Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To if your partner hit your child would you leave them?

166 replies

StarvedMagnolia · 01/05/2022 23:15

What would you do if your partner hit your child? The first time? Would you leave them? Would it depend on what kind of "hitting" it was or what the circumstances are? Or the frequency?

It's a hypothetical situation for me but I always thought if my partner ever raised a hand against my or our child I would leave them irrespective of anything else. I'd feel as if I'm not protecting or standing up for my child otherwise. On the other hand I guess it's not that easy. (If it was a light smack and a one off it might be better for the kids to stay together?? Also, I've got no idea what the legal position is. Wouldn't the partner still have visiting / custody rights anyway or would any fork of violence always result in something like supervised visits only?) I don't think I could respect my partner if they were violent to my or our children.

I'm just wondering if I am being unreasonable. Every once in a while a thread crops up from an upset mum (I've only seen ones from mums) where they are devastated that they have hit their child and everyone tells them not to worry and to just move on. If my partner did that I don't think I could move on.

What do you think? Am I too extreme? Too sanctimonious to think that everyone (including me) can and should avoid being violent to their children?

OP posts:
JoeGoldberg · 03/05/2022 17:29

My mother and father split for a very valid reason (my father at the time had an alchohol issue)

So alcohol abuse is a 'valid' reason to end a relationship but someone hitting a child isn't. Got it.

Is emotional abuse a 'valid' reason? How about marital rape? Financial abuse? Is that one ok?

It's no wonder women end up staying in shitty marriages 'for the sake of the children' when there's opinions like this kicking around.

A child in a one parent home that's stable, with no constant arguments or verbal abuse or a sly shove here and there does FAR better than a child having to suffer from a toxic relationship.

Beginning to despair at this thread. Think I'll hide it now.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 03/05/2022 17:27

@Same1977

Thanks for reconsidering using the phrase, it's one that is fundamentally damaging to women and children more than it is to men.

My mother and father split for a very valid reason (my father at the time had an alchohol issue) .So I definitely do not advocate staying in harmful enviroment.

But you said earlier you wish your dad had been around every day and you were disappointed your parents split because it meant he wasn't and you had to go between two houses etc. As much as it was tough for you, your mum took you out of an environment that previously saw you living with an alcoholic adult. She made the right and loving choice doing that and it's a bit heartbreaking that years later you say:

I would have love to have my father around every day.Instead of years of hostility then some random women, men involved in my parents lives,having to stay at different homes seperate birthdays,holidays etc.It takes a toll on a child.

Because the toll of living with one alcoholic parent and one enabler parent would have been far greater and much more irresponsible of them both.

She did her best to get you out of a harmful home.

Same1977 · 03/05/2022 17:23

KettrickenSmiled · 03/05/2022 17:20

Do you know how damaging broken family is to a child?

You've really got an agenda on this thread ain'tcha, @Same1977 ?
Given that half UK marriages end in divorce, I think the nation's kids are bearing up ok.

OK is not the same as good.

Same1977 · 03/05/2022 17:20

youvegottenminuteslynn · 03/05/2022 17:06

@Same1977

The phrase broken family (along with broken home) has been used for decades on end to shame women into staying in shitty relationships to the detriment of themselves and their children.

It's a horrible phrase that harms children whose parents are no longer in a relationship. It tells children that their family is bad, wrong, less than and not an emotionally safe place. In fact, many parents are perfectly capable of breaking up and co-parenting lovingly with their child as priority.

The child not living in a toxic home or witnessing toxic relationships should be the dream here. Not staying put and remaining unhappy in a toxic dynamic due to the shame attached to such an unhealthy 'broken home' / 'broken family' narrative.

Please consider not using those phrases any more.

Noted! Was not meant for that.My mother and father split for a very valid reason (my father at the time had an alchohol issue) .So I definitely do not advocate staying in harmful enviroment.

I just hate that marriage has become something very few fight for even when kids are involved.

KettrickenSmiled · 03/05/2022 17:20

Do you know how damaging broken family is to a child?

You've really got an agenda on this thread ain'tcha, @Same1977 ?
Given that half UK marriages end in divorce, I think the nation's kids are bearing up ok.

buzzy06 · 03/05/2022 17:18

The phrase broken family (along with broken home) has been used for decades on end to shame women into staying in shitty relationships to the detriment of themselves and their children.

Yes @youvegottenminuteslynn. It's also the same people who will complain if a woman remarries etc. to avoid being a single mother/or bearer of a 'broken' family.

Broken family is very outdated as a phrase.

EvilPea · 03/05/2022 17:12

I struggle when dh tells the kids off (he’s their dad) even when it’s perfectly valid. I immediately defend them and completely undermine him, I can’t help it. So god knows how I’d be if anyone touched them.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 03/05/2022 17:08

@Same1977

I would have love to have my father around every day.Instead of years of hostility then some random women, men involved in my parents lives,having to stay at different homes seperate birthdays,holidays etc.

I'm sorry you had a tough time. That was due to your parents handling the split poorly and introducing you to lots of partners etc. Had they handled it lovingly and as a team, focusing on making you feel safe and secure in your attachment to both of them, they could have split up in a healthy way.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 03/05/2022 17:06

@Same1977

The phrase broken family (along with broken home) has been used for decades on end to shame women into staying in shitty relationships to the detriment of themselves and their children.

It's a horrible phrase that harms children whose parents are no longer in a relationship. It tells children that their family is bad, wrong, less than and not an emotionally safe place. In fact, many parents are perfectly capable of breaking up and co-parenting lovingly with their child as priority.

The child not living in a toxic home or witnessing toxic relationships should be the dream here. Not staying put and remaining unhappy in a toxic dynamic due to the shame attached to such an unhealthy 'broken home' / 'broken family' narrative.

Please consider not using those phrases any more.

Same1977 · 03/05/2022 17:05

SinaraSmith · 03/05/2022 17:00

What is a broken family to you?

How would describe that?

Obviously there are exceptions (too many to count )but traditional family unit of both parents being together and sharing home with their kids.I come from a broken family and I can tell by a mile if someone comes from a happy family.
I would have love to have my father around every day.Instead of years of hostility then some random women, men involved in my parents lives,having to stay at different homes seperate birthdays,holidays etc.
It takes a toll on a child.
It's my personal opinion but when children are involved (I have a child myself) I believe relationships really ought to be fought for (if possible )

SinaraSmith · 03/05/2022 17:02

And would a teenager only be seeing their dad once a week? If they want to see them more?

SinaraSmith · 03/05/2022 17:00

Same1977 · 03/05/2022 16:55

Honestly whatever the question mumsnets answer is always 'leave him'
Do you know how damaging broken family is to a child?
If thai is a one off then I can imagine explaining to your teenager later on that the reason they saw their father once every week is because of a single smack.
Honestly...sometimes I wonder who the commentators are.
Plenty of broken families as it is.
Talk!Resolve and set boundaries.

What is a broken family to you?

How would describe that?

JoeGoldberg · 03/05/2022 16:58

Do you know how damaging broken family is to a child?

Seriously???

Do you know how damaging staying in a home where a slap or a shove is to a child?

Wtf am I reading here??

Same1977 · 03/05/2022 16:55

Honestly whatever the question mumsnets answer is always 'leave him'
Do you know how damaging broken family is to a child?
If thai is a one off then I can imagine explaining to your teenager later on that the reason they saw their father once every week is because of a single smack.
Honestly...sometimes I wonder who the commentators are.
Plenty of broken families as it is.
Talk!Resolve and set boundaries.

buzzy06 · 03/05/2022 16:38

MrsLargeEmbodied · 02/05/2022 11:17

pointless subject to discuss.

Need to at least describe what kind of hitting. Pointless if some people are thinking of a smack on the leg after a long day, and others are thinking of cranking a cane out.

bluesapphire48 · 03/05/2022 16:34

Testing

anon2334 · 03/05/2022 16:23

I meant a friend of mine who's partner at the time smacked the kids, noy her, the court and cafcass recommended contact for dad despite that as she didn't want the kids to go weekends because he used smacking as discipline , he got shared holidays and lots of contact as well.

anon2334 · 03/05/2022 16:20

StarvedMagnolia · 01/05/2022 23:15

What would you do if your partner hit your child? The first time? Would you leave them? Would it depend on what kind of "hitting" it was or what the circumstances are? Or the frequency?

It's a hypothetical situation for me but I always thought if my partner ever raised a hand against my or our child I would leave them irrespective of anything else. I'd feel as if I'm not protecting or standing up for my child otherwise. On the other hand I guess it's not that easy. (If it was a light smack and a one off it might be better for the kids to stay together?? Also, I've got no idea what the legal position is. Wouldn't the partner still have visiting / custody rights anyway or would any fork of violence always result in something like supervised visits only?) I don't think I could respect my partner if they were violent to my or our children.

I'm just wondering if I am being unreasonable. Every once in a while a thread crops up from an upset mum (I've only seen ones from mums) where they are devastated that they have hit their child and everyone tells them not to worry and to just move on. If my partner did that I don't think I could move on.

What do you think? Am I too extreme? Too sanctimonious to think that everyone (including me) can and should avoid being violent to their children?

It's not llegal. A friend of mine did this, they still get contact unless it's bruising and really beating the child or very serious abuse it would never be enough to stop contact. Smacking as punishment will not stop contact at all. This was recent too for a friend, it has to be very bad before judges don't grant any contact to a parent.

I don't agree with it and don't smack but its not illegal.

Kanaloa · 03/05/2022 16:05

fUNNYfACE36 · 03/05/2022 15:33

The dictionary defines 'tap' as a quick light blow

You sound desperate.

JoeGoldberg · 03/05/2022 15:58

@Shakeitshakeitbaby sorry yes I just realised, of course it's already illegal in Scotland and Wales. I've got toddler brain today!

It should be illegal in England too, and all this bullshit about not wanting to 'nanny' parents it just that - bullshit.

Valeriekat · 03/05/2022 15:54

But murder is OK?

fUNNYfACE36 · 03/05/2022 15:33

The dictionary defines 'tap' as a quick light blow

Kanaloa · 03/05/2022 14:46

fUNNYfACE36 · 03/05/2022 13:36

Every punishment hurts in some way, otherwise it wouldn't be a punishment

What a weird way to justify hitting your kids. We don’t even hit people to punish them for murder.

Kanaloa · 03/05/2022 14:45

fUNNYfACE36 · 03/05/2022 13:34

Have you seen how cats give a warning tap? It is already illegal ti strike achild in a way which leaves a mark. How forcefully do you think you can smack anyone without leaving a mark?

Cats also lick their arseholes and shit in my garden so I wouldn’t hold them up as parenting examples. They also swat at their young because (as animals) they don’t have as many ways of communication as we humans do.

A tap isn’t what is being talked about. If you genuinely tap your children as punishment (which wouldn’t even register) then you’re not what’s being talked about.

erikbloodaxe · 03/05/2022 14:08

Smacking and hitting are the same thing. The word 'just' often appears before smack/smacked/smacking though. To lessen the offence. Smack = Hit

Swipe left for the next trending thread