She has wide feet, a high in step and obviously a lot of weight bearing down on her. I've tried sketchers etc, but her feet always hurt in the end. I will definitely look at the anti chafing shorts - so thank you.

I understand diet is key, but I also know how good I feel after being active, and I want her to get that feeling, in hope it will make her want to make better food choices. I also need to work on keeping the momentum going and not cave when trying to get her to eat less junk.

It might be worth noting, that her weight gain increased a lot over the lockdown period. She was still very overweight before, but gained rapidly over the lockdown period.

It sounds like you have been through so much and you sound like an amazing mum. It seems that you and your daughter have trauma to process, but sounds you have the awareness and determination.

Could she possibly be encouraged to join NCS the challenge when she turns 15? They are pretty hot on ensuring it is a safe, respectful environment. It’s a few weeks part-residential with fun outdoor stuff, is self esteem boosting and social. Lots of the young people who do it have their own issues.

wearencs.com

MochaShots · 02/05/2022 12:08

ZealAndArdour · 02/05/2022 12:03

OP it’s worth a Google for a “paediatric dietetics” service and your area of London to see if there’s a service available that you could then ask your GP to refer her into.

I just did a quick Google and found this service but no idea if it falls within the CCG for your area; clch.nhs.uk/services/paediatric-dietetics-nutrition-children-0-19
But it says they do deal with complex obesity.

I would say slimming world is not the right environment for a 14 year old. It wasn’t the right environment for me as an adult woman as it seems to attract a lot of the “loud and proud” obese women and I think you need to be a certain personality type to thrive in that environment. It would be especially difficult for a 14 year old child who isn’t very emotionally mature or confident, and also doesn’t really have great insight into the cause or severity of the problem.

I was obese in my later teens but I was also very tall (6ft) so I guess I got away with it a bit easier than a shorter teen would have done. I gained more weight as an adult and eventually got diagnosed with binge eating disorder. I got treatment for that in an ED service and it has helped me make massive changes to my life. But the single most important lesson I learned is that diets don’t work, and restriction leads to binging which leads to feelings of shame and further restriction and then more binging and it’s a really horrible self-perpetuating cycle.

I think some PP’s have said to take the focus away from restricting and put it more onto making different choices, I agree and perhaps a good change would be the order in which the meal is eaten, filling up on healthy protein first, then vegetables, and then carbs. It’s really not practical to remove all “treat” foods from a teenager (but you could certainly remove the amount available in the house), but it would be better to try to view all food neutrally, none of it is morally good or bad, nor is it a treat or a punishment. It’s just food, it has an energy value, and you can choose where that energy comes from, but some of those nutritional choices make us feel more full and satisfied and energetic than others. Attributing moral value (good, bad, junk, fattening, etc) to certain food groups is a disordered way of thinking about food.

Has she got a smart watch? Would she respond to that kind of motivation? On the Apple Watch you can change your daily targets so that you can start off small and increase them as you become more physically able. When I first got mine I really struggled to meet the exercise minutes and targets, but as time has gone on, I now get the 30 exercise minutes just doing my day to day jobs around the house and running errands.

Thank you for this info. Will look into it.

I'm glad you got the help you needed.

Yes, she has a smart watch, but it has no affect on her desire to move more. She gets in too much pain on her feet:-(

OP posts:
NeverDropYourMooncup · 02/05/2022 12:05

Hope it's OK to drop in some practicals as well.

Queenieke highwaisted leggings in 2XL will fit her and be supportive and comfortable without causing the blistering that cotton leggings do. They're on Amazon and cost around the £20-25 mark. The shorts may be a little too short to avoid the just above the knee bit catching and rubbing (Snag shorts might be better if she doesn't want to wear tights with dresses). The high waist is brilliant for reducing the 'slap', as are full briefs rather than little cotton things that catch under her tummy or disappear up her behind/contribute to friction burns in the fold of her legs. They're more appealing to teenagers as they are more like the things worn by influencers on TikTok, nicer colours and, in all, they actually feel pleasant to wear rather than something to hide in and still be uncomfortable.

She's quite likely to be functionally flatfooted and vulnerable to plantar fasciitis due to the weight, lack of muscle strength and the alterations to posture and gait that the additional weight is causing - the weight of her abdomen alone will drag her forward and cause her lower back to arch, creating anterior pelvic tilt, which also affects her legs, spine, knees and ankle/foot. If you compound this with little slip on shoes or cheapie trainers from Primark, her ankles will be dropping inwards with every step and her arches will be collapsing (or tearing, as per the PF reference). This alteration in gait then means that she'll be dropping due to gravity the equivalent of a family saloon car onto her heel and up her legs and overarched spine with every step she takes. Her feet are also likely to be broader than standard width fitting due to the length of time she has been significantly larger. The entire weight will be focused upon her heel, the inside of her ankles and the inside edge of her foot. No wonder she says her feet hurt - they do and that can cause problems way beyond just a little discomfort.

Going to a specialist sports shop and getting properly fitted shoes in a size that allows her to wear orthotics - so larger than you would normally get - will enable better biomechanics and her foot to work as nature intends, which means she won't be in as much pain and it'll require less effort to move in the first place whilst ensuring that she will have less pain after activity AND also reduce the chances of injury. Brooks are a common choice, as are On shoes. They may not be Airforce Ones, but they will protect her body just on everyday activities. She'll also need orthotics for school shoes - again, the shoes have to be decent quality to prevent pain and injury.

If she chooses to exercise, other things she could consider are indoor rowing - many gyms have sessions where teenagers can attend - a cheap machine for home is likely to not be able to support her weight, whereas the limits for Concept IIs in the gym are somewhere around twice her weight. Recumbent cycling might work for her, but in all honesty, I found rowing to be far more agreeable and useful in terms of all over strength as well as cardio/fat burn activities; 10 minutes on the rower is far, far easier whilst still having good effects than a bike, treadmill or stair climber/elliptical (those buggers always strain my knees, I have no idea how people can use them, but I do have stumpy little legs). If she wanted to - and gym stuff is only if she wants to at a later point - useful resistance exercises would include the leg adduction and abduction machines, as they will strengthen muscles that she needs to walk upright. And it's sitting down again - which is a good thing when you're obese. Then she could, rather than doing squats, which are foul at any weight but damn near impossible when you're 17 stone, use the leg press so that she isn't having to shift her entire weight against gravity. This strengthens her thighs and glutes. The combination of just these three, just doing 3 sets of ten (or 8, 6, 4 if that works better for her) of a manageable weight - people often start at very small weights - would show huge results in just a month, not just in the shape of her legs, but in her strength and ability to move around.

Whilst you will hear that exercise does nothing for weight loss, it's important - it increases the number of calories she burns just existing, it reduces pain, it can make you feel better, it absolutely can make the whole process far more agreeable. And unlike school sports halls, they have aircon and in the ones I've gone to, are certainly much nicer for people of all ages and sizes than the bearpit that is school and PE teachers shouting at you.

ZealAndArdour · 02/05/2022 12:03

OP it’s worth a Google for a “paediatric dietetics” service and your area of London to see if there’s a service available that you could then ask your GP to refer her into.

I just did a quick Google and found this service but no idea if it falls within the CCG for your area; clch.nhs.uk/services/paediatric-dietetics-nutrition-children-0-19
But it says they do deal with complex obesity.

I would say slimming world is not the right environment for a 14 year old. It wasn’t the right environment for me as an adult woman as it seems to attract a lot of the “loud and proud” obese women and I think you need to be a certain personality type to thrive in that environment. It would be especially difficult for a 14 year old child who isn’t very emotionally mature or confident, and also doesn’t really have great insight into the cause or severity of the problem.

I was obese in my later teens but I was also very tall (6ft) so I guess I got away with it a bit easier than a shorter teen would have done. I gained more weight as an adult and eventually got diagnosed with binge eating disorder. I got treatment for that in an ED service and it has helped me make massive changes to my life. But the single most important lesson I learned is that diets don’t work, and restriction leads to binging which leads to feelings of shame and further restriction and then more binging and it’s a really horrible self-perpetuating cycle.

I think some PP’s have said to take the focus away from restricting and put it more onto making different choices, I agree and perhaps a good change would be the order in which the meal is eaten, filling up on healthy protein first, then vegetables, and then carbs. It’s really not practical to remove all “treat” foods from a teenager (but you could certainly remove the amount available in the house), but it would be better to try to view all food neutrally, none of it is morally good or bad, nor is it a treat or a punishment. It’s just food, it has an energy value, and you can choose where that energy comes from, but some of those nutritional choices make us feel more full and satisfied and energetic than others. Attributing moral value (good, bad, junk, fattening, etc) to certain food groups is a disordered way of thinking about food.

Has she got a smart watch? Would she respond to that kind of motivation? On the Apple Watch you can change your daily targets so that you can start off small and increase them as you become more physically able. When I first got mine I really struggled to meet the exercise minutes and targets, but as time has gone on, I now get the 30 exercise minutes just doing my day to day jobs around the house and running errands.