Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

After the third time of asking I shouted

62 replies

RightThenWhatNext · 01/05/2022 16:53

At the kids (8 and 10) for not picking up clothes from the floor. I asked three times (space of 20 mins) really nicely, gently, but there was STILL a screwed up pair of joggers on the floor, that I’d pointed to one of my early requests.

I saw red and shouted and cancelled dessert (we’ve had an early dinner today).

I’ve got a stinking cold today, my patience is thin. I was proud I’d got to three asks and had had kept my cool tbh. The fourth time I could not.

My DM was/is a shouty narc and would stomp about raging and I caught glimpses of her in me then. But I genuinely don’t know how to handle such things in any other way, and no idea of what constitutes normal. DH comes from a family where confrontation is to be avoided at all costs and thinks I needed to chill out <<helpful>>.

Is shouting by the 4th ask unreasonable?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
PumpkinsandKittens · 02/05/2022 20:51

I find it really weird when people on MN claim to NEVER shout, yeh right, I have 4 kids and my two boys fight like crazy! Sometimes I have to shout just to get their attention when they are winding each other up!

Brefugee · 02/05/2022 20:47

Tell your DH to stand over them and supervise then if he thinks that's the best way to parent. Why didn't he take over when he heard you shouting instread of hiding? Tell him you have better things to do with your time

Yep, there is your answer. DH takes over and you're out of it

Lizziekisss · 02/05/2022 09:47

DH will reap as he sows. The kids will already know who makes sure they get things done and who gives them an easy ride and they will exploit it to DH's detriment. I was like your DH when mine were young, Took me years to realise why the kids were always good for partner and played me up. As for why did the picking up have to be done in OP's timeframe. Why not, I imagine the clothing should never have been left on the floor in the first place.

Weatherwax13 · 02/05/2022 09:42

Awesome, DH can supervise in future. Until then please don't feel guilty for shouting once in a while. And don't fucking apologise!

Marty13 · 02/05/2022 09:39

I think you're fine.

And I actually think you were right to cancel dessert. The issue isn't even clothes on the ground, it's your kids not obeying you after you asked them multiple times to do something fairly quick and easy to do. If there are zero consequences for this type of behaviour why should they stop doing it ?

Rainbowshine · 02/05/2022 09:34

Perhaps you and your DH need to agree strategy for handling these sort of situations. So you have a list of typical consequences etc or a normal way of doing things E.g. no tv until tidying is done. I have a 9 year old so I get the frustration of having to ask multiple times. We’ve tried to put some of these things in place and it doesn’t solve everything but it helps me to keep calm as I go through the process rather than having to think on the spot.

teacherorpreacher · 02/05/2022 09:32

Pixiedust1234
Yep

hardboiledeggs · 02/05/2022 09:27

Normal OP. Has happened on occasion for me too, I’m pretty sure my DC ears are just for decoration at this point tbh

Pixiedust1234 · 02/05/2022 01:37

Tell your DH to stand over them and supervise then if he thinks that's the best way to parent. Why didn't he take over when he heard you shouting instread of hiding? Tell him you have better things to do with your time. I bet he doesn't last six months....or the house ends up a dump because he won't step up as a parent. Or do you have to stand over him to supervise him standing over them?

sweeneytoddsrazor · 01/05/2022 23:47

They needed picking up because the should not have been left on the floor in the first place. An 8 and 10 year old unless there are extenuating circumstances should be putting clothes in the proper place. And I would fully expect my DH to pick his stuff up pronto whatever he happened to be doing if he had just left it lying around.

iloveruby · 01/05/2022 23:14

Gizacluethen · 01/05/2022 18:15

Why did they need picking up that instant? We're the kids doing anything while you were asking? I think asking 3 times in 20 minutes is a lot and not really giving them chance to finish what they were doing. I wouldn't expect my husband to do something the instant I asked and I would be pissed off if I'd left something out and he asked me 3 times in 20 minutes to move it tbh.

But the OP isn't married and in an equal partnership with her children?

Sometimes children need to stop what they are doing because their parent has asked them to do something.

trilbydoll · 01/05/2022 23:03

Sometimes I shout on the first time of asking. Then they look all hurt and ask why and I say because in my experience no-one does anything until I shout so I'm saving us all time.

I find this does improve things for a little while. But honestly if they don't do things when you ask what are you meant to do? Develop a repertoire of comedy accents?! Shouting is a natural consequence of ignoring someone imo.

PinkSyCo · 01/05/2022 22:58

Your kids aren’t going to end up in therapy because you shouted at them after they ignored you multiple times when you asked them to do a simple task. You are not your mother and you have no reason to feel guilty.

ChiselandBits · 01/05/2022 22:35

but then it just makes it your job still. At 8 and 10 they absolutely can do a task like that without being stood voer, they are just choosing not too. And "tolerance and sensitivity" is absolutely required when they are having a tricky emotional time about something. When its about not being a lazy selfish sod who won't pick up their socks after 3x asking, not so much. Who cares what else they were doing? It can be paused, put down, walked away from for the 30 seconds it will take to do the thing they should have just done in the first place.

RightThenWhatNext · 01/05/2022 22:24

Thanks all.

Deffo not the first time I’ve shouted. DH heard the tail end and thought I was being harsh, which prompted me to post. He thinks it’s more reasonable to stay with them and make sure it’s done. Supervise rather than demand. I was happier to do that when they were little but 10 years in to parenting and I don’t feel I should have to stand there until a basic job is done. Though actually it turns out that I do….

Repeat repeat repeat. I know it’s this but by fuck it’s tedious.

OP posts:
KarmaStar · 01/05/2022 22:23

😀😀another post with op asking if they wbu then sentences justifying their behaviour before anyone answers..😂

UndertheCedartree · 01/05/2022 21:49

I don't know if this would work for you but I find just keep on asking over and over again doesn't work as it just becomes background noise. So I would ask once then get on with something else i.e not hover waiting for them to do it. Then I would issue a friendly reminder if not done. Then I would help them to do it. I don't personally believe in punishments so wouldn't have done that. But don't beat yourself up - none of us are perfect and you could have done much worse!

CorsicaDreaming · 01/05/2022 21:44

As a PP says, I think the counting to five / ten is far more effective than giving them "three strikes and your out" over 20 minutes.

"I'm going to count to ten and if you two haven't tidied up all the clothes off the floor by then you won't be having any dessert tonight. "

It's quicker, more direct, and they immediately know the consequences if they don't.

Or if you want more of a carrot than stick approach -

"I've got a special surprise dessert for tonight, but you're only getting it if you pick up all your clothes off the floor. I'm coming to check in five minutes. If it's not sorted, then no dessert."

Both the same really but you'll know which will work best with your DCs.

shreddednips · 01/05/2022 21:30

It depends how you shouted. Raised voice, sounding really annoyed, is fine. Really bellowing so that it's scary, too much. I wouldn't apologise unless you really were frightening, just have a chat when you're feeling calmer about doing things when they're asked.

Brefugee · 01/05/2022 20:50

Meh. Don't beat yourself up and don't apologise. They are old enough to know that when you ask them to do something, you expect it to be done. Not getting dessert is a consequence of that.
If they want you to do things - cook, clean, make desserts - they have to do things too.

But now you need to make it clear; you will ask once, then things go in a bin bag, and then they go in the bin if they haven't been put away by bin day.

Pumperthepumper · 01/05/2022 20:42

LowlandLucky · 01/05/2022 19:41

Bloody hell, some of the responses on here are incredible " could be a good opportunity to model self reflection" !!!! No wonder many children these days can't cope with the slightest negative emotion. Christ how the hell are they all going to cope in the adult world.

With the tolerance and sensitivity modelled to them by their parents?

OhJoyOhJoy · 01/05/2022 20:36

The thing is, it's not really hard for the kids to pick up their clothes. They should be doing it, and at 8 and 10 they are old enough to understand that it makes adults cross if they don't.

I also prefer consequences to yelling, but getting cross occasionally will not do them any harm and will help them to realise that you have feelings too.

Goldijobsandthe3bears · 01/05/2022 19:49

Do not apologise, they’ll take the piss even more 😂😂

Tothepoint99 · 01/05/2022 19:44

TheAverageUser · 01/05/2022 17:06

Could just be the same but non confrontational like i notice you still haven't picked up the joggers, this is going to take so long we won't have time for dessert. Or i notice you still haven't picked up the joggers and leave silence for them to explain.

Like this approach. Have to dig deep to remember to use it sometimes though!

LowlandLucky · 01/05/2022 19:41

Bloody hell, some of the responses on here are incredible " could be a good opportunity to model self reflection" !!!! No wonder many children these days can't cope with the slightest negative emotion. Christ how the hell are they all going to cope in the adult world.