Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To if your partner hit your child would you leave them?

166 replies

StarvedMagnolia · 01/05/2022 23:15

What would you do if your partner hit your child? The first time? Would you leave them? Would it depend on what kind of "hitting" it was or what the circumstances are? Or the frequency?

It's a hypothetical situation for me but I always thought if my partner ever raised a hand against my or our child I would leave them irrespective of anything else. I'd feel as if I'm not protecting or standing up for my child otherwise. On the other hand I guess it's not that easy. (If it was a light smack and a one off it might be better for the kids to stay together?? Also, I've got no idea what the legal position is. Wouldn't the partner still have visiting / custody rights anyway or would any fork of violence always result in something like supervised visits only?) I don't think I could respect my partner if they were violent to my or our children.

I'm just wondering if I am being unreasonable. Every once in a while a thread crops up from an upset mum (I've only seen ones from mums) where they are devastated that they have hit their child and everyone tells them not to worry and to just move on. If my partner did that I don't think I could move on.

What do you think? Am I too extreme? Too sanctimonious to think that everyone (including me) can and should avoid being violent to their children?

OP posts:
Marty13 · 02/05/2022 12:16

"we’d never accept physical punishment on any other person in society, but it’s ok to smack children?"

If a husband had the final word on medical treatment for his wife, and decided where she was allowed to go, and never allowed her to go anywhere without him, that would be considered abusive. Yet the same is generally considered to be in their best interests when it's a child instead of a wife.

My point is, a relationship between an adult and a child is not the same as the relationship between two adults.

Last night my son wiped his fork on my arm. I wiped my dirty arm back on him. He was upset. I told him "it's not nice, is it ? Then why do it to me ?" If he slapped me (deliberately) and was old enough to understand what he's doing I can't promise I wouldn't slap back to show him exactly how not nice it is. Although I hope I'll raise him well enough that this situation will never happen.

My parents slapped and spanked me. It didn't happen very often and when it did I knew exactly what I'd done to deserve it. And frankly I did deserve it. But I'm sure some people will come along to diagnose me with some kind of trauma 🙄

pigsDOfly · 02/05/2022 12:15

fUNNYfACE36 · 02/05/2022 03:37

Any violence towards me would be a deal breaker. Reasonable chastisement to a child eg a well deserved smacked bum after a warning, i would be ok with. I would not do it myself, but it is not my job to police partner's parenting style, so long as it's not abusive

Under what circumstances is slapping any part of a child's body 'well deserved'? And you're okay with that?

But if your partner thought you needed a 'well deserved' slap that isn't okay?

I'm finding it really hard to understand your double standards.

If my partner slapped either me or my children I'd very much make it my job to police my partner's parenting style.

Whelmed · 02/05/2022 12:03

No I wouldn't leave my partner for it. There are better ways of dealing with the situation.

Same1977 · 02/05/2022 11:59

Surely discussion would be in order to make sure it doesn't repeat.However if the child is biologically their they also have a right to decide the type of discipline goes.
Women on here forget children are not 80 percent theirs and 20 the fathers.
Also if this is a one off what is worse one off physical chastising or broken family unit.
It is well know (proven by countless studies ) children dare better in functioning family units

badspella · 02/05/2022 11:48

There is hitting and there is hitting, and there is hitting and hitting (and hitting). The problem is not whether we we would leave the partner who hit too hard or hit too frequently, but rather , it is whether we could leave.

Situations in which domestic abuse occurs are often really complex, and a partner can know that what is happening is wrong, but they may not have the means of capacity to leave; they may be victims of the same violence themselves, or there may be a myriad of other reasons why the partner feels s/he could not take the child/ren and leave.

ASandwichNamedKevin · 02/05/2022 11:32

Smacking children is an absolute no in our family. So is threat of violence.

@PumpkinsandKittens your comment just makes me sad that you know many people who choose to hit their children. I would be genuinely shocked if any of my friends did that.
Can I ask if you're in the UK?

I still remember my mum smacking my sibling and we were all upset. I can visualise it so clearly because it really shocked me at the time.
One set of my grandparents did smack.
If a relative lifted a finger to my child that would be it.

Kanaloa · 02/05/2022 11:29

MarinoRoyale · 02/05/2022 11:22

My reasoning for not condoning hitting children is on my first post on page 1. I’m more interested in hearing how those who DO hit children justify it to themselves and the wider world.

Let me trot out the usual justifications.

A short sharp shock is much better than being sent to their room.

What else are you supposed to do, just beg them to behave while cowering as they bash you over the head? That’s why kids nowadays blah blah.

Well he was just about to swan dive into the bath holding a toaster so what else could I do but smack him? There was no other possible way.

When they’re too young to understand hitting them is the only way to communicate.

The real justification is ‘I get wound up by challenging behaviour. Hitting my child relieves that momentarily. I don’t know any other way to correctly teach appropriate behaviour and this is an easy way to frighten my child into obedience.’

MarinoRoyale · 02/05/2022 11:22

fUNNYfACE36 · 02/05/2022 11:17

A measured response is worse in my opinion, I can see how some parents get to the end of their tether but to calmly decide the best option is to hit a child is unforgivable.
That, as you say, is just your opinion, which you havent even attempted to justify.

My reasoning for not condoning hitting children is on my first post on page 1. I’m more interested in hearing how those who DO hit children justify it to themselves and the wider world.

MrsLargeEmbodied · 02/05/2022 11:21

so you are saying,
mother comes on mumsnt, end of tether, smacked child
her dh also end of tether smacks child
double standard answers given?

ApplesAndChalk · 02/05/2022 11:18

OldieWordly · 01/05/2022 23:40

What has happened to the world that everything is thought of only in black and white and nothing allowed in between?

Is context, situation, and reasoning now irrelevant?

Leaving your partner, for a light tap on the back of a child's hand then no, YABU.

Leaving your partner for throwing the child across the room, yes, YANBU

Exactly this.
And, in the first case scenario, if it upset me, I would TALK to them about it. But not leave on a first offence, IYSWIM.
Second scenario is very obviously a different kettle of fish.

MrsLargeEmbodied · 02/05/2022 11:17

pointless subject to discuss.

fUNNYfACE36 · 02/05/2022 11:17

A measured response is worse in my opinion, I can see how some parents get to the end of their tether but to calmly decide the best option is to hit a child is unforgivable.
That, as you say, is just your opinion, which you havent even attempted to justify.

foxlover47 · 02/05/2022 11:15

I went to child services and to court when I saw my ex hit my child (3 at the time )
What he did to me was to me , what he did to my child was my responsibility to make sure he couldn't ever do it again

biggirlknickers · 02/05/2022 11:13

“Leaving your partner, for a light tap on the back of a child's hand then no, YABU.

Leaving your partner for throwing the child across the room, yes, YANBU”

There’s a whole world of different scenarios in between these two, including what my ex did to our DC. I left him because of it. I drew the line - I had to draw it somewhere.

MarinoRoyale · 02/05/2022 11:12

fUNNYfACE36 · 02/05/2022 11:07

be told it’s rarely ever a one off and it will escalate
Tbis is why you should never smack a child unless you are in control of your own emotions. A measured response NOT lashing out

A measured response is worse in my opinion, I can see how some parents get to the end of their tether but to calmly decide the best option is to hit a child is unforgivable.

SinaraSmith · 02/05/2022 11:10

fUNNYfACE36 · 02/05/2022 11:07

be told it’s rarely ever a one off and it will escalate
Tbis is why you should never smack a child unless you are in control of your own emotions. A measured response NOT lashing out

I think for a lot of us, a calm but measured and well thought out smack is just as bad.

If dp hit me in a calm, but measured and well thought out way because I was acting unacceptably to him, then I doubt anyone would be saying ‘he didn’t do it in temper so it’s ok’

OverItThanks · 02/05/2022 11:10

I’ve never understood smacking, we’d never accept physical punishment on any other person in society, but it’s ok to smack children? The most vulnerable? I wouldn’t accept DH giving me a smack, even a ‘light tap’. And I’m sure I can frustrate him something rotten sometimes.

It’s also very rarely isolated.

Smacking isn’t illegal no, but neither is giving a 6 year old alcohol in the home - seriously! Doesn’t mean you should do it. Laws don’t always make sense, we’ve still got a long way to go there.

In regards to leaving, if he was remorseful and it’s wasn’t hard no I wouldn’t, but I would also be policing his parenting and getting him to apologise to our child. A second time - I’m out.

PumpkinsandKittens · 02/05/2022 11:09

Kanaloa · 02/05/2022 11:05

There was plenty of us on that thread saying it was unacceptable. Rather than the posts insisting ‘oh it’s ok we all do it when they’re naughty’ there were lots of posts saying this was a situation where preventative measures had to be put in place ie managing a child’s behaviour and learning to teach your child to behave better, not letting their behaviour spiral out of control then hitting them in anger/temper.

Especially in that case because the crime the child was being hit for? Was hitting!! What sort of lesson does that teach? You must NOT hit anyone. Unless you’re much bigger and stronger than them, then it’s just a ‘tap.’

90% of the posters was telling the op it was fine and she should forgive herself and it’s not a big deal. Anyway no I wouldn’t leave a partner for this, irl most people I know smack occasionally.

HalfShrunkMoreToGo · 02/05/2022 11:08

Smacking/tapping whatever you want to call it goes completely against by beliefs on how children should be raised. Before marrying and having children DH and I spoke about how we would want to raise our children, what we considered acceptable, what we considered unacceptable. We both were clear that any kind of physical rebuke meant no matter how light or how many warnings would not be used.

So if he were to 'tap' DD it would mean he wasn't the person I thought he was and that he told me he was. It would definitely make me look more closely at our relationship.

fUNNYfACE36 · 02/05/2022 11:07

be told it’s rarely ever a one off and it will escalate
Tbis is why you should never smack a child unless you are in control of your own emotions. A measured response NOT lashing out

Kanaloa · 02/05/2022 11:05

PumpkinsandKittens · 02/05/2022 10:48

Nope I wouldn’t leave for this, smacking is not illegal and back in the real world everyone I know smacks their kids so I would be left very lonely if I cut everyone off for it! There was a a thread of here the other day where a woman smacked her 4 year old and she got nothing but sympathy even someone saying children can provoke you to smack them! Funny how this thread is very different

There was plenty of us on that thread saying it was unacceptable. Rather than the posts insisting ‘oh it’s ok we all do it when they’re naughty’ there were lots of posts saying this was a situation where preventative measures had to be put in place ie managing a child’s behaviour and learning to teach your child to behave better, not letting their behaviour spiral out of control then hitting them in anger/temper.

Especially in that case because the crime the child was being hit for? Was hitting!! What sort of lesson does that teach? You must NOT hit anyone. Unless you’re much bigger and stronger than them, then it’s just a ‘tap.’

SinaraSmith · 02/05/2022 11:03

Accept. Not operate 😳

SinaraSmith · 02/05/2022 11:00

I don’t operate violence against children at all. So dp would be gone.

I clicked off the most recent thread of ‘I hit my child but feel so bad. But also here is my list of excuse why I did it’. The posters falling over themselves to reassure the poster that it’s a one off makes me feel a bit sick.

if a posted that their husband did the same (to either them or their child) in the same circumstances and was really sorry, they would be told it’s rarely ever a one off and it will escalate. The poster would be told they must leave their dp to protect their kids.

I hate posts like that

MarinoRoyale · 02/05/2022 10:51

I would leave them, I’ve never smacked my children and it’s not common in my social circle to do so. Dressing it up as a “tap” or whatever you want to call it doesn’t detract from the fact an adult is using their superior strength and position of power to intimidate a child to conform.

PumpkinsandKittens · 02/05/2022 10:48

Nope I wouldn’t leave for this, smacking is not illegal and back in the real world everyone I know smacks their kids so I would be left very lonely if I cut everyone off for it! There was a a thread of here the other day where a woman smacked her 4 year old and she got nothing but sympathy even someone saying children can provoke you to smack them! Funny how this thread is very different

Swipe left for the next trending thread