Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Trains are a fucking shitshow

86 replies

Amethystbluexo · 01/05/2022 15:33

Seriously, they are. Before 2022 they was half alright. They turned up on time, never cancelled, was reasonably priced and wasn’t overcrowded, that’s on my northern route anyway.

Now they’re fucking chaotic, disastrous even. I bought a railcard last year to save money, tickets have now increased in price to the point they’re now originally the same price as they would of been without one.

Constant cancellations. I used to travel regularly and they were fine, now in the past six months every single journey has had a disruption. Either cancelling last minute, cancelling the service halfway through, setting off late. I have been left to wait at Sheffield for over three hours on two occasions because they’re cancelling trains left right and centre. It’s a joke and entirely unreliable.

Overcrowding is now piss poor. I know Northern for a fact are now operating on reduced carriages even on the busier services and it shows. I’ve had seats booked and i’ve turned up to find people sat in them. I ask them politely to move and they either ignore me or tell me to fuck off. Even worse recently a train was so busy, nobody else could even get on because we was packed like sardines at the door. People swearing, getting pissed, there was a woman with a pushchair who burst into tears on one station because she couldn’t get on, not even the ticket man could make his way around.

Not to mention customer service is piss poor. They blame everything on staff shortages and covid but it’s been like this for atleast six months now. I tweet them or send an email and they just send a link for delay refund. However, twice i’ve tried to reclaim on my journey and twice it was rejected.

Honestly, the thought of getting on trains now makes me sick. It’s so so stressful. I would travel on trains each month to my parents house but i’ve reduced this heavily as trains are just so shit. The stress and expenses just doesn’t feel worth it. Even the behaviour of people on stations are shit as i’ve had one man smack me with his bike, and then had an another old lady pull my hair.

Opinions please?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Badbadbunny · 02/05/2022 10:34

RMT are balloting members for strike action

What a surprise.

Why is it always the industries with strong unions that provide such crap customer service?

etulosba · 01/05/2022 22:20

I'm old enough to remember the bad old days of British Rail so don't think discarding the the franchise model is going to improve the railway.

So am I, and I travelled virtually every working day from 1971 to 1991. The bad old days weren’t that bad. Tickets were affordable and you didn’t have to buy them months in advance. Just turn up, buy a ticket, and get on a train.

EngTech · 01/05/2022 22:17

RMT are balloting members for strike action

if it goes ahead, if you think it is bad now, wait till the whole system stops

People WFH more post CV19, so revenue down, no win situation

Ticket prices, yep, very high but people who don’t use trains would say, “Why should I subsidise train fares”

LakieLady · 01/05/2022 22:12

Amethystbluexo · 01/05/2022 19:30

I’m sorry that really does sound shit. No idea why they’re reducing carriages though?? Overcrowding is so dangerous i’m surprised they’re letting this happen!

They reduced the carriages on the trains where I live a couple of years before Covid, from 8 to 4.

The train starts from a town on the S. coast, and when they made it shorter it was standing room only from the 3rd station on the line. People were having to stand virtually the whole distance from the coast to central London. Some mornings, the trains were so packed that people waiting at stations further north were simply unable to get on.

emmylousings · 01/05/2022 22:10

Lonelycrab · 01/05/2022 18:31

If the hundreds of billions that was wasted on hs2 was instead spent on upgrading the existing network, things would be a lot better.

Hs2 will only benefit a few dozen people, the ones that saving ten minutes is important. The rest of the network rots, but hey ho…Hmm

Completely agree.
Trains ok for leisure purposes but crap for work. Mainland Europe seems to have good train networks and services, reliable and pleasant, why can't we? The bloody things were invented here.

Shunter350 · 01/05/2022 21:57

Wizzbangfizz · 01/05/2022 21:38

You are not wrong OP it’s a absolute disgrace. Trans pennine are currently striking “indefinitely” every weekend. Half the trains they do run are cancelled due to staff shortages - how are people supposed to go back to the office if they can’t actually get there. Agree with the loutish behaviour as well - some blokes on a train loudly talking about another one being “sucked off” by so and so - swearing and in a carriage with kids and old people - these were men in their 40s and they weren’t drinking so god knows what they thought they were playing at.

It's unacceptable. You're right of course. My only advice is for people to get actively involved.
We need an enhanced BTP.. the force is ridiculously small.
And pester your MP's etc for a complete ban of alcohol on trains.

Wizzbangfizz · 01/05/2022 21:38

You are not wrong OP it’s a absolute disgrace. Trans pennine are currently striking “indefinitely” every weekend. Half the trains they do run are cancelled due to staff shortages - how are people supposed to go back to the office if they can’t actually get there. Agree with the loutish behaviour as well - some blokes on a train loudly talking about another one being “sucked off” by so and so - swearing and in a carriage with kids and old people - these were men in their 40s and they weren’t drinking so god knows what they thought they were playing at.

andi62 · 01/05/2022 21:36

Horribly expensive, run replacement buses all over the show.
Buses round here are even worse, this was yesterday (Saturday) ..

Trains are a fucking shitshow
CrocodilesCry · 01/05/2022 21:21

We live less than 12 miles from a major city and we're travelling there tomorrow evening, we live in a "commuter town" if it can be called that.

To get there via public transport we'll have to take a taxi 4 miles to the station (as it's nowhere near the actual town centre).
The last train home is before 11pm so we'll have to get an Uber which will likely cost £40+.

They cancelled the once hourly bus service to the city and even if it was running, it finishes before 9pm. People have actually lost their jobs because of this because they can't get in or out of the city via bus now.

It's an absolute joke.

EllaPaella · 01/05/2022 21:19

Basically northern trains are now for people who have no other means of travel because they can't drive, don't own a car or don't want to drive so they can drink as much as they possibly can and make life as miserable as possible for all the passengers who don't think it's normal to start drinking at 10am.

CounsellorTroi · 01/05/2022 21:05

artisanbread · 01/05/2022 17:56

Government policy on climate change is total lip service if they do nothing to improve public transport. More and more people are forced to use cars if the public transport options are woeful. Unfortunately transport is not something Conservative governments are interested in unless they see some way of it making more money.

Total joke that the government bangs on about workers having to come back into the office but does nothing to improve public transport to help them get there.

This. The rail network can’t cope with the number of people using it now, and they want other people to use it.

Public transport has been woefully underinvested in by successive governments who are more interested in avoiding raising taxes because they know people won’t vote for that. The difference is so stark in other European countries.

Shunter350 · 01/05/2022 21:05

Howmuchwood · 01/05/2022 20:50

Off topic slightly but @shunter350 I was recently on the Glasgow to Aberdeen service and it was on time, clean, busy but not crowded and generally a good journey. First time in a couple of years. Love the views at Montrose and along the coast around Stonehaven. Bet you get a great view driving that line.

My favourite route!

HYT · 01/05/2022 20:51

And has anyone been on a train when football fans are travelling? My god. Openly snorting coke in front of anyone. Grim.

Howmuchwood · 01/05/2022 20:50

Off topic slightly but @shunter350 I was recently on the Glasgow to Aberdeen service and it was on time, clean, busy but not crowded and generally a good journey. First time in a couple of years. Love the views at Montrose and along the coast around Stonehaven. Bet you get a great view driving that line.

HYT · 01/05/2022 20:49

Trains are shit. I agree. Northern Rail who were utter crap until they lost their franchise were hideous.

EleanorRavenclaw · 01/05/2022 20:34

I’ve just taken voluntary severance from part of the railway operator. It’s absolutely on its knees exacerbated by Covid and WFH. The railway has always been hugely subsidised and is even more so now but needs massive investment to continue to maintain and improve the infrastructure and don’t even get me started on accessibility! The revenue stream has just died off and I can’t see how it will ever get back to where it was. No one will want to travel while the service is so poor as PP have said but without the revenue I don’t see how it can survive without massive investment from public funds.

EllaPaella · 01/05/2022 20:20

I have hated travelling by train for several years. In the NE you can guarantee that every journey from 9am onwards is full of pissed hen parties/stag parties who have no filter regardless of who they share a coach with.
People disregard seat bookings, swear, shout - it's embarrassing to be British at the moment tbh. I had to travel by train this weekend out of absolute necessity but I would usually pay twice the price to drive or travel by plane. In fact flying is usually half the price and a much better experience. It's basically pissed people who make it so miserable.

Fairisleflora · 01/05/2022 20:16

and I have lived in the north, south east and west and northern trains are without a doubt the worst.

Fairisleflora · 01/05/2022 20:15

I got a train from Manchester to London at Easter. There was a stag do in our carriage. The level of swearing in front of my young kids was utterly disgusting. All openly drinking spirits. It was such a grim experience, a really aggressive atmosphere. Can we just ban drinking on trains? Please? Who NEEDS to do it? And I won’t even start on the grimness of the loos

Toastedbagels61 · 01/05/2022 20:03

Same here. I live in London and sometimes my bus doesn’t even turn up. 45 minutes standing waiting for a bus. Then my second mode of transportation is always delayed so sometimes it takes me 2 hours to get home. I usually take 1 bus and then 1 train. Every single day there’s an issue, and if they do come, they are never on any kind of schedule. It’s totally random. Im sick of it. In London there is no parking because where I work the parking is 2 hour maximum stay, so I’ve got no choice but to put up with it. I never even thought to try and claim money back to be honest.

User135644 · 01/05/2022 20:01

I’m sorry that really does sound shit. No idea why they’re reducing carriages though??

Northern put all the pacer trains out of commission a couple of years ago. Those train carriages were shit but a lot of the capacity hasn't been replaced so there's fewer carriages on their services.

I'd rather be on a 4 carriage train sat on a pacer carriage, than stood in a 2 car train that's overcrowded.

User135644 · 01/05/2022 19:57

DomingoinLittleOakley · 01/05/2022 18:10

Hahaha! Try getting to/from London on Thameslink (if you can spare over £4,300) with any degree of punctuality, and you will be diabused of that notion fairly quickly.

I did add that London trains can be bad as well, just that the London services tend to be ones that have adequate carriages and more frequent journeys.

If a train isn't going to or from London the train is probably 2-4 carriages long, overcrowded and if you're really lucky the service runs twice an hour.

Badbadbunny · 01/05/2022 19:53

MadisonAvenue · 01/05/2022 19:08

Agreed.
I was on a train from Manchester to the Midlands the Christmas before the pandemic and it was rammed. There was a group in our carriage, with a table full of cans and they being abusive to anyone who was within earshot. I went to find the train manager, we were in the last carriage and his hideout was next to it and he was in there with two British Transport Police officers. They actually refused to come and deal with the situation, just saying that they were aware of what was going on.

I've experienced the same with the onboard train manager locking himself in the back cab when there was trouble.

User135644 · 01/05/2022 19:51

Sallycinnamum · 01/05/2022 19:06

The rail network has been effectively nationalised now. I'm old enough to remember the bad old days of British Rail so don't think discarding the the franchise model is going to improve the railway.

It's no good nationalising something if it's in the hands of the Tories who destroy everything they touch.

Momicrone · 01/05/2022 19:50

It's not cheaper if you cost in the car