Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be mad at this birthday present for DS?

160 replies

JakeyRolling · 01/05/2022 16:11

DS turned 4 today.

He's on the pathway for an autism diagnosis and has major sensory issues with his feet and, especially, his hands.

DF knows this and yet bought him slime for his birthday. Not only is it marked for 6+ but DS won't touch it - and if he did get any on his hands it would lead to a major meltdown.

It's not the first time DF had bought age/condition-inappropriate gifts - he got him Guess Who last year - for a child who is severely verbally delayed - and a drone at Christmas.

It all just feels a bit like he's buying for the grandchild he wishes he had rather than the one he's got.

DS is very bright and loves mechanical things/things he can build but DF ignores this when choosing gifts.

OP posts:
Stilsmiling · 02/05/2022 20:31

It sounds like your father needs some
educating, maybe his lack of understanding of autism (and the current lack of diagnosis) means he doesn’t know how to engage with your son. Instead of asking about it he is getting defensive.

Could you have a conversation about autism with him in a way that he knows that it’s new to all of you, you are all finding your way and would like him to be able to enjoy time with his grandson.

I understand how frustrating it is for you, disappointing that your son can’t enjoy gifts from his grandfather and your father can’t enjoy any delight from his grandson when receiving and playing with his gift.

I hope you find a way to work it out.

niugboo · 02/05/2022 20:00

YABU.

I have an autistic child. Look up suggested gifts. Slime is a top gift.

Missingpop · 02/05/2022 19:35

I can fully appreciate where your coming from & of course it feels like he’s buying for the grandchild he wishes he had not the one he’s got, but I’m sure he loves his grandson dearly.
maybe have a chat & say look we could not let him have his birthday present because of the reaction it would cause, he would have suffered dreadfully & we can’t inflict that on him; when it comes to Christmas, birthdays, Easter why don’t you give Grandad a list of gifts your son would absolutely love Grandad to pick from & buy him that way you have an element of control over the gift, I’d even go so far as to suggest grandad helps your son with the gift so he can see first hand the joy, the gift brings him, maybe then the penny will finally drop for grandad x

wildchild554 · 02/05/2022 19:02

Your better off giving him a list, I also have a child who is autistic and one under-diagnosis and this is always the best way as unfortunately, kids are very hard to buy for especially with SEN. I'm sure he's not trying to be hurtful in any way or trying to buy for the grandchild he wishes he had just very hard to understand unless he's there every day constantly like you are.

jewishmum · 02/05/2022 18:34

RemusLupinsBiggestGroupie · 01/05/2022 16:26

YABU He probably thought ds would enjoy the texture of it. You should be grateful for gifts - even ones that don't quite hit right are usually given with thought/love.

I agree with this. Many, many autistic people enjoy things like slime. I personally did not know that drones are illegal in built up areas, but can't you use the drone by taking your son out to a field in the country once every so often?

Chica10 · 02/05/2022 09:25

You are definitely over reacting regarding this.. Some people are just rubbish at buying presents. Just before the next birthday tell your DF the kind of things that your child would really like and appreciate. Send him a list of things to choose from.

Olsi109 · 02/05/2022 09:25

JakeyRolling · 01/05/2022 17:41

just because your kid has additional needs the world doesn't revolve around them

Fairly certain it's completely normal for a family's world to revolve around a child ON THEIR BIRTHDAY.

My sister always made lists for her two (before they were old enough to ask) which I hated and thought of as diktats but I'm starting to think she had the right idea

Definitely make lists/give ideas of what to buy - all our parents/GP's ask for ideas. My side stick to it mostly - DH's usually do.

ChoiceMummy · 02/05/2022 09:16

JakeyRolling · 01/05/2022 18:29

Anyhoo decided to open the slime and test DS. Placed it on my hand, nowhere near his, and he screamed bloody murder at the sight.

Back in the box it goes.

Having an autistic child, with sensory issues, I think that neither of you are in the wrong.
You almost wish to limit his exposure of gifts etc, when slime at the age of 4 or 5is probably viewed as the norm for many children, so I'd say it's not a "bad" present.
Equally, I'm always pleasantly surprised when we do try to something and it works out favourably.
My own child has problems with many things on their hands, but loves the silky feel of slime, playdoh yet couldn't manage silky materials for bedding or clothing.
It sounds as though your dad goes into a shop and takes advice about what toys are the current trends.
Be grateful that he takes an interest.

Marvellousmadness · 02/05/2022 03:50

Ps my in laws always buy age inappropriate gifts though so maybe it is just cuz theyre old senial

Marvellousmadness · 02/05/2022 03:49

I think you are overreacting re slime.

. But i get that you are sad though that your dad wants your kid to be a normal 4yo...He needs to accept your kid is autistic and that it is not something you grow out off or get over

Talk to him.

Bizzlemizzle · 02/05/2022 02:04

*Everything ELSE feels 10 times worse than it really is.

My wording was slightly off on that opening sentence.

Bizzlemizzle · 02/05/2022 02:02

I don't think you are being unreasonable for being upset about it, day to day life with a ND child is hard and I swear everything feels 10 times worse than it really is and I get that. But, you do need to have a really frank conversation about it all with your dad, you might find out more about how he feels and thinks about it and find things that work and develop on them.

When you have an ND child, you might find you have to explain things over and over again, to everyone.
Family, friends, teachers, professionals...it's draining and it is annoying.
Partly because of a lack of understanding around ND people, but sometimes people just miss understand or even forget especially pre-diagnosis and generation difference.

I have had to do many things I don't like doing because they need to be done to make life that little bit easier for him and for the family, so I do agree with the list idea and as someone said previously and Amazon List. I give my parents a list, they use that to get things appropriate for him and it works.

I don't know your dad, or you (obviously), but it takes time for people to understand and sometimes they never get it fully, even those you expect to understand as they are close to the child but I can't see your dad purposely buying slime to cause upset. It might have been a careless decision but also an element of denial (not necessarily 'buying for the GS he wishes he had') which is common and a diagnosis might help with that.

My son's dad (we are separated) was in denial massively when we started the diagnosis process and he still doesn't really get it but we have to watch our sons diet, and limit chocolate and sweets as these tend to heighten everything possible - Birthday and Christmas he comes home from his dad's with a TON of confectionary, it annoys me, it infuriates me in fact because I am the one who has to deal with the sugar overload on his return and the one who deals with meltdowns when I limit his intake, but I just remind that side of the family when I can, and they are slowly getting better and I definitely saw a difference when we got a diagnosis.

I hope the assessment process goes well for you and you are not waiting much longer.

glittereyelash · 02/05/2022 01:52

Could your dad be on the autism spectrum himself? Autism is linked to genetics a lot of the time. My son has similar sensory issues and people find it difficult to understand no matter how much you try to explain. My dad is a similar age to yours and he does his best but just doesn't get autism and thinks my boy will be fine and will grow out of it. Just the dialogue open because it's probably hard for your dad too. I think my dad feels awkward that he can't communicate with my son and he wouldn't have a clue how to pick an appropriate present for my son. I'd never be cross with him though because I know he just doesn't understand fully how badly seemingly normal things can effect my son.

Heartofglass12345 · 02/05/2022 01:05

@DaisyStPatience maybe, but not in this situation by the looks of it. It's not with mine either, it's a generational thing I think, with a lack of understanding of autism and an unwillingness to understand how the child might be different.

StarlingsInTheRoof · 01/05/2022 22:23

I find that most gifts to my kids are not really what they want, as people think that they need to buy "proper presents". What actually gets played with are the box the arm chair came in, grass clippings when we mow the lawn, the stream when we go to the woods, the flour when we do baking etc. I wouldn't expect anyone to know what a child would actually want unless specifically told, even then they are often onto the next thing seconds later. It does sound like there is a lot more to this than slime. I hope you get a diagnosis without having to wait too long and that your father understands and accepts.

minimadgirl · 01/05/2022 22:13

Some pil are terrible at present buying. My mil just bought my daughter a dress for her second birthday, lovely dress except it was age 6-9 months.

IsabelHerna · 01/05/2022 22:12

It sounds like he is trying to be the "cool" grandpa, he may not understand what can create a meltdown, you can explain to him

DaisyStPatience · 01/05/2022 22:01

Heartofglass12345 · 01/05/2022 20:07

Unless people have ND children or are themselves they don't understand. My sons best friend is very articulate and interested in war things etc, my FIL spent ages talking to him last time they were together (both boys are 8)
My son is autistic and likes to play minecraft and show people what he is doing and talk about TV shows that he likes (I know it sounds mundane but he is autistic lol) we show an interest because it's what he likes. My in laws tell him they dont like the programmes he watches because they are too loud/ annoying/ American (whatever that means) and he gets upset then. They don't have to tell him that, just bloody pretend like we do! They can't see why he doesn't want to spend hours looking around castles and similar things, and seem to think that if we force him to do them he will be fine.
Sorry I've gone off on a tangent, but some people just refuse to understand it and like you said, buy things for the grandchild they wished they had.

Maybe some of these people who "don't understand" are neurodivergent themselves and just have a different opinion?

celticprincess · 01/05/2022 21:12

Have you sat your DF down and explained the autism pathway and what this means. My DD is autistic but several of the older generation in the family just don’t get it. And even those who do get it find it confusing. I teach in an sen school and lots of of children love slime and messes play, they go home covered in gloop and alsorts!! Some would also love a drone. I’d think the drone thing was probably too old though even for a NT 4 year old but again, the older generations struggle to keep up with what kids like, or see their friends buying their grandkids a certain toy and think they will buy it too.

we have had loads of inappropriate gifts over the years. I’ve had to teach my autistic daughter since before we knew she was autistic just to smile and say thank you, and then it gets re gifted. Usually from less close relatives though. My DM would now always check before buying what we/DD would want for birthday/ Christmas these days. Sometimes she has gone against that but less so.

Blackbird2020 · 01/05/2022 21:01

OP, this post isn’t really about slime, is it?

It’s glaringly obvious that you have issues with your DF that go way back, maybe even before the birth of your DS. I don’t know what they are, but I can tell that the slime isn’t really the big problem here…

Nanny0gg · 01/05/2022 20:58

RemusLupinsBiggestGroupie · 01/05/2022 16:26

YABU He probably thought ds would enjoy the texture of it. You should be grateful for gifts - even ones that don't quite hit right are usually given with thought/love.

No, actually. Doesn't sound like there was much thought at all there.

Whenthegoatcomesin · 01/05/2022 20:49

@theremustonlybeone I wondered this too. Slime and a speaking and listening game are exactly the kind of things an internet article would recommend for a child with ASD.

theremustonlybeone · 01/05/2022 20:47

Slime is known to be good for children with sensory issues, it may your DF has researched it hence why he has bought it. Unfortunately your DC cant cope with it but it doesnt mean your DF has done it with bad intent.

Xmasbaby11 · 01/05/2022 20:30

I get your frustration as the gp should know your dpn well, especially as he has specific preferences.

My dd has ASD and I used to get upset when people bought her toys that were inappropriate because she was developmentally delayed, when I thought they understood her issues. People have missed the mark with nt dd2 as well but that wouldn't upset me in the same way. I would say is, it's more upsetting when special needs are involved, maybe it's because it's a reminder what you think they should like. That's how it was for me anyway.

Whatever00 · 01/05/2022 20:16

I would just write a few things down with a range of different prices and tell DF he would love anything on the list. Then he can pick something in his prices range.

It sounds like DF doesn't understand DC or his needs. I don't think he is being a dick. He just doesn't get it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread