Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That social services should leave me alone??

142 replies

RubyViola · 02/05/2022 01:13

Social services have recently been involved due to my ex who was abusive stalking and harassing me. I moved 4 times and each time he found my new address.

This has been going on since I left him in February 2020 when our son was 9 months old. I have done literally everything I can to get help and it took the police 2 years to actually do anything. He was arrested 6 times but let go every time despite the fact the police had deemed him high risk. He has finally been charged and found guilty and is awaiting sentencing in the next few weeks.

I was initially happy that social services became involved as I was hoping it would help push the police but as it happened they were unable to actually do anything. They have put my son on a child protection order under neglect and initially stated that once he had been charged it would be stepped down to child in need.

The social worker comes twice a month and as they have no concerns about my parenting we have absolutely nothing to talk about. I work full time and am sick of having to take an hour off work usually on a Monday morning to talk about the weather. It's a waste of all of our time and surely her time could be better spent elsewhere.

My sons father has completely ruined the first few years of his life and now I feel ready to move on and start to enjoy life again I feel like this is holding me back. Every time the social worker calls it's like a reminder of everything he put us through and I just want to cry and scream. They have done nothing to help us and I just want them to fuck off and let me move on from this.

Is there any way I can legally disengage or dispute the child protection plan without looking bad? I would be more than happy to work with them if my son was at risk but I really feel that right now there causing more harm than good.

OP posts:
clairemaddox · 02/05/2022 15:03

It's awful that your life is being encroached upon because our legal system has not jailed this person.

Do you have a non-molestation against him?

How did he find your address?

You need to be ex-directory and not tell anyone your address to be safe.

Then perhaps if you speak to SS and let them know the steps you have taken; not possible for him to find your address as nobody knows it. You are not on any lists. He has a non-mol so if he comes near you will be arrested immediately - then perhaps you have a case for them to finally discharge you?

Apricote · 02/05/2022 15:01

It's astonishing to me how desperate some people on this thread are to believe that the OP is at fault here. Do they just really need to believe that SS and other professionals are to be relied on to be fair and not make mistakes? Because that's not true.

wishuponastar1988 · 02/05/2022 14:40

RubyViola · 02/05/2022 14:36

@wishuponastar1988 The last conference was around 3 weeks ago. The trouble is the IRO stated her thoughts first - the nursery went 2nd and literally just repeated what she had said (I don't think the manager has much experience of CP meetings), the health visitor also said the same although we've only met once 8 months ago and she was half an hour late to the meeting and my IDVA said she thought it should be stepped down due to the reduced risk!

The only outstanding action is for the police to give an update - they didn't attend and there wouldn't have been an update anyway

You are able to challenge the outcome of the conference in writing. Everyone's view should be impartial and based on the evidence of significant harm. It sounds quite oppressive if you are doing EVERYTHING asked of you to keep your child safe. Unfortunately you are not able to control his behaviour but you can control your responses to it to make sure your child is safe and doing ok. Can you speak to the IRO with an advocate or ask for a meeting with the social workers team manager to discuss how you feel? It sounds like there might be professional anxiety around the level of risk (which does sound quite high) but then that has to be balanced against what you have done to maintain/create safety

RubyViola · 02/05/2022 14:39

@BoredZelda I work with young people leaving care and EVERY 6 week visit is completed by the SW/PA as it's a requirement. A lot of the time the kids refuse to engage but the SW will turn up anyway as yes boxes do need to ticked

OP posts:
SteakExpectations · 02/05/2022 14:37

Sorry I didn’t mean to be condescending or to insult your intelligence. I was just drawing from my own experience of CP conferences, in that each professional gives their evidence as to what risks there are to the child and “what good looks like” and then at the end each professional gives their professional opinion as to whether it meets the threshold for CP. There should have been no ambiguity or confusion.

Given your circumstances, it does seem excessive for DC to be a CP plan if ExP is going to serve time, but there must have been reasons given as to why that was the case.

I guess my question is why are you raising this now, rather than at the last conference? If it’s because ExP was not in prison at the time of the last conference, it might be worth speaking with the social worker to contact the conference lead to get their advice as to whether, in the circumstances, the next conference could be brought forward or whether visits could be less frequent?

RubyViola · 02/05/2022 14:36

@wishuponastar1988 The last conference was around 3 weeks ago. The trouble is the IRO stated her thoughts first - the nursery went 2nd and literally just repeated what she had said (I don't think the manager has much experience of CP meetings), the health visitor also said the same although we've only met once 8 months ago and she was half an hour late to the meeting and my IDVA said she thought it should be stepped down due to the reduced risk!

The only outstanding action is for the police to give an update - they didn't attend and there wouldn't have been an update anyway

OP posts:
kungfupannda · 02/05/2022 14:25

There's some misconceptions re sentencing on this thread. The OP has said several times that her ex has breached a 2 year suspended sentence as well as committing further offences. He therefore falls to be sentenced for the new matter(s) and to have the SSO activated. She has presumably been advised by a police liaison officer that isn't a case where they are expecting the court not to activate the SSO - there have to be good reasons for not doing so - or the judge at the last hearing may have indicated that he can expect it to be activated. If the SSO is activated and he receives a further (consecutive) sentence, then even allowing for time on remand, he should hopefully be inside for a decent stretch.

BoredZelda · 02/05/2022 14:23

She's lovely but yes just ticking a box as visits have to be completed while on a CP plan

As I said, they don’t have time for box ticking visits.

RubyViola · 02/05/2022 14:21

@BoredZelda I never said said she was a jobsworth? She's lovely but yes just ticking a box as visits have to be completed while on a CP plan

OP posts:
BoredZelda · 02/05/2022 14:18

Your posts seem to be alluding to you thinking she is a jobsworth just ticking a box. SS are absolutely slammed, there is no time to spare for them to be doing this. I have to assume if they are visiting it’s because they think they need to, not because they have to, to tick a box.

wishuponastar1988 · 02/05/2022 14:16

Also you shouldn't be taking time off for visits. Tell the social worker the times you are available. The LA I am in would never ask a parent to take time off work for social workers to visit x

wishuponastar1988 · 02/05/2022 14:14

I'm abit confused as if the next review conference is in 5 months then you must've had one recently? Child protection plans are reviewed at the conference every 6 months. Other professionals must've voted for your child to stay subject to a child protection plan in the last month or so?

Social workers don't decide alone, every professional involved shares their view and the majority wins overall. When was the last child protection conference? What actions are left on the child protection plan that are reviewed at your core group meetings? Have you asked what more you need to do to evidence your child isn't at risk of significant harm?

AlwaysAWoman · 02/05/2022 14:12

In our LA, if there were no incidents within the next few months and things continued to be positive at conference, you would be stepped down to CIN- unless there were genuine concerns you were still in contact with him.

I agree with speaking to the SW and sorting different time visits at the very least- you shouldn't have to finish work early twice a month? Do they accommodate for later visits, as we do

User57327259 · 02/05/2022 14:11

@DrDetriment
The final sentence of your post is very accurate.

Given that Social Work does not attract the most intelligent people they try to cover their mistakes by attacking those they are meant to be helping. I have no idea why certain supposedly intelligent people believe the rubbish spoken by social workers

DrDetriment · 02/05/2022 14:04

DonnaMae · 02/05/2022 13:09

Totally agree with this - Social Services are not the wonderful angels everyone here seems to think. They can and do make mistakes that destroy innocent families, and they are never held accountable, and nearly every social worker I have met professionally and personally has been on a power trip. I’d definitely push to free yourself OP - it sounds like you are trying to move on with your life, and that you are doing a great job for your DS.

Exactly this. I know someone who asked for help from SS because their teenage son was on drugs and in a gang. SS turned on the family and put all the children on an in need plan. When the parents complained it was upgraded to a CP plan with no evidence (which SS admitted). It took a long time to get this removed and the children (and parents) are traumatised about what they went through. The sad fact is that SS attracts some people who really aren't that clever and get on a power trip, especially when dealing with educated, middle class families. Consciously or not, they want to drag them down to their level.

Snugglepumpkin · 02/05/2022 14:03

Next time the social worker visits, you need to tell her that you don't feel being on a CP is helping your child & ask her what exactly needs to happen for this to be stepped down to a CIN plan.

She should be able to tell you & if she can't, then ask her to do so because it's supposed to be part of a CP or CIN plan.

You should have (in writing) a CP plan which lays out exactly what you are supposed to do.
If you have your copy, go & read it, then if everything on the list is done ask her if each objective has been achieved what is stopping this from moving on, or what is missing that you need to do so that progress can be made to close the case.

If you don't have a copy, ask the SW or contact the chair & ask them for one.

In some areas SS do have a very high threshold for involvement.
In others it's a very different story.

RubyViola · 02/05/2022 14:00

@JetTail his solicitor is absolutely pants! when I gave evidence he attempted to pick on several things which were immediately rejected and at one point he was asked to stop interrupting me Grin He also didn't have any questions and the judge asked multiple times if it was necessary to hear all of the evidence as there was so much.

I'm not sure if I was clear earlier but he had a 2 year suspended sentence which will now be served (stalking and harassment).

He has now been found guilty of stalking again (one charge), multiple breaches of restraining order (I'm assuming just one charge) and is awaiting sentencing.

He continued to breach the order after being found guilty so there is now another outstanding charge.

OP posts:
rainbowruthie · 02/05/2022 13:59

I can't offer any words of wisdom, but i really want to send you my very best wishes as you move forward

User57327259 · 02/05/2022 13:57

The problem here is actually the ex partner and father of the child. Instead of harassing the mum and child it would be more productive if SS and Police put as much effort into forcing the ex partner to see that he is wrong and to follow the mum and child is many different crimes. Police and Social Services need to deal with the offenders and not the victims.
I am not plucking this out of fresh air I have seen this so many times. I have seen cases through work and in newspapers.

I am inclined to think now that SWs find the mothers and children easier to talk to and influence more than criminally intentioned males.
The OP has moved so many times to get away from him she has shown clearly that she does not want him in her life or the child's life so why are SS upsetting the mum and child and not the perpetrator?

RubyViola · 02/05/2022 13:53

@JetTail yes my family have been great and my brother has been especially supportive and helped out with getting proper security for the house.

I'm okay with money, not well off but we don't struggle and we go to lots of activities and classes at weekends.

I did try the freedom programme but didn't find it useful

OP posts:
JetTail · 02/05/2022 13:52

RubyViola · 02/05/2022 13:45

@JetTail I've had a look at the sentencing guidelines and he meets every single one of the aggravating factors and would be in the highest category (if everything is done correctly and the judge is thorough). I would be so disappointed if he gets concurrent sentences - I hadn't even thought about that so Thankyou .

This is the last address he found and was arrested shortly after - I have only just in the last month found another house to rent which will be vacant next week. SS are pleased that I'm moving and were shocked that I was able to organise this myself Hmm they really do treat people like they're incompetent

I'm so sorry that you have to keep moving. Do prepare yourself though for concurrent sentencing and time served on remand. Leniency is often involved if the cnut's solicitor can prove what a fucking exemplary arsehole the cnut is.

I'm wondering whether police might be the ones to assist you better than SS? It's a gamble as you don't know what is going to be used against you sometimes.

Have you family support? Are you in a good position financially? Have you engaged in any suggested therapies the 'experts' aka SS have put out there?

RubyViola · 02/05/2022 13:45

@JetTail I've had a look at the sentencing guidelines and he meets every single one of the aggravating factors and would be in the highest category (if everything is done correctly and the judge is thorough). I would be so disappointed if he gets concurrent sentences - I hadn't even thought about that so Thankyou .

This is the last address he found and was arrested shortly after - I have only just in the last month found another house to rent which will be vacant next week. SS are pleased that I'm moving and were shocked that I was able to organise this myself Hmm they really do treat people like they're incompetent

OP posts:
JetTail · 02/05/2022 13:42

Wanderingowl · 02/05/2022 13:35

Have you ever considered reading the fucking thread before being an utter fucking arsehole to an abuse victim asking for help?

Arrogance combined with idiocy isn't ever a good combination. 🙂

JetTail · 02/05/2022 13:41

Another thing to bear in mind OP is something I learned the hard way. I worked, I provided entirely for my child with no support from anyone. This was not interpreted as me being extremely capable! This was interpreted as me being vulnerable!! 😯

I'm not sure how much support you have, but external support is one of the things SS like to see. Family support or similar. It is acknowledged that mothers with very little outside support are more vulnerable to returning to an abuser. Contrary to proving how capable you are, being entirely unsupported is seen as a risk. So if you have family, friends or neighbours or therapy helping you along, you need to tell SS about this. Financial vulnerability is another one they don't like to see as if you're impoverished, you will go back to an abuser. Low self esteem, refusal to engage in suggested therapies, these are all red flags to social services. So, you tell them about your support system, what support you have etc. etc. You get the gist without me needing to spell it out. YOU HAVE support and tell them so. 🙃

SommerTen · 02/05/2022 13:37

@tomatoandherbs the OPs ex is not 'psychotic'!!
Psychotic means he would be in a state of psychosis ie seriously mentally unwell.
Those in psychosis actually rarely harm others.
Sorry to be picky but I suffer with symptoms of psychosis at times & my pet hate is when people mistake 'psychotic' for 'psychopathic'. Which is what I think you actually meant.

And please don't victim blame @RubyViola for having a child with her ex, that's ridiculous!!