Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To if your partner hit your child would you leave them?

166 replies

StarvedMagnolia · 01/05/2022 23:15

What would you do if your partner hit your child? The first time? Would you leave them? Would it depend on what kind of "hitting" it was or what the circumstances are? Or the frequency?

It's a hypothetical situation for me but I always thought if my partner ever raised a hand against my or our child I would leave them irrespective of anything else. I'd feel as if I'm not protecting or standing up for my child otherwise. On the other hand I guess it's not that easy. (If it was a light smack and a one off it might be better for the kids to stay together?? Also, I've got no idea what the legal position is. Wouldn't the partner still have visiting / custody rights anyway or would any fork of violence always result in something like supervised visits only?) I don't think I could respect my partner if they were violent to my or our children.

I'm just wondering if I am being unreasonable. Every once in a while a thread crops up from an upset mum (I've only seen ones from mums) where they are devastated that they have hit their child and everyone tells them not to worry and to just move on. If my partner did that I don't think I could move on.

What do you think? Am I too extreme? Too sanctimonious to think that everyone (including me) can and should avoid being violent to their children?

OP posts:
Shakeitshakeitbaby · 03/05/2022 00:40

I would leave. Completely unacceptable.

Colourfulrainbows · 03/05/2022 00:19

I would end the relationship and have nothing more to do with them.

Nobody hits my child. No justification for it. I would not hit a child.

Would you be OK with a friend or teacher smacking your child? Because child do play up for others.

If not then why on earth would it be OK for a partner do so do.

I don't believe in smacking, there is plenty of other ways to teach children positive behaviour.

12yearsinazkaban · 03/05/2022 00:16

JoeGoldberg · 02/05/2022 12:25

@Pancakesbeforesunset I left my marriage with just a few of the kids belonging and our clothes in a black bag. We slept on my parents floor for a month while I frantically found us somewhere to live. So I'm sorry but you don't have to have the means or your 'ducks in a row', you just have to be at the end of your tether.

so what would have happened if your parents turned you away? would you have slept on the street with them for a month? no?

Having to sleep on your parents floor is having the means to leave. I'm sorry you had to.

doggiescats · 03/05/2022 00:08

I have never smacked my children…I have walked away,gone into the garden ,sat in my car for a few minutes…all to calm down!! I just think smacking/ hitting is a weakness and I would never behave like that with a child.

12yearsinazkaban · 03/05/2022 00:04

oh great, another stick to beat victims of abuse with.
this week: its all your fault... again.

HalfShrunkMoreToGo · 03/05/2022 00:00

I've never understood why anyone would smack/tap a child.

My 7yr old is 14 inches shorter than me, so me smacking her would be the equivalent of a 6ft 10 inch person smacking me (5ft 8). Would anyone who saw that say it was acceptable?

If smacking/tapping is used only for very serious naughty behaviour, what is that behaviour? The worst thing I can imagine my child doing at this age is bullying/hitting another kid. So the ridiculously hypocritical scenario would be:

"DD you know that hitting is wrong and bad and should never be done! I will now hit you to punish you for your crime of hitting".

It's madness.

AngeloMysterioso · 02/05/2022 23:41

If it’s not ok for adults to smack each other, then it’s not ok for adults to smack children. I would never smack my DC and I would leave DH if he did. My Mum smacked me regularly as a child and it didn’t change my behaviour, it just made me angry and resentful towards her.

The number of people trying to justify disciplining their children with violence by framing it as “a quick smack” or a “tap” is fucking sickening.

JoeGoldberg · 02/05/2022 23:28

fUNNYfACE36 · 02/05/2022 23:15

We can never have a meaningful debate about smacking, because so many posters are too thick to see the difference between tapping a child's hand and abuse.

What does tapping a child's hand achieve exactly? It just shows them that if someone smaller and weaker disobeys them they can hit them. Way to go. Not.

ElfDragon · 02/05/2022 23:23

Yes, and I did. Well, I started the process. exH refused to leave, and I couldn’t (no money, 3 disabled dc), so it took almost 2 years before we were living separately, but I initiated divorce, and I made sure it didn’t happen again.

re: contact and access, yes, he is allowed access. I don’t agree he should be, and I don’t like the way he treats the dc (no more violence), but I am not able to stop contact. We had social services involved over eldest dc (the one he hit), but tbh, other than talking to him and then telling me that he said he only did it because he was stressed (like that apparently makes it ok!), they did nothing.

fUNNYfACE36 · 02/05/2022 23:15

We can never have a meaningful debate about smacking, because so many posters are too thick to see the difference between tapping a child's hand and abuse.

StyxBankDweller · 02/05/2022 18:10

Bednobsbroomsticks · 02/05/2022 08:41

I would police my partners parenting if he hit the kids . A light tap i would say no that's not how I want to raise the children . If he stopped then fine if he continued I'd have to rethink definitely

I totally agree. Parents should have a united approach to parenting and for me that means all sorts of hitting are out. Fortunately, my late husband and I were on the same page from the start.

IncompleteSenten · 02/05/2022 17:03

Yes I would. Having been hit as a child I have zero tolerance for it.

Before we had children we sat down and discussed our beliefs and one of my non negotiables was hitting the children. It is absolutely out of the question.

He also felt that way. Tbh, I would not have stayed with him if he believed hurting them was acceptable.

Frogslegsbigfeet · 02/05/2022 17:00

Yes of course that’s a once and out situation. I wouldn’t let him hit me and I’d even less let him hit a child, mine or anyone else’s.

SinaraSmith · 02/05/2022 16:59

Pancakesbeforesunset · 02/05/2022 16:24

@SinaraSmith

What do you mean by at risk?

Yes she would allow him to abuse her child, and they were together during part of my childhood up to now. He's been abusive throughout, it's been very damaging, even though it was never physical from him though that I'm aware of. I would've rather taken a hit if I'm honest, mum has even acknowledged this and feels this way herself, so I'm unsure that she would draw the line at physical abuse. If there is any line, I'm not sure. They keep breaking up and getting back together, but she's never actually left him. Breaking up involves sleeping on the couch for a night and nothing else.

Then that child would be removed because it would be the absolute wrong thing. A child isn’t in more danger in a hostel or hotel, than they are at home with their abuser.

Your mum can leave. It’s incredibly hard. But she can. Right now she is choosing not to. Understandably. But she can leave.

Someone whose kids are being hit, have a responsibility to those kids to leave. Of course it often takes time and is difficult but it’s doable for the vast majority of people.

SinaraSmith · 02/05/2022 16:54

ManyATime · 02/05/2022 16:36

@SinaraSmith
Thanks, I’m thinking of retaliation as much as self-defence.

No I don’t allow my kids to hit someone in retaliation or in temper. Especially, someone who isn’t not a danger to them and much smaller and weaker.

My kids kickbox and it’s something enforced by the Dojo as well.

Wordlecurdle · 02/05/2022 16:54

Hitting a child as a punishment evokes a scenario in which the adult is in control and is deliberately hurting their own child in order to teach them a lesson. If the adult is in control, then words and explanation can teach them the very same thing.

A parent who has lost control based on frustration as to how their child is acting is, well, a parent who has lost control. And that is never a good thing.

But what about a situation whereby immediate action is necessary? Say for example a child reaching for an open flame? Is a quick smack of the hand in order to get the child’s hand away from that danger ok? Forcefully pulling a child by their arm who is about to run out into the road of oncoming traffic?

There are many examples where you reacting in such a way that could potentially hurt your child is the only course of action. And that course of action in that moment may be needed to prevent an alternative which could be much worse.

Children demand 100% of their parents attention. Their social awareness is poor, and this can be tiresome and relentless, at the best of times. But the adult should know this. In short, every course of action that is taken as a parent should be in the best interests of their child, and while situations may and invariably will arise which require immediate action (which may hurt the child as a result), never should a child be intentionally struck as a punishment, or struck because the adult has themselves lost control.

For me, if my partner hit my child as a punishment or because they lost control themselves, then they would be my partner no more.

ManyATime · 02/05/2022 16:36

@SinaraSmith
Thanks, I’m thinking of retaliation as much as self-defence.

ManyATime · 02/05/2022 16:34

DysmalRadius · 02/05/2022 16:10

By that logic, surely the expectation is that your child will hit you back if you hit them?

Just asking. I’m genuinely wondering how people think these days.
And yes, that’s always a risk.
I did hit my Dad back once.

Pancakesbeforesunset · 02/05/2022 16:24

@SinaraSmith

What do you mean by at risk?

Yes she would allow him to abuse her child, and they were together during part of my childhood up to now. He's been abusive throughout, it's been very damaging, even though it was never physical from him though that I'm aware of. I would've rather taken a hit if I'm honest, mum has even acknowledged this and feels this way herself, so I'm unsure that she would draw the line at physical abuse. If there is any line, I'm not sure. They keep breaking up and getting back together, but she's never actually left him. Breaking up involves sleeping on the couch for a night and nothing else.

SpringLobelia · 02/05/2022 16:13

Yes. One off smack, yes I would leave.

I was hit alot as a child and I know how it feels. I would not be able to stomach staying.

It has to be said though that I am looking through a prism where I work with families who are usually in need in some way. Hitting in my experience is the tip of the iceberg and I would find it hard toi believe that it is not symptomatic of violence being normalised.

DysmalRadius · 02/05/2022 16:10

ManyATime · 02/05/2022 15:12

To all those saying it’s always unacceptable:
if someone of whatever size hit your child wouldn’t you want your child to hit them back?
or at least you’d consider it reasonable?

By that logic, surely the expectation is that your child will hit you back if you hit them?

Underhisi · 02/05/2022 16:09

A one off end of tether smack- no
Violent assault - yes.
I wouldn't choose to have children with someone who used smacking as discipline.

SinaraSmith · 02/05/2022 15:59

ManyATime · 02/05/2022 15:12

To all those saying it’s always unacceptable:
if someone of whatever size hit your child wouldn’t you want your child to hit them back?
or at least you’d consider it reasonable?

If they were defending their own safety. Yes I would be fine with him hitting another child back.

However, an adult hitting a child as punishment isn’t trying to preserve their own safety. The vast majority of times it is not because the adult is trying to protect themselves. If a parent hurt a child who was very strong and was hurting them and the parent defended themselves I think most people would have sympathy. But that’s not what we are talking about.

clairemaddox · 02/05/2022 15:59

Yes 100%. Attacking children, or anyone, is not on. But if someone physically assaulted my child I would not have them around my child again.

SinaraSmith · 02/05/2022 15:54

Pancakesbeforesunset · 02/05/2022 12:58

@SinaraSmith Some people have nowhere to go besides a homeless shelter or the street and it would leave them open to worse abuse especially if they are vulnerable. I have no idea why my mum wont disclose that he is an abuser but I'm sure she's got her reasons or she would've done it

Even if a child was at risk?

She would allow him to abuse her child? That’s what I asked

Swipe left for the next trending thread