Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would it be offensive & rude to ask a family member to stop sending me pics of their dc?

157 replies

FabulousFlowerpots · 01/05/2022 20:32

I just want to check if I'm being rude here. I want to ask (nicely) a family member not to send me pics of their kids. I'm not interested in a 100 pics of what Johnny ate for breakfast, Johnny getting the bus, Johnny eating his ice cream, Johnny at soft play, Johnny having his afternoon nap etc. You get the idea. I told a friend I want to stop the pics and she said there's nothing I can say that won't cause offence. What d'you think? Aibu? How can I handle this better?

OP posts:
balalake · 02/05/2022 06:50

I wonder if asking who else they are sent to could be a starting point, if you don't know. Concern that it could lead say to their house being burgled because too many people will know when they are not at home, for example. Or asking do you get agreement from others in the photos if they are any.

RedHelenB · 02/05/2022 06:47

FabulousFlowerpots · 01/05/2022 20:41

I see no one's saying tell them. I bet other people would be annoyed with me if I spammed them with pics of every bit of my motorbike that I'm restoring.

If you can't see the difference I feel sorry for you but I've a feeling you're on a wind up. And yes, a true friend would put up with pics of a motorbike if it was of great interest to you.

RedHelenB · 02/05/2022 06:45

FabulousFlowerpots · 01/05/2022 20:32

I just want to check if I'm being rude here. I want to ask (nicely) a family member not to send me pics of their kids. I'm not interested in a 100 pics of what Johnny ate for breakfast, Johnny getting the bus, Johnny eating his ice cream, Johnny at soft play, Johnny having his afternoon nap etc. You get the idea. I told a friend I want to stop the pics and she said there's nothing I can say that won't cause offence. What d'you think? Aibu? How can I handle this better?

Yabu. I agree with your friend. It takes what, a minute of your time tops to look at them

NoCleverNickname · 02/05/2022 06:24

The problem with muting the WhatsApp chat, is that they will know you aren't looking at the pics.

Whenever you send a message in WhatsApp, regardless if it's text or pictures, 2 little grey ticks appear in the bottom right of the message. Those grey ticks go green when the message is seen.

The sender will know you're not looking at the pics.

Depends how close you are to the relative as to whether you say something or not.

I would say something but I'm neurodiverse and even though I really try my best, I can't help myself, I have to say something!

PlainSpeakin · 02/05/2022 05:43

I wrote an essay. :) In advance, my apologies for the length. But I really needed to respond to this.

As far as I'm concerned, it's within your rights to feel annoyed by this. Even more so as general opinion seems to be you should shut up and accept it because it would offend her. Quite frankly, that's her problem not yours. Any reasonable person would feel this way and I think it's ridiculous, and ironically, even more offensive that as a whole, a score of women in this day and age is telling another to silence her voice and feelings. Get real.

What she needs to do is back off, she's disrupting your life by barraging you constantly with photos and messages that actually have very little point. Yes, you welcome the milestones, everyone does; first word, saying their name, riding a bike, etc. But otherwise it is akin to being told on social media every time someone has farted - there's been plenty of those types, and they're not welcome. You understandably become a little resentful and even dread getting messages. Completely normal. Not only that, but if this behavior is also on a public setting, that child's life has been seen and can be tracked by how many people? What about consent?

As said before, she needs to back off and RESPECT your boundaries, if she can't understand and do that, well, that shows what type of person she is doesn't it? Besides, honesty is always best, and even if hearing it people get offended in the beginning, if it makes your relationship richer (because it's a two way street people!) then all the better, right? A good analogy for a relationship (any one) is it's like a garden, you have to feed it, water it, and prune it, to make it flourish.
Also, why on earth do you have to go to a forum discussion to ask a question like this? Get some dignity and self respect woman! Own your feelings, you're allowed to feel them, it's why we have them.
A better question would be: How do I phrase this so it causes the least offence?

In conclusion, you need to get your big girl pants on, and tell her. Sharing opinions and feelings isn't disrespectful, it's HOW you deliver them. And you don't need to justify them, when they are your right.
Don't block her, don't be petty, don't be mean. Simply tell her.
Cause if you never say anything, nothing will ever change.

And maybe she'll be a little hurt initially, but if she gets offended and lashes out, quite honestly, she needs to put HER big girl pants on. Then again (as I don't know her), she might merely be embarrassed and sorry for not realizing the impact that it was having on you, that she got a bit overzealous. You know her, you know how to speak to her. Do it.

To everyone:

  • Just because an opinion might cause offence to someone doesn't mean you should have to sit down and shut up. I thought this was something we have been fighting against?
  • Communication and honesty allows people to gain a true relationship; knowing where each person stands, and being able to trust that person. (I've been able to have some really great relationships because I was honest, not cruel, but honest. Others felt they could be the same way with me. There was no judgement, there was no cruelty. Just opinions that were constructive, pointed out the flaws, and showed us where we erred, and what we could fix. So we could grow. There may have been a little bit of hurt initially (which is understandable), but in the end what came out of it all was strong and pure.)
  • Respecting a person's boundaries is important. If you can't do that, you show you don't respect them
  • No one should ever make you feel guilty for having feelings and opinions, it's your right to have them, it's your right to voice them.

Please remember:

Equal rights.

Respect.

Don't just say them. Live them.

expat101 · 02/05/2022 05:16

That's a tricky one. I receive photos of my Cousin's kids, and to me, the oldest one is a definite bully. Do I say something? No.

I take the easy way out and delete them. 😁

savagegrant · 02/05/2022 04:54

Suggest to him/her to create a group for the pics because you want to see even more of them and all in the one place for convenience. lol

Marchitectmummy · 02/05/2022 04:42

Life is full of spam, yours happens to be pictures of kids. I'm sure you don't need a group of people to tell you it's offensive to mention anything, it takes seconds to delete / mark as read or whatever you need to do. No need for a big fuss and bother that will offend.

AzazaelsFury · 02/05/2022 04:00

I'd probably just stop responding to the messages. I think it would be rude to say anything. A lot of people I know with kids seem to think they're the only people on the planet to reproduce and think your interested in seeing a minute by minute run down of their day.... Best to just not reply and they will get the message. If they ask at some stage did you get them just a "yes sorry I was flat out" and leave it at that. Most people would get the hint eventually but then again they might not.

WibblyWobblyJane · 02/05/2022 03:20

Is it via WhatsApp?

I think you’d be able to ask if they can post them on social media instead of via message. “Easier to enjoy them on the big computer screen when I’m online.” Or something similar.

Lurkerlot · 02/05/2022 03:10

FabulousFlowerpots · 01/05/2022 20:41

I see no one's saying tell them. I bet other people would be annoyed with me if I spammed them with pics of every bit of my motorbike that I'm restoring.

No. I would just ignore them

gumball37 · 02/05/2022 03:02

I'd ask if they could add the photos to a shared album in Google photos or something that you can check in on, because the notifications for so many photos are getting to be too much. It isn't then that you don't want to see Johnny's photos (even if you don't) but rather that you'd like one place to check them🤷‍♀️

tortadicarote · 02/05/2022 02:58

Yes, it's annoying and ott, but the kind of person who sends that many photos probably will be offended if you ask them to stop. Hide the photos and only check once a day, every few days, whatever you decide is reasonable. Respond politely but sparingly to keep the peace, unless this is someone you don't mind offending. They'll either take the hint or get bored on their own, eventually. No-one can keep up that pace indefinitely.

me4real · 02/05/2022 02:41

I see no one's saying tell them. I bet other people would be annoyed with me if I spammed them with pics of every bit of my motorbike that I'm restoring.

Yes but hardly anyone would say 'don't send me pics cos I'm not interested.' They'd have manners.

If you CBA with the pics the just ignore them; just reply to the person's written messages, or go 'oh lovely' without actually looking at the pics.

You don't have to reply to any messages/pics immediately.

I don't have kids BTW couldn't have them, but I still like to see cute pics especially as they hold meaning for friends.

But if the pics annoy you just ignore the pics. Or go 'oh that's nice.'

noodlezoodle · 02/05/2022 02:41

You're not being unreasonable to not want the pictures, but you are unreasonable to think there's any way to stop it without the sender being offended. So realistically your choices are:

Tell them to stop but accept they'll be pissed off, or
Mute the thread and bite your tongue

If you're feeling particularly belligerent then for every pic they send you, send them one of your motorbike. But I don't imagine that would end very peacefully either!

Vikinga · 02/05/2022 01:59

Either stop commenting or start sending lots of pics of your day.

Lunarpsychobitch · 02/05/2022 01:55

YANBU, but I agree with others that no matter how nicely you word it, they probably will be offended or upset.

I'd go with ignoring the pictures first to see if it eases off a bit.

Cameleongirl · 02/05/2022 01:43

I've had to mute the family chat (DH's side), because it also got ridiculous with the photos. I send the occasional photo that everyone might actually find interesting....but I don't need to see what you're having for dinner unless it's something really spectacular or unusual (yes, one SIL really does this sometimes) Grin

ManateeFair · 02/05/2022 00:41

FabulousFlowerpots · 01/05/2022 20:41

I see no one's saying tell them. I bet other people would be annoyed with me if I spammed them with pics of every bit of my motorbike that I'm restoring.

  1. A hobby is not remotely equivalent to a child to whom you are related, because generally it’s reasonable for people to assume you have a degree of affection for nieces/nephews/whatever. You sound like you actually resent the child’s existence as much as you resent the photos.
  1. Just mute the chat ffs. There is no nice way to say “I actively dislike seeing photos of your child”.
NotMushroomInEre · 02/05/2022 00:32

'How can I handle this better?'

Turn off notifications and stop the images going into your gallery automatically.

DogWithMyOwnRoom · 02/05/2022 00:24

Oops - I voted YANBU (because you really aren’t) but realised that perhaps the other is a better answer to your question.
Sadly yes, it will cause offence to most people. It wouldn’t to me but I am thick-skinned… but also sensible and wouldn’t be sending multiple photos anyway!
Strongly advise muting the WApp group though - I’ve muted several large groups (constant pings with non-urgent msgs drive me nuts)

jytdtysrht · 02/05/2022 00:13

You’ll have to either ignore most pics or start to send motorbike pics in response.

if Johnny is getting the bus, send a motorcycle pic saying can’t wait til he’s old enough for cooler transport. Etc.

Sailorsgirl44 · 02/05/2022 00:09

I send my MIL photos of my three kids every now and again..maybe one photo every week or so, depending on what we're doing. Usually showing what we're up to..eg at the beach, zoo, etc. She almost never comments on them..Op - be honest - are you my MIL??!

SugarNspices · 02/05/2022 00:02

You haven't said if it's a family group or just you personally? If it's a family chat yabu because obviously they share it with other family members and you could just delete them. If it's personally for just you and the person posting them to you expects a response or reply every time then yanbu. I would just ignore and delete and maybe send the odd message now and then. But if they expected more interaction I would probably have to say thanks but can you just update me now and then so you have time to reply. Just to be polite and hope they get the hint.

marvellousmaple · 01/05/2022 23:50

I read it as dic pics too, and wondered why you needed to be polite! You can tell those of us with filthy minds. You don't have to respond to every photo OP. You haven't said how close a relative it is either.