Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To if your partner hit your child would you leave them?

166 replies

StarvedMagnolia · 01/05/2022 23:15

What would you do if your partner hit your child? The first time? Would you leave them? Would it depend on what kind of "hitting" it was or what the circumstances are? Or the frequency?

It's a hypothetical situation for me but I always thought if my partner ever raised a hand against my or our child I would leave them irrespective of anything else. I'd feel as if I'm not protecting or standing up for my child otherwise. On the other hand I guess it's not that easy. (If it was a light smack and a one off it might be better for the kids to stay together?? Also, I've got no idea what the legal position is. Wouldn't the partner still have visiting / custody rights anyway or would any fork of violence always result in something like supervised visits only?) I don't think I could respect my partner if they were violent to my or our children.

I'm just wondering if I am being unreasonable. Every once in a while a thread crops up from an upset mum (I've only seen ones from mums) where they are devastated that they have hit their child and everyone tells them not to worry and to just move on. If my partner did that I don't think I could move on.

What do you think? Am I too extreme? Too sanctimonious to think that everyone (including me) can and should avoid being violent to their children?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
CapMarvel · 04/05/2022 14:26

ManyATime · 04/05/2022 11:51

They don’t represent the same level of violence and nastiness. It’s that simple. I think you are tying yourself in knots to suggest otherwise.

I would disagree. Hitting a child, regardless of where that hit lands is not acceptable. Really the only difference between it being on the face/arm etc is that it's harder to hide bruises on the face for those so inclinded.

If my partner hit my kids that would be an absolute deal breaker.

5128gap · 04/05/2022 14:18

Kanaloa · 04/05/2022 14:07

@5128gap

Yes I understand that people who hit their kids are trying to aim for areas that will cause their child pain/humiliation rather than serious injury.

That question was actually for the poster who said face slapping is totally different as it’s ‘violent and nasty’ whereas slapping the rest of the body isn’t. I was just wondering why it’s violent and nasty to slap one part of your child but not another part.

I know. Its something people struggle with if they are of a generation where they were smacked or gave the occasional smack. My loving, non violent mum smacked my bottom on occasion and hated it, but believed it was her duty to overcome her instinct and punish me for my own good. She wasn't abusive, she was just acting within the norms of the day. Obviously things have changed, as they should, but people struggle to reconcile behaviour that is abusive and violent through today's lens, with their memories of loving parents delivering what was considered appropriate punishment at the time; hence making the same sort of distinctions that were made in decades past.

Kanaloa · 04/05/2022 14:07

@5128gap

Yes I understand that people who hit their kids are trying to aim for areas that will cause their child pain/humiliation rather than serious injury.

That question was actually for the poster who said face slapping is totally different as it’s ‘violent and nasty’ whereas slapping the rest of the body isn’t. I was just wondering why it’s violent and nasty to slap one part of your child but not another part.

JoeGoldberg · 04/05/2022 13:55

Kanaloa · 04/05/2022 11:40

Honestly I knew anyone who hits kids had to be pretty stupid but the knots people will tie themselves in to try and make it sound acceptable is shocking.

Isn't it just. So much justification and minimising in order to make it sound acceptable when it just isn't on any level.

user1471598758 · 04/05/2022 13:54

Slightly different as we were already separated, but my ex threatened our children with smacking and as a result missed contact time with them because I didn’t send them again until he’d apologized and promised he would never do it. So yeah I think I would leave a partner over it, I feel pretty strongly about violence towards children.

5128gap · 04/05/2022 13:50

Kanaloa · 04/05/2022 11:39

Okay, so why is it acceptable then? Why is slapping a child on the upper arm or bottom okay and acceptable to you, but slapping their face is unacceptable? They both represent the same levels of violence and nastiness. They both hurt and humiliate. Why is the face not okay?

And a silly story about your mother slapping your arm as an adult is irrelevant. As is the fact that you’d find it humiliating to stand facing a corner - that’s a hugely outdated punishment and nobody is suggesting it as a good alternative to hitting children.

No smacking is OK. But the distinction arises because the face is more delicate than the bottom or limbs and there is risk of injury to the child of being struck near the eyes, nose or mouth. When smacking was acceptable in previous decades most parents restricted it to areas where physical injury would not be the result.

Siht · 04/05/2022 13:17

ManyATime · 04/05/2022 11:51

They don’t represent the same level of violence and nastiness. It’s that simple. I think you are tying yourself in knots to suggest otherwise.

I also don't understand why your dad slapping your hand away wouldn't be acceptable but your mum doing it is? Sex/gender shouldn't be an issue, a slap is a slap.
It also doesn't really equate, your mum moving your (adult) hand away to keep you from opening up stitches, likely causing you no pain, to a child being hit/slapped/spanked/however it's framed, as punishment.

Kanaloa · 04/05/2022 12:10

ManyATime · 04/05/2022 11:51

They don’t represent the same level of violence and nastiness. It’s that simple. I think you are tying yourself in knots to suggest otherwise.

Why? How is slapping the bottom different that the face? What makes one act of violence ‘nastier’ than the other? I genuinely can’t see why one is worse or better than the other.

ManyATime · 04/05/2022 11:51

They don’t represent the same level of violence and nastiness. It’s that simple. I think you are tying yourself in knots to suggest otherwise.

Kanaloa · 04/05/2022 11:40

Honestly I knew anyone who hits kids had to be pretty stupid but the knots people will tie themselves in to try and make it sound acceptable is shocking.

Kanaloa · 04/05/2022 11:39

Okay, so why is it acceptable then? Why is slapping a child on the upper arm or bottom okay and acceptable to you, but slapping their face is unacceptable? They both represent the same levels of violence and nastiness. They both hurt and humiliate. Why is the face not okay?

And a silly story about your mother slapping your arm as an adult is irrelevant. As is the fact that you’d find it humiliating to stand facing a corner - that’s a hugely outdated punishment and nobody is suggesting it as a good alternative to hitting children.

ManyATime · 04/05/2022 11:16

“Slapping someone’s face is no different than slapping their legs/chest/bottom/arms. It’s the same action. If anything, it’s odd that you think slapping one part of someone’s body is acceptable violence while another isn’t.”

No, not really. The last time my mum slapped my arm and said ‘naughty’ it didn’t seem unacceptable. If she had slapped my face it would have been. I had been scratching my stitches following minor surgery so she wasn’t exactly joking. I was thirty-seven.
Admittedly, if my father had done that it probably wouldn’t have seemed acceptable, although still not a matter for police involvement.

I have to say I find punishments such as being made to stand facing the corner more humiliating and unacceptable. It would be the same in an adult relationship. There would have to be real malice involved in someone forcing their partner to do that.

I suppose I am just out of touch.

Kanaloa · 04/05/2022 08:16

fUNNYfACE36 · 04/05/2022 06:51

Nobody is talking about slapping anyone's face.
Straw man

Slapping someone’s face is no different than slapping their legs/chest/bottom/arms. It’s the same action. If anything, it’s odd that you think slapping one part of someone’s body is acceptable violence while another isn’t.

Although by your repeated attempts at justification and minimising I’m guessing you actually do know it’s wrong to hurt and hit people. Especially those vulnerable people in your care.

fUNNYfACE36 · 04/05/2022 06:51

Nobody is talking about slapping anyone's face.
Straw man

Kanaloa · 04/05/2022 01:23

I could understand if someone was very remorseful and it was a one off, why you wouldn’t leave them. It just wouldn’t work for me because it’s so far outside of our family values and philosophy that I couldn’t tolerate a man who loses his temper and hits people. I mean I’ve had bosses who are horrific, shouted in my face etc, I’ve dealt with o2 customer service several times, I’ve had customers swear at me. At no time during these necessary interactions was I allowed to ‘lose my temper’ and give someone a well-deserved slap in the face.

For me it would be my principles and lifestyle and I couldn’t overlook it or see my husband the same way again. I know he would feel the same if I hit one of the children.

StarvedMagnolia · 03/05/2022 20:21

Thanks for the replies everyone. For me the dilemma is that principally I am against violence against children and that includes any of its euphemisms like a smack or tap, etc. I always thought I'd have zero tolerance for that because it is WRONG.

However, at the end of the day we have to do what is best for the child. What is that? I'm obviously not talking about an abusive environment but a normal loving environment where a parent lost their temper, is regretful and apologetic and promises to never do it again.

I remember my sil once smacking her ds. She felt terrible about it and cried fir days. My brother let it go and comforted her when she vowed it would never happen again. As far as I know it didn't. So would it have been better to break up the family? Wouldn't that have been more traumatic for the kids?

I don't know the answer and like I said on principal one time in any circumstance is one time too many but is that really always what is best for the kids?

OP posts:
SinaraSmith · 03/05/2022 19:39

Same1977 · 03/05/2022 19:22

Having randoms around didn't help but it comes from missing my dad,from hating staying st different houses etc.
I think I am being misunderstood.If the hypothetical situation is a happy family unit (adult relationship,kids not scared etc ) and the single smack is the only blemish than all I'm saying is that children surely would be happier if the situation was resolved by means other than a split.
You can have happy single parent family it is simply hard for children if they actively miss the set up they used to have.

Again, you missing your dad is the issue you have been left with. He could have been around more. Or stopped drinking before it ruined the family. Had they stayed together you may have other issues and be one of the people who wishes their parents had split.

Some kids may miss the set up. But again some kids wish their parents weren’t together because they make each other miserable.

dontknowhow2help · 03/05/2022 19:36

The only 'tap' I've given my child is when she hit me pretty badly, obviously it didn't hurt me as she's only 3.5 but after a few times of me dealing it with it by saying "would you like me to hit you back?" and her saying no, I gave a light tap on her arm as a warning. She's not violent at all and I've no idea where she picked this reaction up from, certainly not my calm-as-f*ck DH, though I can be pretty shouty when she doesn't listen (which I am really trying to change). I think this example is a shade of grey. Despite it being a 'controlled' tap I won't do something like that again as I feel words and explanations are far better. Well, that or bribes/threats to take her favourite things away!

I was beaten black and blue as a child and would never repeat that cycle. I love my mum but judge her for not challenging my dad more about it. In hindsight, he was horribly abusive at times. Parenting is bloody challenging but no need for physical violence.

Same1977 · 03/05/2022 19:22

SinaraSmith · 03/05/2022 18:59

@Same1977 you are mixing issues. Your parents didn’t need to randoms around. Your feelings come from how your parents dealt with the situation.

households with one parent can be just as happy, or more, that one with 2 parents.

I know loads of people whose parents stayed together ‘for the kids’ and their kids (now adults) wished they had split because it was an unhappy home. That doesn’t mean all households with 2 parents are unhappy.

Poverty has the biggest impact on outcomes and that can be the cases in any household. You can recognise people who came from a happy home. I came from a happy, single parent, household. It wasn’t broken or damaged. It was whole.

Having randoms around didn't help but it comes from missing my dad,from hating staying st different houses etc.
I think I am being misunderstood.If the hypothetical situation is a happy family unit (adult relationship,kids not scared etc ) and the single smack is the only blemish than all I'm saying is that children surely would be happier if the situation was resolved by means other than a split.
You can have happy single parent family it is simply hard for children if they actively miss the set up they used to have.

SinaraSmith · 03/05/2022 18:59

@Same1977 you are mixing issues. Your parents didn’t need to randoms around. Your feelings come from how your parents dealt with the situation.

households with one parent can be just as happy, or more, that one with 2 parents.

I know loads of people whose parents stayed together ‘for the kids’ and their kids (now adults) wished they had split because it was an unhappy home. That doesn’t mean all households with 2 parents are unhappy.

Poverty has the biggest impact on outcomes and that can be the cases in any household. You can recognise people who came from a happy home. I came from a happy, single parent, household. It wasn’t broken or damaged. It was whole.

Stompythedinosaur · 03/05/2022 18:05

Yes, I would leave them.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 03/05/2022 17:38

@Same1977

He didn't drink for long and got sober not long after the divorce.

Then your mum definitely made the right choice as her leaving him was what made him take stock and make changes. Had she stayed he probably wouldn't have stopped.

Besides he was always good with us kids.

You say that but an alcoholic parent is fundamentally a selfish one. Anyone I know who has been alcoholic will say this. It's a crippling addiction because it makes people prioritise alcohol over everything else including loved ones.

He may have been 'good with' the kids but that was at the expense of your mum not having an equal partner for the mental load of family life, watching someone waste money on booze, not having an emotionally supportive partner etc.

Having a partner with alcohol or any other addiction problems is all consuming, completely unfair and impacts every bit of your life.

Even if he was 'good to the kids' your mum shouldn't have been expected to tolerate him being bad to her.

I hope you can all heal and I'm glad to hear he stopped drinking when she left, genuinely. It must be so bloody tough for partners who are brave enough to walk away that it took them walking away for the other person to change, that they didn't do it for them before it got to that point, but however it happened I'm glad he did get well.

Same1977 · 03/05/2022 17:32

youvegottenminuteslynn · 03/05/2022 17:27

@Same1977

Thanks for reconsidering using the phrase, it's one that is fundamentally damaging to women and children more than it is to men.

My mother and father split for a very valid reason (my father at the time had an alchohol issue) .So I definitely do not advocate staying in harmful enviroment.

But you said earlier you wish your dad had been around every day and you were disappointed your parents split because it meant he wasn't and you had to go between two houses etc. As much as it was tough for you, your mum took you out of an environment that previously saw you living with an alcoholic adult. She made the right and loving choice doing that and it's a bit heartbreaking that years later you say:

I would have love to have my father around every day.Instead of years of hostility then some random women, men involved in my parents lives,having to stay at different homes seperate birthdays,holidays etc.It takes a toll on a child.

Because the toll of living with one alcoholic parent and one enabler parent would have been far greater and much more irresponsible of them both.

She did her best to get you out of a harmful home.

Agree on all you have said here.I wish my father had been around every day yes.
He didn't drink for long and got sober not long after the divorce.Besides he was always good with us kids.
My mum did the right thing.Obviously if the reason for the divorce was let's say 7 year itch I might have been more resentful .
I didn't do too badly but my brother acted out a lot and went to live with my daddy relationship with him also never recovered.So many sad aspects regardless of how well thought out the divorce was

KettrickenSmiled · 03/05/2022 17:30

Same1977 · 03/05/2022 17:23

OK is not the same as good.

Good is not possible if your parents are only staying in a marriage they are no longer committed to so that people won't point judgey fingers at a "broken home".

bringonsummer2022 · 03/05/2022 17:29

My husband hit my two year old once. He smacked her on the hand. It was the middle of the night, she was messing about, he was exhausted and frustrated. We were both hit as children so there's something deep in our brain conditioning us that's the response. He was devastated within a second of doing it, he held her and cried and apologised to her. He has never done anything close ever again and I would bet my life he never will. He is a wonderful father who adores his children, made a mistake, regretted it and learnt from it.